Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think father should pay csa even if he doesn't want the baby

365 replies

Bear45 · 08/12/2021 18:03

As title says!
He wanted me to have an abortion and I've not heard off him for 3 weeks now. I'm 13 weeks, obviously it's a way off but just wondering what peoples opinions are

OP posts:
CiaoForDiNiaoSaur · 08/12/2021 20:54

Yes he should pay. If you have sex you risk pregnancy. If you don't want a baby use multiple forms of contraception but also remember that they can fail and you are still risking pregnancy.

Women have the added option of abortion because they are the ones risking their physical and mental health by having a baby.

And to the PPs who are blathering on about "who's going to pick up the tab if men don't pay?" You are aware that CM isn't taken into account for benefits aren't you? So don't worry. You aren't paying to cover the maintenance that those shitty men aren't paying (although you seem to be using it as a reason for why women shouldn't be allowed to continue the pregnancy) because they could claim the same amount of 'your' hard earned taxes regardless.

TractorAndHeadphones · 08/12/2021 20:54

@Sowhatifiam

If a woman can’t raise the baby and her partner doesn’t want it she should abort it. Full stop.Of course you can’t make her do it. And legally she has a choice. But she should. On the sole principle that nobody should have a baby that they can’t afford themselves. Or have to pay for a baby they didn’t want when the option of abortion is easily available!

Full stop? I had 2 children with my cheating ex. His parting gift was to have sex with me multiple times without contraception. I was in no way able to support a third child on my own. In your world, he had a right to demand abortion? As it happens, he refused to consider an abortion and promised he would support the baby. Said baby is now 12 and he hasn’t paid a penny. Why does he have all the rights and his child has none?

Single parents through choice are different to those who become single parents in my view

Jesus fucking wept. No single parent should ever need to explain to anyone/everyone why it is that they are single so they can be respected/judged accordingly. I’ve met women like you in the playground. It is beyond me why anyone thinks they get to know the finer details of someone’s life just because they are single with children. You would never judge a woman with a ring on her finger, many women with rings on their fingers make utterly shite life choices but do so without anyone questioning their motives.

Reading comprehension love. The post you quoted from clearly stated, right above the line above. "We’re considering people with clear positions. People changing their minds and abandoning halfway through not considered."

Of COURSE if a man agrees to support the baby, and changed his mind halfway, baby is already born etc etc yes he 100% should be supporting it and I've said as much. Also if abortion isn't medically possible of course there's no other option.

However if a woman can't raise a baby alone , her partner has stated he doesn't want it and she has the choice of abortion. And she chooses not to exercise the choice. It's 100% her fault.

If my daughter was in this position of course I can't force her either to abort, or give birth. But I can encourage or influence her choice. And said encouragement/influence would be to abort. Not to keep the baby and go after the father.
Similarly if my son was in a similar position and his partner chose to keep the baby I would of course make him pay. However I wouldn't expect him to change his life plans for a baby he didn't want when there were other options available.
Again assuming both parties were in agreement and this was a contraception failure.

Glassofshloer · 08/12/2021 20:47

This doesn’t have to be an issue where men or women are the ‘winners’, neither does it need to be black & white.

Men get the shitty stick of rolling the dice every time they have sex, with consequences ranging from nothing to a lifetime of parenting/CMS.

Women get the shitty stick of having to make the decisions & implement them at personal bodily and emotional cost - whether to use hormonal contraception, whether to take the MAP, whether to have a termination, whether to go through with the pregnancy.

I suppose the crux of the matter is that generally women hold all the agency and power should a pregnancy happen, but that isn’t great either - unless it’s a longed for pregnancy in a good relationship, it’s going to be a painful decision with even more lifelong consequences than for the man.

I think the current system is the right one, but unfortunately it’s a blunt instrument that doesn’t (and can’t) take into account personal circumstances.

Basically it’s messy for all involved.

justustwoandmoo · 08/12/2021 20:43

I'm in two minds with this one. I know someone who was desperate for a baby and pretended to be on birth control. Got pregnant and the bloke absolutely didn't want the baby and made that v clear even before they had sex. Should he have to then pay 18 years worth of CS? I don't think so (although he is as he had no choice).

That's the thing though isn't it. Why should choice only apply to the woman....

tallduckandhandsome · 08/12/2021 20:43

Looks like the MRA are out in force today..ll

linelgreen · 08/12/2021 20:43

No you could have avoided this by using proper contraception or had the abortion why should he be penalised.

getsanta · 08/12/2021 20:39

@AnotherOneWithNoGoodName yes. Just be very perfunctory about it at this point.

ChiefStockingStuffer · 08/12/2021 20:39

Pursue CSA
circumstances change, and he should be supporting his child no matter what.

