Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to have requested single sex rape crisis therapy?

564 replies

IamSarah · 08/12/2021 13:56

My local rape crisis centre offers a dedicated support group for trans and non-binary survivors and a women's group open to anyone who identifies as a woman.

After a male (presenting as male) turned up in the women's group I requested an additional group for women who were born women. This request was turned down and I was told that group support isn't for me. AIBU?

YABU: You shouldn't need an additional, exclusive group for biological women

YANBU: Under these circumstances, a single sex group just for biological women was a reasonable request

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
Feelingoktoday · 09/12/2021 21:37

@Hont1986

I voted YABU. There were some comments earlier saying that people who voted YABU should explain why. Charities don't have unlimited resources and I don't feel you can expect them to provide additional groups that go against their moral/political beliefs at your request. So that's why.
Unbelievable. It has nothing to do with funding. It is about woke beliefs.
lifeturnsonadime · 09/12/2021 21:22

Urbanbudda but it doesn't really make sense to say that TWAW but yet recognise instances in which women need single sex spaces.

If they are not always women then what are they? What is the difference?

Feminism is for females, TW are not females. Can't you see that the very way that TRAs are behaving, in insisting TW are women, makes it impossible for TW and feminists to be allies? TRAs aren't doing TW any favours which is why many TW don't agree with the TWAW mantra. It aids no one because it's not the truth.

urbanbuddha · 09/12/2021 21:16

@urbanbuddha

What I don't understand at all is why transwomen are not empathetic to a woman rape survivor. Why don't these people who claim they are women realise that a person with a penis in the room is the last thing this woman needs?
As I said earlier I totally agree with the need for women to have safe spaces and I think that a rape crisis centre must offer support to women only groups. The trauma of rape means that the need for safe spaces for (natal) women to start to heal is paramount. Transwomen should respect this. However it does not follow that I therefore think that transwomen are not women. In the specific instance of a rape survivors' group they cannot be present. Sneering about feminism comes from a very masculine standpoint. A more enlightened regard for feminist viewpoints in the trans community would benefit everyone.
ShrillSiren · 09/12/2021 20:28

Lurkers, take note of the #bekind crowd, notice that they're only ever kind to people that follow the party line (and men, always kind to men, if they really saw TWAW they wouldn't be kind to them either).

They won't care about you or your trauma unless you're pure enough. Think about if this is really something you want in schools and universities, in all areas of government and much more. Start to fight back because it's not actually about being kind at all. It's about taking over.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 09/12/2021 20:24

And there was no man joining in on a women's group, because it was a woman, a trans woman. I know you don't believe that, but I and more importantly the charity providing the service do.

Why do you personally believe them? Do you know this person IRL? If not, it's literally just a random male person declaring themselves to be a woman. Is that what you think a woman is?

SolasAnla · 09/12/2021 20:23

@MizzFizz
Most people use the words female and male in the contest of sexual reproduction. You will note there are only 2 reproductive roles identified.
Female indicate the sex who's reproductive role is to produce ovum.
Woman (as in adult human female) is the word allocate to differentiate the sex of human which is ovum producing from other animals.
Male indicate the sex who's reproductive role is to produce sperm.
Man (as in adult human male) is the word allocate to differentiate the sex of human which is sperm producing from other animals.

"Cis" is a word used within a belief system to merge members of opposite sexes into an classification organised around a political ideology of gender roles.
The belief system would define woman as adult human female and some males
and define man as adult human male and some females.

@Hont1986
Are you able to put your belief system into words?

If you can, please expand on what elements you would use to differentiate between
• a male presenting as a male who was sexually assaulted
and
• a male presenting as a woman who was sexually assaulted
when it comes to including or excluding them from groups providing support for people who were sexually assaulted.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 09/12/2021 20:19

You're quite right, NeedsCharging. We need to enshrine the right of women to single sex rape crisis services in legislation.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 09/12/2021 20:17

it was a trans woman who presumably identified as a woman.

