Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to have requested single sex rape crisis therapy?

564 replies

IamSarah · 08/12/2021 13:56

My local rape crisis centre offers a dedicated support group for trans and non-binary survivors and a women's group open to anyone who identifies as a woman.

After a male (presenting as male) turned up in the women's group I requested an additional group for women who were born women. This request was turned down and I was told that group support isn't for me. AIBU?

YABU: You shouldn't need an additional, exclusive group for biological women

YANBU: Under these circumstances, a single sex group just for biological women was a reasonable request

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
C8H10N4O2 · 10/12/2021 14:08

@Hont1986

I voted YABU. There were some comments earlier saying that people who voted YABU should explain why. Charities don't have unlimited resources and I don't feel you can expect them to provide additional groups that go against their moral/political beliefs at your request. So that's why.
When charities are the third sector providers of a service to an area their personal ideologies should be irrelevant.

Many health, social care, refuge and other services are now provided by third sector as exclusive subcontractors to an area. They should be providing the service needed, not what a group of people who are not even in their client cohort want to impose.

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 10/12/2021 12:25

Thanks.

I find it odd as I only have any expertise from the very dry perspective of funding. I don't work in the centres themselves, apart from a few days a week when, as part of the food bank, I run cooking classes, help make communal meals. I hear the women talking, their almost adult kids, including sons, talking and it is clear what they need and what they cannot handle at that particular time. REALLY CLEAR.

We have been asked to look at helping a totally different organisation - one that helps abusive men, including those who have just come out of prison. The board of that charity were really understanding when we said we would need to have a board meeting as their remit was somewhat at odds with that of some of our existing partners and we would need to explore possible conflicts. We had to decide that they couldn't join our loose cooperative but that we would support them a and when it was mutually beneficial. That seemed harsh to me, even though I was one who had to speak against them, but they understood and have been really cooperative in a couple of joint ventures over the last year or so.

I dread having the same conflict of interests with any group that has the Stonewall/TRA attitude we've all seen so much of. It could scupper us!

SwanShaped · 10/12/2021 12:21

Fucking hell, Sarah that response from them is awful. Can’t provide a safe space for all. I wonder what they say to their funders about that. I bet they don’t acknowledge that to them. I hope you’re doing ok.

RedToothBrush · 10/12/2021 12:16

@HoardingSamphireSaurus

Sorry, I seem to be thread hogging. I shall wander off again!
You should be hogging the thread though.

Its kind of the point that those with the expertise and understanding of the problem of sexual abuse and rape have been completely side lined, talked over and marginalised in favour of those with an ideological agenda that comes before centring female victims and how to support them.

Helleofabore · 10/12/2021 12:15

Can someone explain to me in what way transwomen are women? Other than in name.

And this is one of the major issues. An activist academic recently made it very clear that this is the issue with allowing the language to change to allow males to become 'women'.

They started using the ploy 'well we are known as women now, why are we to be excluded from anything that other females have access to' - my paraphrase. It is clear that this is the effect of forcing the language change, the mantraing' all along.

And once you see that, it is actually pretty hard to unsee it.

Throckmorton · 10/12/2021 12:05

Fucks sake. Can someone explain to me in what way transwomen are women? Other than in name. Of course no one can.

I'm so sorry this happened to you Sarah. It's beyond shit.

Artichokeleaves · 10/12/2021 12:04

@bloodycoldagain

So tell me again, why is it unreasonable to ask that the womens group be single sex?

Because then they would have to acknowledge sex matters to how women experience the world. And they can't. Because then TW are not W in exactly the same way as other women are.

All of this is the result of the need to maintain a fiction. They cannot allow any chink as the whole thing starts to fall apart if they do. Any allowing any chink will lead to THEM being accused of transphobia.

If meeting the needs of TW service users is not compatible with meeting the needs of all other women service users, if the cost of TW inclusion is female exclusion, then sadly the conclusion has to be that TW's needs cannot be met within women's services.
HoardingSamphireSaurus · 10/12/2021 11:55

Sorry, I seem to be thread hogging. I shall wander off again!

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 10/12/2021 11:54

@IamSarah

no we don't offer a safe space for recovery, no we don't offer inclusive services for all women from all communities, no we don't seek to prevent predatory males from entering our services

They acknowledge all this but for some reason are unwilling / unable to provide the very simple solution of a single sex group. Even though the trans people they surveyed would prefer their own group. It's baffling.

OMG!

Given the meeting I sat through yesterday I cannot believe they they can remain so blind to their error.

Your complaint would not have come to me directly, if you had compained here. But I would have been asked for my input based on the guidance of funders, the possibilities for change within the groups etc.

We could not have said that in our reply as our remit is to provide a safe space for recovery. That's it. All else revolves around that. Without that we are not a crisis centre nor a refuge.

^We provide women and children a safe space to recover from domestic abuse and violence, rape and sexual assault"

And yes, as you say, the trans individuals included in our regular client surveys also want specific groups, not to join mixed sex groups but to be supported as trans individuals.

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 10/12/2021 11:45

[quote MizzFizz]@PurgatoryOfPotholes oh right! Yeah I guess that's the piece I was missing from the OP. It's a tough situation isn't it. We as humans don't trust people we don't know to begin with, then add the trauma experienced by those in a rape support group...and the trauma of being excluded for your gender identity. It's not an easy situation is it 😢[/quote]
We can also write that from the perspective of a woman, a female, all the right gametes etc.

