Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should i stay out of it or mention to her mum?

165 replies

ImJustMum · 09/12/2021 10:56

Doing the school run this morning and a nan of a little boy in my sons class was taking him to school along with his younger sister who is in reception. Little girl was upset about something and crying whilst holding nans hand and walking along. Nan turned to her (not realising i was behind her) and said 'shut up X, youre always crying for attention, just like your mum'. Now there was no need for the last comment nore to speak to her like that and id be fuming if i found out my own mum had spoken to my child like that. Little girl was clearly very upset afterwards still and looked very down trodden. I wasnt sure wether to ping their mum a message asking if X was okay as nan seemed a bit frustrated with her this morning. I mentioned it to my friend who said nan favours the boy and isnt particularly nice to the little girl. I know id want to know but i dont want to be shit stirring either!

OP posts:
Almostmenopausal · 09/12/2021 17:25

@ImJustMum Definitely tell her. Her child is being abused......

FabriqueBelgique · 09/12/2021 17:21

It’s hard because it could backfire on you and them both call you liars, you don’t know just how messed up the family dynamics are.

But that shouldn’t stop you possibly protecting a little girl from verbal abuse I suppose.

ChangeChingyChange · 09/12/2021 15:52

@Staryflight445

‘ ChangeChingyChange

Usually I would say stay out of it. But since reading about poor Arthur I now have to attitude of report/say everything. Never let a child go unnoticed. So I'd say something. I would tell the mum what she said, even if it backfires and she sides with her mum I'd still tell her.’

Surely the story of Arthur should remind others to not be reporting petty little incidents like in the OP, social services are overstretched and things would be taken more seriously if people stop doing this.

Goodness me.

I didnt say report this incident to social services Hmm I said tell the mum.
IncompleteSenten · 09/12/2021 15:37

Quick question for the ones bringing up reporting to social services.

Given the OP asks if she should stay out of it or tell the mum, and those replies saying 'tell' are for the most part saying tell the mum - do you think she should tell the child's mum the facts of what she saw?

1forAll74 · 09/12/2021 15:13

i would stay out of this. It doesn't indicate that anything is amiss within the family set up of the Nan,the child, or the child's Mother etc.. I have heard much more horrible comments spoken to children,by their Mothers and Fathers of Grandparents, whilst walking to school, or walking in towns etc, basically complaining about a childs behaviour of some kind.

ABCeasyasdohrayme · 09/12/2021 15:08

That's not why they're doing it. This isn't a game. I'm sure his grandparents would want people to share worrying information more quickly.

You literally don't know what his grandparents stance on this would be Confused

A grandparent snapped at their grandchild and Arthur's murder has been used to justify implementing safeguarding procedures.

Its not a game, you're right, so why people think that it's OK to use his murder to somehow prove their point.

I've seen it numerous times on here over the last week or so, if you can't make your point without having to use another families tragedy then it's probably not a valid point in the first place.

Encouraging people to REPORT REPORT REPORT this one minor incident is irresponsible and will over stretch services that are already overstretched.

If there was a few instances, or the mum was also behaving like this, or there was anything else worrying, fair enough, one incident of snapping at a kid on the school run does not warrant school or SS intervention.

RobertaFirmino · 09/12/2021 15:08

@VainAbigail

I mentioned it to my friend who said nan favours the boy and isnt particularly nice to the little girl

Thing is, that’s just your friends opinion.

So that's two people who have noticed how the little girl is being treated...
IWantMoreStationery · 09/12/2021 15:06

@Wopies

Ask yourself if you could want to know if that was your child and your mum? I would want someone to tell me.
Me too.
AliceMcK · 09/12/2021 15:06

I’d say something. I’ve no problem saying things to people if I see something off. I’ve done it several times, similar with a grandparent, when I told the mother she admitted she hated her in-laws watching her kids because they were ridiculously harsh on her kids (they don’t like her) but she was limited with childcare. another time I witnessed a Dad having a go at his DD at the park, I knew there were ongoing issues with the little girl not wanting to see him, this confirmed to the mum what she suspected and was very greatfull as a couple of other parents had also witnessed things and told her. If someone tells me to fuck off and mind my own business then that’s fine, but at least I know I had at least said something.

littleburn · 09/12/2021 15:06

@Alltheblue

On a separate note I don't think people should be bringing up the murder of a child to make their point tbh. His death isn't a point scoring exercise to get people to agree

That's not why they're doing it. This isn't a game. I'm sure his grandparents would want people to share worrying information more quickly.

