Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pay to be Poor

230 replies

LetterBug · 09/12/2021 07:58

Got sent into an un- arrangement overdraft and it costs £30. So you are fined for having no money. Meaning when I'm paid I will be £30 down from the off. Meaning I will more likely run out of money again. costing another £30.

Pay to be poor.

OP posts:
goingback · 10/12/2021 22:17

bosses get free parking at nearby car park , one parks and charges her Tesla no congestion charge , pleb staff can get reduced rate parking of £15 per day plus congestion charge for my older petrol car

Happyhappyday · 10/12/2021 20:15

OP you are absolutely right, you pay more to be poor in time and money at virtually every turn. I say that as someone who has been well off my whole life (2% not .1%). I see it and I have no idea what to do to help apart from pay my taxes and vote to increase them for people like me every chance I get.

Yesterday I popped into the cheaper chain of supermarkets where I live and all the queues were rammed (maybe 10-15 minute wait). I got annoyed and left knowing I can just pop to the expensive one near me and it won’t have a queue at all. And yet my time is less stressed, we’re a two income full time family with a reliable nanny (because we can afford to pay someone at the top of the local salary range) a cleaner & lots of retired older relatives around to help us. My supermarket should take longer in the queue because I can afford the time but it never will.

Reliable childcare means I won’t miss work because of illness and in any case I was able to pick a flexible employer because it didn’t matter if I was off work for a little longer.

And behind all of this is a deep well of family money that means we will never really worry about not paying bills.

I don’t know how we can change the inequality, either as individuals or as a society.

Joysutty · 10/12/2021 19:28

Yes, so unfair. My husband has an "arranged" overdraft that has no charges of think £200 whereas know if for people on benefits then the banks will not allow you to have a free overdraft facility. We check our online banking each morning and know its a hard time of the year for all thats unfortunately how the banks make their money. However my son at one time about 8 years ago made an appointment with his bank and got 2 x the overdraft charges back which think was about £10 each so that was good so its worth getting an appointment as you just never know the outcome. Once I myself get my weekly state pension in a few more years time (as it now 66 years of age) then it will certainly make our lives much more enjoyable + can afford a few more luxuries, as so many of my female friends got theirs at age of 60 (most of who are much better off than us in any case). But thats another great debate to talk upon for sure.

lightisnotwhite · 10/12/2021 19:26

And forgot about flying! Work means he’s got enough points for a BA lounge. So that’s free food and drinks ( including alcohol) for as long as you want in the comfy lounge. His work mean we can have a 3 hour lunch with unlimited wine and wine and fizz. Really nice showers and toilets too.
I get discounts and best prices as a budget conscious poor person but it’s not in the same league at all.

CayrolBaaaskin · 10/12/2021 19:24

It’s not true though that you can’t change pre payment meters. You can and it’s free (provided non payment wasn’t the reason it was put in in the first place). Also free food at work is pretty rare for most outside the restaurant trade

TheRemotePart · 10/12/2021 19:13

*only ask

TheRemotePart · 10/12/2021 19:12

My bank will let you have it back , but you can als ask once every 12 months ?

CayrolBaaaskin · 10/12/2021 19:10

Generally though the reason there are higher rates for poorer borrowers is because smaller loans with higher levels of default are more expensive for the bank. So they charge more. Micro finance for example has high interest rates - it’s an expensive way to borrow.

safariboot · 10/12/2021 18:47

@LetterBug

Got sent into an un- arrangement overdraft and it costs £30. So you are fined for having no money. Meaning when I'm paid I will be £30 down from the off. Meaning I will more likely run out of money again. costing another £30.

Pay to be poor.

Banks were prohibited from charging fees for overdrafts in 2019. They can only charge interest at a percentage rate, meaning a small overdraft costs a small amount of interest.

www.which.co.uk/news/2019/06/banks-banned-from-charging-extortionate-overdraft-fees/

Banks can reject a payment attempt (eg a Direct Debit) and charge a fee for that rejected payment, but these are supposed to be restricted.

So unless you ran up a big overdraft your bank may well be breaking the law.

mrsdaltongrant · 10/12/2021 18:44

I think if they don't refund its time to shop around for a bank with a free overdraft.

lightisnotwhite · 10/12/2021 18:33

Word.

My husband works freelance. Normally paid £35-50 a day for “expenses”. But travel or hotel plus crew catering are included for free with the work. So goodness know why they need any.
Meanwhile I get paid for my job, spend a fortune on petrol and walk ages to not pay for parking. I bring in a salad so I don’t spend £18 a week on meal deals.
He’s 3x my wage. We could do each other’s jobs.

