Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think father should pay csa even if he doesn't want the baby

365 replies

Bear45 · 08/12/2021 18:03

As title says!
He wanted me to have an abortion and I've not heard off him for 3 weeks now. I'm 13 weeks, obviously it's a way off but just wondering what peoples opinions are

OP posts:
PeterPomegranate · 09/12/2021 03:36

[quote MrsLarry]@peterPomegranate

So, what if the man wanted to keep the baby but the woman didn't?[/quote]
My starting point is that only the pregnant woman is a decision maker on her pregnancy because it’s her body. She can choose to involve other people in the decision (eg the father) but she doesn’t have to.

getsanta · 08/12/2021 22:31

Should a woman be forced to have a baby she doesn't want when contraception fails for her? No, of course not, so neither should a man who tried to have "safe" sex but was one of the "accidents".

Thankfully this isn't the law. Confused

PrincessNutella · 08/12/2021 22:19

The money is for the benefit of the child, so of course you should get it.

Bizawit · 08/12/2021 22:17

@Stiffcondomhat

If you really don't want a baby don't have sex (applies to men and women) If you don't want to continue a pregnancy, have an abortion (only applies to women as men can't get pregnant) If you have a baby you are financially liable for their upkeep, whether you wanted it or not and whether you have contact or not (Because a baby is a human not a pay per view tv channel).
Excellently put 👌🏻
HugeAckmansWife · 08/12/2021 22:15

tractor I don't understand your point about benefits and costing the tax payer? Leaving aside for a moment the fact that I work ft, receive no benefits other than CB and pay tax myself, the amount received (or not) in CMS has no bearing on benefits that may be received by a lower earning or sp needing childcare. Also, you keep maintaining that abortion is a choice. Actually, for many people it wouldn't be. Just because it's physically possible doesn't mean it's always an option... Or can you not imagine ever being asked to do something you would find utterly wrong? Two people make a child, either through carelessness or genuine error. At that point, yes, the biology intervenes to give the woman one additional option. Lets not forget that there are thousands of non paying absent fathers out there who don't have too much trouble evading the cms even having been a present and involved father before, so forgive me if I'm not bleeding sympathy for the poor menz who get 'caught' this way. They still know, ultimately, they could just piss off, refuse a paternity test and zip would be done.

SethWho · 08/12/2021 22:11

@BeeDavis

I personally wouldn’t keep a baby if the father wasn’t interested. But that’s me 😵‍💫
I kept mine. Really like her. 👍
AlmostAJillSandwich · 08/12/2021 22:03

To clarify, by "safe" i mean where any form of contraception is knowingly used, be it condoms, or female based such as her being on the pill or having an iud/implant/depo shot etc.

TheCloudBotherer · 08/12/2021 21:58

We've become inured to the fact that men frequently father children and then, while being aware of their existence, make no effort at all to be part of their lives. Whenever this is framed as a problem, it's always framed as the taxpayer having to pick up the bill for absent fathers. (And that's if the father is mentioned at all. The majority of the time, it's single mothers getting the flack.)

That so many men are seemingly happy to have no relationship with the children they've fathered is almost never picked up as an issue. Because you've got to be a real cunt to do it. But it's so common that it's not though of as unusual at all.

TractorAndHeadphones · 08/12/2021 21:58

@MultiStorey there seems to be a view that whatever the woman wants goes and if she wants the child she should keep it no questions asked.
Leaving aside the question of CSA (which isn't counted in benefits, so would cost the taxpayer money anyway) raising a child is hard work and you can't force a man to be involved, even if he paid.

Why is saying that there should be a consideration about the practicalities so unacceptable? A woman may have 'feelings' but if they can't give the child a good life it's unfair to it.

AlmostAJillSandwich · 08/12/2021 21:58

I don't agree with the "just don't have sex" posters.

Healthy, fulfilling adult relationships where both partners are happy, that don't involve sex, are very rare. Sex is far more often done for pleasure, intimacy and bonding, etc, than it is to make a baby.

Realistically, who is going to commit to a sexless relationship willingly, even from the female side, when it is so often a huge part of a healthy, happy relationship?

What we need, is more contraceptive options for males. It isn't as easy as "get a vasectomy", they dont just refer anyone, plus what if he wants kids, just not at this point in his life/with this partner? It's a surgery, that isn't easy to reverse and be successful. As for condoms, they can break, slip off, and for many greatly reduce the sensations.

Should a woman be forced to have a baby she doesn't want when contraception fails for her? No, of course not, so neither should a man who tried to have "safe" sex but was one of the "accidents".

If an abortion is still available, then the guy should get the option to walk away from all parental/financial responsibility if he doesn't want the baby, but she chooses to continue the pregnancy knowing it will be as the single financial provider.

TractorAndHeadphones · 08/12/2021 21:43

@Indoctro

So if you didn't want the baby but he did would you if kept it for him.?

I don't think he should as it's your choice to have the baby so you need to be in a financial position to be able to have it

I think men have no say in keeping a baby or not and that isn't fair

Personally if it was me I would keep baby and take full financial responsibility for it myself

Which incidentally is what the OP very responsibly is doing...although she has created this thread because 'other people' have said she should claim CSA
MultiStorey · 08/12/2021 21:40

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

CiaoForDiNiaoSaur · 08/12/2021 21:39

@getsanta how is the tax payer covering the difference? My ex pays £0 towards our DC. If by some miracle he suddenly grew a conscience and decided to pay towards the dc he wanted my benefits would not decrease. I would cost "the tax payer" the same as I do now.

