Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think father should pay csa even if he doesn't want the baby

365 replies

Bear45 · 08/12/2021 18:03

As title says!
He wanted me to have an abortion and I've not heard off him for 3 weeks now. I'm 13 weeks, obviously it's a way off but just wondering what peoples opinions are

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Jessie75 · 13/12/2021 09:56

@AntiEverythingToday

I can see both sides of the argument here. Seeing a lot of 'if the man doesn't want a baby he shouldn't have sex' .. I wonder what people think about if the circumstances were that the man was raped and the woman fell pregnant. Should he be liable for child maintenance to his rapist?
I am prepared to concede that if a man is restrained and his sperm is removed by force that he shouldn’t have to pay for that. However it’s in the same vain as men saying oh we can’t even say hello any more to women, I’d refer them to the YouTube video of difference between a cup of tea and consent and I think they’ll conclude that most of them actually consented to having their sperm withdrawn from them.
Notjustanymum · 13/12/2021 09:34

I think he should pay, yes. However, (and my knowledge may be slightly out of date, as my DS is older now) I remember having “the conversation“ with him about how, even if birth control is used, there is a small chance of a pregnancy, and how a pregnancy would effectively mean at least 18 years of his life caring for the resultant baby/child/teenager.
He didn’t believe me at first, because School PSHE lessons had given his 14-year old self the impression that all contraception was 100% reliable.
Luckily, I was able to show him studies that backed me up, but remember thinking at the time that if parents were too squeamish to talk about these issues and left them to the School, then a whole generation of boys were being misled…

TractorAndHeadphones · 13/12/2021 08:28

@HugeAckmansWife

tractor its not an equation ffs. If you think that a woman chooses an abortion solely on grounds of comparable pain or discomfort you havent the faintest fucking clue what you're talking about and should not be commenting. Those on this thread who see the woman's choice to abort as a simple 'she can just' are failing to factor in a whole raft of arguments and factors about what some people (not me by the way) think about ending a foetus life. In the case of a split condom, I do think both parties should be proactive about getting hold of the MAP, however so the 'problem' never really gets started.
I do know, because that was my own choice. But then again I came from a country where abortion wasn’t a choice so was very glad to have been in the U.K. where my life wouldn’t have been ruined. I’d never have had sex in my home country.

I’d also spent thousands of pounds studying in the U.K., would have to leave the country. I reckoned that the emotional fallout from throwing my whole future away would probably have been much much worse than getting rid of a bunch of cells.

As pp have said whoever thinks foetus = precious life really shouldn’t have sex. Even if a man pays CSA it’s a measly sum.

CiaoForDiNiaoSaur · 13/12/2021 04:25

Women can't, under UK law, rape a man.

AntiEverythingToday · 13/12/2021 02:38

I can see both sides of the argument here.
Seeing a lot of 'if the man doesn't want a baby he shouldn't have sex' .. I wonder what people think about if the circumstances were that the man was raped and the woman fell pregnant. Should he be liable for child maintenance to his rapist?

safclass · 13/12/2021 01:35

And what if she wants him on the certificate and he refuses?

strivingtosucceed · 13/12/2021 00:15

I think the problem is a lot of you give men too much credit, so many men sleep with multiple women and expect them to sort out their own contraception because their bodies don't bear the consequences.

My cheating ex was sleeping with me (I was on the pill) and at least one other woman with no protection. She got pregnant and I had a scare, which is when he told me about her. Does anyone seriously think it would be right for me and the however many women to be forced to have abortions while he simply walks away with no consequence?

Another question is where do you draw the line on "giving up rights"? At 6 weeks? Many women don't know yet. At 10 weeks, you're already looking at a surgical abortion. How many pregnancies can a man do this for? What about abusive men who say they want kids then reverse the decision at the last minute?

Bollindger · 12/12/2021 22:07

If a man gives his seed, then he knows he could have made a baby,
Guess what, condoms mostly protect men from this problem,

Duchess379 · 10/12/2021 22:26

@FriendWoes111

I dont believe the "a man agrees to a potential pregnancy when he has sex" line. It's so simplistic. It belongs in the same category as "a woman agrees to have sex when she undresses".

Why should a man have a vasectomy? Maybe he would like kids one day, just not now and not with you.

In most cases as women we have ample opportunity to stop a pregnancy if we choose. Going ahead with it when the man doesnt want it is selfish towards the kid, the man and society. I see it as the ultimate capitalistic act, in which your own wants take precedence over just about everybody else's. The man doesnt want to be a father. The child would want a father. Society doesn't want to pay for your wilfully poor financial decisions.

Some women on here seem to confuse empowerment with selfishness.

This 👍🏼
RealBecca · 10/12/2021 14:37

Yanbu.men shiuld pay.

Men can choose sex with varying levels of risk. Their choice is deciding the level of risk they accept. No condom, condom, vasectomy, vasectomy and condom, abstinence.

Women can choose what contraception they accept men using and any opt for anything further. No obligation to have an abortion.

WFHiswank · 10/12/2021 14:32

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/pregnancy/4372507-pregnant-with-ex-s-baby-help

I don't know if you are a troll but you already have 2 older kids whose father don't have anything to do with them? Why hadn't you talked about what you would do if you became pregnant accidentally? It wasn't exactly a ONS.

You've said your ex isn't in a good place mentally. Obviously it's going to get worse with a baby he doesn't want. Do you really think your kid is going to have the best life possible?

