Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the anti-lockdown brigade have been proved right?

393 replies

Libertaire · 08/12/2021 19:34

We were told that if we all got vaccinated life would return to normal, and that process would be ‘cautious but irreversible’. So we complied. I am triple-jabbed and extremely grateful for the work of the brilliant scientists who made this possible.

Yet now, we are heading inexorably back into another lockdown. The fear mongering is being ratcheted up day by day. If this was ever about public health, it cannot be now because everyone who is vulnerable to covid has been offered at least two doses of vaccine.

We surrendered our freedoms willingly, to protect ourselves and one another and because we believed that we would get them back. But that isn’t happening, is it? An authoritarian government has confiscated them permanently and we will never get them back until we take them back, which is what anti-lockdown campaigners said from the start. They have been proved right, haven’t they?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
montysma1 · 09/12/2021 00:31

Whats been proved is that lock downs prevent the absolute collapse of the health system. Which is what we were told it was for.
All the freedom whingers achieve is more cases and more pressure on hospitals.

MrsPsmalls · 09/12/2021 00:31

Of course they will comply. If there is a proper lockdown there is no option. How will they attend the theatre,football eat out if everything is shut? How will they visit relatives in hospital if they are banned? Send kids to school if they are closed?

fluffi · 09/12/2021 00:27

We're nowhere near another lockdown ... WFH is only being introduced on Monday. This time last year we were still WFH and were considering ourselves extremely lucky if were were going to be allowed back by Spring! Football is still on, nightclubs are still open (remember they only opened in the summer), large events are still allowed. There is not even any talk of restricting gathering sizes, aka rule of 6 or social distancing in hospitality or other settings yet.

Masks, WFH and covid passes do not equal a lockdown! Masks and covid passes enable us to get on with things as much as possble!

MountainDweller · 09/12/2021 00:26

What lockdown? The U.K... no, England... now has similar restrictions to the those that rest of (the continent of) Europe has had since the summer. While England has been enjoying 'freedom' we have been quietly wearing masks indoors, using vaccine passports and working from home where possible. Until recently our cases were 1/10th of the UK's. Stop whinging!

sst1234 · 09/12/2021 00:20

Get real folks and stop with the ‘oh but there’s no lockdown’. A lockdown is coming. Many on MN and within general public love lockdowns.

For those that don’t like being locked down, what will you do? Serious question, will you comply?

Nancydrawn · 09/12/2021 00:17

[quote AutomaticMoon]charleseisenstein.substack.com/p/mob-morality-and-the-unvaxxed[/quote]
Of course Charles Eisenstein has a substack. Of course he does.

BoredZelda · 09/12/2021 00:05

Scotland never stopped wearing masks or wfh

Hardly anyone I know still works from home unless it is their preferred option.

Hardly anyone wears masks either. Except in my daughter’s high school, where there have been a some isolated cases but no outbreak. Three kids in her class have tested positive at different times since August. There have been no contact cases in her class.

NoddyMcdoddy · 09/12/2021 00:04

[quote AutomaticMoon]@FromEden I was just about to post links to the stats about how in Ireland 100% of people dying with covid were vaccinated. You can infer different things from this, eg: are the deaths being counted as ‘with’ covid or ‘due to covid’. And 100% vaccinated Gibraltar is having a major outbreak and major restrictions. People are so liberal with their scapegoating of the unvaccinated, there’s actually a good article about that, how this isn’t a logical process but the ancient practice of scapegoating which is not logic based.[/quote]
What stats are these ? Currently 60% of deaths in Ireland due to covid are in the unvaccinated group and considering this cohort is less than 10% of the population that equates to a significant more number of deaths attributed to being unvaccinated.

The stats speak for themselves vaccines reduce deaths

To think the anti-lockdown brigade have been proved right?
Rummikub · 09/12/2021 00:02

Is that true /\

doublemonkey · 09/12/2021 00:02

[quote Firkinhavinalaugh]@doublemonkey that’s a false argument, the mutations don’t come from the vaccinated.[/quote]
I'm sorry but that is absolute nonsense. What a ridiculous thing to say.

Firkinhavinalaugh · 09/12/2021 00:01

@doublemonkey that’s a false argument, the mutations don’t come from the vaccinated.

Firkinhavinalaugh · 08/12/2021 23:57

A lockdown would be irritating but better. key here is WFH if you are in retail or hospitality of any sort you are expected to be at work, with far fewer customers ( as they’re wfh) but without the benefit of furlough or rate reductions.

It’s shit with a capital S

doublemonkey · 08/12/2021 23:45

@lisaandalan

The trouble is not everyone has been vaccinated, which is their choice but because of this, the virus will keep mutating and even though the vaccinated will not get as Ill as the unvaccinated, we will keep spreading it around because of the number of non vaccinated it gives the virus chance to keep getting stronger.
This doesn't make sense. There are likely to be way more mutations in vaccinated people. Firstly because there are way more of them and they're more likely to be infected but asymptomatic.

