Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Under 14s in NZ to be banned from ever buying cigarettes in their lifetime

234 replies

Shouldiwearmyhairinaponytail · 09/12/2021 15:42

metro.co.uk/2021/12/09/new-zealand-bans-people-14-and-under-from-ever-buying-cigarettes-15743607/

Thoughts?

OP posts:
CourtRand · 09/12/2021 18:32

@Shouldiwearmyhairinaponytail

So eventually nobody will be able to buy cigarettes regardless of their age.. or am I just misunderstanding
Correct. They can't be sold to anyone with a birthdate after X date. So never. When they're 35 they still can't buy. That way the trade will slowly phase out completely
CourtRand · 09/12/2021 18:31

Fabulous. Wish they'd done that when I was a teen 😩

IAAP · 09/12/2021 18:31

Do it here please

TheFrendo · 09/12/2021 18:26

This is a ludicrous plan.

It will both criminalize young, disproportionately Maori, smokers.

And provide a crime opportunity in the illegal supply of cigarettes.

AlternativePerspective · 09/12/2021 18:09

I wonder if people would be celebrating if it was alcohol they were proposing a ban on. Somehow I think not.

LuluBlakey1 · 09/12/2021 18:03

www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/p088gvpq

This is the episode about the ITU in Wales. It really struck me that so many serious health issues are related to poor lifestyle choices and how those are related to social deprivation and its impact on people's lives and how they live. The conversation with the Drs about it starts about 28 minutes in and it's fascinating. You also see some of the patients and the impact on them and what they lose in life through their choices.

I don't want to baby people but what kind of society does not take factors that impact on the health of the nation seriously.

Far fewer teenagers smoke now than did 15-18 years ago when I started teaching. The ones who do generally live in households where adults smoke. I do think smoking is one we could change by a process of banning it and banning vaping on the same process. I think it should be illegal to smoke in any public space, including outside. We have made progress with smoking and should not be afraid to keep extending those restrictions.

Obesity, alcohol, drugs are more difficult.

BiBabbles · 09/12/2021 18:02

I agree it feels very headline grabby, it seems an odd priority in terms of health inequality, and I wonder if this is extended to other nicotine products.

The plan to reduce who can sell them is an interesting concept, if concerning on how that will be implemented.

Like I say where do you draw the line. Will it eventually be all junk food too and alcohol?

While I'm for decriminalization and moving addiction more into a social care issue if there was the resources there among other things to reduce drug use, there are plenty of products that are banned in the UK.

I mean, we had sprinklegate over what we have can have in cake decorations not that long ago.

cigarettes don’t get you high and are just massively addictive and harmful vs MDMA or weed.

Some people do experience a type of high on cigarettes as they have a stimulant as well as a depressant effect and it causes a release of reward neurotransmitters like alcohol, marijuana and MDMA.

Alongside the brain reward boost, part of cigarettes addictive quality is that it gives energy and relaxation hit that later when it's out of the system causes the hormones connected to stress and anxiety to rise again causing the cravings. Much like those who smoke weed, the effects can be seen in some who live with smokers, for better and for worse, and there are alternative ways than smoking to get the same effect without risking others.

There are many factors when it comes to addictiveness and harm that making direct comparisons are difficult to make, but claiming something is 'just' addictive and harmful with no benefits has no benefit itself. We can't really get into harm reduction and alternatives if we don't recognize what makes different forms of self-medication enjoyable, no matter how much we may personally dislike them.

I was also very struck by the liver specialist on the programme Adrian Chiles made about his drinking who told him that if we had understood the effects of alcohol and were discovering it now, it would be a banned substance because it causes so much damage.

The idea that banning is entirely wrapped up in how much harm something causes is popular, but it's more complicated than that, often balanced with benefits (like cars and the internet), control of supply and alternative industries lobbying to maintain power, social ideas around who uses a product, among other factors.

People invent things all the time that cause harm and have many risks. The question is what is the government's role in mitigating that, considering how what's been tried so far has worked, and what roles can/should others play in that when it comes to recreational drug use for pleasure or to self-medicate away pain. The destructive risks make that complicated.

HotPenguin · 09/12/2021 17:59

Great idea. It's another step in making smoking socially unacceptable.

Blossom64265 · 09/12/2021 17:57

It makes sense. Ban it for anyone who hasn’t picked up the habit. As the population ages, eventually there will be no more customers left.

It should have worked to simply tell people how crazy it was to start smoking so this should have happened years ago, yet somehow young people still keep trying it and get addicted.

ColleysMill · 09/12/2021 17:54

Cant quote directly but there are papers out there detailing the (very few!!) Positive benefits to smoking. Just going on memory but I think I remember blood vessel dilation, relaxation, reduction of stress levels (along those lines?) And some others

But these are very few compared to the vast number of detriments that we all widely know (and obviously we know more now than we ever did in the past.)

It's an interesting concept but if you're really looking to improve the overall health of a nation you need to look at all the other risk factors that exist and address those too. One addiction tends to get replaced by another in my experience and I'd agree history shows that prohibition doesn't usually work.

