Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think father should pay csa even if he doesn't want the baby

365 replies

Bear45 · 08/12/2021 18:03

As title says!
He wanted me to have an abortion and I've not heard off him for 3 weeks now. I'm 13 weeks, obviously it's a way off but just wondering what peoples opinions are

OP posts:
firstimemamma · 08/12/2021 19:28

Of course the father should pay.

Pixiedust138 · 08/12/2021 19:24

@PleasantBirthday

I can’t believe some people think there is no moral obligation to a life they have helped create.

Society is very keen on consequence free sex for men. For some reason, plenty of women don't examine that.

I'm keen on consequence free sex for women too but unfortunately we aren't in a place where any contraceptive is 100% effective yet.
Pixiedust138 · 08/12/2021 19:23

@Bear45

I'll do one big reply and hope I've answered/replied to most, didn't realise it would have so many replies

I was taking the pill, have successfully been taking the pill for 11 years and never once even had a scare how ever it's not 100% effective and we did not use another form of contraception at the same time as all of the other times had not resulted in pregnancy and trusted the pill.

I am happy to have this baby on my own, I am financially stable enough to do so and have an awesome support network, the baby will be loved and cared for and not want for anything.

I was asking as a few people at work have said I should be asking for csa from him as the baby is also his responsibility. I do however believe that he does have a choice and he has chosen to not want it so wasn't planning on asking him for anything. I was wondering what the general view was from a wider range of people as I only work with men so it's only their view.

Its absolutely your decision. The law says that you can pursue him for child matinance so ultimately it doesn't matter what any of us think as you have a right to do that if that's what you wish. If it was me personally and I didn't want him to have any involvement I wouldn't go for the CSA because I wouldn't want him to have anything to use in a argument for custody if he ever changed his mind but it's extremely personal and as you can see everyone will feel differently x
WhatWhenWhoWhy · 08/12/2021 19:21

but she must accept the consequences of that choice

And equally men have to also, if they have sex.

Men are choosing to have sex, they are choosing to do that knowing there is a possibility of pregnancy.

Women, due to their biology, are able to consider whether to have the baby once pregnant. Men don't, because they don't have the same biology and don't risk a medical procedure either way.

At the end of the day though, this isn't about some or men's rights, this is about the rights of the existing child.

Goldbar · 08/12/2021 19:20

@drpet49

** Rabblesthecat I go against the grain - no they should not.

Everyone (including the mother) has a choice up to 22 weeks. It may be a choice you don’t want to make but you are still making a choice the other way to keep it.

No baby conceived has to be born so I don’t see why they should have to pay if they have no say in its existence.

I agree with this 💯**

^I agree with this too.

The child has no choice though. It's not the mother's right to support, it's the child's right.
PleasantBirthday · 08/12/2021 19:18

I can’t believe some people think there is no moral obligation to a life they have helped create.

Society is very keen on consequence free sex for men. For some reason, plenty of women don't examine that.

Goldbar · 08/12/2021 19:17

@IncompleteSenten

Yes.

People can be quite stupid about this issue and one argument you hear a lot is bleating on about how women have the power and control and if a man impregnates a woman but doesn't want her to proceed with the pregnancy he should be allowed to walk away because it's really unfair that he isn't allowed to knock her unconscious and carry her down to the abortion clinic and have them whip it out before she wakes up.

The actual point is that there are three people involved. The mother. The father. The baby.

It is the rights of the child that a lot of people seem to forget when they're arguing about this

A child has the right to be supported by both the people who created it. It really is as simple as that.

This. The child has a right to support from the father. Not the mother, the child. So the circumstances between the mother and father are irrelevant. Nothing the mother does (or doesn't do) negates the child's right to support. It is independent of the mother.
Numbertime · 08/12/2021 19:16

I can’t believe some people think there is no moral obligation to a life they have helped create.

Bear45 · 08/12/2021 19:16

I'll do one big reply and hope I've answered/replied to most, didn't realise it would have so many replies

I was taking the pill, have successfully been taking the pill for 11 years and never once even had a scare how ever it's not 100% effective and we did not use another form of contraception at the same time as all of the other times had not resulted in pregnancy and trusted the pill.

