Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to have requested single sex rape crisis therapy?

564 replies

IamSarah · 08/12/2021 13:56

My local rape crisis centre offers a dedicated support group for trans and non-binary survivors and a women's group open to anyone who identifies as a woman.

After a male (presenting as male) turned up in the women's group I requested an additional group for women who were born women. This request was turned down and I was told that group support isn't for me. AIBU?

YABU: You shouldn't need an additional, exclusive group for biological women

YANBU: Under these circumstances, a single sex group just for biological women was a reasonable request

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
Thefartingsofaofdenmarkstreet · 09/12/2021 18:20

I also think that the assimilation of a transwoman into society is a process which takes time and requires empathy on all sides. It does not happen overnight.

No one is saying that transwomen cannot 'assimilate into society'. It's just that, as males, they shouldn't be allowed access into female only single sex spaces and provision, in the same way that other males are not allowed this sort of access.

EricCartmansUnderpants · 09/12/2021 18:07

As I said earlier I think there is room - and a great need - for much more nuanced discussion on this.

As long as males are using and destroying women's single sex spaces and safeguards, effectively turning those provisions in to mixed sex services, there is no discussion to be had.

Transwomen need their own services sure. Their needs however are completely different to women's, as they are not women. Women have unique needs of their own that are not the same as men's. Presenting as a woman does not make someone a woman, even if they have their penis removed. They remain a male, without a penis, dressing how they perceive women dress according to gender stereotypes. It's biology that makes someone male or female. Not feelings.

Transwomen are slightly different in some, but not all ways, to other men. A combination of male services and trans only services to meet needs around dysphoria and mental health / surgery issues would suffice.

But destroying women's services to supposedly meet the needs of transwomen (males) is not acceptable. No more nuanced discussion needs to take place around how women can be further persuaded into accepting some males into their spaces because of their womanly feelings.

TheKeatingFive · 09/12/2021 18:07

Because their desire/need to be accepted as a woman is demonstrably strong and dominates the way they live their lives.

That may be, but it is biologically impossible for them to change sex, regardless of their desires.

That has implications for others. In this instance vulnerable women who may be triggered by male bodies in a place they go to to deal with trauma.

So yes, of course we should have empathy. And I support people's desire to live however they want. But empathy should not be expected to stretch to denying biological reality.

Runningupthecurtains · 09/12/2021 18:02

Because their desire/need to be accepted as a woman is demonstrably strong and dominates the way they live their lives

Lack of a penis doesn't make them a woman because the differences between men and women don't start and finish with a penis. When a rape survivor with PTSD is triggered by the presence of a male they don't have to see a penis to be triggered. Even if that was the only difference the vast majority of transwomen retain their penis.
But that desire doesn't make them a woman. They can "live as a woman" (what ever that means) but they cannot become one and frankly the lack of empathy as to why there are places that are not suitable to be mix sex just highlights this. People are free to dress as they like, to call themselves what ever they want to, to use what ever pronouns they want but when they can't (or won't) accept that it is not possible to change sex (they can't under do their socialization, the way the world see them, their body that has developed a certain way because of male puberty etc) but even if they could and even if every single transwomen ever is gentle and kind and timid and has zero tendancy remaining toward male behaviour how can segregate spaces to admit some men without also opening up to other men who are less kind, less benign? Once we loose the power to challenge one male born person in what should be a female only space we loose the ability to challenge any man in that space.

IamSarah · 09/12/2021 17:35

I would really like to know if it is the TW service users driving this, or if the service leaders are doing this in their name without their knowledge and consent. I think this matters a great deal.

I'm pretty sure it's all driven by Stonewall.

The trans service users want their own group as that's where they feel safest. SN proudly state this on their website.

OP posts:
urbanbuddha · 09/12/2021 17:33

How are they different to a man who has lost his genitals to injury/illness? Because the ones I know would be very distressed and offended to be told that they are now women.

Because their desire/need to be accepted as a woman is demonstrably strong and dominates the way they live their lives. A man injured in an accident is not subject to this - it's a red herring to raise this when discussing the position of transwomen in society.

I also think that the assimilation of a transwoman into society is a process which takes time and requires empathy on all sides. It does not happen overnight.

As I said earlier I think there is room - and a great need - for much more nuanced discussion on this.

Artichokeleaves · 09/12/2021 17:10

@Derbee

It's also worth mentioning that when I suggested creating the additional support group just for biological women I suggested it was arranged discreetly and sensitively. It could have simply been called a 'closed peer support group' meaning group members don't come and go, it's always the same people. Those people would just happen to all be biologically female

@IamSarah I don’t even think you should have to have asked to be discreet and secretive. You have a fundamental right to access support that feels like a safe space and doesn’t make you uncomfortable.

If trans women are actually women, and wanting to BE women, surely they should understand that other women have triggers (men, in a case such as rape by a man) which l we should support each other not being forced to be triggered by. If you join the sisterhood, don’t pick and choose which bits you like and which suit you, and trample all over others.

