Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boyfriend doesn't want to spend Christmas together

213 replies

eem12345 · 09/12/2021 10:49

Hi everyone I wasn't sure whether to post this but I've been feeling a bit upset about it...ive been with my boyfriend for nearly 2 years and we live together and its an amazing relationship. But whenever I bring up spending Christmas together he gets a bit annoyed and tries to shut the conversation down. He goes away with his family every year and they are really close and I just don't think he wants to give that up but I would like to alternate Christmas between families to make it fair and to see each other as well. He doesn't seem to want to spend Christmas with me at all! I just think its strange and have started thinking maybe he doesn't see a future together- because at what point will we spend Christmas together when we already live together. Am I overreacting? Thanks everyone

OP posts:
GreenOlivesinGin · 09/12/2021 13:34

Just to offer a different perspective..
My husband and I have been together for years, but we always spent Christmas separately (each with our respective families). This was because Christmas was very important to his family, so for their sake he would spend it with them, and I always wanted to see my family who were less fussed about Christmas but they live far away so visits were rare. It did not mean we were not serious for one another, and we did spend the rest of the year together. It was only after maybe 6 years in (don't quite remember) that we started spending Christmas together, and now that we have kids we are always together as well.
Of course if you are not happy about it that's a separate point, and we can have no idea what your boyfriend's reasons are, but I don't think that spending Christmas apart two years in is necessarily indicative of a bigger issue: I would just look at the bigger relationship picture.

thedefinitionofmadness · 09/12/2021 13:29

How can it be "too early" to be spending Christmas together when they are already co-habiting?

thedefinitionofmadness · 09/12/2021 13:27

He's just not that into you

Blossom64265 · 09/12/2021 13:27

The key is that you live together. That step should be significant and indicate a shift in the relationship, like spending Christmas together. If he wasn’t ready for that level of commitment, it was too early for cohabitation.

Antsgomarching · 09/12/2021 13:26

I’d prefer to go to my family too tbh and i did before DH got married. Its a special dynamic that changes when kids/marriages etc come along.

DedalusBloom · 09/12/2021 13:25

There are so many dynamics -Christmas is a very fraught time. I love spending time with my family but I know its very stressful for a lot of people. it also depends where they live - I had a boyfriend for about 4 years whose parents live in the Hebrides, so as I work up to the last minute on xmas eve, travel was never going to work out (and frankly I didnt fancy the schlep, even though they were lovely) so he always spend xmas with them. We used to visit at other times. 2 years doesnt seem a lot to be starting 'new traditions' to be honest. Can you have an early Christmas on the 22nd?

If you dont have a great relationship with your own family I can see how it must seem like you are being excluded. But as PP have said -who pays for the holiday is an issue. I also suspect given your ages that his parents pay for the immediate family and partners arent invited as it could get a bit unwieldy.

I do think its a positive when families are close, but as PPs have also said, that can also indicate massive man babies who aren't off the teat into their thirties and beyond.

You say he's a great man so we can assume he's not tied to his mums apron strings -I would let this Christmas pass and raise the subject when he's back.

plan a lovely new year celebration together and spend as much time as you can with friends and family.

Earwigworries · 09/12/2021 13:23

OP - I don’t think you’re wrong to be upset - if you live together then I’d assume that includes Christmas too … otherwise you are little more than flat mates . How long you have lived together , when the holiday was booked etc all have an impact on how reasonable this is though . The big clue is that he isn’t willing to talk about it , shuts you down and gets annoyed . He doesn’t care how you feel . If you must give him the benefit of the doubt then get rid of him before next Christmas if he pulls the same stunt again

KatherineJaneway · 09/12/2021 13:23

I did try to suggest I would go but he just ignored it really

This would worry me far more than him wanting to be with his parents at Christmas if he can't talk openly with you about a simply subject.

TheNinny · 09/12/2021 13:22

I should add 2 years as adults. Also, at 26 and 28, is it not time for his family/your partner to relinquish the clutches just a bit? My now DH was 30 when started dating me. We had been together a only a few months at Xmas but he was happy to come to mine for Xmas day. He said his family had him every year for 30 years so they could deal with it 😂😦 (they aren’t so steeped in tradition, but still). Expecting grown adults not to bring partners they are living with is weird.

gogohm · 09/12/2021 13:22

We are spending Christmas together going to my family, 3rd Christmas (last year lock down so obviously at home together) - but in our case there was no invitation to his so an easy decision. His girls are coming to my parents too (aren't they greatGrin)

But I know married couples who each go to their families at Christmas, there's no set rules

Thatsplentyjack · 09/12/2021 13:16

@Pipsquiggle

Also when did they book this holiday?

