Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Under 14s in NZ to be banned from ever buying cigarettes in their lifetime

234 replies

Shouldiwearmyhairinaponytail · 09/12/2021 15:42

metro.co.uk/2021/12/09/new-zealand-bans-people-14-and-under-from-ever-buying-cigarettes-15743607/

Thoughts?

OP posts:
AlternativePerspective · 10/12/2021 08:52

Good idea. Cigarettes are totally different to alcohol. A glass of wine is fun. A cigarette is rank. so? Wine kills too, and it kills a lot more people than cigarettes do because in general more people drink than smoke.

There are to issues here. The first is that people are applauding this headline grabbing move because most people don’t smoke and don’t like to be exposed to it. fair enough. smoking is vile. I detest it and Would love for it to not exist, but it does. And by the same token, where people find alcohol fun some people find cigarettes enjoyable. I have no idea why but they do. So maybe alcohol should be banned as well? And apart from “it’s fun,” if not, why not? Alcohol consumption leads to liver and heart failure, increased violence, including domestic violence. Alcohol is not something which only affects those who drink it, it has far-reaching consequences. In fact it is fair to say that alcohol addiction is far more detrimental than addiction to cigarettes.

Alcohol causes people to lose their jobs, their homes, their friends and families, it creates victims of violence and abuse, and that’s before we get to the health consequences. Other than health smoking doesn’t cause any of those things. But most people wouldn’t be applauding a ban on alcohol because they personally drink and they would see it as an erosion of their freedoms. So if the purchase of cigarettes is to be banned then so should the purchase of alcohol. There is 0 reason why alcohol purchase can’t be treated in the same way.

The second thing is that this ban is progressive. I suspect that if it were suddenly banned altogether, while people would argue that it would create a black market, thE majority would say that it was a good thing over all.

But here cigarettes aren’t just being banned, the age of responsibility is being increased. Right now people have to be 16 to have sex, 17 to drive, 18 to drink or to vote, or to buy cigarettes. What the government over there is proposing is that the age of consent to certain things is increased year on year.

So next year you might need to be 18 to buy cigarettes, (or is it 14 given that’s the age they want to bring in?) the year after 19, then 20, until one day it’ll be said that “you need to be 18 to drink, but 45 to buy cigarettes, even though you can smoke them if you wish….”

Where does it end? Where else will the government feel they can just gradually increase the age limit where you can do things? To drink? To vote? To have sex? Maybe to claim certain benefits? Cigarettes are an easy way to bring this kind of thing in through the back door because on the whole most of the younger generation don’t smoke so it won’t affect them. But once a law is brought in and made solid to be able to increase the age of certain responsibilities it’s a lot easier to extend that law to other elements of life.

YourenutsmiLord · 10/12/2021 08:44

I think the minority groups in NZ are the ones smoking most. Most likely older people I would think.

50ShadesOfCatholic · 10/12/2021 07:34

@Theluggage15

Lots of things kill, it’s no different for smoking than any other lifestyle choice. I never get this obsession for everybody apparently needing to live to 95 and to do that people flail about looking for things to ban. Arden will probably go for alcohol next.
But smoking-related disease is totally avoidable so why would we not seek to prevent it? Just because "lots of things kill" doesn't mean we shouldn't try to prevent avoidable harm and death.

Generally a good health service will try to support its clients to maintain good health so to turn a blind eye to the legalisation of the most addictive drug has been the travesty. Well done to Labour for having the balls to make a stand and help the next generation maintain good health. My son is 14 and thinks its an "awesome" development.

Next we need to tackle the way alcohol is marketed.

megletthesecond · 10/12/2021 07:32

Good idea. Cigarettes are totally different to alcohol. A glass of wine is fun. A cigarette is rank.

Presumably the loss of tax will be balanced out by a healthier population with fewer cancers and heart disease.

Theluggage15 · 10/12/2021 07:26

Lots of things kill, it’s no different for smoking than any other lifestyle choice. I never get this obsession for everybody apparently needing to live to 95 and to do that people flail about looking for things to ban. Arden will probably go for alcohol next.

