Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pay to be Poor

230 replies

LetterBug · 09/12/2021 07:58

Got sent into an un- arrangement overdraft and it costs £30. So you are fined for having no money. Meaning when I'm paid I will be £30 down from the off. Meaning I will more likely run out of money again. costing another £30.

Pay to be poor.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Dontwanttolivewithmylover · 29/12/2021 09:37

Banks are businesses. How else do you think they operate? As for overdrafts. They are, in essence, lending you that money so are entitled to charge you interest.
Regarding paying car tax over a period of time instead of all in one go, the same thing applies. They are virtually paying it in full and you repay them monthly, plus interest.
I can never understand how people think they shouldn't pay extra in these circumstances. If you want a loan you pay interest commensurate with the amount and length of the loan period. Overdrafts and car tax etc are no different.
I lend money to people in need but the risks of default mean my interest rates are 8% and above, depending on the size of the loan.

LetterBug · 18/12/2021 14:17

@thepastisanothercountry

I was thinking about this when I bought my bus pass today and I was shocked when I realised.

I pay £65 for a 28 day bus pass.

A daysaver on the local buses is £4. (basically anything more than a single ticket which is £2.20)

Assuming I use my bus pass for 20 days working and perhaps 2 weekend days I will pay about £3 a day but a person doing the same journey who cant afford the ticket upfront will pay £4... so by the end of the 22 days they have paid £88. They have now paid £23 more than me AND I still have the option to use it on the other 6 days if I want to.

So by the end of the year the person who can't afford the pass up front has spent £299 more than me for the same thing and more if they need to travel on the other 6 days.

Now that's paying to be poor and I'd never thought of it before today.

This is true to another level. But add to it, if you need to get bread but can't afford to get the bus pass for the whole month then you have to buy bread from the local corner shop because it isn't time efficient to go to the supermarket 30 min walk away for one loaf of bread. So I stead of paying 30p for a loaf of bread if you had a bus pass (which as you said costs less than using the bus without one) you now have to pay £1.45 for a loaf of Warburtons in the corner shop. But please god make sure you have the £1.45 in change other wise you will have to buy something else to reach the £5 limit and try not to cry on the way home.
OP posts:
Downtherefordancing · 18/12/2021 10:33

The system is so silly.
I had to call EDF this week to say I couldn’t afford their new monthly DD (gone from £84 a month to £190). The person I spoke to said they couldn’t reduce it so my only option was to cancel the DD and I’d have to get in touch in Jan to work out a payment plan.
EDF’s response? They have now put me on a higher rate for gas and electricity so my debt will build up a bit quicker.
Thanks EDF 😡

Cloakedmerry · 12/12/2021 00:36

I’ve done that a few times in the past and rang my bank and got it back

Beachmummy23 · 11/12/2021 23:41

Seriously change your bank account. Over ten years ago I ended up going bankrupt due to getting into such a mess with bank fees. Every month it was more and more. After bankruptcy I got a basic bank account no overdraft etc but no fees if something bounces. I refuse to upgrade my account despite earning good money and owning my own home. The cycle is too dangerous.

PegasusReturns · 11/12/2021 23:31

Im sorry OP that’s tough. It’s true it’s expensive to have no money.

??? Waitrose having a secret deal where if you show them your bank statement you get a 25% discount?

@MLMshouldbeillegal Hmm

I have a corporate job and get fed regularly: salads and sandwiches most days I’m in the office and plenty of dinners out.

There’s a constant supply of chocolate, biscuits and soft drinks, nights out and treats sent to my home address for various celebrations.

thepastisanothercountry · 11/12/2021 23:07

I was thinking about this when I bought my bus pass today and I was shocked when I realised.

I pay £65 for a 28 day bus pass.

A daysaver on the local buses is £4. (basically anything more than a single ticket which is £2.20)

Assuming I use my bus pass for 20 days working and perhaps 2 weekend days I will pay about £3 a day but a person doing the same journey who cant afford the ticket upfront will pay £4... so by the end of the 22 days they have paid £88. They have now paid £23 more than me AND I still have the option to use it on the other 6 days if I want to.

So by the end of the year the person who can't afford the pass up front has spent £299 more than me for the same thing and more if they need to travel on the other 6 days.

Now that's paying to be poor and I'd never thought of it before today.

GrealishHairband · 11/12/2021 15:37

@DameCelia way more than that, and to be fair I’m thinking more people who earn money outside of being employed. I know a relative who is so wealthy they’ve been able to avoid paying any tax whatsoever by leaving the country. Something which just isn’t an option for anyone who is employed, it’s deducted at source and the more you earn the more you pay. Super Wealthy SE people can afford whole teams of accountants to maximise efficiencies and loopholes and can definitely minimise the amount they pay as they have enough to make their money work for them as opposed to working for their money in many respects.

Coldcoffeeclub · 11/12/2021 14:48

@absolutelynotfabulous

Bailiff action following CCJs etc doesn't come out of the blue, and neither do the bailiffs on Can't Pay (usually).

The biggest irony (in case no one has already mentioned it) is bankruptcy, which costs £680. You couldn't make it up!

When I had to go bankrupt I withdrew the fee on a high interest credit card that would then get written off with the bankruptcy - if you can get the credit for the fee somehow it is ok but otherwise I agree it is crazy!
WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 11/12/2021 14:20

Are people still having to use top up cards for electricity at hugely inflated cost?

I don’t understand how that’s even legal.

