Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Horrible nickname in DDs Christmas cards

140 replies

BullFrogDog · 08/12/2021 15:17

DD (12) came home with a Christmas card last week which read “to fat thing, merry Christmas from Ria x”
I asked why it said fat thing to which DD said this is just what this girl calls her and she has nicknames for everyone. I said it was a horrible thing to call someone but DD insisted she wanted the card displayed and I was asked not to make a fuss.

Since then 2 more cards have surfaced addressed to “Fat Thing” from different girls. I called the school, they have finally rang me back and said they spoke with DD and the girls involved and it transpired that this is a nickname for DD which she states she doesn’t mind. The teacher has banned the nickname and has instructed DD to inform her if anyone calls her it again.
Rightly or wrongly I’ve just had a quick look on her laptop and this name has been in use for months, at least as far back as the main lockdown.

AIBU to want to take it further or am I being OTT?

OP posts:
minitree · 08/12/2021 17:07

Ok @Negligee you sound so uptight

TeaSoakedDisasterMagnet · 08/12/2021 17:07

All those asking if she’s fat, why does it matter? It’s rude to comment or nickname on someone’s weight either way. It’s horrible and isn’t acceptable whether she’s fat, thin or even just average. Asking if she’s fat or saying it’s ok because she might be thin so it’s a joke is horrible, both are body shaming and fat phobic. Stop it!

Hankunamatata · 08/12/2021 17:05

Or Op dd says she is ok as she is desperate to fit in - rather is xmas card with awful nickname than no xmas cards!

Negligee · 08/12/2021 17:04

@minitree

What difference does it make what the OP's child's BMI is? If she is an overweight child, does it make the nickname more or less acceptable?

If the OP's daughter is fat, the nickname is obviously unacceptable.

If the OP's daughter is stick thin, then it could be a friendly nickname in good humour. Much like my bean pole brother being called Fatty, and my absolutely gargantuan uncle being called Pixie.

Nuance.

I really don't think nuance means what you think it means.

Or that, as I said above, that the rest of the OP's child's friendship gang is likely to consist of Spotty (because she has a glorious complexion), Cankles (because she has great legs) etc,

Sparklfairy · 08/12/2021 17:04

When we were teens our friendship group had a girl whose nickname was related to being a (fat) cow. It was some in joke in her family and said with affection at home. So when we met on first day of year 7 she said "hi I'm VaguelyInsultingNickname". We all thought it was cool in our little group and gave ourselves nicknames related to unattractive animals normally related to insults Grin

Hankunamatata · 08/12/2021 17:02

I'm bloody shocked by response's. Its not ok to comments on someone's weight never mind a nickname. We wouldn't accept it amongst adults why the hell would you let vile pre teens get away with it

minitree · 08/12/2021 17:02

What difference does it make what the OP's child's BMI is? If she is an overweight child, does it make the nickname more or less acceptable?

If the OP's daughter is fat, the nickname is obviously unacceptable.

If the OP's daughter is stick thin, then it could be a friendly nickname in good humour. Much like my bean pole brother being called Fatty, and my absolutely gargantuan uncle being called Pixie.

Nuance.

Negligee · 08/12/2021 17:00

@dumdedumpop

I'll be on the fence until the OP lets us know if her daughter is indeed overweight, and gives us an idea of what the other girls are nicknamed. Context is everything!
I'd be really surprised if the other girls are known as Spotty, Sarah Two-Chins, Cankles and Midget.
mam0918 · 08/12/2021 17:00

Its not your place to step on your daughter's identity... she said she is fine with 'fat thing' and has relayed that multiple times maybe she ACTUALLY likes it.

My nickname was deemed offensive by some as frankly, they had dirty minds and it says more about them than me (Names Cat, the nickname was Pussy) they tried to forcibly 'stop it' and it didn't work because I overrode their 'offense' and its MY personal identity not theirs.

I'm a fully grown adult and still go affectionately by Pussy with several friends through choice and the only people who were disrespectful and bullying were those who tried to control my nickname against my wishes and who refuse to listen to me and acknowledge what I was telling them.

DH nickname as a teen was Shithead and he still uses it among his old friends and happily refers to himself as Shithead because 'hes the shit' with his old school mates... childish definitely but offensive no as only he has the right to be offended by a name used for himself.

