Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to have requested single sex rape crisis therapy?

564 replies

IamSarah · 08/12/2021 13:56

My local rape crisis centre offers a dedicated support group for trans and non-binary survivors and a women's group open to anyone who identifies as a woman.

After a male (presenting as male) turned up in the women's group I requested an additional group for women who were born women. This request was turned down and I was told that group support isn't for me. AIBU?

YABU: You shouldn't need an additional, exclusive group for biological women

YANBU: Under these circumstances, a single sex group just for biological women was a reasonable request

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
PurgatoryOfPotholes · 10/12/2021 00:22

Extract from explanatory guidance on the exceptions in Equality Act 2010

•The need for authenticity or realism might require someone of a particular race, sex or age for acting roles (for example, a black man to play the part of Othello) or modelling jobs.

•Considerations of privacy or decency might require a public changing room or lavatory attendant to be of the same sex as those using the facilities.

•An organisation for deaf people might legitimately employ a deaf person who uses British Sign Language to work as a counsellor to other deaf people whose first or preferred language is BSL.

•Unemployed Muslim women might not take advantage of the services of an outreach worker to help them find employment if they were provided by a man.

•A counsellor working with victims of rape might have to be a woman and not a transsexual person, even if she has a Gender Recognition Certificate, in order to avoid causing them further distress.

www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2010/15/notes/division/3/16/26/1/1/3

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 10/12/2021 00:02

[quote MizzFizz]@PurgatoryOfPotholes oh right! Yeah I guess that's the piece I was missing from the OP. It's a tough situation isn't it. We as humans don't trust people we don't know to begin with, then add the trauma experienced by those in a rape support group...and the trauma of being excluded for your gender identity. It's not an easy situation is it 😢[/quote]
Such issues were pre-empted with the creation of the specialist trans and non-binary group.

But now women who don't feel comfortable discussing their experiences in front of any random male human are being excluded because there is no provision for them

SolasAnla · 09/12/2021 23:59

[quote MizzFizz]@PurgatoryOfPotholes oh right! Yeah I guess that's the piece I was missing from the OP. It's a tough situation isn't it. We as humans don't trust people we don't know to begin with, then add the trauma experienced by those in a rape support group...and the trauma of being excluded for your gender identity. It's not an easy situation is it 😢[/quote]
So you can recognise a human with a penis after all.
(What a surprise + shocked face emoji)

Are you trying to avoid typing it?
"Someone who has been sexually assaulted should not be given single sex provision.
Adding tear drop emoji"

....

EricCartmansUnderpants · 09/12/2021 23:56

However the dickpandering apologists for colonising males can fuck off to the far side of fuck and when they get there they can fuck off some more.

Yes. It needs to be said.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 09/12/2021 23:53

They're not being "excluded for their gender identity", but because they are male sex. Identity isn't relevant.

MizzFizz · 09/12/2021 23:48

@PurgatoryOfPotholes oh right! Yeah I guess that's the piece I was missing from the OP. It's a tough situation isn't it. We as humans don't trust people we don't know to begin with, then add the trauma experienced by those in a rape support group...and the trauma of being excluded for your gender identity. It's not an easy situation is it 😢

Feelingoktoday · 09/12/2021 23:48

[quote MizzFizz]@Feelingoktoday AHH ok thank you. I guess the title of the OP was a hint but I just didn't put 2 and 2 together. I got a lot of gender theory info (always good to learn more) but I just really didn't get the situation.[/quote]
Now that you understand do you still think it is ok for a identifying woman to be in a rape group for women?

MizzFizz · 09/12/2021 23:46

@Feelingoktoday AHH ok thank you. I guess the title of the OP was a hint but I just didn't put 2 and 2 together. I got a lot of gender theory info (always good to learn more) but I just really didn't get the situation.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 09/12/2021 23:44

The person will have said I identify as a woman.

Male-presenting means that there were no visual cues that the person wished to be seen as a woman.

For example, this is a male-presenting biological male identifying as a woman.

AIBU to have requested single sex rape crisis therapy?
Feelingoktoday · 09/12/2021 23:38

[quote MizzFizz]@SolasAnla I guess I just don't understand the OP. They didn't explain why the person was allowed at the meeting... Do they identify as a woman? I just read "male" and "male presenting" just isn't clear to me what the situation was....[/quote]
It is a biological male identifying as a woman.

MizzFizz · 09/12/2021 23:33

@SolasAnla I guess I just don't understand the OP. They didn't explain why the person was allowed at the meeting... Do they identify as a woman? I just read "male" and "male presenting" just isn't clear to me what the situation was....