You can always put it in an account for your child for their future if you don't need it.

AnotherOneWithNoGoodName · 08/12/2021 20:37

Don't have any more contact with him if you don't want to, and claim through CSA.
Tough luck if he doesn't want to be a father. His choice in that has ended, and it's about you and the baby now.

Sowhatifiam · 08/12/2021 20:36

If a woman can’t raise the baby and her partner doesn’t want it she should abort it. Full stop.Of course you can’t make her do it. And legally she has a choice. But she should. On the sole principle that nobody should have a baby that they can’t afford themselves. Or have to pay for a baby they didn’t want when the option of abortion is easily available!

Full stop? I had 2 children with my cheating ex. His parting gift was to have sex with me multiple times without contraception. I was in no way able to support a third child on my own. In your world, he had a right to demand abortion? As it happens, he refused to consider an abortion and promised he would support the baby. Said baby is now 12 and he hasn’t paid a penny. Why does he have all the rights and his child has none?

Single parents through choice are different to those who become single parents in my view

Jesus fucking wept. No single parent should ever need to explain to anyone/everyone why it is that they are single so they can be respected/judged accordingly. I’ve met women like you in the playground. It is beyond me why anyone thinks they get to know the finer details of someone’s life just because they are single with children. You would never judge a woman with a ring on her finger, many women with rings on their fingers make utterly shite life choices but do so without anyone questioning their motives.

SusannaQueen · 08/12/2021 20:35

@getsanta
I feel like I'm in an alternate universe

Ditto. Bloody unbelievable.

HugeAckmansWife · 08/12/2021 20:35

Abortion isn't always an option. Its not like having a mole removed. Depending on your view, the developing foetus could be a person with rights, or you may have religious objections or whatever. The point is that it ISN'T always an option and the man, unless he was off that day at school, understands the risks.

Thehouseofmarvels · 08/12/2021 20:34

Do the people who think that men should be able to opt out think the woman should access money from the tax payer equivent to what that man would contribute or that the child should go without things if the mother is poorer ? I think if men opt out the tax payer would need to cover the child maintainance. You would need to have checks in place where couples claimed the bloke was opting out to claim this benefit.

prynaithda21 · 08/12/2021 20:33

Men should not evade their responsibilities nor force a woman into an abortion.

Even if they are Prime Minister.

ShrillSiren · 08/12/2021 20:33

The man gets to make his decision before sex and the woman gets to make the final decision after sex. It's as simple as that and everyone knows how it works and how babies are made.
Why do so many want men to have even less responsibility for paying for their kids than they already do?

When I read threads like this I'm always amazed at just how many women are their own worst enemies.
You'd seriously make other women feel like they had to get an abortion because the man doesn't want to pay and would like to fuck his way around without any consequences.

If you believe that there aren't men out there that would agree to pay and then miraculously change their minds are X weeks, you're naive. How would you be able to prove that they had or hadn't agreed to pay, surely it would be one person's word against the other? How about if the woman doesn't find out she's pregnant until after the abortion cut off limit?

TractorAndHeadphones · 08/12/2021 20:31

@CombatBarbie

Bit confused by some of these comments.... No contraceptive is 100% so by having sex there is always a risk......
Yep. People going all ‘well have your tubes tied them’ so you’re saying women should never have sex until they want a baby? Vasectomies aren’t reversible as well over the long term.
HugeAckmansWife · 08/12/2021 20:31

tractor and headphones oh good. I don't really want to do 99% of the parenting since my ex fucked off and pay about 90% of their costs. Can I stop then? Yay. Sorry kids, no tea tonight. I don't want to do anything I don't want to. Like millions of other single parents, I wasn't given a choice about it when ex upped and left. Maybe a man who finds himself an unwilling father to a baby in utero is similar. He has no choice at that point so has to suck it up. His choice was at the point of sex. Mine was at the point of having kids with someone who turned out later to be a cheating twat but the 'damage' is done. Of course I love my kids, wouldn't be without them etc (before someone accuses me of terrible mothering) but I didn't choose single parenthood. How is that different to a man not choosing fatherhood and being given an opt out?

getsanta · 08/12/2021 20:29

OP took contraception as she did not want a baby.
She has now changed her mind and decided she does want a baby.
Both have been completely her choice.

Yup. One area of reality where women have a semblance of control in this country at least.

TractorAndHeadphones · 08/12/2021 20:28

Also @HugeAckmansWife why are you ignoring the fact that the woman can abort the baby?
She’s making a choice to keep it. A choice that the man doesn’t have.
If she keeps it 100% her choice, nobody is forcing her.