This:

And it has to be faced. The situation has been created in which male people have become the gatekeepers of female services and which females they may choose to grant the privilege of access.

In a women's service.

In which they were included on the ground that TWAW and therefore women's services were excluding women, and this was obviously unacceptable. However it does not seem to be a problem at all that TW are now excluding women.

I would really like to know if it is the TW service users driving this, or if the service leaders are doing this in their name without their knowledge and consent. I think this matters a great deal.

Derbee · 09/12/2021 16:14

It's also worth mentioning that when I suggested creating the additional support group just for biological women I suggested it was arranged discreetly and sensitively. It could have simply been called a 'closed peer support group' meaning group members don't come and go, it's always the same people. Those people would just happen to all be biologically female

@IamSarah I don’t even think you should have to have asked to be discreet and secretive. You have a fundamental right to access support that feels like a safe space and doesn’t make you uncomfortable.

If trans women are actually women, and wanting to BE women, surely they should understand that other women have triggers (men, in a case such as rape by a man) which l we should support each other not being forced to be triggered by. If you join the sisterhood, don’t pick and choose which bits you like and which suit you, and trample all over others.

Runningupthecurtains · 09/12/2021 15:44

@IamSarah I'm so sorry 💐. Please know that the vast majority of people think you are not being unreasonable and can totally understand why you need a single sex group. I hope you are able to find support that meets that need.

Runningupthecurtains · 09/12/2021 15:38

I don't think a person who has elected to
have surgery to remove their penis and to have female surgery can be counted as a man. I would see her as a woman.

How are they different to a man who has lost his genitals to injury/illness? Because the ones I know would be very distressed and offended to be told that they are now women.

Despite what nursey in Blackadder thinks a boy without a winky is not a girl.

IamSarah · 09/12/2021 12:16

@ElPolloLoco

Devastated that it’s come to this.

A rape crisis centre that supports everyone except women who have been raped and need a single sex space.

The irony is that they sell themselves as a feminist organisation with a feminist approach.

Even the most liberal feminists believe in equality of the sexes, not prioritising the male sex over the female sex.

They fail to mention they exclude and block female rape survivors who ask to be treated equally to male / trans rape survivors.

AIBU to have requested single sex rape crisis therapy?
OP posts:
ElPolloLoco · 09/12/2021 11:59

Devastated that it’s come to this.

A rape crisis centre that supports everyone except women who have been raped and need a single sex space.

EricCartmansUnderpants · 09/12/2021 11:51

Women who believe TWAW and who want to be good allies are more than welcome to join them in all the other mixed sex women's groups. Nobody is trying to stop those groups or take that option away.

Yes. And those women are welcome to take that option. They don't get to take the right away from women who don't consent to this. Well they might try. Along with the men who are doing their best. But they're going to have a fucking huge legal battle on their hands. They're not going to win this.

Helleofabore · 09/12/2021 11:39

It's also worth mentioning that when I suggested creating the additional support group just for biological women I suggested it was arranged discreetly and sensitively. It could have simply been called a 'closed peer support group' meaning group members don't come and go, it's always the same people. Those people would just happen to all be biologically female.

That is neat solution. Sadly, I can see that to purists this would still not be acceptable.

VestofAbsurdity · 09/12/2021 11:27

Everything @Artichokeleaves said with bells on.

Yes. As always Artichokeleaves absolutely nails it.

IamSarah · 09/12/2021 11:19

Everything @Artichokeleaves said with bells on. Particularly this:

The trans rights are met. Thoroughly. Enthusiastically. It in no way affects trans service users to permit female people of different beliefs to them to have access in the only way they can access help.

Women who believe TWAW and who want to be good allies are more than welcome to join them in all the other mixed sex women's groups. Nobody is trying to stop those groups or take that option away.

It's also worth mentioning that when I suggested creating the additional support group just for biological women I suggested it was arranged discreetly and sensitively. It could have simply been called a 'closed peer support group' meaning group members don't come and go, it's always the same people. Those people would just happen to all be biologically female.

Therefore there would be absolutely no reason for trans clients to even know that this group existed and they were excluded from it.

Even this was a step too far for my centre. Because of course trans women are the most marginalised in society.

OP posts:
SolasAnla · 09/12/2021 10:15

men should be able to examine women who have been raped

In Scotland it was more nuanced than that and IMO rather vile.

It went to the heart of the legal dilemma of asking people to deny the evidence their eyes see and their ears hear.

The aim of some in Scotland is to have Gender self ID rather than gender reassignment legislation.

The argument was about changes to legislation dealing with sexual assault and if the law used the word sex or gender

At the time I belive there were more men than women employed to carry out the examinations and evidence collection.

The State provides, suitably qualified and trained, HCP's to carry out the examination. The State would formulate policy to meet needs of the State. All witnesses, both for the State and defence, giving testimony under oath. HCP collect evidence on behalf of the State and should be a neutral witness as the accused has the right to a fair trial.

In this aim there is no conflict in using the word sex or gender.

The State would also provide, in as far as practical, for the needs of the person being examined. So in the legislation a woman asking for a woman or a man asking for a man would determine the [sex gender] or [sex gender] of the HCP.