MizzFizz · 09/12/2021 23:31

@lifeturnsonadime @ShrillSiren I thought PP said they were " male and also male presenting" and thus assumed male presenting meant they self-identified as male. I am not trying to get into the ideology just literally not understanding what pp is saying... so the person identifies as a woman? I completely support trans inclusion but sorry I just still don't understand OP...

Smileyaxolotl1 · 09/12/2021 22:48

Thank you to the wonderful people on here standing up for women and especially the poster who is running single sex groups for traumatised women while also providing services for other categories of people.

However the dickpandering apologists for colonising males can fuck off to the far side of fuck and when they get there they can fuck off some more.

YouSetTheTone · 09/12/2021 22:32

Afghanistan 2021 - women aren’t allowed to be educated.
The U.K. 2021 - women who have been raped aren’t allowed single sex spaces to be counselled for their trauma.

I hope that 2022 will be better for women everywhere.

SolasAnla · 09/12/2021 22:17

[quote MizzFizz]@SolasAnla your explanation doesn't help me understand why a man was in the women's group? Or did I miss something?[/quote]
@MizzFizz

The question is:
What are the meanings of the word man and woman?

Your definition differs from the service provider

ShrillSiren · 09/12/2021 22:16

[quote MizzFizz]@SolasAnla your explanation doesn't help me understand why a man was in the women's group? Or did I miss something?[/quote]
Well, how do you tell the difference between a TW and a man? TW don't need to make any changes to themselves whatsoever. Not clothes/hormones/surgery.

In this brand new world, it's not the old style transexuals anymore who may have made some sort of effort (not that I think they should be in female only rape crisis groups either). It is literally any male that wants to be there.

How can you prove they're not a woman if it's all based on a feeling in their heads?

lifeturnsonadime · 09/12/2021 22:15

Miss Fizz, gender ideology doesn't require a change in physical appearance. Gender is innate. A simple declaration that a man is a woman is enough.

So a man who appears to be male who declares to be a woman must be believed when he says he is a woman.

KaycePollard · 09/12/2021 22:14

That is quite different from a trans woman attending a women's group, which I think is fine.

No it's not. That automatically turns the group into a mixed sex group.

Single-sex groups are not illegal, whatever some ill-informed activists & their followers may tell you.

MizzFizz · 09/12/2021 22:09

@SolasAnla your explanation doesn't help me understand why a man was in the women's group? Or did I miss something?

SolasAnla · 09/12/2021 22:05

urbanbuddha, the contradiction in that statement actually demonstrates how you dont support your own meaning when altering the word woman to read as adult human female and some males.

Your policy position only works if you classify by and recognise biology.

What I am reading is as follows:
As I said earlier I totally agree with the need for women females to have safe spaces and I think that a rape crisis centre must offer support to women female only groups. The trauma of rape means that the need for safe spaces for (natal) women females to start to heal is paramount.
Transwomen Males should respect this.
However it does not follow that I therefore think that transwomen males are not women females. In the specific instance of a rape survivors' group they males cannot be present.

No organisation can have a policy which uses 2 different meanings for the same word.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 09/12/2021 21:58

MN that only people with a penis can rape. This is not the case.

It's the case that a penis is always involved. That is the offence of rape in this country. There are only two ways a "woman" is guilty of rape.

A) She is the female accomplice of a male rapist and assists him in the act of penetrating someone of either sex with his penis

The "woman" is a male person

Ereshkigalangcleg · 09/12/2021 21:52

However it does not follow that I therefore think that transwomen are not women. In the specific instance of a rape survivors' group they cannot be present.

I think it's pretty obvious that you know they are not. Let's bear in mind that a "transwoman" is any male who declares that they are a woman. Your statement is a faith based one, and you think inclusion of these biologically male people into the social class "woman" takes precedence over scientific reality and most sex based situations.

TheKeatingFive · 09/12/2021 21:44

However it does not follow that I therefore think that transwomen are not women.

Biologically they are demonstrably not women.

What other definition of woman trumps biology?

EricCartmansUnderpants · 09/12/2021 21:43

@Feelingoktoday

So if TWAW would you be happy for your daughter to share a group shower with a TW? If so, then you would be happy for her to share a group shower with a man.
No fucking way. To both.
Feelingoktoday · 09/12/2021 21:40

So if TWAW would you be happy for your daughter to share a group shower with a TW? If so, then you would be happy for her to share a group shower with a man.