Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boyfriend doesn't want to spend Christmas together

213 replies

eem12345 · 09/12/2021 10:49

Hi everyone I wasn't sure whether to post this but I've been feeling a bit upset about it...ive been with my boyfriend for nearly 2 years and we live together and its an amazing relationship. But whenever I bring up spending Christmas together he gets a bit annoyed and tries to shut the conversation down. He goes away with his family every year and they are really close and I just don't think he wants to give that up but I would like to alternate Christmas between families to make it fair and to see each other as well. He doesn't seem to want to spend Christmas with me at all! I just think its strange and have started thinking maybe he doesn't see a future together- because at what point will we spend Christmas together when we already live together. Am I overreacting? Thanks everyone

OP posts:
Poppingmad123 · 09/12/2021 17:19

I agree with @Pedalpushers and all that have said don’t be clingy. But I am interested in what reason he’s given you?

Could it be just that it would change the dynamics bringing you along and he wants to simply spend one day with his family and the way they’ve always done it?

May also indicates he’s not fully ready to settle and commit, which is fine if you’re young and in newish relationship, 2 years is not that long but why not have the talk and ask him if he sees a future? That will give you a better idea if it’s worth sticking at this one or not. Hopefully it is but listen to your gut.

Laiste · 09/12/2021 17:07

Sorry if this has been asked already, but

Have you met the parents and siblings OP?

Were they friendly/welcoming?

WhereYouLeftIt · 09/12/2021 16:28

This man is not a keeper @eem12345. He certainly doesn't see you as his future. I'd be rethinking what I want from life. It really shouldn't be thisSad.

Suprima · 09/12/2021 16:18

@eem12345

Hi everyone I wasn't sure whether to post this but I've been feeling a bit upset about it...ive been with my boyfriend for nearly 2 years and we live together and its an amazing relationship. But whenever I bring up spending Christmas together he gets a bit annoyed and tries to shut the conversation down. He goes away with his family every year and they are really close and I just don't think he wants to give that up but I would like to alternate Christmas between families to make it fair and to see each other as well. He doesn't seem to want to spend Christmas with me at all! I just think its strange and have started thinking maybe he doesn't see a future together- because at what point will we spend Christmas together when we already live together. Am I overreacting? Thanks everyone
In my deadend student relationship that lasted too long, I refused to do Christmas because I didn’t see him as my future, and didn’t want to forgo any Christmases without my family for him.

As soon as I met OH, we were christmassing from the first year.

Is he doing anything else that makes you think he is not committed to you?

Nevermakeit · 09/12/2021 16:16

My DH and I spent Xmas apart for 10 years - we only stopped when we had the DC. It's only been 2 years, that's really not that long.

I was happy with my parents, he with his - and we saw each other for the 364 other days of the year, so what's the problem?
Definitely wouldn't force it, or you will come across and needy and annoying (and both he and his family will resent you - not great for the future).

ravenmum · 09/12/2021 16:02

I think you're right maybe the issue is we haven't talked about it as he is unwilling to which is probably the biggest issue
It really is. When else has he got annoyed about you?

Ourlady · 09/12/2021 15:55

Its the fact that he won't even discuss it which is the problem. He needs to grow up and have an adult conversation about it. You're obviously upset about it.

Bookworm20 · 09/12/2021 15:48

@ememem12345

Thanks everyone for all of your comments its really helpful.

His parents pay for the apartment for everyone and then my BF pays for his flight/ spends etc and I'd expect to pay for myself but the conversation has never got that far. I suppose I hadn't thought that this might be the reason but maybe you're right. And his siblings are younger so don't have BF/GF to bring yet so I suppose we're the guinea pigs.

I think you're right maybe the issue is we haven't talked about it as he is unwilling to which is probably the biggest issue.

Also when I say its upset me that he's going away for a week over Xmas its not that he's going away that doesn't bother me and any other week of the year I really wouldn't be bothered, its the fact that he hasn't thought to include me in his Xmas celebrations. Even if he suggested that I could fly out on Boxing Day I would have been happy with that but he's just said bye I'm leaving on 23rd and coming back 29th!

Thanks again

I do find it odd that as you are living together he is not including you in his xmas plans at all!