In this aim there is a conflict in using the word sex or gender.

So should it be sex or should it be gender?

Is a person who has been sexually assaulted expected to define what their request means?
" I want a woman/man, female/male, human with vulva/penis "

Or is the witness is saying
" I consent to this examination provided it is carried out by a woman/man, female/male, human with vulva/penis "

The consent of the witness should take precedence so the word sex should be used.

As the State is taking account of a sex bias expressed by those being examined the recruitment policy will be formulated around historic data for sexual assaults and current staffing levels.

In this aim there is a conflict in using the word sex or gender.

The State need to know the sex of the person who was attacked and their preferences as to the sex of the HCP. Again the consent of the witness should take precedence so the word sex should be used

Once this is established the State would be reflected in the number of each sex who should be recruited and trained.

In this aim there is a conflict in using the word sex or gender.

They first look at the existing employees.

Then if more women are attacked and preferred to be examined by a woman then the State would actively discriminate on the basis of sex by recruiting more women than men.

They would also be actively discriminating on the basis of gender reassignment by excluding females from the classification "man" and males from the classification "woman".

The State provides a HCP to carry out the examination and giving testimony under oath.

In this aim there is a conflict in using the word sex or gender.

In a sexual assault case consent or lack of consent is the key element that needs to be proven.

The HCP will testify as to their physical examination. That's usually a physical external and internal examination of the primary witness.

The first thing they offer the court is that the witness consent to this examination or some other circumstance which resulted in the HCP giving testimony under oath.

For a HCP informed consent is not obtained if the person limits the consent in a way which specifically excluded the HCP. The HCP would take the stand and under oath testify as to their own act of sexual assault.

That was the essence of the debate.
That a HCP would carry out a "legal" sexual assault.
That a HCP could legally trick a woman or a man who had not consented.
That the HCP could testify under oath about evidence obtained by deception.

For me the question remains what type of mental gymnastic is needed to argue that the word gender should replace sex in any legislation which needs consent?

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 09/12/2021 10:01

That graphic is really good Purgatory

EmmaWoodhousestreehouse · 09/12/2021 09:51

@SweetPetrichor

YABU for starting another thread. We’ve had this topic already.
Clearly the issues initially raised are a fucking million miles from being addressed. There could never be enough threads about womens’ rights being eroded.

@Pixiedust138 having your penis lopped off does not make you a woman.

Artichokeleaves · 09/12/2021 09:41

And I'll add to that: it has also been proven by this one situation, all over again, that how those male people identify makes no practical difference to the outcome in a mixed sex service.

Artichokeleaves · 09/12/2021 09:40

And that, in a nutshell, is why mixed sex women's services don't work, will never work, and why women argued from the start that making women's services mixed sex would not work.

Because in mixed sex groups, males dominate the time, resources, access, focus, staff and everything else and female needs cannot be effectively met. The female needs in a women's service become secondary and minor and openly viewed (as demonstrated on the thread by those of this political view) as much less important, less human, with less rights than the male needs.

We've tried this. We've proved (all over again) that this does not work for females. Female humans have rights too. They pay taxes too.

Artichokeleaves · 09/12/2021 09:37

support trans right

Which rights?

Because the right to prevent anyone else from having access to services and resources and to be tax payers but excluded and discriminated against because of political intolerance should not be a right at all, for anyone, under any circumstances.

The trans rights are met. Thoroughly. Enthusiastically. It in no way affects trans service users to permit female people of different beliefs to them to have access in the only way they can access help. To refuse them is purely down to political intolerance. A preference to see females suffer and be excluded rather than permit them to not conform and obey one specific political view. It dismisses and derogates all other protected characteristics these females may have. It is a position of bigotry and intolerance. And misogyny, as you can split the needs met/needs not met people entirely by sex .

IamSarah · 09/12/2021 08:23

@PurgatoryOfPotholes

Remarkably, despite that poster, Clementine Ford is full TWAW.

I wonder if she will always be. It's such a good poster that focuses on the crux of the issue: the feelings of the being with the trauma. For anyone who missed it, I include it again.

This is a great poster, it's going on Twitter. Thanks for sharing.
OP posts:
PurgatoryOfPotholes · 09/12/2021 08:18

Remarkably, despite that poster, Clementine Ford is full TWAW.

I wonder if she will always be. It's such a good poster that focuses on the crux of the issue: the feelings of the being with the trauma. For anyone who missed it, I include it again.

AIBU to have requested single sex rape crisis therapy?
EricCartmansUnderpants · 09/12/2021 08:11

That really tells people all they need to know Helleofabore. The males that push their way into those spaces for women; that they know they shouldn't be there. They get a thrill and a feeling of excitement about breaking those rules and taboos. This won't be just Midrul. It will be every one of them who pushes themselves into women's spaces. And there's men that support them to do this. They know too. And they don't care about women. And the women who cheerlead them on. I can only assume those women don't understand this when they're trying to be kind and inclusive. They're being gaslighted.