P0ntiacBandit · 10/12/2021 07:22

This will just create a black market and something like a drugs market. Her obsession with bans is stupid.

Theluggage15 · 10/12/2021 07:22

If hardly any young people smoke in New Zealand, there’s no need to ban it.

RoseAndRose · 10/12/2021 07:15

@CrikeyPeg

All this will do is create another black market revenue stream for the gangs to run alongside their P distribution. Roll on 2023.
Yes, that will exist, but I doubt it'll be a major factor. Because the aim is for that generation and all following never to take up smoking in the first place,
user7514254 · 10/12/2021 06:40

But it’s a fact that we make a huge amount of tax from smoking, far more than costs the country in treating smoking-related illness. Where is that shortfall going to be made up from? Are people prepared to pay higher income taxes to make up the shortfall?

Smoking kills, get a grip, what other harmful habits can we make money from? What a dumb reason lol

GoIntoTheLight · 10/12/2021 05:56

I’m also in NZ and as someone else pointed out, hardly any young people smoke, so this will fit in with the general trend.

As for “government control” - please. As it stands - I can’t smoke in a car with my kid in it. I can’t smack my kid. I need a licence to drive and to fish. When those things were introduced people jumped up and down too - if it was all down to “but my freedom” we would be lawless.

YourenutsmiLord · 10/12/2021 05:53

She applauded the transwoman taking the place of a local indigenous woman - burnt her boats there as far as I'm concerned.

YourenutsmiLord · 10/12/2021 05:51

@Enb76

Because banning stuff works so well.

Prohibition works
War on drugs etc...

This is a terrible thing - the only thing that banning stuff does is lead to criminality. Banning something gives it a power it would not otherwise have.

I agree with this. It will be interesting to see the long term results - more of other drugs??
50ShadesOfCatholic · 10/12/2021 05:36

@XenoBitch

Tobacco industry makes a shit ton of tax. It is all about money in the end.
Yes that's why it hasn't been banned in many countries.

I'm so glad it's being banned here. We have known for decades that nicotine is horribly addictive and damaging, now let's do something about it. Well done Labour.

50ShadesOfCatholic · 10/12/2021 05:34

@AlternativePerspective

I find it rather interesting that people seem to think that JA is such an inspiration for having curtailed the freedom of an entire country for the past almost two years and yet those same people seem to be up in arms when the government here suggest they should wear a mask in shops.

It’s easy to applaud the rules someone else makes when you’re not the ones being forced to follow them.

And yet she is such a popular leader. Despite your countless posts spitting vile and your claims to know her "real" agenda.

Maybe, just maybe, you don't speak for everyone? Maybe the Labour government is well supported because they are doing a good job.

But hey don't let facts and stats get in the way of your anti-Jacinda crusade.

50ShadesOfCatholic · 10/12/2021 05:29

@LarryTheLurker

Ardern is a fanatic who wants to impose her own values on the people of NZ regardless of what they want.

She has been a disaster and will be gone soon.

😂 😂 😂
Kokeshi123 · 10/12/2021 05:22

I detest smoking but Adern is unbearable.
I doubt very much whether this will be the end of it. She obviously enjoyed being The PM Who Make COVID Disappear (kind of) and seems to have acquired a taste for banning stuff.

Skydaze · 10/12/2021 05:09

What a load of hysterical bollocks on here, and a whole lot of Western privilege to boot. Did a pp really compare banning of cigarettes to - oh let's see, the mass slaughter of civilians buried in unmarked graves a-la Saddam Hussein? How about live organ harvesting from political prisoners as in China? Or the teenager sentenced to death by firing squad for smuggling in a copy of Squid Game in North Korea? I am in New Zealand and have yet to see anything remotely like this, and honestly to compare this legislation to the horrors my refugee friends have been through is just beyond the pale. The internet is just ridiculous for this equating of minor things with the worst atrocities, it only makes light of the very real suffering of people around the world. The fact you're even complaining about this shows you are privileged beyond your wildest dreams & yes, if you, unlike my friend, haven't had your entire family murdered by your govt and had to run for three days straight to get to safety, with soldiers hunting you and shooting at you and never knowing if your next breath will be your last - yes, you are unimaginably privileged. Get some perspective. You may not like JA but she's pretty damn far from a dictator.

