My DP suffered the most horrific abuse as a child and he’s managed to grow up without becoming a murderer.
While in some instances issues as children might lead to them committing atrocities as children or young adults, no-one should be falling back on their childhood or on mental illness to excuse their atrocious acts.
I think we can all agree that nobody who murders and tortures someone is mentally normal.But that doesn’t equal them being mentally ill or deserving of sympathy.
Often people who have MH issues are led to feel victimised by the assumption that x or y murderer must be mentally ill, because the assumption seems to be that mental illness equals liable to commit atrocious acts. In the same way if we assume that someone who murders someone must have had a disturbed childhood, so those who have had bad upbringings run the risk of being seen as bad people by virtue of their childhoods.
My DP for instance was told that it’s rather strange that he didn’t grow up with awful behaviours, was told he shouldn’t be in contact with small children because sexual abuse as a child would lead him to become a paedophile as an adult, and that being an abused child equals becoming a criminal as an adult.
People are individuals. If Arthur had become a murderer had he lived to adulthood he would have been no more deserving of sympathy because of his childhood, as an adult, he would have been responsible for the acts he committed as an adult.