If your daughter was upset or being bullied by these girls then that's a world of difference and you have every right to get the school involved and give out a warning but this legitimately sounds like an affectionate in joke between friends.

minitree · 08/12/2021 16:59

@Ubiquery

Op needs to let us know if her daughter is fat or not

Yeah, 90 minutes on this is still a fairly important detail that OP hasn't clarified Hmm

I believe we've all been had.
Negligee · 08/12/2021 16:59

@Ubiquery

Op needs to let us know if her daughter is fat or not

Yeah, 90 minutes on this is still a fairly important detail that OP hasn't clarified Hmm

What difference does it make what the OP's child's BMI is? If she is an overweight child, does it make the nickname more or less acceptable?
dumdedumpop · 08/12/2021 16:59

I'll be on the fence until the OP lets us know if her daughter is indeed overweight, and gives us an idea of what the other girls are nicknamed. Context is everything!

IncompleteSenten · 08/12/2021 16:58

@Ubiquery

Op needs to let us know if her daughter is fat or not

Yeah, 90 minutes on this is still a fairly important detail that OP hasn't clarified Hmm

She most likely is but if the op has been on here more than 5 minutes she'll know how that will go! Lots of supportive replies but an equal number of what do you expect, put her on a diet, this is your fault, fat people are sent from the devil and all that shit.
hivemindneeded · 08/12/2021 16:58

I had a teacher whose nn for me was Old Fat Thing. I told him it upset me and he said the joke was that I was not old or fat or a thing.

If your daughter isn't upset by it, I'd leave it. In an ideal world, kids wouldn't give demeaning names but the next best thing to that is to raise a child to absolutely not care if they do and for it to do zero damage to their sense of self worth. If she is at that stage, good for her.

But if she is chubby and self conscious about it, I'd have a word with teachers and ask them to look out for name calling.

ShinyHappyPoster · 08/12/2021 16:57

You've already contacted the school and they've spoken to the girls, and told them not to use it again. There's nothing else for the school to do here.

Except as PPs have said, work on your DD's self-esteem and encourage her to be more open with you. You might need to be more on top of her social media and messaging so you can nip stuff like this in the bud sooner.

IncompleteSenten · 08/12/2021 16:56

I'd be amazed if she was actually ok with it

Unless maybe there's some really weird and funny back story and it's nothing to do with her weight and even then I'd be doubtful at that age.

What are the other girls' nicknames? Are they similarly offensive?

People who are, on the surface, part of a friendship group find it hard to face it if they are being bullied by that group. They may even accept it in order to remain in the group. It's hard and she's so young. This is too much for her to navigate without you, no matter what she says.

Ubiquery · 08/12/2021 16:55

Op needs to let us know if her daughter is fat or not

Yeah, 90 minutes on this is still a fairly important detail that OP hasn't clarified Hmm

Ubiquery · 08/12/2021 16:53

I think your daughter has found a way, her way, of handling the situation. I'm not saying you should support it, but I don't think you should undermine it.
Bullying shouldn't exist, but it does, and the best thing we can do is support our children to develop their coping strategies, be it passivity, humour or whatever.

MuguetRose · 08/12/2021 16:51

@Kittykat93

Fucking hate young girls, sorry but the majority of them are arseholes. I don't blame you for ringing the school, not sure what else you can do but you have my sympathies..I'm not looking forward to the teen years.
I really hope you don't have daughters with such sexist, hateful attitudes to young girls.
CovidMakesThingsHard · 08/12/2021 16:49

Of course she’s going to say to the teacher she’s fine with it, she wants to keep her friends, even if that is really horrible of them.

MuguetRose · 08/12/2021 16:48

Why do people use posts like this as an excuse to make sexist, hateful comments about girls? I know loads of nice young girls. Would we think it OK to write "I fucking hate old women, they are arseholes?" No we wouldn't and rightly so.

luverlybubberly · 08/12/2021 16:43

Do the other girls have nicknames ? Are they "mean" too?

Negligee · 08/12/2021 16:43

@icedcoffees

Because a lot of children will pretend they're fine when they're being bullied

Absolutely, but at the same time, not everything that's offensive to adults is offensive to children.

I think that all children of that, and especially girls, have a strong sense that 'fat' is one of the worst possible insults to apply to someone. DS is heading for ten, and that's the sense I get from him and his friendship group.
minitree · 08/12/2021 16:42

We call my youngest brother Fatty because he's a beanpole.

Op needs to let us know if her daughter is fat or not

WhenISnappedAndFarted · 08/12/2021 16:40

Is she fat?

My DP's friend is called 'little Dave' as a nickname, the man's 6 foot 8.

Swipe left for the next trending thread