Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think father should pay csa even if he doesn't want the baby

365 replies

Bear45 · 08/12/2021 18:03

As title says!
He wanted me to have an abortion and I've not heard off him for 3 weeks now. I'm 13 weeks, obviously it's a way off but just wondering what peoples opinions are

OP posts:
getsanta · 08/12/2021 18:30

I'm an ardent feminist but I do think if the sperm donor wants nothing to do with the child there should be some mechanism within the abortion window where they can relinquish parental responsibility and have no financial obligations.

You are no feminist. Unreal.

OutOfCyan · 08/12/2021 18:30

@Waxonwaxoff0 but that is what was being suggested

NynaeveSedai · 08/12/2021 18:29

@User135792468

I don’t agree. A woman also had sex.. does that mean that the man should be able to force her to have the baby against her will, take the baby at birth and then claim maintenance? Of course not, the concept is abhorrent.

It’s hard but if a woman chooses to have a baby and the man makes clear he doesn’t want the baby when pregnant, he should be able to revoke parents responsibility and she should make the decision based on being able to afford to raise the child herself.

Women have options that men don't have. That's a fact of biology. There is no parity in decision making over whether pregnancy continues or not, and there should not be.
reesewithoutaspoon · 08/12/2021 18:29

Its not about whether its fair he should pay if he didnt want it. The child is still here and still has the same needs for food, clothes, housing as every other child and its their parents responsibility to provide this. Not wanting them doesnt automatically reduce that need to 50%.

Roundeartheratchriatmas · 08/12/2021 18:29

No consent to sex doesn’t equal consent to pregnancy. Just leads to it as a direct result Hmm

MissCruellaDeVil · 08/12/2021 18:28

[quote OutOfCyan]@MissCruellaDeVil Surely a father who doesn't want to pay would just refuse to go on the birth certificate?! [/quote]
Which would relinquish parental responsibility. So yes.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 08/12/2021 18:28

[quote OutOfCyan]@MissCruellaDeVil Surely a father who doesn't want to pay would just refuse to go on the birth certificate?! [/quote]
Not being on the birth certificate doesn't mean they don't have to pay.

NynaeveSedai · 08/12/2021 18:28

So maybe it’s fair this way too - it’s the equivalent thing really.

U fuckin wot??

Forcing women to terminate pregnancies is not equivalent to allowing men to opt out of paying child support! There is no equivalence fgs. Only one sex gets pregnant.

AliasGrape · 08/12/2021 18:28

@PeterPomegranate

Being a pregnant woman and being the father of an unborn baby are NOT the same thing. AT ALL. If you’re pregnant the baby is in your body. Therefore the pregnant women’s choice and no one else’s. That’s it.

If you’re a parent of a child whether you are a father or a mother then you have financial responsibility for that child. That’s a responsibility to the CHILD. Your child.

Both of the points above can be true.

Absolutely this.
EmmaWoodhousestreehouse · 08/12/2021 18:27

What steps were you both taking to ensure you didn’t get pregnant @Bear45

NynaeveSedai · 08/12/2021 18:27

@thatstheloveiwantiwantlove

If the mother names him on the birth certificate then yes he should pay. If she doesn't then no he shouldn't.
Women can't put men on the birth certificate against their wishes so this doesn't work. Onus is on putative father to prove he isn't, not the other way around.
Waxonwaxoff0 · 08/12/2021 18:27

Yes, he should pay.

Men can demand equal rights towards this when women have equal rights. That's that.

AliasGrape · 08/12/2021 18:27

@Rabblesthecat

I’ve never met any woman for whom pregnancy would be intolerable who got accidentally knocked up. Always been those who are well hey it’s an accident so I’ll get him to pay.
Then you have led a very sheltered life.

Many many women who would find pregnancy 'intolerable' get pregnant- the vast majority of them will terminate. But I can think of lots of reasons just off the top of my head why they might not.

But also, we're not talking about women who would find a pregnancy intolerable here. We're talking about a man who apparently finds it so - pretty sure theres some foolproof or near enough foolproof ways of ensuring he doesn't get anyone pregnant. Maybe instead of casting aspersions about how the woman in question must have been out to trap him for whatever paltry amount the CSA can force him to pay, you should wonder why someone so against becoming a parent didn't take those steps.

