Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to have requested single sex rape crisis therapy?

564 replies

IamSarah · 08/12/2021 13:56

My local rape crisis centre offers a dedicated support group for trans and non-binary survivors and a women's group open to anyone who identifies as a woman.

After a male (presenting as male) turned up in the women's group I requested an additional group for women who were born women. This request was turned down and I was told that group support isn't for me. AIBU?

YABU: You shouldn't need an additional, exclusive group for biological women

YANBU: Under these circumstances, a single sex group just for biological women was a reasonable request

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
Helleofabore · 09/12/2021 07:49

The current CEO of the Edinburgh Rape Crisis Centre also admitted in an interview that it gave them some kind of thrill to gaslight women into believing they were talking to another woman while deciding which women got assistance to get food or not in their role in a call centre in India. The call centre was a help line for assessing additional welfare for women and families in need.

This person has told people who they are time and time again and sadly, they have been elevated to this position of authority despite it. It really is like there is new subset of males who have been declared exempt from safeguarding.

Helleofabore · 09/12/2021 07:42

I am sure I saw a thread started last night with Mr Menno’s latest video.

Penises have been censored out but it is still confronting enough to need a content warning!!!

However, saying that it is rather a relevant string of pictorial evidence on the fact that while not all TW are like that, you cannot tell until it is too late which is which.

I won’t link it as Mr Menno’s YouTube links tend to get deleted so I am just suggesting you search for it yourself.

It does include reference to the fast growing porn category of transitioned penises being masturbated in female toilets.

I mention this because there is large elephant in the room that certain posters who keep pleading for females to lower their boundaries like to ignore. There are a known, although small, group of males who DO find pleasure in being in female only spaces. This may be sexual, but it may also be based on other motivations.

But only those who are either uninformed, or determinedly adhering to their own agenda will seek to silence women discussing this particular group. Those who are uninformed do it because they don’t want to believe it happens. Those who know it happens, ignore it while silencing anyone who highlights it because it may damage their political aims. Well, there are also those who directly benefit from this being kept silent, but I hope it is not the motivation of anyone on this thread.

My advice to those who are attempting to silence anyone from having this discussion, or to control the discussion, even via shaming tactics and emotional manipulation (including hyperbole) is to examine why you wish to deny this (very small) group of males exist. What else, other than silencing women discussing it, are they actively doing to facilitate it? What is their personal motivation?

How do they believe these people are to be filtered out? Do they think these males wear a sign that states their intention?

And do you honestly believe ANY female’s trauma or discomfort should be used in this way?

LimpLettice · 09/12/2021 07:13

@EricCartmansUnderpants

So Midrul is a male, presumably identifying as a female. Who left the SNP because Midrul thinks men should be able to examine women who have been raped. And now has got a job leading Edinburgh rape crises. Right at the centre of where abused, traumatised and vulnerable women are. Midrul is there shaping the organisation for the benefit of men. Where abused woman turn to, born males like Midrul are waiting for them. Supposedly to ease their trauma. Sounds like a second assault to me. It's astounding how men have got themselves into these positions and got ahead of law and policy in order to establish a foothold. And males like these, that seem to have little regard for women, are the last males women should ever be sharing their sex segregated space with.
Yep!
NotBadConsidering · 09/12/2021 06:23

@PurgatoryOfPotholes

This entire thread reminds me of this graphic.
Remarkably, despite that poster, Clementine Ford is full TWAW.
ClaudiaJ1 · 09/12/2021 04:20

The reason why 2 posters are complaining about Sarah starting this thread, on AIBU, is because they don't want the truth of what is happening to get out, they want to silence her, to stop the wider community becoming aware.

Tough titties to those 2 posters! We will shout about this and never, ever, ever shut up. We won't stop until our SEX-BASED RIGHTS, enshrined in law, are restored/stop being removed. We will win.

ClaudiaJ1 · 09/12/2021 04:13

@DdraigGoch

I suspect I have more lived experience in providing support to rape victims than the majority of posters on this thread. Which says a lot *@Stompythedinosaur*, though not in the way you had intended. No wonder services are in such a state.
I doubt very much Stompy has ever even met a rape victim. No one could be so sociopathically lacking in empathy, intuition and understanding of a rape victim's needs if they had.
Kyliealwayshadthebestdisco · 09/12/2021 04:03

You are not the one being unreasonable here in this particular situation. It’s madness that they can’t see this.

SD1978 · 09/12/2021 03:49

YANBU. you can't have a group that protects one 'type' of women, and not others. Sex is still a protected characteristic, and whilst you'll never win this one, and I'm sorry about that and hope you get the help,you need and deserve, it's another example,of the unfairness and inequalities women face. We can be in all your places, because we are you, but you can't play where we say you can't play......

