Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think father should pay csa even if he doesn't want the baby

365 replies

Bear45 · 08/12/2021 18:03

As title says!
He wanted me to have an abortion and I've not heard off him for 3 weeks now. I'm 13 weeks, obviously it's a way off but just wondering what peoples opinions are

OP posts:
HugeAckmansWife · 08/12/2021 20:20

I think that this idea 100% stems from a deeply ingrained belief that men should not have to do anything they don't want to do, but women are always expected to just cope with whatever. Look at the last 18 months. Studies have shown its been working women who have done the vast majority of homeschooling, isolation childcare and wfh juggling. Men can't possibly compromise their Big Job with such things. So assuming the pregnancy is a genuine error, contraception failure, there is a child. With two parents. Biology dictates in this one small area the woman has both the 'advantage' of the extra option of abortion but also the 'disadvantage' of having to have the abortion, or the pregnancy and birth and postpartum injuries, loss of earnings, pension, career progression etc. And men (and some woman) are complaining that a man in this situation shouldn't have to ring fence 20% of his post - pension contribution pay to support the child. He can't be forced to go on pat leave, work part time, pay for childcare, spend time or emotional energy on the child. Just a pretty minimal financial contribution. But that would be totally unfair apparently.

getsanta · 08/12/2021 20:20

There are far more contraceptives available to women than men.

And should they be left holding the bag when it fails?

TurnUpTurnip · 08/12/2021 20:19

Unpopular opinion but my kids dad doesn’t see them at all (his choice) for this reason I do not claim cm, I don’t want to take money off someone that doesn’t want to see my children, that’s my choice though and I get others feel differently

DroopyClematis · 08/12/2021 20:19

Yes men can choose not to have sex but so can women.
If a man wears a condom , that has failed, then it's a tricky situation.

Women are allowed body autonomy.
They can have a coil, the pill, injections, implants, female condom and insert spermicidals.

Women are allowed a morning after pill or , at an extreme, an abortion.

There are far more contraceptives available to women than men.

ForbiddentoForbid · 08/12/2021 20:18

@Rabblesthecat @TractorAndHeadphones you're correct, my apologies, I tagged the wrong poster.

SparklyGlasses · 08/12/2021 20:17

He should pay, yes. However, you're left with the situation you have rather than a morally correct ideal.

In my case, I chose not to pursue child maintenance for various reasons and I think it helped DC's Dad become involved - because he was a twat who would have used any excuse not to be but actually now many years on, DC feels loved by him (because, for all ex's failings he can be loving - not true of everyone of course!) and that is worth a huge amount.

I don't understand why people are comparing the father and the mother's situation in this - it's totally different due to the physicality of the situation for the mother. Nobody should be manipulated into an abortion, not through threats of no CM or anything else - the idea is abhorrent (and I'm pro choice). And the maintenance isn't for the mother, it's for the child. Regardless of tales of women spending it on having their nails done, nights out etc, realistically most CM paid makes a small dent in the costs of raising a child.

WonderfulYou · 08/12/2021 20:17

I'm an ardent feminist but I do think if the sperm donor wants nothing to do with the child there should be some mechanism within the abortion window where they can relinquish parental responsibility and have no financial obligations. The woman can then proceed with the pregnancy knowing this, or at that point have an abortion. I think there are women who would prefer this as well, knowing they have no contact obligations in the future.

I agree but this is something you have to think about too OP.

My DDs dad didn’t want to be involved and I didn’t claim maintenance or ask anything from him.
But 10 years later he decided he wanted to get involved which was very frustrating as he made a decision to not be involved.
So he could change his mind later on after you’ve done all of the hard work and there’s nothing you can do about it.

getsanta · 08/12/2021 20:17

@WonderfulYou

As contraception was used then no I don’t think he should pay. If you weren’t on contraception and he didn’t bother using any either then he should pay.

Using contraception shows that you don’t want a baby. He probably assumed that since you were on contraception you would choose not to continue with a pregnancy.

Did you ever have a conversation about what would happen if the pill failed?
I imagine if he knew there was a chance you wanted to keep the baby he would have used extra protection.

So who should pay then?
getsanta · 08/12/2021 20:16

I feel like I'm in an alternate universe.

TractorAndHeadphones · 08/12/2021 20:13

[quote ForbiddentoForbid]@Rabblesthecat I found pregnancy intolerable and did not want the child.

Should I never have sex? Or immediately have my tubes tied? [/quote]
I think you meant to tag @Etinoxaurus…

WonderfulYou · 08/12/2021 20:13

As contraception was used then no I don’t think he should pay.
If you weren’t on contraception and he didn’t bother using any either then he should pay.

Using contraception shows that you don’t want a baby. He probably assumed that since you were on contraception you would choose not to continue with a pregnancy.

Did you ever have a conversation about what would happen if the pill failed?
I imagine if he knew there was a chance you wanted to keep the baby he would have used extra protection.

Sowhatifiam · 08/12/2021 20:12

No baby conceived has to be born so I don’t see why they should have to pay if they have no say in its existence

What about the baby? Where are his needs in all of this?

If the mother names him on the birth certificate then yes he should pay. If she doesn't then no he shouldn't

She can’t name him if not married to him. He also can’t be forced to sign the birth register.

FOR girls to value themselves more . If he treats you like shit .. he is not going to behave better or love you more 'if you have his baby' ... he will still leave you. With a baby

Hmm…my ex was an absolute prince right up to the moment he decided he had no more use for me. You can’t educate for that.