It's legal because those in charge of making the law are very much not in a position of needing to pay for their bills that way; so at best, it just doesn't register with them as 'a thing' and at worst, they simply don't care - as it's the poor folks' fault for not wanting not to be poor, or something like that.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 11/12/2021 14:17

But remember, they will charge you too if you can't manage your money. Learn to do that and you will be quids in.

I think this is the attitude that most better-off people seem to have towards the poor: that it's just that they spend recklessly and/or can't be bothered to budget sensibly. Whilst there are some like that, a great many simply have no choice.

If you had a bucket of water with absolutely no access to any more, but had to fill a bathtub to the brim with it, in order to 'earn' the essentials that you need for life - how much wisdom, prudence, care, budgeting and grasping of opportunity do you think it would take before you would succeed and could then live without worry?

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 11/12/2021 14:08

I would do what I can to improved my situation or earnings in your position. Also, check your outgoings and see if you can reduce some expenses. If it is not possible now make a plan. Do not leave your money in an overdraft. We live in a country with many opportunities but we need to see the forest for the trees. May be you can’t do it now but have a plan to leave poverty. I was you in the past so hopefully you can too.

I know you mean well, but your advice seems to boil down to 'try to stop being poor' - as if most poor people have never thought of that.

Also, you don't leave your money in an overdraft - it's the bank's money that you're having to borrow, as you don't currently have enough yourself - so the exact opposite.

I agree with you that it's always good to be looking for opportunities to increase income and/or lower outgoings, but those opportunities simply won't always exist for everybody, however hard they may try.

DameCelia · 11/12/2021 13:09

@HaaaaaveyoumetTed
Thanks, so barristers, CEOs of big companies etc.

HaaaaaveyoumetTed · 11/12/2021 10:46

[quote DameCelia]@GrealishHairband
What sort of schemes are there? (And what is proper rich?, Inherited estate? Earning over £100k a year? Earning over NMW?)[/quote]
Top 3% probably. Which is household incomes of roughly £500k+ I think.

Skyll · 11/12/2021 10:43

Yes @MrsSkylerWhite. Very common still.

MrsSkylerWhite · 11/12/2021 10:43

Are people still having to use top up cards for electricity at hugely inflated cost?

I don’t understand how that’s even legal.

HaaaaaveyoumetTed · 11/12/2021 10:41

@Mere1

The more you earn, the more tax you pay, including vat on purchases. ,and this is used to benefit everyone.
Except the proper rich aren't rich due to earnings. There rich due to income from holding companies and investments. It's possible to massively reduce the tax you pay when income isn't through PAYE earnings.
CatsArePeople · 11/12/2021 10:15

This is shocking isn't it? I've always commented on celebrities being offered things for free as part of a promotion but this above must be the case for so many highly paid people.

There are rules and contracts too. I remember there was this celebrity who had to pay a massive fine because she wore a wrong designer's watch to an event. Cartier instead of Gucci, or something like that.

Hoppinggreen · 11/12/2021 09:42

We not proper rich and we pay all taxes we have to.
BUT due to various perfectly legal schemes etc we are able to pay a lot less tax (pro rata) than a MW job I’m sure
We are hardly in the sending it all offshore league but we have a good Accountant and via work I also have access to things that reduce my tax bill

DameCelia · 11/12/2021 09:18

@GrealishHairband
What sort of schemes are there? (And what is proper rich?, Inherited estate? Earning over £100k a year? Earning over NMW?)

GrealishHairband · 11/12/2021 08:59

Nah if you’re proper rich then there’s all sorts of tax saving schemes out there.

Mere1 · 11/12/2021 06:55

The more you earn, the more tax you pay, including vat on purchases. ,and this is used to benefit everyone.

fournonblondes · 11/12/2021 05:56

I would do what I can to improved my situation or earnings in your position. Also, check your outgoings and see if you can reduce some expenses. If it is not possible now make a plan. Do not leave your money in an overdraft. We live in a country with many opportunities but we need to see the forest for the trees. May be you can’t do it now but have a plan to leave poverty. I was you in the past so hopefully you can too.

sjpkgp1 · 11/12/2021 00:54

I know @LetterBug did not especially mention Beaver / Cub or Scout subs, but others have, notably @fluffythedragonslayer. And then mentioned by @bupyloulou, @ragwort, @DownToTheSeaAgain, @hivemindneeded. @Chasingsquirrels. @AnneElliott, @WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll. Thank you all for the comments, they are spot on. Like others listed above, I'm involved in a group, and sometimes people struggle to afford it when there is so much going out for other things. One quick (and confidential) email to the GSL, which is shared with the Treasurer only about subs tends to do the job. Nobody who volunteers in Scouting EVER wants to see a child unable to come because of the money. Not all groups are cash rich (and they are independent charities), but even the groups that have to fund-raise etc. have recourse to their District, and ultimately, to County, and then Nationally to get a bit of support. I'm a GSL, and would honestly rather stand down than someone not be able to come, and I think I speak for most of our volunteers. xxx

Mirw · 10/12/2021 23:42

"banks aren't businesses". Where did you get that idea? Banks are there to make money from their customers - you! They are not charities that give money/services to you with no payback. You use theircservices, you pay for them. If you want to pay less, try your local credit union. But remember, they will charge you too if you can't manage your money. Learn to do that and you will be quids in. I can now manage everything bar the rent in £800 a, month. Rent is always paid first...