Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do people have sympathy for murderers and child abusers?

132 replies

Sweetchocolatecandy · 08/12/2021 15:50

I’ve seen a few comments recently on threads about child abuse (specifically little Arthur) where some posters have said they feel sorry for the likes of murderers such as Tuston as she must have had mental health issues or a rough upbringing herself to make her commit an act like that. Do people really think like this? I suffer from mental health issues but I would never, ever hurt a child and I know people deal with past experiences differently but I think it’s insulting to blame ‘mental health’ for committing abuse and murder.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Hospedia · 08/12/2021 16:09

I haven't seen anyone express sympathy towards them but I have seen comments around the lack of support services and lack of early intervention - usually due to budgetary cuts - and that if these services/interventions had been available then perhaps they wouldn't have ended up killing someone. There have been numerous cases where the perpetrators were failed by the system, this doesn't mean that their crimes are forgivable or excusable, its just an acknowledgement that they were not acting in a vacuum and that the system was culpable in creating the circumstances that led to the crime.

ChristmasJumpers · 08/12/2021 16:08

My DH and I were just talking about this poor little boy. Sadly if he hadn't died from his cruel treatment, the chances are he would have grown up with severe issues from his childhood. Who's to say how he'd have behaved towards others with the mental scars he'd have.

No sympathy whatsoever towards anyone who could hurt a child but it does have me wondering what exactly was wrong with them or anybody who could lay their hands on a child!

Samcro · 08/12/2021 16:06

people always do this. they can't believe some people are just evil,

Dahlietta · 08/12/2021 16:05

I don't think that pondering whether something caused a person to act so abominably means that you have sympathy for them exactly.

x2boys · 08/12/2021 16:04

Maybe because ,she's female ?
Mumsnet can be very anti men but when it comes to women doing something abhorrent,some posters try to look for a reason .

BrightonOrLancaster · 08/12/2021 16:02

You can find someone horrific and deplorable and want them locked away without completely overlooking their past

If Arthur had lived and had grown up to be a violent man, would you not also think back to his tragic childhood with some empathy?

GreetingsAndSalutations · 08/12/2021 16:00

I don’t think wondering what someone’s mental health/upbringing is/was like is being sympathetic towards them when that person has gone to commit a terrible horrendous crime(s). I have poor mental health myself and had a shifty upbringing, for what it’s worth. I am not a child abuser but I’m not offended by people pondering this.

I have idly wondered what lead to such hatred for a little child to the levels of cruelty Arthur was subjected to even before his violent death. Not got an ounce of sympathy for either of those wastes of oxygen. That said, I do feel empathy for Arthur’s birth mother who has also killed someone, as one mother to another. I would feel that for any other parent who’s child had died.

Swipe left for the next trending thread