Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think father should pay csa even if he doesn't want the baby

365 replies

Bear45 · 08/12/2021 18:03

As title says!
He wanted me to have an abortion and I've not heard off him for 3 weeks now. I'm 13 weeks, obviously it's a way off but just wondering what peoples opinions are

OP posts:
Ionlydomassiveones · 08/12/2021 19:59

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

PleasantBirthday · 08/12/2021 19:57

Why does the moral solution never involve anything difficult for men?

Woodmarsh · 08/12/2021 19:56

‘No baby conceived has to be born’ what a horrible sentence.

Don’t worry little baby foetus you didn’t survive because your Daddy didn’t want to support you financially.

@numbertime it's true though it doesn't have to be born and a parent not wanting it is a good reason for it not to be. At that stage it is just a foetus, a collection of cells

HugeAckmansWife · 08/12/2021 19:56

My dp has always been adamant he wants no children (now, we both have them from previous relationships). When we first met, I was on the pill, he used condoms and usually withdrew as well. Over time that relaxed until it was just the pill but one night we were talking and I said I wouldn't have an abortion if there was a failure. He looked into and booked a vasectomy the following week. That is a grown up approach. Not having all the fun and then expecting someone else to bear the consequences alone, whether that be raising a child or aborting. It's really really simple. Men have several choices. Abstain (which is perfectly do-able, sex isn't some god given right or necessity unless you're an INCEL), take responsibility for own contraception, being aware it may fail, don't have PIV full sex or accept that you may become a father with a pretty fucking minimal cms contribution to pay.

TractorAndHeadphones · 08/12/2021 19:55

[quote WhatWhenWhoWhy]@TractorAndHeadphones

No contraception is 100% so there is still a risk of pregnancy. Even if they both agree prior to sex they do not want a baby there is still a risk of pregnancy. Even if the women says she will abort prior to sex, there is still a risk of pregnancy.

BOTH parties play a part here, BOTH contributed to creating the child, BOTH should take responsibility.

The focus should not be on what the woman wants, but on what the child needs.

And yes ideally I'd suggest to any woman who doesn't want any medical procedure to not have sex, because having sex can lead to just that! That does not negate on what the child needs though. The child is not to blame for any failings of its parents. And there are two of them![/quote]
Hmm I see where you’re coming from.
Legally - if the woman keeps the baby and someone has to pay then the father should be made to pay rather than the taxpayer.
Morally - the woman should abort the baby if she can’t pay for it herself and the father doesn’t want to.

However because you can’t force women to abort babies, or let children starve, the most efficient solution is to make the father pay.

Numbertime · 08/12/2021 19:53

‘No baby conceived has to be born’ what a horrible sentence.

Don’t worry little baby foetus you didn’t survive because your Daddy didn’t want to support you financially.

Anordinarymum · 08/12/2021 19:53

This is a difficult one because after eleven years of taking the pill it could be/would most likely be assumed all was OK.
If he asked her to have an abortion this means he did not want her to get pregnant and made it clear from the beginning his lack of interest.
The fact OP decided to have the baby was her choice and not his.

Tiredtiredtired100 · 08/12/2021 19:51

I was in the same position and have chosen not to. Never even really considered it as, like you, I’m financially sound on my own, but also because my ex was abusive and I didn’t want to poke the bear (as they say).

That being said, I see no moral problem with you claiming it and if I was you (I.e. not afraid of my ex) I would do so and put the money aside for my child in later life or for emergencies for them. Ultimately even if he’s a low earner that maintenance money could go a long way in time and secure your child’s future.

Georgy12 · 08/12/2021 19:48

@Rabblesthecat

I go against the grain - no they should not.

Everyone (including the mother) has a choice up to 22 weeks. It may be a choice you don’t want to make but you are still making a choice the other way to keep it.

No baby conceived has to be born so I don’t see why they should have to pay if they have no say in its existence.

He had his say when he chose to have sex, that's the risk he took. If he absolutely didn't want a child, keep it zipped, simple.
Numbertime · 08/12/2021 19:48

@Bunnyfuller so men have no responsibility at all of contraception then? Unbelievable!

WhatWhenWhoWhy · 08/12/2021 19:48

@TractorAndHeadphones

No contraception is 100% so there is still a risk of pregnancy. Even if they both agree prior to sex they do not want a baby there is still a risk of pregnancy. Even if the women says she will abort prior to sex, there is still a risk of pregnancy.

BOTH parties play a part here, BOTH contributed to creating the child, BOTH should take responsibility.

The focus should not be on what the woman wants, but on what the child needs.

And yes ideally I'd suggest to any woman who doesn't want any medical procedure to not have sex, because having sex can lead to just that! That does not negate on what the child needs though. The child is not to blame for any failings of its parents. And there are two of them!

MintJulia · 08/12/2021 19:46

@Rabblesthecat You haven't heard of them because those who get pregnant and choose to terminate, do so quietly and without fanfare because it is seldom an easy or happy decision.