MultiStorey · 10/12/2021 14:24

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

CounsellorTroi · 10/12/2021 10:54

Women shouldn’t have sex if they don’t want to become pregnant/have a termination/raise a child alone without support.

Just the same for men if they don’t want to be fathers.

asha456 · 10/12/2021 10:54

@NynaeveSedai

Why do women advocate for men being able to spunk at will then relinquish responsibility for babies they create? I literally cannot understand why any women would advocate for something so wholely bad for women and children and society in general, where the only benefit is allowing men to have risk free sex with whoever they want. What on Earth?
I wouldn't assume that everyone in the thread is a woman.
girlmom21 · 10/12/2021 10:31

[quote GrannytoaUnicorn]@thatstheloveiwantiwantlove What?!?! The mother cannot 'refuse to leave the father's name off the birth certificate!' Mothers CANNOT by LAW add a father's name or anybody's name onto a birth certificate without them present to sign it! Give your head a shake[/quote]
She can if they're married

GrannytoaUnicorn · 10/12/2021 10:25

@FriendWoes111

I dont believe the "a man agrees to a potential pregnancy when he has sex" line. It's so simplistic. It belongs in the same category as "a woman agrees to have sex when she undresses".

Why should a man have a vasectomy? Maybe he would like kids one day, just not now and not with you.

In most cases as women we have ample opportunity to stop a pregnancy if we choose. Going ahead with it when the man doesnt want it is selfish towards the kid, the man and society. I see it as the ultimate capitalistic act, in which your own wants take precedence over just about everybody else's. The man doesnt want to be a father. The child would want a father. Society doesn't want to pay for your wilfully poor financial decisions.

Some women on here seem to confuse empowerment with selfishness.

Wow. Just wow. What a truly heartless individual you are. Staggering
GrannytoaUnicorn · 10/12/2021 10:20

@thatstheloveiwantiwantlove

If the mother names him on the birth certificate then yes he should pay. If she doesn't then no he shouldn't.
The mother CANNOT 'name him' on the birth certificate ffs! 🤦🏼‍♀️🤦🏼‍♀️🤦🏼‍♀️🤦🏼‍♀️ He HAS to be there and name himself and bloody SIGN the damn thing!
GrannytoaUnicorn · 10/12/2021 10:18

@FabianK

I’ve always thought men should be able to opt out of parental responsibility including csa payments up to a certain time.

Women can make a choice and men should be able to also.

That is more than fair.

So the woman has to pay everything just because the man has decided "Nah, no thanks" HmmHmmHmmBiscuit
GrannytoaUnicorn · 10/12/2021 10:17

@thatstheloveiwantiwantlove What?!?! The mother cannot 'refuse to leave the father's name off the birth certificate!' Mothers CANNOT by LAW add a father's name or anybody's name onto a birth certificate without them present to sign it! Give your head a shake

girlmom21 · 10/12/2021 10:16

I'm sorry but the law states otherwise!

It's a debate about morals vs law. We know what the law says.

GrannytoaUnicorn · 10/12/2021 10:15

@peboh

I do not agree. I think if a man makes it clear straight away in pregnancy that he doesn't want a child then he should be able to revoke parental responsibility. The same as if a woman was to not want a child, but the father did, she would be able to make the choice for both of them.
So the woman should have to pay for everything just because he's decided "Nah, don't fancy being a Dad, sorry!"

No. The law is clear. So so clear.

GrannytoaUnicorn · 10/12/2021 10:12

@Thegreencup

Unless the condom he was wearing and the hormonal contraception he was using failed, then he should face the consequences of his choices.
Oh so because the contraceptive failed, the mother should pay for everything?!?!? No sorry. The law is clear. You father a child - you pay for the child
GrannytoaUnicorn · 10/12/2021 10:11

@Rabblesthecat

I go against the grain - no they should not.

Everyone (including the mother) has a choice up to 22 weeks. It may be a choice you don’t want to make but you are still making a choice the other way to keep it.

No baby conceived has to be born so I don’t see why they should have to pay if they have no say in its existence.

I'm sorry but the law states otherwise! Everyone knows ANY sex can potentially lead to conception. If he doesn't want the responsibility then he should not have sex!
FoxgloveSummers · 10/12/2021 10:09

The most recent episode I know like this was a settled relationship where the woman got pregnant unexpectedly (I don’t know their contraception set up but they weren’t planning a baby). The boyfriend immediately demanded she get an abortion, and when she refused (catholic and also was willing to raise this child) he left and ghosted her completely. Thank FUCK his family as well as society have made him take responsibility and support his child because it was no-one’s fault and him freaking out about it shouldn’t mean the woman had to abort what became a much loved child. By the “logic” of some on this thread she should have been forced to.

(Surely when you find yourself advocating forced abortion or taking perfectly loved kids into care, that’s when you turn around and go “am I the bad guys?”

HugeAckmansWife · 10/12/2021 09:22

Sex isnt necessarily casual or recreational in 2021. Plenty of established relationships go tits up when an unexpected pregnancy happens. It's really honestly pretty simple. Men know biology. They know a woman can't be made to have an abortion so there is a chance they will be 50% responsible for a foetus. Lucky them that they can fuck off and do zero parenting and pay just 14% of their post pension pay. Not really onerous is it? But they KNOW this. Their choice is just as real as the woman's. They have one fewer roll of the dice but thats unalterable biology.