Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do people have sympathy for murderers and child abusers?

132 replies

Sweetchocolatecandy · 08/12/2021 15:50

I’ve seen a few comments recently on threads about child abuse (specifically little Arthur) where some posters have said they feel sorry for the likes of murderers such as Tuston as she must have had mental health issues or a rough upbringing herself to make her commit an act like that. Do people really think like this? I suffer from mental health issues but I would never, ever hurt a child and I know people deal with past experiences differently but I think it’s insulting to blame ‘mental health’ for committing abuse and murder.

AIBU?

OP posts:
DeadbeatGasbag · 08/12/2021 18:17

I really don't understand why people get so invested in others reactions to horrible events like this. Unless we personally have power to change the events or similar events in future our reaction is irrelevant, and if we do have the power to make a difference then it's less a question of emoting the right way and more making the right practical decisions.

It's a good, dare I say even beautiful, thing to be able to extend sympathy to anyone, even a people who've done abhorrent things - that level of empathy is the source of a huge amount of art and literature as well as a willingness to try and improve social functioning rather than just round up all the bad people and shoot them.

It's also valuable for society that people have anger toward people who do harm to others especially those that harm the most weak and vulnerable, that anger motives and energises efforts to make changes and take down unjust power structures.

Both reactions have valuable social roles and there's room for both.

Svadhyaya · 08/12/2021 18:15

I haven't seen anybody use it as an 'excuse'. But if we don't look for explanations for this behaviour then how are we going to prevent it from happening again?

lisaandalan · 08/12/2021 18:14

You always get stupid do gooders around, absolutely pathetic people as daft as they come, they'd probably forgive these people Even if they did something to their family too, they must be a bit deranged themselves.

MoonRiverLaLaLa · 08/12/2021 18:11

@sst1234

Because some people go through life making excuses for themselves and others. All bad behaviour has to be mental health related or a result of some trauma of because of upbringing. Personal responsibility is simply not a thing some people. It’s ok as long as others suffer, but the badly behaved must be shown ‘empathy’ at all times. And those not us that do not look for excuse's are simply savages.
This.
U2HasTheEdge · 08/12/2021 18:11

People are just trying to understand. I don't believe that people are born evil.

The fact is, developmental trauma can lead to psychopathy. We know developmental trauma causes physical changes in the brain.
The age and stage of brain development that someone experienced trauma can change the affect trauma has on someone. So many factors are involved, which is why two siblings can have the same experiences but turn out so differently.

People who have not experience significant trauma don't tend to end up like Tustin. Something has happened. I don't have sympathy, but no one is born evil.

AlternativePerspective · 08/12/2021 18:10

My DP suffered the most horrific abuse as a child and he’s managed to grow up without becoming a murderer.

While in some instances issues as children might lead to them committing atrocities as children or young adults, no-one should be falling back on their childhood or on mental illness to excuse their atrocious acts.

I think we can all agree that nobody who murders and tortures someone is mentally normal.But that doesn’t equal them being mentally ill or deserving of sympathy.

Often people who have MH issues are led to feel victimised by the assumption that x or y murderer must be mentally ill, because the assumption seems to be that mental illness equals liable to commit atrocious acts. In the same way if we assume that someone who murders someone must have had a disturbed childhood, so those who have had bad upbringings run the risk of being seen as bad people by virtue of their childhoods.

My DP for instance was told that it’s rather strange that he didn’t grow up with awful behaviours, was told he shouldn’t be in contact with small children because sexual abuse as a child would lead him to become a paedophile as an adult, and that being an abused child equals becoming a criminal as an adult.

People are individuals. If Arthur had become a murderer had he lived to adulthood he would have been no more deserving of sympathy because of his childhood, as an adult, he would have been responsible for the acts he committed as an adult.

MoonRiverLaLaLa · 08/12/2021 18:09

Why do people have sympathy for murderers and child abusers?

It makes them feel so woke and empathetic.

I personally couldn't care less what childhood they had. Not everyone who has a difficult childhood becomes an abuser. They are not children anymore. They are responsible for their choices and should be judged by them.

IntermittentParps · 08/12/2021 18:06

I'm not actually interested in why she is a psychopath in this case
We kind of need to be (as a society, not individuals necessarily, but you take my point) if we are to have any hope of understanding and possibly curing/ameliorating conditions like psychopathy, and/or preventing this sort of thing happening with people with these conditions.

RepentMotherfucker · 08/12/2021 18:05

@Kanaloa

I can feel sorry for someone while abhorring the crimes they’ve committed or disliking the person they are. When I hear if a case like this I feel sorry it ever had to happen.