I am happy to have this baby on my own, I am financially stable enough to do so and have an awesome support network, the baby will be loved and cared for and not want for anything.

I was asking as a few people at work have said I should be asking for csa from him as the baby is also his responsibility. I do however believe that he does have a choice and he has chosen to not want it so wasn't planning on asking him for anything. I was wondering what the general view was from a wider range of people as I only work with men so it's only their view.

OP posts:
Georgyporky · 08/12/2021 19:14

Both parties could - perhaps should - have used contraception.
An abortion would seem the answer to the situation.

Estellelove · 08/12/2021 19:13

Men's involvement in creating a child ends with ejaculation. That's why his right to an opinion ends there.
A woman's involvement in creating a child continues for 9 months and involves a lot of physical and emotional pain. That is why her right to an opinion on whether to create the child continues for 24 weeks.
And that is equality.

Roundeartheratchriatmas · 08/12/2021 19:13

I’d never trust a mans say so on contraception but I agree men should be able to take it to better protect themselves.

I’ve always found it’s men who are reluctant to use a condom until I point out not doing so may well result in a child because I can’t take hormonal contraceptives.

Blossom64265 · 08/12/2021 19:13

Of course he should. His point of decision was before his genetic material left his body.

CSA is the absolute bare minimum of financial support he should provide.

TractorAndHeadphones · 08/12/2021 19:12

@Mumoftwoinprimary

Men know when they have sex that if the woman gets pregnant then they won’t get to choose whether the pregnancy continues. This has been the law since abortion was legalised. (Nearly 50 years!) They choose to have sex knowing this. It isn’t a shocking surprise. It is a risk they choose to take on.

It isn’t as if women are in a great situation….. If a woman gets pregnant she has two choices.

  1. Have an abortion. This has a mortality rate of about 1 in 100,000 in the U.K. pretty low but similar to that of jumping out of a plane with a parachute.
  2. Have the baby. This has a mortality rate of about 10 in 100,000 in the U.K. So 10 times that of jumping out of a plane with a parachute.

There is no option for a pregnant woman that doesn’t involve risking her health.

Well if women think the risks are too great they can just not have sex, like pp are suggesting men should have done. Can’t have it both ways. Historically women were supposed to more pure etc not just as a way to control women but because of the very real biological risk that she would be left holding the baby. We’ve left that era and women still carry the higher risk but we have legal abortions now. If a woman doesn’t want to avail herself of something millions of women in other countries have fought for her choice - but she must accept the consequences of that choice .
drpet49 · 08/12/2021 19:10

** Rabblesthecat
I go against the grain - no they should not.

Everyone (including the mother) has a choice up to 22 weeks. It may be a choice you don’t want to make but you are still making a choice the other way to keep it.

No baby conceived has to be born so I don’t see why they should have to pay if they have no say in its existence.

I agree with this 💯**

^I agree with this too.

lololololollll · 08/12/2021 19:09

I agree they should. But the naive people who say they have to if CSA are involved obviously haven't had the CSA being totally crap believing every very lie they tell them about why they can't afford it. Am currently helping my friend through dealing with my this. Congrats on your pregnancy and stick to your guns, hopefully he will do the right thing in the end

TractorAndHeadphones · 08/12/2021 19:08

@User135792468

I don’t agree. A woman also had sex.. does that mean that the man should be able to force her to have the baby against her will, take the baby at birth and then claim maintenance? Of course not, the concept is abhorrent.

It’s hard but if a woman chooses to have a baby and the man makes clear he doesn’t want the baby when pregnant, he should be able to revoke parents responsibility and she should make the decision based on being able to afford to raise the child herself.

Exactly. If she does not want to raise the baby alone she should abort it. She shouldn’t be able to have it against his will and then force him to pay.

The fact that there are many deadbeat dads etc etc is irrelevant.

And you can’t say ‘well don’t have sex’ because in countries where that happens (like mine) and abortion isn’t allowed you just get baby dumping.