ClaudiaJ1 · 09/12/2021 03:35

@Pixiedust138 That's just not accurate. Some trans women have had gender reassignment surgery and therefore do not have penises.

Only 3%, that's three percent, of trans women have had their penis removed. The massive OVERWHELMING MAJORITY, 97%, retain their penis. Despite claiming they 'feel' woman.

When 97% percent of trans women retain their weapon - their penis, then safeguarding needs to be made of this basis.

ClaudiaJ1 · 09/12/2021 03:25

@Stompythedinosaur

Most services don't offer a cis only group for the same reason they don't offer white only groups, straight only groups or men only groups. Because private space is generally reserved for the oppressed group.
@Stompythedinosaur BIOLOGICAL WOMEN ARE the oppressed group! Which means that male bodies however they 'identify' as are NOT the oppressed group and have no right being there.

Btw, the centre has a man-only group, AND a trans-only group. Just not a women-only group.

ClaudiaJ1 · 09/12/2021 03:22

@Stompythedinosaur I would say that if an individual can't access group support alongside the other woman using the service then it is reasonable to offer 1:1 support as an alternative.

OR, if an individual can't access group support alongside the other women using the service because a male is present, then it is reasonable to offer a biological woman-only service as an alternative.

ClaudiaJ1 · 09/12/2021 03:18

@Pixiedust138 A trans woman is very different than a man turning up.

No it isn't because they are both one and the same. Both a penis-haver.

ClaudiaJ1 · 09/12/2021 03:16

@Stompythedinosaur I think you'll find most NHS employees support trans rights.

Supporting trans rights is irrelevant, we all support trans rights. But we support women's sex-based rights, that are enshrined in law.

Btw, employees of NHS and their union are campaigning to have the NHS leave Stonewall.

ClaudiaJ1 · 09/12/2021 02:52

@Stompythedinosaur Women are a minority. An oppressed minority. A male born person is not a minority.

Only on mn is it a far out belief to say it is OK to be trans.

No one on Mn is saying it's not ok to be trans. Just that women should have a right to biological sex-only spaces. How is that so difficult for you to understand?

ClaudiaJ1 · 09/12/2021 02:41

@Stompythedinosaur

But the issue here is ultimately a trans identity issue.

I believe that a trans woman is a woman, so should be able to attend a woman's group. The reality of that we have no idea and no need to know what is in anyone else's underwear.

I want everyone to to able to access appropriate support after rape. But what do you expect services to do when you decline to share space based on a prejudice? They are hardly going to exclude another woman who also needs support due to such feelings.

I have an experience of running a MH support group where a member didn't want a gay woman to be able to join as this made her uncomfortable and her belief was that homosexuality is wrong. Clearly we did not go along with that. I think the situation being described here is very similar.

That said, if the situation described by the op (an attender who was a man, rather than a trans woman) happened then I think they have been very poorly treated and should complain.

@Stompythedinosaur No, the issue here is WOMEN and THEIR TRAUMA, not the selfish needs of trans 'identity'. The issue here is SEX-BASED TRAUMA, not 'identity'. A trans woman is not a woman and never can be, not by DNA, not biologically, not anatomically.

This centre already had a trans specific group, designed for trans women to go to. Instead, they chose to infiltrate the biological woman's group, as a power play and to 'get off' on listening to women's trauma stories. This is what 'trans women are women' leads to. It's a dangerous lie.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 09/12/2021 02:08

This entire thread reminds me of this graphic.

AIBU to have requested single sex rape crisis therapy?
PurgatoryOfPotholes · 09/12/2021 01:53

@SweetPetrichor

YABU for starting another thread. We’ve had this topic already.
You just told a rape survivor that she was unreasonable for speaking about this because there had been one thread. So there is a thread limit, is there? Would you like to be more specific and tell us how many posts any given survivor is allowed to make about abuse on MN before she's used up her allotment? Is she supposed to be over it all by the time one thread is filled up?

Were you born without the capacity to sympathise with others like Daleks, or was it scoured from you later by some mechanical means, as with the method used to produce Cybermen in Doctor Who?

Beyond your curt reproof to Sarah for apparently posting too much in your opinion, you seem to forget there is a wider context. Do you think only one woman has ever been subjected to sexual violence by a man in the entire history of the UK?

In fact, according to statistics collated in 2013 and released in An Overview of Sexual Offending in England and Wales, by the Ministry of Justice (MoJ), Office for National Statistics (ONS) and Home Office, approximately 85,000 women experience rape, attempted rape or assault by penetration in England and Wales alone every year.