If they were obviously male, why should OP care what their inner personal identity was? Why is it relevant?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 09/12/2021 20:15

Feminists set up these spaces through their blood, sweat, and tears

Most of the spaces set up by actual feminists recognise the need for women to have single sex spaces. Unfortunately there are a lot of people who put other things before women's rights in the charity sector. Plus funding issues, and a push to be "inclusive" which is deaf and blind to being inclusive of female rape survivors who overwhelmingly don't want males in their recovery spaces.

EricCartmansUnderpants · 09/12/2021 20:07

And there was no man joining in on a women's group, because it was a woman, a trans woman

I'd like to know the difference between the two.

TheKeatingFive · 09/12/2021 20:06

And there was no man joining in on a women's group, because it was a woman, a trans woman

Nope. A biological man. You cant physically change sex. Are you going to argue you can?

Franklin12 · 09/12/2021 20:03

So so sick of this. Women need female only spaces, not spaces that can be entered by men who say they feel they are women. What could possibly go wrong....

Sorry to make this political but this is why Labour are in such a mess with their self identity policies.

Can we have women only spaces be that hospital wards, changing rooms and indeed rape therapy centres.

Anything else is madness.

lifeturnsonadime · 09/12/2021 20:03

Hont is being honest.

It's a men's rights movement. Women come last.

Anyone who doubted this and reads the last 2 pages and is of sound mind will now know the truth of the agenda.

MrsTerryPratchett · 09/12/2021 20:01

@NeedsCharging

I will hide this thread as what I want to say to Hont will get me banned.

When these safe spaces for women were set up women were biological women not fucking perverted men looking to crack one out listen to rape victims discuss their trauma.
The fact that some idiotic stupid patriarchy loving women accept these perverts doesn't make it right!.

I shall await deletion.
Sorry MNHQ.

It will be deleted but I just wanted to send you some love and support. I know it's difficult to talk about your experiences in the face of hostility and almost psychopathic lack of empathy.

Peace and light to you.

VestofAbsurdity · 09/12/2021 19:55

Feminists set up these spaces through their blood, sweat, and tears, and shouldn't be told who they can and can't let in the spaces. In this case, the people who actually shed the blood, sweat, and tears have chosen to make the women's group open to all those who they feel are women, and not offer a cis-only group.

Feminists did indeed set up refuges with their own blood, sweat and tears against the most appalling opposition from men, those refuges were set up for women by women.

In this case the refuge is funded by tax payers, it is not a Charity, it is failing women who pay taxes by excluding them from the service they want and need.

Those running it are not feminists in any way shape or form, nor are they behaving in line with their duty as public servants utilising tax payer funds.

Strangely they offer a group for men only so they are therefore discriminating 100% against women.

There is something seriously wrong with anyone whose politics and morals allow what is happening here.

Artichokeleaves · 09/12/2021 19:53

It's the new party line.

If a female service has been forcibly commandeered and turned mixed sex, for the exclusive benefit of males and resulting in excluding females - well off you pop females, and set up all over again from scratch.

If exclusion is fine and dandy and a group needs to trot off and set up more appropriate resources for themselves....... I'd think very carefully about popularising that line. And you've lost any lingering hope of using the word 'inclusive' and being believed.

Inclusive would be mixed sex women's services where male service users were politically tolerant enough to allow female needs to be met too. #Bekind. Although why male users appear to be the gatekeepers of what female service users may be permitted in a highly sensitive women's crisis service is a question that needs very serious addressing. Obviously. Plot beyond lost there.

EricCartmansUnderpants · 09/12/2021 19:51

women's group open to all those who they feel are women, and not offer a cis-only group

Out of interest, am I allowed to bring my penis to these groups and sit in? Will that be ok for you?

EricCartmansUnderpants · 09/12/2021 19:49

In this case, the people who actually shed the blood, sweat, and tears have chosen to make the women's group open to all those who they feel are women, and not offer a cis-only group. If you disagree with it, set up your own.