Good lord! People are bringing up Arthur to make the point that his murder has made them reflect and think differently about their response in situations like this. It's not to 'point score' Hmm
Alltheblue · 09/12/2021 14:55

On a separate note I don't think people should be bringing up the murder of a child to make their point tbh. His death isn't a point scoring exercise to get people to agree

That's not why they're doing it. This isn't a game. I'm sure his grandparents would want people to share worrying information more quickly.

littleburn · 09/12/2021 14:49

@ChangeChingyChange

Usually I would say stay out of it. But since reading about poor Arthur I now have to attitude of report/say everything. Never let a child go unnoticed. So I'd say something. I would tell the mum what she said, even if it backfires and she sides with her mum I'd still tell her.
Totally agree. I've promised myself not to turn a blind eye however 'small' the incident may seem
mummywithtwokidsplusdog · 09/12/2021 14:43

I would send a message. It’s important she is aware, and if you send a message you can take your time to compose it etc whereas in person might be more tricky- and she might appreciate reading it away from an ‘audience’.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 09/12/2021 14:41

I agree with sending a message as you can present it factually and it can be referred to exactly as it is. I did the same thing when I saw someone I know’s childminder distracted on her phone on a busy road whilst her 2 year old toddled along precariously. The mother shrugged it off but I was pleased I had said all the same. There’s actually a few mothers I regret having not said things to for the sake of being polite (eg the mother who strapped her 1 year old in the adult front seat of a car for a 5 min journey as she ‘couldn’t be bothered’ with the children’s car seat in the back”)

It’s never wrong to say something. Don’t know how you should phrase it but someone with better ideas than me will come along

ABCeasyasdohrayme · 09/12/2021 14:34

[quote Newmumatlast]@starcup reporting to SS hasn't been suggested...[/quote]
Reporting to the school has, and others have suggested reporting but not specifying where they recommend reporting to.

On a separate note I don't think people should be bringing up the murder of a child to make their point tbh. His death isn't a point scoring exercise to get people to agree with you. Imagine if his family is on this site and seeing Arthur being brought up on lots of threads at the moment to shut down others. It's really disrespectful.

Make your point, by all means, but don't use someone else's tragedy to do so.

Lesina · 09/12/2021 14:34

Say something to the childs mother. It may be an isolated incident, it may be something that happens every day. Either way, say something. Children deserve as much respect as an adult and it is on all of society to make sure they get it. Quite disturbing that some people think other wise.

Alltheblue · 09/12/2021 14:33

I'd send a message because that way you can put the facts down (just state them clearly, don't diminish them or embellish of course) and she has time to reflect.

Alltheblue · 09/12/2021 14:32

Are children not to be told off any more

Not like that, no.

Alltheblue · 09/12/2021 14:30

stay out of it

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 09/12/2021 14:30

Fuck me, I’m glad some of you aren’t my mother! Absolutely horrified by people who think this is acceptable.

Alltheblue · 09/12/2021 14:30

I would describe exactly what happened and leave it with her.

We need more people doing this. Have the 'start out of it' advisers learned nothing in recent weeks? We have no idea what picture this could be building - or not. Hence the need to collate information that's at all concerning, which this is.

MrsToothyBitch · 09/12/2021 14:27

I would say something- although I'd tie myself in knots trying to frame it & overthink. My logic is that I would want to know if it was my child!

My mum can be pretty vicious and I can 100% imagine her saying this, the exact dripping with hate tone of voice and everything. Obviously that wasn't her only mode of behaviour but it did cut deep and I
was late teens/adult before people outside the family started acknowledging that she could be extremely unkind and domineering and it wasn't ok. Damage was done by then. I love her but she hurt me. DPs mum has some caprices/playing favourites with her kids behaviour in her history too. Should we ever end up using them even as last resort childcare, even if it was only once, we would need to know about something like this.

Scbchl · 09/12/2021 14:25

Id want to know.

diddl · 09/12/2021 14:21

Sadly the mum might already know but is desperate for the help.

I'd want to know if my daughter was being treated like that by her GM.

It might not change anything though.

diddl · 09/12/2021 14:19

@VainAbigail

I mentioned it to my friend who said nan favours the boy and isnt particularly nice to the little girl

Thing is, that’s just your friends opinion.

Well it seems to be backed up by what Op heard!