Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should i stay out of it or mention to her mum?

165 replies

ImJustMum · 09/12/2021 10:56

Doing the school run this morning and a nan of a little boy in my sons class was taking him to school along with his younger sister who is in reception. Little girl was upset about something and crying whilst holding nans hand and walking along. Nan turned to her (not realising i was behind her) and said 'shut up X, youre always crying for attention, just like your mum'. Now there was no need for the last comment nore to speak to her like that and id be fuming if i found out my own mum had spoken to my child like that. Little girl was clearly very upset afterwards still and looked very down trodden. I wasnt sure wether to ping their mum a message asking if X was okay as nan seemed a bit frustrated with her this morning. I mentioned it to my friend who said nan favours the boy and isnt particularly nice to the little girl. I know id want to know but i dont want to be shit stirring either!

OP posts:
PinkAndPurpleClouds · 09/12/2021 13:34

@BlondeDogLady

Are children not to be told off any more? Blimey. You have no idea of the circumstances. My niece for example, is always crying for attention and it's a nightmare because her parents pander to it, every single time.
@BlondeDogLady

Are children not to be told off any more?

Not in front of everyone FFS! Hmm

Speaks volumes about you that you think this acceptable. Poor girl probably constantly gets her brother favoured over her. Probably why she 'plays up.'

And has anyone actually stopped to find out WHY your niece is crying for attention? Maybe if she GOT some she wouldn't need to 'cry for it.'

Earwigworries · 09/12/2021 13:33

OP - my mum was like this when I was a child and I never once left my own children alone with her . I’d bet money that little girls mum has no idea this is going on .

ColourBeautiful · 09/12/2021 13:32

I would message…. Havent we learnt anything recently? Speak up for children if you can, if it’s nothing it will be fine, if it’s something it will give a much needed piece of the puzzle

shouldistop · 09/12/2021 13:31

I don't think saying "shut up" is very nice but not everyone uses nuanced speech when they are frustrated, just look at all the swearing on MN.

Swearing on an adult forum is entirely different and personal attacks (which this was against the girl) are deleted here.

BlondeDogLady · 09/12/2021 13:30

Are children not to be told off any more? Blimey. You have no idea of the circumstances. My niece for example, is always crying for attention and it's a nightmare because her parents pander to it, every single time.

PinkAndPurpleClouds · 09/12/2021 13:30

Absolutely speak up.

It's not uncommon for some women of a certain generation to favour boys over girls, from generally ignoring them and putting the boys first, to actually bullying/goading, and smacking the girls.

This sounds like one of those cases. Defo make sure you speak up @ImJustMum

nitsandwormsdodger · 09/12/2021 13:28
  • fakereview.

I swear all the time on MN but do not swear or use abusive language towards children

Goldenbear · 09/12/2021 13:26

Not that it matters but how old is the girl she was being horrible to?

Nogoodusername · 09/12/2021 13:25

I would want to know if it was my child, and I also think if this is what she is happy to say in public it is probably much worse behind closed doors.
I think everyone needs to get a lot more comfortable with safeguarding children being all our responsibility - if it was just a bad day, all good, easily resolved, but we need to stop letting things slide as ‘none of my business’

BatshitBanshee · 09/12/2021 13:24

Say something. That's disgusting behaviour and I don't care what the fuck kind of morning you're having, you don't tell an upset child to shut up, you don't tell them they're just crying for attention or that they're "just like your mum" in a negative way. Fuck all of that. If that what she says to the child in front of people, I dread to think what she says in private.

Iwonder08 · 09/12/2021 13:22

You should tell mum. Just tell her exactly what happened and add that as a mum you would like to be aware of such thing. Don't add any comments of what you thought or why it happened

nitsandwormsdodger · 09/12/2021 13:22

This child’s mother is crying and children are being emotionally abused and you think it’s ok to say nothing !?
HAVE WE LEARNED NOTHING!!!!
Report report report
Don’t wait to be certain
Don’t concern yourself with the ramifications
Don’t do casual passive texting/ comments - REPORT!