And 2 years is not too soon to start spending xmas together.Confused

I can't imagine any scenario in the future where one of my dc is living with someone and we go away for xmas and do not invite their partner. In fact we'd likely invite them even if they were not living together if it was a serious relationship.
And if it was a regular xmas thing to be honest once they were living with someone/in a serious relationship i'd expect them not to want to come and spend it with their partner.

I mean at what point will he decide he isn't buggering off for the entire xmas with them each year? It definitely needs a discussion.

Is he definitely going? I'd be rethinking everything if I were you. He obviously isn't bothered that the person he is supposed to love the most is going to be waking up over the entire xmas period alone. And the fact he won't even discuss it. He must realise how crap that is of him surely?

For him to even consider going at all is really shit. For him/his family to then not even invite you is even worse.

MrJollyLivesNextDoor · 09/12/2021 15:25

I'd be using the time constructively

Packing for example

1forAll74 · 09/12/2021 15:19

I think he should be able to do what he wishes, without being curtailed in any way. It's not the end of the world,if he want's to keep up with some family traditions.

WalkingOnTheCracks · 09/12/2021 15:19

Not inviting you may or may not indicate a lack of commitment, but taking you would not necessarily indicate commitment.

I have a relative who shows up for Christmas with a different plus-one every year.

thamesriviera · 09/12/2021 15:13

if this bothers you, then you're not compatible and should move on from this relationship.

Doesn't matter what other people in similar situations do, the fact he keeps you at arms length over christmas when you want to spend it with him, means you're not on the same life path.

Move on.

Chloemol · 09/12/2021 15:08

Sounds sad to me that you are living together, but he doesn’t want to spend time with you. Do his siblings have partners? Do they go or stay behind?

I would start arranging weekends away with friends, and not him, I would arrange family holidays and not include him. What’s good enough for him is good enough for you

Retain your independence

Buy you also need to think about the future, what happens if you have kids? Will he still go away with his parents and leave you all behind?

ememem12345 · 09/12/2021 15:04

Thanks everyone for all of your comments its really helpful.

His parents pay for the apartment for everyone and then my BF pays for his flight/ spends etc and I'd expect to pay for myself but the conversation has never got that far. I suppose I hadn't thought that this might be the reason but maybe you're right. And his siblings are younger so don't have BF/GF to bring yet so I suppose we're the guinea pigs.

I think you're right maybe the issue is we haven't talked about it as he is unwilling to which is probably the biggest issue.

Also when I say its upset me that he's going away for a week over Xmas its not that he's going away that doesn't bother me and any other week of the year I really wouldn't be bothered, its the fact that he hasn't thought to include me in his Xmas celebrations. Even if he suggested that I could fly out on Boxing Day I would have been happy with that but he's just said bye I'm leaving on 23rd and coming back 29th!

Thanks again

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 09/12/2021 14:59

Its hard to say when we don't know if you've met his family before or not.
Its clear you'd like to be with the man you live with over Christmas after two years its odd that he won't discuss it.
I think he should give you a reason why he hasn't asked them to include you, even if that reason is just that its too soon and although people say its only a week, its actually quite a difficult week to be on your own ( unless you are going to your family or could take off on a holiday of your own (difficult at this time with Covid etc)
I would be having a serious discussion with him about this and considering based on the results of that discussion whether this situation will be continuing and if that would work for you in the long run.

NdujaWannaDance · 09/12/2021 14:56

I think the issue here is what is the OP doing, if not being with her boyfriend? Obviously if she has no family, or they are in Australia or whatever, then that makes a huge difference to whether it's unreasonable or not for the BF to go off on holiday over Christmas without her, or to not invite her along. But as she hasn't come back to the thread for a while I guess we'll never know.

PrincessNutella · 09/12/2021 14:51

OP, this is a very helpful Christmas present, wrapped in a bow. The best Christmas present you need to help you have a wonderful future. I know, you're looking inside the box and you're puzzled. There's nothing in it. What kind of fucking present is this? you're wondering.
I'll tell you.
It's a present without this useless man in it.
A present where you can find someone who loves you so much that he is proud to share holidays with you.
A present where you never have to ask this kind of question again.
XOXO

Wnikat · 09/12/2021 14:46

Didn't spend Christmas with my husband until we had kids...

