Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does anyone else have a cat who fails at being a cat?

167 replies

RocketPanda · 09/12/2021 09:26

Moggy managed to catch a cooled hot water bottle drag it to the top of the stairs and subsequently fell down whilst still holding onto it. Did not let go, did not fall on his feet. Had surgery yesterday and all going fine. Its not the first time he's done himself a mischief because he cannot cat properly. He was cleaning himself whilst sitting on the patio furniture, toppled and broke his tail last year. If he sees a mouse he just meows wistfully at it.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
8
thatsallineed · 15/12/2021 12:22

The smaller the cat, the larger the prey IMO.

Many years ago one of mine, a tiny ball of fluff, would bring home dead pheasants and hares twice the size she was.

Medium sized cat - baby rabbits, robins, frogs, stoats, and once, a mole. That, unfortunately, was still alive and made the most god-awful mess in the garden until she caught it again and finished the job.

One of my current overlords, the biggest fattest one, catches butterflies.

Although, having said all that, another big boy who currently goes under the name of Dickhead, was sitting in the front garden yesterday lunchtime staring intently upwards at his potential prey and waiting to pounce. At a red kite, which was circling overhead. It was similarly looking down at him.

SammyScrounge · 15/12/2021 11:55

@PurpleNebula84

Oh actually - just thought of something my cat does that is quite amusing - if hes out and I go for a walk, he will follow me but run in front of me and then turn around and hiss at ME for following HIM 🤷🏻‍♀️🤷🏻‍♀️😂😂 I once abandoned my car just off my estate due to traffic and he came all the way with me and I ended up having to give him a loft back as I wasn't sure if he had roamed there before 😂😂
Chauffeur for a cat! Loved that!
Notenoughchocolateomg · 13/12/2021 12:47

I've found my people! Mad cat lady here so loved reading all these posts about your hilarious cats!
My old cat Frank was so shit at being a cat. He actually lived next door to us, but the woman was really shouty so he moved himself in with us. They named him aptly though after Frank Spencer because he was just so stupid. He was hilarious to watch trying to walk along a fence! He had big goofy teeth and looked like Hitler. Our own cat accepted him in to our house and tried to teach him how to cat. She would bring moths inside and Frank would be terrified if they moved near him. He would then pretend he had killed the moth once it was already dead and would stalk around thinking he was well hard! He used to sleep on the grid in the garden and if dogs barked at him he'd see that as a sign to go right up to them! I miss that floofy thicko!

My cat now, well she's a true beauty, a real mummy's girl but tbh she struggles to cat. The most hard-core hunting she's managed to date is a woodlouse. She just likes to bring in feathers and the odd leaf and she's always so proud of herself! We have a microchip activated cat flap, when she stands next to it it makes a click to open and then she can walk out...in theory that is. In reality she stands there for bloody ages with the sodding thing keep clicking because she's so stupid she forgets every day how it works!

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 13/12/2021 12:27

I remember a thread on here, a few years ago, about the things MNers cats have caught and tried to bring in through the catflap - next door's Yorkshire terrier was a highlight, and also a big bird - maybe a pheasant!

LizzieW1969 · 12/12/2021 22:00

I have 3 cats, all of them aged 5. Two of them are really efficient hunters and regularly bring mice and birds (and rabbits) into our conservatory. The third cat, a male, is completely inept. He catches a mouse but then doesn’t know what to do with it. He lets it go and it hides from him, leaving him baffled. He reminds me of Tom from Tom and Jerry. Grin

The mice always end up being caught by one of our other cats.

Tom (not really his name) is a very affectionate cat, though, following us around everywhere and watching what we do. He’s even tolerant of my DD2 (9), who constantly wants to pick the cats up and cuddle them.

TAKESNOSHITSHIRLEY · 12/12/2021 21:32

ive got a cat with special needs

hes 12 soon and just not all there, been that way since birth.
hes a bit cross eyed and odd
hes a good cat though just not "normal "when it comes to other cats

its mad as my ex and 2 boys have disabilities as well

PurpleNebula84 · 12/12/2021 20:35

Oh actually - just thought of something my cat does that is quite amusing - if hes out and I go for a walk, he will follow me but run in front of me and then turn around and hiss at ME for following HIM 🤷🏻‍♀️🤷🏻‍♀️😂😂 I once abandoned my car just off my estate due to traffic and he came all the way with me and I ended up having to give him a loft back as I wasn't sure if he had roamed there before 😂😂

PurpleNebula84 · 12/12/2021 20:27

I'm loving these soooo much 🤣🤣🤣 I do have a cat, but he's actually very good at catting - went out the front door this morning to find a dead rat 🙈🙈🙈 Thank goodness he's given up bringing his presents through the cat flap now though - that's really gross.

tomorrowalready · 12/12/2021 16:42

Killing a spider seems to be surprisingly tricky for cats, I have often watched mine trapping and pouncing on the tiniest spider but it getting away. Maybe it's a case of 4 legs good, 8 legs better. My cat has a wide range of sounds from baby crying to deep , don't-dare-take- my- mouse-from-me growls, to territorial yowls but he cannot purr. He does not make a sound when he lets me stroke and pet him yet I can feel the vibration in his throat.

user1471538283 · 12/12/2021 08:31

My DBoycat is uncatlike apart from being quite aloof and a bit of a fussy eater. He doesn't see well so has never caught anything. He has never climbed, he runs oddly, he doesn't like heights, he doesn't sit on your lap and doesn't like a fuss. He can be temperamental and demanding. He is a gorgeous older boy and can be sweet.

sashh · 12/12/2021 06:52

When I was fostering I had a pair, one a beautiful white lady cat who was always dignified and a small all black male who didn't know he was a cat.