Also just to point out, you can only spread an illness if you actually have that disease. You can't spread a virus by being unvaccinated.

TheGoogleMum · 08/12/2021 23:42

It's nothing like a lockdown. Nothing will change for me as I already work from home when I can (I can't often) and wear masks most indoor places. I'm unlikely to go to any large gatherings but if I did I'm up to date with vaccines so no problem

Puzzledandpissedoff · 08/12/2021 23:38

Johnson did say once they know if vaccines will work ok with this variant, there will have to be a National conversation about what will happen next

I confess I found that amusing - not the concept, but the suggestion that the public would be involved

I don't know how many posters have been involved in government "consultations", but IME they generally work by them deciding what they're going to do, pretending to listen to others' views (though with ill hidden irritation) and then doing whatever it was anyway

rossclare · 08/12/2021 23:34

But right now.

We aren’t in lockdown.

UserOfManyNames · 08/12/2021 23:32

So the Illuminati have got the world’s governments and top scientists in their pockets Grin. Covid is happening globally not just in the UK.

The fact is Covid is a NOVEL (which means new for the hard of thinking) virus and we have not had long enough to study it to see what it can mutate into. New mutations are always going to be a worry as we won’t know the effect they can have on the body. Therefore it makes sense to limit the spread, to reduce the mutations for a start, which with an AIRBORNE virus means keeping away from others and keeping your respiratory inhalations to yourself.

If another lockdown happens, it’ll be because of twats who refuse to wear masks and kept their distance not because the illuminati want to keep tabs on you (are you really that interesting?), or control your mind and create 8 billion zombie slaves.

lisaandalan · 08/12/2021 23:32

The trouble is not everyone has been vaccinated, which is their choice but because of this, the virus will keep mutating and even though the vaccinated will not get as Ill as the unvaccinated, we will keep spreading it around because of the number of non vaccinated it gives the virus chance to keep getting stronger.

Janeandjohnny · 08/12/2021 23:30

@LizzieSiddal

Ithrnonoy reason we are having to ace Plan B is because people aren’t getting vaccinated.

Johnson did say once they know if vaccines will work ok with this variant, there will have to be a National conversation about what will happen next.

No, the only reason he introduced this all of a sudden is to divert attention from the christmas party scenario. He was quite happy to have lots of people dying every day up to now. He only wants power, nothing else.
AutomaticMoon · 08/12/2021 23:29

@skeptile charleseisenstein.substack.com/p/mob-morality-and-the-unvaxxed

Puzzledandpissedoff · 08/12/2021 23:28

could you please explain to us all why it is that there have been lockdowns in many other countries. Is that all about the NHS as well??

I can't comment about countries of which I have no experience, but venal politicians are hardly exclusive to the UK and I'd be very surprised if those elsewhere don't have something to sell to their cronies, even if it's not a state health system. Generally, where there's advantage to be taken of a population who've been deliberately frightened (see SAGE minutes) then politicians will take it

... there is no evidence to suggest that further (vaccine) doses will make things better

It could well make things better for the pharma companies in terms of pure monetary gain; I assume people have noted what's happened to their share prices since the summer?
And before people start bouncing up and down I'm not suggesting that's their only motivation in this ... simply that it's another example of profits which can be made from Covid

doublemonkey · 08/12/2021 23:28

[quote PieMistee]@doublemonkey People not getting vaccinated per se haven't caused all the hospital waiting lists but they sure as fuck have made them longer.[/quote]
That's not true though, is it. Hospital numbers and deaths are going down. There's a massive backlog, nearly two years worth of other medical issues to be dealt with.

This figure won't be reducing, and will continue to grow, because GP's are still not seeing people and it's nearly fucking impossible to get any medical treatment at the moment.

Don't blame healthy people going about their business for NHS winter overcrowding.

PizzaCrust · 08/12/2021 23:24

@Libertaire

It is wise to take a step back and realise that there is a very likely chance, especially with a new variant, that they will pull the plug on gatherings over Christmas once again.

Well, they can try, but it’s highly likely that if they do tens of millions of fully vaccinated people will tell them exactly where to stick their lockdown. Especially as the rules don’t apply to them, of course.

They can’t arrest us all, you know…

I wouldn't be so confident on that one.

There will be a lot of work at play over the coming weeks. People generally have very short memories. How many lockdowns did we have last year? And the majority complied, despite saying with each lockdown they'd never do another one again. People complied over Christmas despite how it was taken away with so little notice.

A lot of people cannot afford fines, especially for so many guests as Christmas' usually has. A lot of people are still very worried about Covid, and so the news of a new variant will be frightening to them. The old 'protect the NHS' slogan will be out in full force.

Think about all the government rule breakers from last year. Dominic Cummings, Margaret Ferrier, and so on. There's very little mentioned about them now, isn't there?

A new drama always overshadows old news. It's how things work in the media. And the government have enough time to overshadow the party scandal with something seemingly 'much much worse'.