Dibbydoos · 10/12/2021 18:22

Easy fix, call them, tell them you will never do it again but are struggling, they'll give it you back. All you have to do is try to stay in the black...!

EvilPea · 10/12/2021 18:10

The ones that get me is being ill. It costs so much to have a cold! Let alone prescription costs.

Cyw2018 · 10/12/2021 17:58

@MLMshouldbeillegal

the further up the ladder you go, the more free stuff you get. If you're really well off, you can even get free food!!

??? Waitrose having a secret deal where if you show them your bank statement you get a 25% discount?

Would love to know how this works.

Tesco was doing free kids meals last half term, so will hopefully continue this in future school holidays. They also do free babycinno. No obligation to buy anything at the same time.
2319inprogress · 10/12/2021 17:52

@fluffythedragonslayer

Thanks for comments re scout subs - we don't qualify as a low income family so not entitled to any financial help with anything. I can afford the installments just not all in one go.
This might be mad but I wonder if you could manage to stager the fees so that you could pay child1 3 terms then child2 3 terms etc rather than child123 1 term. Might be worth asking the leader
wentworthinmate · 10/12/2021 17:52

Money goes to money. My mother always said that and now I'm old(er) it is so true.

Lifethroughlenses · 10/12/2021 17:43

@fluffythedragonslayer that’s appalling. I thought the scouting association prided themselves on being accessible to all? I would query that - don’t be embarrassed about doing that. I’m horrified.

HaaaaaveyoumetTed · 10/12/2021 16:59

@MintJulia

What do you mean, you were 'sent' into an unarranged overdraft?

You spent more than you had?

Why don't you arrange an overdraft then?

Because an arranged overdraft is the privilege of the better off (and students). Banks don't allow people who would likely use an overdraft to have cheap one.
freezingtoes12 · 10/12/2021 16:53

@FissionMailed whilst I understand your point. This is just basic economies of scale. It’s always this way until you get into the wine game.

FissionMailed · 10/12/2021 15:33

@cinderhella

The poverty premium is very real.
I saw it today, or an example thereof

Washing liquid.
Look at per ltr price, it gets cheaper the more you spend. If you have £10 for a big bottle it's considerably better value than of you only have £2 for a bottle.

cinderhella · 10/12/2021 14:36

The poverty premium is very real.

RandomLondoner · 10/12/2021 14:24

Interestingly, Barclays also say that if you do go overdrawn, because they've been unable to stop a payment, they won't charge any interest.

I think OP needs to move to a different bank.

RandomLondoner · 10/12/2021 14:20

I have just googled Barclays, as a random UK bank, as I wanted to find out how it was possible to be charged £30 for an unauthorised overdraft. They first page I've found say they don't do them, they will just not make payment, which is as it should be. I guess they changed what they do when charging for unauthorised overdrafts was banned.

RandomLondoner · 10/12/2021 14:16

"original debtor" is wrong, I meant original organisation you owe money to.

RandomLondoner · 10/12/2021 14:14

@BoredZelda

And they dont HAVE to let the DD go through that pushes you into your unarranged overdraft or let you draw out money that pushes you into it either, but why would they stop it when they can hammer you with a £30 fee and charge you daily fees.

Of course they do. A DD is an instruction to your bank to pay an amount. If your account has an overdraft facility they can dip in to it. If you don’t want that, and would prefer payments to be rejected, ask for your account to have no overdraft facility. But if you know a DD is going to put you in to overdraft, call your bank.

You've overlooked that she did not have an overdraft facility. Bank accounts should work the way you assume, but the way most UK banks have always worked is that they let you go overdrawn anyway and then charge you even more than they would if you had wanted an overdraft in the first place.

She would have been better off if the bank had just not made the payment. By making the payment on her behalf, the bank substitutes a debt to itself for an amount owed to someone else, charging her an enormous fee for the privilege. (This is so outrageous that, as a number of posters have pointed out, it has been banned. OP has not addressed how come this is happening when it's no longer allowed.)

It is outrageous that Banks allow payments to create unauthorised overdrafts in any circumstance than a person having explicitly opted in to them doing so. One can get bank accounts that don't, but they are exceptional, possibly because they aren't very profitable for banks.

I also disagree that she should have an overdraft. The best solution to the problem of outgoings exceeding income is to stop the outgoings, make the original debtor wait for the money, not switch the debt to someone who will charge you more for the privilege.