The incidents you hear about are normally when the woman chooses to keep the baby and the man expresses his outrage noisily and indignantly, tries to pressure her into terminating etc.

Bunnyfuller · 08/12/2021 19:46

@getsanta the point at which a woman allows an unprotected penis into her vagina she implicitly accepts there may be a baby.

Unless he forced it or the contraceptives failed it is as much on her.

Bunnyfuller · 08/12/2021 19:44

Without the full facts of any attempts by either of them to avoid pregnancy I would say it’s impossible to say.

If stringent contraception failed then it’s her call.

If they consensually had unprotected sex then it’s on both of them, and she is not being fair by expecting her joint recklessness to be upheld.

Although the whole idea is someone else taking responsibility. If he doesn’t pay, taxpayers will.

getsanta · 08/12/2021 19:43

The point where a man puts his penis inside a woman’s vagina is the point where he takes responsibility for any child that is a product of that act.

100% agree. Otherwise, who is responsible? A single mother and, unfortunately, often the tax payer. Not being right wing about it, it's the truth that a large proportion of those entitled to benefits are single mothers who have been left holding the bag by feckless sperm donors.

Sofiegiraffe · 08/12/2021 19:40

@drpet49

** Rabblesthecat I go against the grain - no they should not.

Everyone (including the mother) has a choice up to 22 weeks. It may be a choice you don’t want to make but you are still making a choice the other way to keep it.

No baby conceived has to be born so I don’t see why they should have to pay if they have no say in its existence.

I agree with this 💯**

^I agree with this too.

I also agree with this.
getsanta · 08/12/2021 19:40

@MrsLarry

What about situations where the woman lies about taking contraception? The woman that's decided she wants a baby no matter what? This happens a lot more than you think.
Too bad.
Woodmarsh · 08/12/2021 19:39

FabianK

I’ve always thought men should be able to opt out of parental responsibility including csa payments up to a certain time.

Women can make a choice and men should be able to also.

That is more than fair.

Agreed. Just because you get pregnant you don't have to stay pregnant.

Women bringing babies into a world where they know the father won't be around and money will be tight times hard etc and all the disadvantages that brings are incredibly selfish

Krakenchorus · 08/12/2021 19:38

Of course the father should pay. The money is to raise the child he created by having sex. That child exists and needs to be looked after by the two parents who created him or her. I don't see what the possibility of abortion has to do with it, or whether the mum put the Dad's name on the birth certificate, or whether he has contact with the child, or whether mum lied about being on the pill, or whatever. That's all smoke and mirrors.

Had sex. Child born. Dad pays.

The money is about the child, and for the child, not about the circumstances of its conception or the continuation of the pregnancy.

flippertyop · 08/12/2021 19:36

I don't think he should but I think legally he has to

dworky · 08/12/2021 19:35

Of course, he impregnated a woman so is liable to pay for the upbringing of his child.

Heatherjayne1972 · 08/12/2021 19:33

Yes he should pay
Go through cms. My ex was so awkward they actually go into his account to take the money whether or not he likes it !!

If he’s the dad then yes he should pay something regardless of if he’s involved in baby’s life

JaniceBattersby · 08/12/2021 19:33

The point where a man puts his penis inside a woman’s vagina is the point where he takes responsibility for any child that is a product of that act.

Sex is not compulsory. If you do not want to take responsibility for a child then do not have sex with a woman. It’s really that simple. If men actually thought about the consequences of their actions for one second before having sex then they would not be ‘forced’ Hmm into pay for a child they don’t want.

gogohm · 08/12/2021 19:33

I think if it's a contraceptive failure and he states at a very early stage (eg under 8 weeks when medical abortions are still possible) he doesn't want the child and you go ahead saying you are willing to raise the baby alone no you shouldn't put him on the birth certificate or claim csa

TractorAndHeadphones · 08/12/2021 19:31

@WhatWhenWhoWhy

but she must accept the consequences of that choice

And equally men have to also, if they have sex.

Men are choosing to have sex, they are choosing to do that knowing there is a possibility of pregnancy.

Women, due to their biology, are able to consider whether to have the baby once pregnant. Men don't, because they don't have the same biology and don't risk a medical procedure either way.

At the end of the day though, this isn't about some or men's rights, this is about the rights of the existing child.

But the child wouldn’t exist if aborted. That’s my point. Men and women go into sex knowing it could result in pregnancy. According to the law women can make the choice whether to keep it - fine. However what’s not fine is that a man has no say in whether to pay for it.

Consider this scenario ; both man and woman on birth control, agreed that any child as a result of failure would be aborted. However if it happens woman chooses to keep it then she should be responsible. She could have aborted it if she didn’t want it. In the OP’s case she’s financially able.

Also single women can have children with sperm donors - we don’t make the sperm donors pay do we?

If a woman wanted zero medical procedures or zero chance of anything she should not have sex. End of.

Btw in this case the man is culpable as he didn’t use protection. Howveer im talking about the general idea

Swipe left for the next trending thread