I think some people (not saying all, and not criticising) get too involved with cases like this. It’s like the not enjoy exactly but get some sort of energy out of being so wrapped up in it. I have an acquaintance who does it every time a case like this comes up, she reads every detail/article of the case and every time you see her she has to tell you how heartbroken she is for ‘poor little Arthur’ and how she hopes ‘those bastards rot in hell’ and what she’d do to them if she got her hands on them etc etc etc.

But when I suggest she might want to volunteer with me, working with foster children? No she doesn’t want to. When I mention that I buy gifts for children every Christmas her hands are full buying presents for her kids.

Basically, to sum it up, I think people like to say they’re monsters/evil/not human, because it absolves you of any actual societal responsibility. It’s easier to say a murdered is inhumane because it saves us of having to consider whether our society played a part in creating this ‘monster,’ and whether there’s a possibility we could know someone who has the potential to be like this as well.

Totally agree.

These threads are full of people saying 'I would have rescued that little boy and wrapped him in my arms etc etc' alongside 'those bastards are just evil blah blah'. How many kids just like this have those people fostered or adopted? None.

And just look at the number of people in AIBU telling others to mind their own business when they are concerned about a child.

It's all part of the same process where we put 'evil' in a box and claim it has nothing to do with the real world we live in. There is nothing we can do to help and so we have no obligation to do anything at all.

ToykotoLosAngeles · 08/12/2021 18:02

I followed the trial for quite a while. In my opinion, she is a psychopath and he was easily lead (by his penis) plus thick as shit.

I'm not actually interested in why she is a psychopath in this case, more that she never gets her hands on anyone else's kods again, including her own grandchildren in 29 years.

CommonRoom · 08/12/2021 17:58

OP although I have not read every thread about this murder I think I can confidently say that nobody on here (or anywhere) would have expressed sympathy for the murderers. Please can you share the evidence that they did?

Some people have discussed the possible reasons why people abuse or murder children because we really need to understand how it happens. It's a essential step in stopping it happening again. But discussing the reasons why somebody does something is not the same as sympathising. Problems in society get fixed by people looking at what causes them. We really have made a lot of progress in society this way. Children are much safer now than they were 100 years ago. If you don't allow anybody to talk about why things happen then nothing changes.

DottyHarmer · 08/12/2021 17:58

Yes, it’s entirely reasonable to examine behaviour dispassionately - clinically - but it’s another step to eagerly absolve them from blame because, because, because…..

Thegreencup · 08/12/2021 17:56

If you understand the reasons why something has happened, then you can go some way to stop it from happening again.

No crime is ever cut and dry. Plenty of nice, respectable people do evil and horrendous things. Plenty of evil people still take their mum out for lunch on a Sunday, take the kids to school and walk the dog.

IloveRitaConnors · 08/12/2021 17:55

I'm not sure it's sympathy, I do wonder about why, mainly because if we know why, then we can maybe recognise it early and stop them from actually killing and abusing. Surely it would be better that their issues are recognised and supported rather than these things being brushed under the carpet resulting in it all going to ratshit and some poor sole dying.
It's not about sympathising with them it's about stopping them from harming.

LizzieSiddal · 08/12/2021 17:54

I don't think that pondering whether something caused a person to act so abominably means that you have sympathy for them exactly.

I agree. Also it’s important for professional to ask these questions. If we know why people do these things we may beable to stop it in the future.

Kanaloa · 08/12/2021 17:53

That’s not be saying that murderers and child abusers can’t help it or anything like that. I’ve had a difficult childhood and I’m the opposite - I don’t want to pass that to my kids.

I was just pointing out that saying ‘x is evil and a monster so no point considering how that happened’ isn’t helpful really. It doesn’t help the victim, and it won’t stop it happening in the future the same way trying to make systemic and societal changes will.

Kanaloa · 08/12/2021 17:51

I can feel sorry for someone while abhorring the crimes they’ve committed or disliking the person they are. When I hear if a case like this I feel sorry it ever had to happen.

I think some people (not saying all, and not criticising) get too involved with cases like this. It’s like the not enjoy exactly but get some sort of energy out of being so wrapped up in it. I have an acquaintance who does it every time a case like this comes up, she reads every detail/article of the case and every time you see her she has to tell you how heartbroken she is for ‘poor little Arthur’ and how she hopes ‘those bastards rot in hell’ and what she’d do to them if she got her hands on them etc etc etc.

But when I suggest she might want to volunteer with me, working with foster children? No she doesn’t want to. When I mention that I buy gifts for children every Christmas her hands are full buying presents for her kids.