Atla · 09/12/2021 13:20

On balance , I think I would say something. I would want to know of it was my child. You could just say something like, "this has been bothering me all day I wasn't sure if I should say something, but x,y,z...."

Elsiebear90 · 09/12/2021 13:19

I would tell the mum, my MIL was verbally and physically abusive to my fiancée when she was a child and on occasion lashed out at her pets, she assured me she had changed and wasn’t the same person any more, after a few years of knowing her and never witnessing anything off I believed her. That was until we realised she’d been hitting our dog (dog stayed with her for a week while we went away and started flinching every time we raised a hand).

Her daughter might also believe she’s changed and have no idea she’s treating her child this way.

billy1966 · 09/12/2021 13:17

You can indeed tag on a remark like "if she speaks like that to her in public, what is she like in private. You little one was just SO upset".

Horrible way to speak to a child.
Says so much about the grandmother.

Goldenbear · 09/12/2021 13:17

I think she sounds awful and seriously how stressed can a Gran be if she doesn't live with the children. She clearly isn't cut out for the job of taking them to school. All of the grandparents just dote on my children, I thought that is what they are supposed to do!

billy1966 · 09/12/2021 13:14

OP,

That is such a nasty thing to say to the child.

If it had been a teacher that heard she could well have brought it to the attention of the Principal who might indeed pull the mum aside and tell her what was heard.

I would frame it that you are giving her a heads up about awful it sounded and how it could be made into something, particularly as her daughter was very very upset.

You can frame it kindly, but telling her clearly how unkind her mother was.

No overt judgement, just a clear heads up that it really sounded awful.

whitehorsesdonotlie · 09/12/2021 13:12

And people wonder why horrendous cases of child abuse go unreported.... Hmm

I'd say something to the mum.

That's a horrible thing to say to a child.

MistyFrequencies · 09/12/2021 13:12

I would speak to the mum. "shut up" is an awful thing to say to a child. And if the Nan tells a little child to shut up like that in public, what the hell is she doing behind closed doors?

whereislittleroo · 09/12/2021 13:09

I would speak to the mum. I'm a Psychologist and you wouldn't believe (or perhaps you would) how many of my clients have come from backgrounds like this, where they were belittled or shouted at for having feelings, where they weren't safe to express themselves or make mistakes, where they had to tiptoe on eggshells
around the adults in their lives. If it is sustained behaviour it can have lifelong impacts on the child's confidence, sense of self, and intimate relationships.

Bagamoyo1 · 09/12/2021 13:08

@WOTW

Stay out of it. You have no idea what kind of morning the Nan has had. She could've just vented in a way she usually wouldn't. We've all had those mornings. Leave it alone.
that's probably what people thought when they saw Emma Tustin talking to Arthur.
fakereview · 09/12/2021 13:07

But since reading about poor Arthur I now have to attitude of report/say everything. Never let a child go unnoticed

but reporting it didn't help Arthur, did it. Social services did nothing.

I have to say I can't really see the issue here. The little girl might be attention seeking and her mum might have been the same. Maybe she's been driving the grandmother mad all morning. I don't think saying "shut up" is very nice but not everyone uses nuanced speech when they are frustrated, just look at all the swearing on MN.

FortunesFave · 09/12/2021 13:02

Tell the teacher. I would. Then she can watch out...and choose if she thinks it's appropriate to speak up. I once "told on" a childminder at my local playgroup....I saw her being openly unkind to her charge.

I found out the name of the child's Mother and contacted her on Facebook. She sacked the CM and reported her. No idea what happened after if she was investigated or not.

MoiraNotRuby · 09/12/2021 13:01

It happened at school, I'd mention it to school, they will know what to do next.

thinkingaboutLangCleg · 09/12/2021 12:58

Usually I would say stay out of it. But since reading about poor Arthur I now have to attitude of report/say everything. Never let a child go unnoticed.

I agree. I’m surprised some PPs are so relaxed about it.