NdujaWannaDance · 09/12/2021 14:43

Why are there always a competition on mumsnet of who took their relationship the slowest? “Oh it’s ONLY been 2 years, you barely know them”. I find it so bizarre and certainly not how things are in the real world, in my circle anyway

Totally agree. In my two very long term relationships we were pretty inseparable within a few weeks and I think when you are with 'the one' that's usually the case.

Of course some people think everyone is 'the one' and throw themselves fully into every bloke that ever comes along, but for most us, we know the difference.

Having established that you love him/her and they love you back, it's pretty normal to want to spend major events like Christmas together. Unless there are logistical issues that make that very difficult I don't think it's weird in the slightest to expect to be together.

My three young adult DCs all have relationships that are less than 2 years old but they all live with their partners. They are doing a mix of spending Christmas Day together or not, depending on their own personal circumstances, logistical factors, work commitments etc, but at no point is there a suggestion that the relationship isn't serious or permanent enough to warrant being together if it were possible. In each of those situations I think my DC would have been invited to go on holiday with their partner's family and if they couldn't, then fair enough, but the option was there.

Likewise DH and I wouldn't dream of inviting our DC to any holiday or big family thing and not extending the invitation to their GFs/BFs. Whether they came or not, is not the point.

EerieSilence · 09/12/2021 14:35

He could at least suggest it.
Looks like not even after two years his family consider you a serious partner and neither does he.

TheCraicDealer · 09/12/2021 14:30

Unless you're literally going to be on your own otherwise, or you have a complicated relationship with your own family which means Xmas with them isn't exactly a delight, I'd say YABU.

As someone else pointed out, this holiday was probably booked months ago. It's a longstanding family tradition; presumably the BF and his siblings have had a partner over Xmas previously and yet they have chosen to keep it 'family only', perhaps because his parents are paying. As you've got together over COVID I would assume that you haven't had much chance to really get to know his family, and they may baulk at spending an extended period with someone they don't know that well. It changes the dynamic of the trip, which they all clearly value the way it is.

That being said I do not think you're being unreasonable to expect a frank discussion about future Xmas plans. DH and I were apart for our first nine Christmases, but we had agreed that once kids came along we would start alternating.

todaysdilemma · 09/12/2021 14:29

@Batshitkerazy

Why are there always a competition on mumsnet of who took their relationship the slowest? “Oh it’s ONLY been 2 years, you barely know them”. I find it so bizarre and certainly not how things are in the real world, in my circle anyway

We spent Christmas together after 6 months and have alternated since, it would be really strange not to! We live together and are in a committed long term relationship, my family would be very confused if I spent it with them instead of him!

So no OP, I don’t think you are being unreasonable

Agree with this wholeheartedly. Some people just do everything a lot slower, and there is absolutely no scientific or psychological reason a relationship that needed years to settle is stronger than one that doesn't.

OP, I have always been invited to every partner's Xmas-es even when I chose to not go. The same way the invitation was always open at my parents. And I've never had a relationship where we didn't spend at least a few days of the Xmas period together unless someone needed to travel home which was abroad - in fact I don't know of anyone in my entire social circle who just refuses to invite a live-in partner along or spends the entire period apart. If he's happy to share a house and finances, you are his family too.

However, he may have valid reason, BUT it is concerning that he won't even talk about it or explain why. Why not just have an open conversation about it. The getting annoyed and shutting it down would pi55 me off because he's not treating your concerns seriously - even if just to allay your fears. And would also make me question WHY you're never invited. Can you just point blank ask him if he'd ever be spending Xmas with you, or is it just assumed that for the rest of your life, it'll be spent separately?

Crunchymum · 09/12/2021 14:28

Have you met his family? What is your relationship with them like?

Are you excluded from all family events (birthdays etc) or is it just Xmas?

Do any of the siblings have partners or kids?

GatoradeMeBitch · 09/12/2021 14:27

If he was just at home and didn't want to see you I'd find it weird, but if his family have this thing of going away for a week then I get it. If you went it would probably change the dynamic.

I don't think alternating Christmas between families and "making it fair" is really a thing until you have children. In a way it's fair now. You're with your family, he's with his. I'd wait until there's more of a commitment and you're closer to his family before you make a thing of this. Ask yourself whether you might just be miffed that you're not going on a bonus holiday!

toomuchlaundry · 09/12/2021 14:27

Do there partners go on this holiday?