I am guessing they booked the holiday at least 6 months out as it's quite a busy time to go away.
So at this point, you would have been going out for less than 18 months so I would say that it would be too early to automatically be included in this family holiday

Yeah and also the fact this has only happened once before. This is only the second time this has come up. Would also be interested in who pays for the holiday. Bet its the parents. I wouldn't want to give up a weeks holiday paid by my parents, and I certainly wouldn't be cheeky enough tk ask them to pay for my partner to come with us.
dollbaby868 · 09/12/2021 13:16

@thegrassisalwaysgreener

I think 2 years is quite soon to be spending Christmas together. DH and I only really started alternating christmases between families when we moved in together after 5 years together. Maybe he just thinks it's too soon?
I agree with this. You've only been together two years, I'd defo think it's too early to be spending Christmas together or whatever. I don't think his family need to invite you either. Could just be a time that they like to spend together and it's been that way for years
Pipsquiggle · 09/12/2021 13:12

Also when did they book this holiday?

I am guessing they booked the holiday at least 6 months out as it's quite a busy time to go away.
So at this point, you would have been going out for less than 18 months so I would say that it would be too early to automatically be included in this family holiday

Elodeastar · 09/12/2021 13:11

It might seem hard OP, but the fact that he loves spending time with his family is actual a positive, imho anyway! You have not been together that long, maybe he would prefer you wait a little while and either invite you along too, come to your family, or, as you seem to suggest, alternate it. Make sure you do stuff together on the run up to Christmas and after. I think those who are telling you that 'you should come first' just now maybe need to see this as less of a competition - not saying you are doing that, but there are a few posts that are! I hope you have a lovely Christmas whatever you do. :)

shiningstar2 · 09/12/2021 13:06

Where is this dynamic coming from op? What are his s parents like? If , for example, if you suggested directly to o his mother that you came along what do you think the reaction would be? To me it's either the family or he himself is telling them you don't want to come.

Pipsquiggle · 09/12/2021 13:05

Yes @phishy - good point

who pays for this holiday?

VikingOnTheFridge · 09/12/2021 13:05

At 2 years in, twentysomething, living together but not married or DC yet it's a borderline one.

Pipsquiggle · 09/12/2021 12:59

I didn't spend Christmas with my OH now DH until we'd been going out for more than 4 years and we lived together as well

So essentially they go on holiday together over Christmas - does he have siblings? Do their OH's go on this holiday?

It's quite full on to go on the family holiday when you haven't been going out for that long. My guess is that if you get engaged / you are 'the one', you will be invited on this family tradition.

I guess you need to work out whether this is a deal breaker - not really for this year but ongoing. You've been going out for a while but not that long.
Does his family welcome you on other occasions / are they nice to you?

CantGetDecentNickname · 09/12/2021 12:58

As a PP has said upthread

I would make it clear to him that you're taking it as a clear sign that he sees your relationship as fairly casual... so you will be doing the same.

If it was me, I'd pack my bags and go and stay with my own family for the duration that he is away and beyond. I probably wouldn't bother putting up any decorations or a tree in my own place as not going to be there. I would return on Sunday 2nd January if working on Monday 3rd. If he can bugger off on holiday and leave you to Christmas by yourself, then you can leave him to the New Year by himself. He is expecting you to be available to pick up and drop when it suits him and I wouldn't be around for this. I would also be arranging summer holidays either with my family or be going away with the girls and not bothering to mention it to him.

It looks as though he is happy to enjoy living with you, but not treating you as an actual partner. Please view the relationship as casual as this is what he is doing. Don't commit more than a fair share of money in your place and make sure you will be able to cope financially should it come to an end. Also please don't ever apologise for doing what suits you; he doesn't. He needs to see that you are not a doormat who will always be waiting at home for him, but a person who is independent with a life of their own and doesn't "need" to have him around. The fact that you are not clingy and can walk away if it suits you may make him wake up a little.

Weirdlynormal · 09/12/2021 12:58

You're a housemate, not his life partner

JammyRedRooo · 09/12/2021 12:57

I would be upset at this too - my in laws had made me feel like part of the family by two years in, I'd definitely be put out if they wanted to exclude me from christmas. I'm not the slightest bit clingy either, we both have our own lives but Christmas is a time for your loved ones and I very much included my DH in that even after 'only' 2 years.

Be very direct and ask why he doesn't want you to come away with them. Explain its important to you and how hurt you would feel if you were sidelined every Christmas.

MadgeMak · 09/12/2021 12:53

We did separate christmases up until we had kids, despite living together for a couple of years prior to that. That was fine for us. If this isn't ok for you, OP, then perhaps you are not compatible.

TheNinny · 09/12/2021 12:52

I think it’s weird to be essentially acting single when you are living together, and presumably are a unit now. There are those to spend Xmas separately even while married or living together but this is weird imo. I don’t know anyone in real life who does this. For ‘family tradition’ to be so insular is strange. Can they not except family members circumstances change? Living together is a fairly big deal and not acknowledging it or extending invite is odd. And dating 2 years exclusively is long enough to be’allowed’ into family traditions. I would want the person I love most in the world to be part of any tradition I have

Coffeepot72 · 09/12/2021 12:51

OP, don’t forget that on MN you are supposed to be the Cool Girlfriend, anyone asking for a committed relationship is accused of being clingy …

phishy · 09/12/2021 12:47

*with a boyfriend, not friend

Swipe left for the next trending thread