As I say interesting.

Roundeartheratchriatmas · 09/12/2021 17:53

I’m sure nothing ever gets smuggled into NZ.

Banning something makes it more desirable.

Thatsplentyjack · 09/12/2021 17:51

@TomPinch

I'm in NZ. This will work. It's very, very rare to see a young person smoking. Only old people do it.

The reason is that the young people are all vaping like crazy and vape shops seem to be everywhere. The government isn't doing anything I know about this. My DD's school has a big vape problem and it's the best state school in the city.

Yes, imo they should ban vapes first. Loads of kids here are vaping but you can't smell that off them when they come in. So easy to hide.
Theluggage15 · 09/12/2021 17:51

Such a stupid idea. As if it will actually stop people smoking. You have to be so naïve to think it will work.

Her pandemic policies pushed 18000 more children into poverty but oh she’s so inspirational and cares about the young.

Grida · 09/12/2021 17:35

I don’t get people’s enthusiasm for banning stuff. It is as if some people would like to be school children for their entire lives and have all decisions taken away from them.

LuluBlakey1 · 09/12/2021 17:28

It's a great idea.

I know the 'freedom fighters' would moan here but it's a no brainer really.

I was also very struck by the liver specialist on the programme Adrian Chiles made about his drinking who told him that if we had understood the effects of alcohol and were discovering it now, it would be a banned substance because it causes so much damage.

Last night, DH and I watched a programme on BBC iplayer about an intensive care ward in Gwent, Wales and the ITU Leader said addicts are their biggest users and they are often full of alcoholics or long term drinkers/smokers who have caused awful damage to their organs with alcohol use or smoking.

I do think there is a question about what we allow people to do to themselves. I have a friend who works as a consultant in an ITU and he says alcohol dependency is at the root if a lot of their admissions.

It costs a fortune to keep a patient in an ITU for even a day.

julieca · 09/12/2021 17:27

Brilliant idea. They should do it in Britain as well.

TomPinch · 09/12/2021 17:27

For the UK that's

Starmer 31%
Johnson 27%

www.statista.com/statistics/710316/prime-minister-voting-intention-in-great-britain/

Darkpheonix · 09/12/2021 17:25

As a smoker I think this is a good idea.

I have conquered may things in my life. But not being able to quit smoking for more than a couple of years.

Going to try in the new year again. I started at 13. Wish they just didn't exist to be honest.

TomPinch · 09/12/2021 17:25

@AlternativePerspective

And from what I’ve read and from people I know over there JA’s popularity is fast diminishing.

“Ahead in the poles” means nothing. So is Boris Johnson, and yet…..

class="underline">pollingforthenextNewZealandgeneralelection Polling for preferred PM November 2021

Ardern (Labour) 42%
Seymour (ACT) 12%
Collins (National) 7%
Luxon (National) 3%.

She remains popular and her nearest rival reminds me of Ramsey Bolton from Game of Thrones.

VeryLongBeeeeep · 09/12/2021 17:22

I hate smoking. Never smoked, never wanted to. Used to work in a bar pre-smoking ban and ended up with cough variant asthma that the GP thought was almost certainly a result of passive smoking.

I still don't think this is a good idea. I don't agree with banning things in general, and as a rule it doesn't end the activity, just pushes people into criminality.

ClowningAround21 · 09/12/2021 17:22

@ConfusedParticle

Cars cause cancer too, but nobody is in a rush to cancel them.

I can get away from a smoker but i cant get away from traffic, sadly.

Our world is simply fucked up and fairly random. Yet governments make a serious shitshow of exhibiting any true concern about climate change or the environment.

Whilst that is true, Govts have tried to reduce the harm from car exhausts, so banned lead in petrol, tighter emissions but transport is needed for our society to function, smoking is not.

The reason most Govt's don't make any real effort on climate change is because we, the electorate, do not demand it, we'd rather pretend it wont happen

Fuuuuuckit · 09/12/2021 17:21

@Shouldiwearmyhairinaponytail

I agree it certainly does, but then I think, what’s next? Alcohol, fast food ?
There are zero benefits to smoking. Zero. You have to eat, and fast food has its place in a healthy lifestyle. Not sure yet where I stand on booze but it should be more expensive to reduce consumption.

I'm all for smoking bans. What's to lose?

trumpisagit · 09/12/2021 17:19

Well it doesn't sound like a bad idea. Interesting to see how it pans out.

fromdownwest · 09/12/2021 17:18

I think the elephant in the NZ proverbial waiting room is Obesity.

Ranked 3rd in the OECD rankings for adult obesity.

This will kill far more than smoking? Mandatory government exercise?
No junk food if BMI >18? Mandatory Gastric Band operations?

Provide people with choice, but more importantly, provide them with education, so they can make a well informed choice.

RebeccaCloud9 · 09/12/2021 17:17

@alternativeperspective not the smokers 😂

Swipe left for the next trending thread