That said - whether this policy is a good one I don't know. Prohibition is not always the best way, as the drug industry shows us. However I do note no-one is yelling about removing the prohibition on the production and distribution of child pornography (also a commodity driven by the underworld and a demand that will not cease despite legislation), or calling us a dictatorship because we make vehicles and drivers pass safety checks before they're allowed to be on the road, or because food products and medicines have to pass specific safety tests before being allowed on the market. How about regulations on baby cots to prevent unnecessary deaths? Carseat safety? Clean drinking water? The recent recall on lead-contaminated sugar? Earthquake proofing our buildings? No? Just smoking then, I guess. Because #freedom.

GADDay · 10/12/2021 03:31

Lol at those who think JA is shit.

She can string a sentence
She doesn't lie without shame (she probably lies but at least has the good grace to lie well)
She at least pretends to be human

So in my book of very low standards she beats the other wankers hands down.

Phasing out smoking is a bloody awesome idea.

CrikeyPeg · 10/12/2021 03:30

All this will do is create another black market revenue stream for the gangs to run alongside their P distribution. Roll on 2023.

gofg · 10/12/2021 02:57

I think JA is frightening

All these ridiculous comments such as the above. Do you seriously think the PM makes all these decisions, gets legislation passed etc. without a word of consulation or debate with anyone else in parliament?

"Frightening" is simply the most ludicrous word to describe her. I would be far more frightened if we had a complete buffoon for a PM (mentioning no names).

BootsScootsAndToots · 10/12/2021 02:35

Do we think you should just be able to rock up to a shop and buy heroin?? Cigarettes are worse!

Of course it's a good idea. Kudos to NZ.

GreenWhiteViolet · 10/12/2021 02:33

@Grida

I don’t get people’s enthusiasm for banning stuff. It is as if some people would like to be school children for their entire lives and have all decisions taken away from them.
I do wonder about the consequences of telling our young people that petty authoritarian rules at school are good for them and prepare them for adult life. Both on the young people and the parents who tell them this.
GreenWhiteViolet · 10/12/2021 02:28

I think JA is frightening. Being pleased because of course you don't want 13-year-olds to smoke makes no sense. According to the law, one day you'll have to be 30 to smoke. Then one day, 50-year-olds will be told they're too young. It's weirdly authoritarian. Rates of smoking have already decreased dramatically through educating people about the risks. If an adult still wants to do so, that's their choice.

(I've never smoked, but I respect that other people can make different choices to my own.)

LunaTheCat · 10/12/2021 02:18

@LarryTheLurker

Ardern is a fanatic who wants to impose her own values on the people of NZ regardless of what they want.

She has been a disaster and will be gone soon.

Actually she’s brilliant. We have one of the lowest death rates from COVID in the OECD. We also have one of the most highly vaccinated populations. She is measured, mature and seeks specialist advice.
CheeseMmmm · 10/12/2021 02:12

@AlwaysLatte

I don't know why cigarettes can't just be banned for general sale immediately - giving time for withdrawal programmes first. Terrible stuff. Except the government gets a lot of tax, so it won't be banned here, probably.
I can give some reasons apart from tax.

Loads of people smoke and are addicted.
Loads of people smoke socially.

Total ban means a lot of people desperate for fags.

Black market will supply. Including fake ones containing all sorts of shit even worse than not fake.
People going continent smuggling loads back.
Illegal imports.
Buying fags if illegal would I imagine be something that drug dealers would do a lot.

Result-
People being exposed to black market/ engaging in criminal behaviour/ dodgy people with all sorts of other stuff for sale that they never had any contact with before.
Smoking becomes illicit. Makes it cool again for young people,/children,? Good chance I reckon.
In general having lots of otherwise law abiding people engaging in criminal activity has an effect of weakening the weight of the law. Looking at the police differently. Changing view in general of crime, law, that sort of thing. Because they are now one of the bad people.

All that side of it.

That's why the NZ approach is good.

Swipe left for the next trending thread