Yes its a fucking disgrace that men can walk away so easily. But the fact they do doesn't change how much single parents can claim in benefits.

Indoctro · 08/12/2021 21:36

So if you didn't want the baby but he did would you if kept it for him.?

I don't think he should as it's your choice to have the baby so you need to be in a financial position to be able to have it

I think men have no say in keeping a baby or not and that isn't fair

Personally if it was me I would keep baby and take full financial responsibility for it myself

Bigassbeebuzzbuzz · 08/12/2021 21:33

He made a child, he should have to pay for the child. End of discussion. Men have 3 choices, abstinence, vasectomy or condoms.
Would love to see the figures of how many poor men are being harassed by the cms because of a condom failure Hmm

FestiveMelts · 08/12/2021 21:32

I actually agree in principle with those who say the woman has the control and if she chooses to go ahead as a single mum, that's on her.

But ultimately it's the child who loses out by that approach. None of it is their fault. If a man takes the risk and it results in a baby he didn't want it's unlucky, but better the bloke suffers financially than the child, who gets the least say of all!

SantasGoodLittleGirl · 08/12/2021 21:31

So, basically, people are saying that if a woman has sex, she deserves to be pregnant/a mother without financial support? The underlying principle here being that women are not entitled to full and happy sex lives unless they are married? And what about those of us who become single parents through divorce? I remember reading a comment (not here, in the press in the '80s) that our children should be boiled and eaten - hopefully a classical reference rather than an actual suggestion!

Well, that's a load of bollocks. Invented by the patriarchy to keep their 'saleable' daughters and potentially unfaithful wives under control, so that said patriarchs don't end up raising some other man's children. And, guttingly, the idea is supported, maintained and policed by women, who are happy to condemn any woman who steps out of line.

getsanta · 08/12/2021 21:27

[quote CiaoForDiNiaoSaur]@Theunamedcat yes I'm aware of that. But the implication in previous posts isn't that it's unfair on the woman because she'll shoulder the cost alone is it. It's implied that the tax payer is 'picking up the tab'
Unless I'm reading it wrong. And 15 years on MN makes me think I'm not.[/quote]
The tax payer is picking up the difference between what the father should be paying and what the mother is paying. Absolutely outrageous that any father should be able to walk away from his obligations and expect the mother and tax payer to cover his obligations.

CiaoForDiNiaoSaur · 08/12/2021 21:24

@Theunamedcat yes I'm aware of that. But the implication in previous posts isn't that it's unfair on the woman because she'll shoulder the cost alone is it. It's implied that the tax payer is 'picking up the tab'
Unless I'm reading it wrong. And 15 years on MN makes me think I'm not.

Theunamedcat · 08/12/2021 21:20

@CiaoForDiNiaoSaur

Yes he should pay. If you have sex you risk pregnancy. If you don't want a baby use multiple forms of contraception but also remember that they can fail and you are still risking pregnancy.

Women have the added option of abortion because they are the ones risking their physical and mental health by having a baby.

And to the PPs who are blathering on about "who's going to pick up the tab if men don't pay?" You are aware that CM isn't taken into account for benefits aren't you? So don't worry. You aren't paying to cover the maintenance that those shitty men aren't paying (although you seem to be using it as a reason for why women shouldn't be allowed to continue the pregnancy) because they could claim the same amount of 'your' hard earned taxes regardless.

Not all single parents claim benefits
lunar1 · 08/12/2021 21:09

A man's right to choose ends when he decides to have sex with a woman, any contraceptive can fail.

getsanta · 08/12/2021 21:07

However if a woman can't raise a baby alone , her partner has stated he doesn't want it and she has the choice of abortion. And she chooses not to exercise the choice. It's 100% her fault.

This is shocking.

LolaSmiles · 08/12/2021 21:00

Yes he should pay. The nature of sex and bodily autonomy means that the choice to continue a pregnancy lies with the pregnant woman. I don't doubt there's a lot of so called 'happy accidents' or women who want a baby so are maybe not very good at remembering their pill, but if a man is sleeping with a woman and isn't insisting on barrier protection then that's the risk he is taking (and I'm in no way defending those women who do lie to orchestrate so called unplanned pregnancies).

Whether it would be wise for a woman to continue with a pregnancy on the assumption that the the father (who has openly said he doesn't want to be involved with & would prefer an abortion to being a parent) stumps up the tiniest amount of CSA is another matter.

Krakenchorus · 08/12/2021 20:58

This topic always brings all the misogyny out in the open. How depressing.

Many, many women would never consider abortion. That includes a whopping percent of those on birth control. I'm damned glad that abortion is an option for any woman who chooses it, but it should not be considered the obvious default if the man wants no part. He should know that any woman might feel very differently about an abortion when actually faced with the choice, than she did when it was theoretical.

That doesn't absolve the father of responsibility for the child.

Someone upthread wondered why should the poor man pay for 18 years just for having sex. Did you skip biology at school? Jesus wept.

HugeAckmansWife · 08/12/2021 20:54

Yeah all those women through the ages who've been left pregnant by men who disowned them.. They definitely had all the power. Men do have a choice. The ppwho just said she knows someone who lied about the pill... The man is an idiot not to take responsibility himself. No woman would trust a man to take a pill with so much at stake. No man should trust a woman too either if he is so absolutely dead set on avoiding fatherhood.