All other Inequalties while true and make a nice emotional argument have sweet FA to do with the point of dicussion

CombatBarbie · 08/12/2021 20:28

Bit confused by some of these comments.... No contraceptive is 100% so by having sex there is always a risk......

getsanta · 08/12/2021 20:26

@HugeAckmansWife

I think that this idea 100% stems from a deeply ingrained belief that men should not have to do anything they don't want to do, but women are always expected to just cope with whatever. Look at the last 18 months. Studies have shown its been working women who have done the vast majority of homeschooling, isolation childcare and wfh juggling. Men can't possibly compromise their Big Job with such things. So assuming the pregnancy is a genuine error, contraception failure, there is a child. With two parents. Biology dictates in this one small area the woman has both the 'advantage' of the extra option of abortion but also the 'disadvantage' of having to have the abortion, or the pregnancy and birth and postpartum injuries, loss of earnings, pension, career progression etc. And men (and some woman) are complaining that a man in this situation shouldn't have to ring fence 20% of his post - pension contribution pay to support the child. He can't be forced to go on pat leave, work part time, pay for childcare, spend time or emotional energy on the child. Just a pretty minimal financial contribution. But that would be totally unfair apparently.

Spot on.

WonderfulYou · 08/12/2021 20:26

I think that this idea 100% stems from a deeply ingrained belief that men should not have to do anything they don't want to do, but women are always expected to just cope with whatever.

I disagree.

OP took contraception as she did not want a baby.
She has now changed her mind and decided she does want a baby.
Both have been completely her choice.

Woodmarsh · 08/12/2021 20:23

@sowhatifiam no it's not, I won't ever be one, there has never been any possibility I would.

Single parents through choice are different to those who become single parents in my view

TractorAndHeadphones · 08/12/2021 20:23

@HugeAckmansWife

I think that this idea 100% stems from a deeply ingrained belief that men should not have to do anything they don't want to do, but women are always expected to just cope with whatever. Look at the last 18 months. Studies have shown its been working women who have done the vast majority of homeschooling, isolation childcare and wfh juggling. Men can't possibly compromise their Big Job with such things. So assuming the pregnancy is a genuine error, contraception failure, there is a child. With two parents. Biology dictates in this one small area the woman has both the 'advantage' of the extra option of abortion but also the 'disadvantage' of having to have the abortion, or the pregnancy and birth and postpartum injuries, loss of earnings, pension, career progression etc. And men (and some woman) are complaining that a man in this situation shouldn't have to ring fence 20% of his post - pension contribution pay to support the child. He can't be forced to go on pat leave, work part time, pay for childcare, spend time or emotional energy on the child. Just a pretty minimal financial contribution. But that would be totally unfair apparently.
NOBODY should have to do something they don’t want to do. A woman should not have to give birth to a baby she doesn’t want even if the man does!
TractorAndHeadphones · 08/12/2021 20:21

@Sowhatifiam

No baby conceived has to be born so I don’t see why they should have to pay if they have no say in its existence

What about the baby? Where are his needs in all of this?

If the mother names him on the birth certificate then yes he should pay. If she doesn't then no he shouldn't

She can’t name him if not married to him. He also can’t be forced to sign the birth register.

FOR girls to value themselves more . If he treats you like shit .. he is not going to behave better or love you more 'if you have his baby' ... he will still leave you. With a baby

Hmm…my ex was an absolute prince right up to the moment he decided he had no more use for me. You can’t educate for that.

Women bringing babies into a world where they know the father won't be around and money will be tight times hard etc and all the disadvantages that brings are incredibly selfish

It’s just ‘othering’, right? You want single parents not to look like you. You want them to be selfish and irresponsible and stupid and utterly to blame for their single parent status precisely because you don’t want to face the possibility that if a single parent looks like you, you might one day be one.

Why aren’t men who abandon pregnant women, who refuse to support their children selfish? Why do they get the opportunity to walk away and be applauded for that decision whilst the person quite literally left holding the baby is treated like a second class citizen?

There are two parts to the story. We’re considering people with clear positions. People changing their minds and abandoning halfway through not considered. Part À : Abortion window If a woman can’t raise the baby and her partner doesn’t want it she should abort it. Full stop. Of course you can’t make her do it. And legally she has a choice. But she should. On the sole principle that nobody should have a baby that they can’t afford themselves. Or have to pay for a baby they didn’t want when the option of abortion is easily available!

Part B : Baby is already born
Nothing to be done. It’s here already so father should pay.

If my son were in the above scenario and his partner chose to keep the baby I would tell him that he had to pay. I wouldn’t think very highly of her however for keeping it if she had no means to support it.

Thé precedent for a woman supporting a baby alone has already been established the moment we let single women have babies via sperm donation.