OutOfCyan · 08/12/2021 18:27

@MissCruellaDeVil Surely a father who doesn't want to pay would just refuse to go on the birth certificate?!

MrzClaus · 08/12/2021 18:27

Consent to sex does not equal consent to pregnancy. It's not the same thing.

That should be equal for both parties - the man and the woman. I believe that if we say a woman shouldn't be pressured into keeping a baby a man wants but she doesn't, the reverse should also be the same. If a man has absolutely zero say and it's all up to the woman, and he has no choice in the matter then I don't think it's fair to make them pay.

PeterPomegranate · 08/12/2021 18:26

Being a pregnant woman and being the father of an unborn baby are NOT the same thing. AT ALL. If you’re pregnant the baby is in your body. Therefore the pregnant women’s choice and no one else’s. That’s it.

If you’re a parent of a child whether you are a father or a mother then you have financial responsibility for that child. That’s a responsibility to the CHILD. Your child.

Both of the points above can be true.

MissCruellaDeVil · 08/12/2021 18:26

IMO only fathers with parental responsibility should pay, ie on the birth certificate. If not then they don't have parental responsibility for their child, why should they pay?

User135792468 · 08/12/2021 18:26

I don’t agree. A woman also had sex.. does that mean that the man should be able to force her to have the baby against her will, take the baby at birth and then claim maintenance? Of course not, the concept is abhorrent.

It’s hard but if a woman chooses to have a baby and the man makes clear he doesn’t want the baby when pregnant, he should be able to revoke parents responsibility and she should make the decision based on being able to afford to raise the child herself.

NynaeveSedai · 08/12/2021 18:25

@Ohsugarhoneyicetea

I'm an ardent feminist but I do think if the sperm donor wants nothing to do with the child there should be some mechanism within the abortion window where they can relinquish parental responsibility and have no financial obligations. The woman can then proceed with the pregnancy knowing this, or at that point have an abortion. I think there are women who would prefer this as well, knowing they have no contact obligations in the future.
Why??
NynaeveSedai · 08/12/2021 18:25

@Thegreencup

Unless the condom he was wearing and the hormonal contraception he was using failed, then he should face the consequences of his choices.
He should still pay even if he used contraception.
Ohsugarhoneyicetea · 08/12/2021 18:25

I'm an ardent feminist but I do think if the sperm donor wants nothing to do with the child there should be some mechanism within the abortion window where they can relinquish parental responsibility and have no financial obligations. The woman can then proceed with the pregnancy knowing this, or at that point have an abortion. I think there are women who would prefer this as well, knowing they have no contact obligations in the future.

NynaeveSedai · 08/12/2021 18:24

@Rabblesthecat

I go against the grain - no they should not.

Everyone (including the mother) has a choice up to 22 weeks. It may be a choice you don’t want to make but you are still making a choice the other way to keep it.

No baby conceived has to be born so I don’t see why they should have to pay if they have no say in its existence.

The point where he spunked in the vicinity of a uterus was when he gave consent to a pregnancy happening.
Roundeartheratchriatmas · 08/12/2021 18:24

Or as a pp said get a vasectomy - it’s amazing this never seems to be considered for all those men that “never wanted” a kid or were “trapped” by a woman.

PicaK · 08/12/2021 18:24

Yes. There's no grey areas here.
That said pop over to the separated section and see just how many dads don't pay up.
Plus its not that much. Even my fairly lovely ex whacked as much into his pension as he could to avoid handing over more.
Demand what is your baby's right. But make sure you give their rights too - access to their dad if desired in the future. etc.
I adopted. In the training you're told to be very honest and mention birth parents all the time (age appropriately but honestly) so no chance of Cinderella syndrome and crushing disappointment in the teenage years

OutOfCyan · 08/12/2021 18:24

@thatstheloveiwantiwantlove Wouldn't that just mean that men would refuse to go on the birth certificate then? That wouldn't work