Men and the #bekind allies have done this, infiltrating and taking over these charities on the blood sweat and tears of the women that set them up, and the many women who continue to run them. This, alongside the removal of grant funding unless men are included so that they can have their real life theatre show. The decision to remove that funding made again by men, and #,bekind allies to get diversity points. The majority of women who work in these charities do not agree with mixed sex groups. They have limited choice because without funding they would struggle to continue and then women, who really need this service, would have nothing. But they can't have the funding unless the men are allowed to watch. Pretty sick really.

Artichokeleaves · 09/12/2021 19:47

There really is no point in wittering on about TWAW and that's the reason for inclusion in women's services because they must not exclude any women, when once the service is made inclusive of TW the TW and their politics immediately refuse to permit the service to be diverse or accessible to all females so that this inclusion works, and insist that women must be excluded from women's services.

If exclusion of some women is ok, then why was it ever a problem to exclude TW?

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 09/12/2021 19:45

Ok Hont I'll bite.

Let's say my DH was to decide he was a woman. He suffers a trauma also. Can he join this group too? Just wondering what, beyond "coz I feels like one" the qualifying criteria to be a woman are?

.... disclaimer, he wouldn't because he isn't a gaslighting dick but I'm curious how you would be able to know this.

PWYP76 · 09/12/2021 19:44

A transwoman is a male bodied individual.

Yes, yes and YES!!

Runningupthecurtains · 09/12/2021 19:42

So it is not the removal of the penis that makes a man a woman (but we know that anyway because TWAW and the vast majority of TW retain a penis) it the desire to have the penis removed, the desire and feelings (even though plenty of TW show absolutely no desire for surgery). So these desires and feelings and wants are so important that we all need to set aside biological fact, scientific reality and agree that if a man says he is a woman then he is. Great really important that people's feelings and desires are listened too and acted on...... Except what about the feelings of IamSarah and other women? Why do those feelings not matter. Why is the desire of a man to be a woman so important that we rewrite language and throw biology in the bin but the desire of women to be treated with respect and dignity and their wants to be able to receive support for having undergone horrific experience at the hands of male bodied people without the presence of male bodied people worth nothing. Either feelings and desires are the most important thing or they aren't. But where we are at the moment some people's feelings really really matter and everybody else's count for nothing.

NeedsCharging · 09/12/2021 19:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Artichokeleaves · 09/12/2021 19:40

@Hont1986

there are no circumstances in which women can get what they NEED which is single sex spaces because you don't believe that women needing single sex spaces, even traumatised women have the political right to spaces for them?

I don't have a disagreement with single-sex spaces in theory. I think you should be able to offer your privately-run refuge/gym/support group to anyone you wish. If OP or anyone who agrees with her wants to set up their own space and offer it to the people of their choosing, then I believe she has a political right to it and will have my moral support.

Feminists set up these spaces through their blood, sweat, and tears, and shouldn't be told who they can and can't let in the spaces. In this case, the people who actually shed the blood, sweat, and tears have chosen to make the women's group open to all those who they feel are women, and not offer a cis-only group. If you disagree with it, set up your own.

No, this is the job of the LA.

Who should not be funding a service that is supposed to serve the entire population of women, not just the women they happen to be interested in. An exclusionary, inaccessible public service is a dramatically failed public service.

Artichokeleaves · 09/12/2021 19:38

And there was no man joining in on a women's group, because it was a woman, a trans woman. I know you don't believe that, but I and more importantly the charity providing the service do.

Absolutely irrelevant.

ANY TW entering that service has three groups they can choose from to best meet their need for rape crisis support. Three.

ANY female entering that service has one mixed sex group available.

Any female who CANNOT ACCESS a mixed sex space is left without ANY rape crisis support.

It does not matter HOW a TW wants to identify, they can pick from their groups and have all the help they want and no one is trying to stop them or reduce this service or provision in any way for them .

The sole reason that females are being refused any access or support to a bloody women's service for crying out loud, is that male people do not want a group to be allowed to exist for them .

What kind of a prejudiced bigot do you have to be to have all your chosen services but insist that your greater power is used to block some raped female people from having any help at all because you don't like the thought of them being permitted it ?