Basically, to sum it up, I think people like to say they’re monsters/evil/not human, because it absolves you of any actual societal responsibility. It’s easier to say a murdered is inhumane because it saves us of having to consider whether our society played a part in creating this ‘monster,’ and whether there’s a possibility we could know someone who has the potential to be like this as well.

RatsolutelyFabulous · 08/12/2021 17:50

With this case, she had 4 of her own children, whom she never harmed, so why did Arthur, a child that isn’t biologically hers, get murdered by her?

I think it’s a grey area between mental health and someone just being pure evil. I think in this case, if she could manage to never lay a hand or treat her own children like she did Arthur. Then she is just a callous, horrid, evil woman, it has nothing to do with her upbringing or mental health problems.

I do agree with you though OP, that I do get sick of the mental health card getting brought up any time someone commits a crime, of course there are plenty that will of had horrendous upbringings and will cause them to act in a violent manner and we need to understand this to prevent future generations from potentially becoming killers by giving them the help they need to deal with their problems, but I do believe there are some people who are just pure evil and enjoy killing for no other reason than the high/power and control.

I also say this as someone who has had a really shite childhood and suffer with mental health problems, just before anyone jumps on me for saying about the mental health card.

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 08/12/2021 17:49

@Mosbiusdesigns

It's the cycle of abuse isn't it. I don't think what they've done is right obviously but for example Arthur's dad and step-mother, what were their childhoods like for them to think that's OK? What is wrong in them that they would do that? People will also, understandably, never want to think people have done horrific things purely for the enjoyment of it, so we look for the why. Mental health, drugs, abusive childhood, coerced, financially forced/motivated.
Well Hughes brother managed to be a father perfectly fine.
PermanentTemporary · 08/12/2021 17:44

Some really interesting posts. I agree with @StoneofDestiny.

I also find it a little depressing that people don't understand how common it is in abusive households to have a 'scapegoat child' who suffers abuse including neglect while the others are treated reasonably or favoured. Cinderella wasn't about the dress.

Chasingaftermidnight · 08/12/2021 17:43

Because monsters aren’t born, they’re created. And if we just dismiss people as ‘evil’ instead of trying to understand a) what made them the way they are and b) what could have prevented them from doing what they did, then our society will never improve.

Coyoacan · 08/12/2021 17:43

So you, OP, think it is wrong for society to want to learn from these crimes. Humans need to be curious and empathetic to progress and avoid repeating wrongs.

If that empathy helps to obtain insights that stop other human beings turning out like that couple, surely it is worth it.

As for your believing yourself smeared because of the reference to mental health, surely there are as many different mental health problems as there are physical health problems.

StoneofDestiny · 08/12/2021 17:42

I know many people who have suffered significant trauma and do not go on to abuse and murder people

Means nothing. Individual circumstances are just that - individual. We hear often of survivors of rape who go on to thrive in life, others say their lives are ruined. Different things come into play for all of us. Neither response is right, neither is wrong.

JaninaDuszejko · 08/12/2021 17:42

The only people I've met who were devoid of empathy are foster children that were most dreadfully abused and have complex mental and physical health issues. They have shut down the ability to bond with others at a very early age as a self protection mechanism and are considered unsuitable for adoption at preschool ages so will spend their childhood in care. It's truly tragic. Even those who have been adopted (so are less affected by their early childhood abuse or neglect) can have ongoing issues due to their abuse.

If you look at the prison population then 27% of prisoners spent some time in care as a child (to put it another way half of all children in care will end up in prison), 90% have a mental health problem, 29% of the prison population have suffered childhood abuse, 46% came from homes in which they either experienced or witnessed violence, 15% were homeless immediately prior to incarceration and 62% have drug problems. If we don't want crime we need to break the cycle of abuse and declaring someone as 'pure evil' is not helpful, it's abdicating any responsibility to deal with the issue which just means the next generation will repeat the same mistakes.

If the OP is one of the lucky half of children in care who survived the system well enough to go on to form healthy relationships she should be very proud of herself and realise she is exceptional because many people would not have achieved what she has achieved.

DottyHarmer · 08/12/2021 17:41

There may be reasons or explanations for an individual’s behaviour, but they should never be excuses . It is useful to examine how someone came to commit crimes, particularly vile ones, but having “sympathy” leads us down a dangerous path of “Aw, it’s not their fault” and someone must be to blame.

Additionally I agree with a pp who observed that some people are so open-minded their brains have fallen out of their head which does apply to some on here who are keen to “side” with the perpetrator of a crime (eg Manchester bomber - I nearly combusted when a poster said they felt equally sorry for him and his family Angry )

Swipe left for the next trending thread