WhatWhenWhoWhy · 08/12/2021 19:07

This is bonkers. There are millions of couples who don't want children. Does that mean they should remain celibate forever, just in case?

No, but hopefully as adults we all realise the consequences of sex, and the main consequence of sex is pregnancy. Both parties have to acknowledge their responsibility of they don't use contraception, or that contraception fails. If the couple are in a committed relationship, then one would hope that "what if?" is a conversation they've had.

At the end of the day though, it's an inescapable fact that having sex can lead to procreation!

Mumoftwoinprimary · 08/12/2021 19:03

Men know when they have sex that if the woman gets pregnant then they won’t get to choose whether the pregnancy continues. This has been the law since abortion was legalised. (Nearly 50 years!) They choose to have sex knowing this. It isn’t a shocking surprise. It is a risk they choose to take on.

It isn’t as if women are in a great situation….. If a woman gets pregnant she has two choices.

  1. Have an abortion. This has a mortality rate of about 1 in 100,000 in the U.K. pretty low but similar to that of jumping out of a plane with a parachute.
  2. Have the baby. This has a mortality rate of about 10 in 100,000 in the U.K. So 10 times that of jumping out of a plane with a parachute.

There is no option for a pregnant woman that doesn’t involve risking her health.

Rainbowqueeen · 08/12/2021 19:02

No contraception is 100 percent effective. So there is always the risk of pregnancy. Every single time

The focus in society now is on sex being purely for pleasure. Well it’s not. There are potential consequences and these should not be solely the responsibility of women.

Having an abortion is not an easy option with no impact on a woman. At the very least it involves time - to organise it, recover from it etc. then it is part of your life forever. It is part of your medical history, something that you will be asked about in the future. People judge you for it. There is a lot of evidence about mental health issues relating to past abortions.

No matter the outcome of the pregnancy it will have an impact on a woman.

Like all woman’s issues it needs to be taken more seriously and not just ignored in favour of doing what best suits men

Finknottlesnewt · 08/12/2021 19:01

Parents of boys need to educate them.
The education system is woefully inadequate in this regard.

  1. Parents need to talk to their son and educate them to guard their fertility if they do not want to be responsible/financially responsible for children.
  1. Schools need to educate boys AND girls. Boys to understand that EVERY act of sex can result in a pregnancy and therefore a financial responsibility for life.

To get it through their stupid heads that a girl telling you ' it's alright I'm on the pill' .. to NEVER take that as an absolute and to use their own contraceptive precautions.

FOR girls to value themselves more . If he treats you like shit .. he is not going to behave better or love you more 'if you have his baby' ... he will still leave you. With a baby.

Honestly ..
Education, education, education.

Morechocolatethanbarbara · 08/12/2021 19:01

I love the way that none of the ardent "men's rights" supporters have suggested how said baby should be paid for if the father doesn't contribute.

Most people I know either need 2 incomes and/or help from the state to raise a child these days. So are you suggesting that the tax payers pay for the child-rearing instead of the father?

Or do we send the mother to the poor house if she can't afford to raise the child by herself and refuse her state support?

Why should people who had no input to the child being created (tax-payers) pay for it, or a child be left in poverty whilst the man (who had sex knowing it may create a child) walk away absolved of any responsibility?

That makes no sense whatsoever.

NynaeveSedai · 08/12/2021 19:00

This is bonkers. There are millions of couples who don't want children. Does that mean they should remain celibate forever, just in case?

No, they should use reliable contraception that they are both happy with. That might include no ejaculating inside the woman. There is more to sex than man squirting inside woman.

mbosnz · 08/12/2021 19:00

I'd really hate to have sex with a man that was incapable of putting on a condom. Or thinking 'what if I don't put on a condom'?

Generally, it seems to be men that are resistant to taking personal responsibility for contraception, given that it apparently interferes with their sexual pleasure. Oh dear. How Sad. Saddle up boys.

NynaeveSedai · 08/12/2021 18:57

@MrsLarry

What about situations where the woman lies about taking contraception? The woman that's decided she wants a baby no matter what? This happens a lot more than you think.
Men still have the choice to use their own contraception. Or not ejaculate inside their partner.