I think therapeutic support provision for an issue that affects 85,000 women every year merits more than one bloody thread.

MrsTerryPratchett · 09/12/2021 01:40

what's insulting about the word CIS? It literally means person who identifies as the gender that they were assigned at birth.

I just wanted to revisit this.

There is a fundamental difference between sex and gender. One that has been muddied by an inability to say 'sex' and by people with an agenda.

SEX is observed at birth. XX or XY, vagina or penis. Which means might you have eggs or ejaculate sperm? Basic biology of not just humans, but any animals that sexually reproduces. You cannot pretend that doesn't exist. It is the only reason the human race exists. Dog breeders don't put any two dogs together and say, "who knows if they will breed?" if they both have the same plumbing.

Partially as a result of SEX differences, gender expectations arose. Woman as nurturer, man as warrior. Woman as gatherer, man as hunter. Some of these also have some biological crossover.

Then we decided pink was for boys ,then for girls. Nice shoes; boys then girls. And so on. Foot binding, neck-stretching, tattoos and their placement, waxing, you name it we assign it. This GENDER stuff is assigned. And it hurts women (and men but I'm a feminist so I care if the patriarchy hurts women).

I am a woman, in all my bleeding, feeding gloriousness. I love myself and my sisters, I don't reject my womanhood. I embrace my SEX. But I reject GENDER in it's entirety. Not for me, but totally. Wear pink, drink pints, throw darts, wrestle a lion. You do you.

But if it's fundamentally about SEX you behave that way. And in the UK at least, rape is with a penis. It's is SEX based.

If there are groups that are based on GENDER (golf clubs, knitting circles) make them GENDER based if you want. But prison, sports, rape centres, DV shelters and the like, SEX based.

TL;DR sex is observed, gender is a cage.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 09/12/2021 00:33

I fully agree with that summary, Eric.

Lalliella · 09/12/2021 00:33

@Stompythedinosaur

A male presenting as a male should not have been allowed in, so maybe that is the issue to raise? That is quite different from a trans woman attending a women's group, which I think is fine.
It’s not different. It’s the absolute fucking same.
MiddleEasternMummy · 09/12/2021 00:25

Sarah pls know you are supported by so many women . So proud of you speaking here and on Twitter . Your strength is amazing. What has happened to you is a travesty. Big hugs you amazing determined woman 🤗

EricCartmansUnderpants · 09/12/2021 00:20

So Midrul is a male, presumably identifying as a female. Who left the SNP because Midrul thinks men should be able to examine women who have been raped. And now has got a job leading Edinburgh rape crises. Right at the centre of where abused, traumatised and vulnerable women are. Midrul is there shaping the organisation for the benefit of men.
Where abused woman turn to, born males like Midrul are waiting for them. Supposedly to ease their trauma. Sounds like a second assault to me. It's astounding how men have got themselves into these positions and got ahead of law and policy in order to establish a foothold. And males like these, that seem to have little regard for women, are the last males women should ever be sharing their sex segregated space with.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 09/12/2021 00:04

Are these centres that were set up by transwomen? Or ones that have been taken over?' I expect it's the second one. Same principle through. Men destroying women's privacy at the bottom and directing it from the top. What really puzzles me is that some women cheerlead this behaviour. It's almost as if they don't understand what men can be like.

Edinburgh Rape Crisis, in a 2015 publication by a survivor about the process women go through with the police and courts, refer to the importance of having a female person deal with your rape examination. Exactly the same thing the now director Mridul Wadhwa left the SNP in a huff over them voting for this in the Forensic Medical bill.

EricCartmansUnderpants · 08/12/2021 23:46

@Overthinkingx3

In Scotland amd Canada - there are currently cases whereby rape crisis support is run by transgendered people … anyone who doesn’t want that support, and prefers natal women to provide it is told they are prejudiced and need to leave …
Are these centres that were set up by transwomen? Or ones that have been taken over?' I expect it's the second one. Same principle through. Men destroying women's privacy at the bottom and directing it from the top. What really puzzles me is that some women cheerlead this behaviour. It's almost as if they don't understand what men can be like.
Feelingoktoday · 08/12/2021 23:41

Thank you Op for raising this. I can’t believe some posters think you should shut up and fade away. How would they feel if you were their daughter who had been raped!!

Well done for shouting and screaming about these issues. More and more of us are learning here why we need to understand the difference between sex and gender and how by ignoring sex women lose out. Not men. Women are abused, raped, killed at birth, put in period huts, uneducated all because of our sex, not our feelings.