Black male (BM) made it his mission to escape, he ran up the fence and onto the roof (bungalow) and then cried to be got down, but wanted to be got down without being touched.

We nicknamed him, 'the joey cat' as he was pretty but dumb.

He almost caught a spider, my friend lifted him up, he put his paw on the spider, then moved it to check and the spider scuttled away.

I had a pretty bed cover, he would wrap himself in it until it looked like a bolster.

I had a sofa bed and a friend stayed, friend put the bed back into a sofa configuration and then we heard BM wailing from inside.

FW cat would just look at him with disdain.

I think the only time they interacted was when we took them to their new home (the same owners, had not been able to take them into temporary accommodation but had got a house) they got out of their carriers and saw........ stairs.

The just ran up and down the stairs mewing at each other.

Dontbeamugallyourlifesucker · 12/12/2021 06:43

Mine climbs the apple tree and falls into the birdbath underneath it most days!!! He climbs up to box at the few apples left on it😁🐱🐈 then cries at the door because he is wet!

ablutiions · 12/12/2021 05:40

Oh I forgot to add that current cat head it's furniture. It makes an audible thumping sound, and she looks a bit dazed and then does it again.

I love all of these daft cat tales.

ablutiions · 12/12/2021 05:38

Yep, had one of those. He used to play on the bannisters at the top of the stairs and fell off. Landed fine. Did it agin the next day, broke his leg.

The current one is very special . Will eat anything off the floor (like a dog), including cheesy wotsists, pieces of thread or wool etc and then vomit them up , generally on carpet, a few hours later.
She also does this thing when she sees you she throws herself to the floor in total adoration. Which is lovely but somewhat precarious when she's on top of a high fence, or the top of the stairs. She just falls off. Idiot. We love her so much thoughGrin

HappyDays40 · 12/12/2021 05:08

My cat drags things through the cat flap as a gift which I know he hasn't killed himself. Last one wass half rotted pigeon avec maggots that 8d seen my neighbours cat kill previously.

JaceLancs · 12/12/2021 01:06

My two Dcat are having a Xmas truce - they’ve forgotten how much they hate each other because it’s chilly and the tartan Xmas rugs are out!

Does anyone else have a cat who fails at being a cat?
Sistedtwister · 12/12/2021 00:25

I used to have 3 cats.
1 was a proper cat, could cat for England. His sister on the other hand, fell asleep and tumbled off the sofa head first in to a pint of water as a kitten, good job I was there to pull her out, ran head first into the garden gate and knocked herself out, got her tail trapped in the gate, brought me daffodil heads and follwed me to the pub, jumped on the bar and made herself at home.
I then was acquired by another cat (cruelty case). Would have nothing to do with me just appeared for tea. Stole hair bands, tea spoons and small change and stashed it in the attic. Fell utterly and completely in love with DH when he moved in ☺. I do miss them

GrrrlPwr · 11/12/2021 22:55

Our cat is scared of the birds in the garden. Crouches down so they 'cant see' her. Well they've just learnt that she is zero threat. And she can't climb. So stats safe in the garden. Embarrassingly crap at catting! But very lovely to cuddle

PolkadotsAndMoonbeams · 11/12/2021 17:50

When I was at university my flatmate had a cat. She'd come and cry at you until you walked her to her bowl and pointed at the food.

She also loved to snuggle on your knee if you were watching television, but half the time couldn't work out how to get up on the sofa to you. She'd put her paws against your shins and look sad, but wouldn't actually jump. If you tried to pick her up to put her next to you she'd instantly spit and stick her legs straight out. Hmm

haveyouopenedyourbowelstoday · 11/12/2021 17:41

My little Miss M never got the 'cats catch birds/mice/etc' memo. So she brings us bread that the neighbours throw out for the birds.
Today's offering was a stale bagel. She was so proud.

thatstheloveiwantiwantlove · 11/12/2021 17:24

@Stoneliz

My Xmas tree eating cat is also a pregnancy detector 😂 - he started to hump me literally every second he got - the horny little devil wouldn't leave me alone - I was actually waiting to start IVF so rather embarrassingly took him to the vets to check in case his nueuturing had reversed itself (I know I know looking back now I'm mortified!) the Vet laughed and sent me home to take a pregnancy test 🤦🏻‍♀️

Last year I was pregnant with twins so the horny little bastard went into overdrive - he enjoyed the 9 months more than I did at least! 😂

Stoneliz · 11/12/2021 15:00

I have 2 cats both rescues.

Phoebe is a typical lazy cat who finds the warmest spot and won't move. She only went hunting once and returned with 7 mouldy pears from the tree in the garden.

Hartley is a super-hunter. Athletic and a vicious killer but hampered by severe clumsiness. Hit by a car twice, fallen and ripped his entire leg, snapped his claws off. He costs me a fortune. But, he is so loving and sleeps under a duvet, fusses for hours, dribbles with excitement and sucks his own tail for comfort.

Both cats knew I was pregnant before I did and wouldn't leave me alone!

DingDongDenny · 11/12/2021 14:38

So our girl cat is in the dogbox today. She brought a live bird into the house at about 4.00am and in the scramble to catch it and release it, my DH has dislocated a toe. Meanwhile, she is sulking because we took her 'toy' off her

thenewduchessofhastings · 11/12/2021 12:35

Mine gets the concept of hunting things and catching them;once he catches them he has no idea what to do with them hence the reason I've had to catch an assortment of terrified/peeved off small creatures/insects in my house and release them back outside after he's brought them home as his new friends.

The worst was a very pissed off magpie under my table;those things are vicious;he/she didn't appreciate being carried in by my idiotic cat.

thatstheloveiwantiwantlove · 11/12/2021 12:24

My cat is currently sat eating the Christmas tree.......the artificial one 🤦🏻‍♀️