Women bringing babies into a world where they know the father won't be around and money will be tight times hard etc and all the disadvantages that brings are incredibly selfish

It’s just ‘othering’, right? You want single parents not to look like you. You want them to be selfish and irresponsible and stupid and utterly to blame for their single parent status precisely because you don’t want to face the possibility that if a single parent looks like you, you might one day be one.

Why aren’t men who abandon pregnant women, who refuse to support their children selfish? Why do they get the opportunity to walk away and be applauded for that decision whilst the person quite literally left holding the baby is treated like a second class citizen?

ForbiddentoForbid · 08/12/2021 20:12

@Rabblesthecat I found pregnancy intolerable and did not want the child.

Should I never have sex? Or immediately have my tubes tied?

Etinoxaurus · 08/12/2021 20:11

@Rabblesthecat

I go against the grain - no they should not.

Everyone (including the mother) has a choice up to 22 weeks. It may be a choice you don’t want to make but you are still making a choice the other way to keep it.

No baby conceived has to be born so I don’t see why they should have to pay if they have no say in its existence.

Men can choose not to have sex. I’ve told my dcs not to have sex with anyone they’re not prepared to be tethered to for 18 years. My dds have more agency (weak cheer) but dss- won’t have sex if you wouldn’t countenance a child.
ForbiddentoForbid · 08/12/2021 20:10

@Ohsugarhoneyicetea

I'm an ardent feminist but I do think if the sperm donor wants nothing to do with the child there should be some mechanism within the abortion window where they can relinquish parental responsibility and have no financial obligations. The woman can then proceed with the pregnancy knowing this, or at that point have an abortion. I think there are women who would prefer this as well, knowing they have no contact obligations in the future.

I actually agree with this.

I'm in no way an advocate of forced abortion. But part of me thinks that if the man relinquishes all involvement in the first 12 weeks there should be a clean break.

I've had an abortion. I do not want children. My partner at the time was enormously against me having an abortion and did everything to stop me having it. The idea of having the child made me ill.

Men should have zero say over a woman's medical choice, I absolutely believe in that.

But I can see it from the other side also.

Donut22 · 08/12/2021 20:10

If he's not going to be involved then I wouldn't want a penny from him, so much stress for abit of money, I would take no money no stress over trying to make him. Trust me I've been their.

Numbertime · 08/12/2021 20:09

@Woodmarsh

‘No baby conceived has to be born’ what a horrible sentence.

Don’t worry little baby foetus you didn’t survive because your Daddy didn’t want to support you financially.

@numbertime it's true though it doesn't have to be born and a parent not wanting it is a good reason for it not to be. At that stage it is just a foetus, a collection of cells

I’m not talking about one parent not wanting the child I’m talking about a ‘get out of paying’ abortion before 22 week clause that has been suggested.
CombatBarbie · 08/12/2021 20:05

There isn't a "think"..... Legally he has to 🧐

TractorAndHeadphones · 08/12/2021 20:04

@PleasantBirthday

Why does the moral solution never involve anything difficult for men?
Because like it or not women are the ones who get pregnant. Any solution once she gets pregnant is difficult.

If you would like to fund research into a 100% effective birth control solution kindly go ahead

Bunnyfuller · 08/12/2021 20:04

There is equal responsibility.

Having read the update it is a contraceptive fail, so they both have to put the baby first on all fronts

Youdoyoutoday · 08/12/2021 20:03

What was the relationship before you finding out you were pregnant?
Are you prepared to leave his name off the birth certificate?
Do you want him involved?

getsanta · 08/12/2021 20:01

[quote Bunnyfuller]@getsanta the point at which a woman allows an unprotected penis into her vagina she implicitly accepts there may be a baby.

Unless he forced it or the contraceptives failed it is as much on her.[/quote]
And the man accepts the possibility of a baby at the same time. What on earth is your ridiculous point?

WhereYouLeftIt · 08/12/2021 20:00

@FabianK

I’ve always thought men should be able to opt out of parental responsibility including csa payments up to a certain time.

Women can make a choice and men should be able to also.

That is more than fair.

Men can make a choice. They can use a condom.
WhatWhenWhoWhy · 08/12/2021 20:00

[quote Bunnyfuller]@getsanta the point at which a woman allows an unprotected penis into her vagina she implicitly accepts there may be a baby.

Unless he forced it or the contraceptives failed it is as much on her.[/quote]
I think the issue is that everyone is busy playing the "blame game". It's not a competition or at least it shouldn't be.

There is a child that needs supporting.

I find men who walk away from their responsibilities morally repugnant.

AgentDavid · 08/12/2021 19:59

@peboh

I do not agree. I think if a man makes it clear straight away in pregnancy that he doesn't want a child then he should be able to revoke parental responsibility. The same as if a woman was to not want a child, but the father did, she would be able to make the choice for both of them.
I also agree if a woman wants to keep the baby but the man doesn't, the man should be able to be absolved of duty prior to birth. It's not fair women can choose to keep or choose to abort but a man either loses a wanted baby or has to pay maintenance to an unwanted one. (It is, of course, fair that a woman has the say over their own body, just not fair for men in those two scenarios, they get no say but end up with the repercussions).

I don't think it's as simple as "you have sex, you pay for an unwanted child for 18 years" and I would never ask for money from a man where I have chosen, against his wishes, to keep his child. I just don't think it's fair.

Swipe left for the next trending thread