We as humans don't trust people we don't know to begin with, then add the trauma experienced by those in a rape support group...and the trauma of being excluded because they allow men into women's single sex, safe spaces

I'm out in the rural hinterland. We have trans people, one of our youth groups is run by a young NB person, it's not a thing that requires comment. We don't have many trans people coming to us in the crisis centre but we do accommodate them, have set up a specific service for them. Now, I'd like to point out that, as with many/most other trans services this actually mean for transwomen because transmen don't make the same fuss and they accept any strictures based on dignity and perceptions - ask me how I know and I will repeat my posts upthread and elsewhere!

It IS easy. Would be even easier if funding streams would stop pushing.

And far, far more easy if TRAs would stop. Because the trans people I work with, am freinds with, have nothing in common with TRAs. No viewpoint, no needs, no voice. They are even more reluctant than I am to say what the believe in real life because they absolutely know that they will lose some of their support/friendship network to the agitators who don't seem to care what actual, real life trans individuals want or need.

bloodycoldagain · 10/12/2021 11:39

So tell me again, why is it unreasonable to ask that the womens group be single sex?

Because then they would have to acknowledge sex matters to how women experience the world. And they can't. Because then TW are not W in exactly the same way as other women are.

All of this is the result of the need to maintain a fiction. They cannot allow any chink as the whole thing starts to fall apart if they do. Any allowing any chink will lead to THEM being accused of transphobia.

Cellobear · 10/12/2021 11:34

I am very supportive of trans rights and happy to use whatever pronouns someone wants however in cases of support groups for rape I think a choice of a seperate biological female/biological male group should be allowed.... a biological male cannot possibly know what it's like to be raped as a woman, for example sometimes women need to get the morning after pill, abortion or continue a pregnancy after an attack. I'm not saying that a transwoman or biological male suffers any less by a rape but it is inherently different and should be treated as so. I can imagine that it would be very distressing to feel a biological man eyes on you as you discuss your trauma. In a bid to be inclusive we are actually excluding women.

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 10/12/2021 11:27

@Hont1986 catching up again.

Have you actually read the thread? I have already explained the reaons why the servcies shoudl be very very clear and that a woman's group that allows transwomen fucks up the therapy for everyone.

THINK about the realities of the act of rape on women and on transwomen. Not the same are they?

Transwomen need an entirely different set of support specialist to truly meet their needs. A woman's gorup would leave them lacking in support and having to set aside their own immediate reaction to a malebody would traumatise the womem members. THINK ABOUT IT.

Stop proselytising and actually think about the real life situation you are talking about.

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 10/12/2021 11:21

@Hont1986

I voted YABU. There were some comments earlier saying that people who voted YABU should explain why. Charities don't have unlimited resources and I don't feel you can expect them to provide additional groups that go against their moral/political beliefs at your request. So that's why.
OK. I'm late to this one, mainly because I spent most of yesterday afternoon in a meeting to discuss future proofing a group of charities, including a food bank and a refuge. Apologies if all of this has already been said but this has angered me!
  1. We don't have unlimited resources
  2. We do have specific remits, our legal reason for existing
  3. Those remits govern what we can and cannot do
  4. Funding streams like the Lottery are starting to make us have to re-write those remits in order to maintain funding levels

Real life example:

A womens refuge, operating for just under 30 years. Started small, operated by and for women with no external help, funding etc.

Grew, got charitable status. Remit: to house and support women and their children in times of crisis.

Problems: I have, over the last 2 - 3 years, got more and more pushback from funding streams about our diversity. We have been questioned specifically as to why we don't have any male staff or clients.

We don't provide a male service. We have lost c. 30% of our funding because of this.

We do support local men's services,. Have done for about 15 years. I do (voulnteer funding admin) the same job for them as I do for the women's refuge, we share board members, helped them set up as a charity and we part fund some of their groups. But that is not enough. We must include men within our services, apparently.

And no, they don't get the same pressure as their government backed funding is for men!

So tell me. How does that fit with your YABU?

Have you looked a tt the group being discussed? A feminist group

survivorsnetwork.org.uk/about-us/who-we-are/

Women and children form the vast majority of people who experience sexual violence. We acknowledge and believe male victims of sexual violence, and see their experiences and lack of reporting as being caused by the patriarchal society in which we live.

So, as Sarah has said, they already provide women's services, men's services AND a trans service.

So tell me again, why is it unreasonable to ask that the womens group be single sex?

Artichokeleaves · 10/12/2021 11:21

Imagine if women were showing this intolerance towards TW? And saying no, they cannot have any service at all, their needs cannot be met on this site even if all my services are fully available to me and it would not affect me in any way to provide for those rape victims?

Women here would be up in arms about the unfairness of it and it would be front page headlines. Why is even basically acceptable to have this appalling behaviour directed towards females?

Artichokeleaves · 10/12/2021 11:19

@Helleofabore

MizzFizz

Can you post instances where you think that people under the trans umbrella are excluded in society apart from the area's feminists are asking for sex to be prioritised over gender?

And keep in mind while answering this that all females are asking for is to be provided for alongside male and trans needs being met.

No one is saying that the trans services should be reduced or removed at all. It's great to meet those needs.

But female needs should be met too. If trans inclusion in fact means female exclusion and discrimination, why should women be signing up for this? It's not a great thing is it? And it comes down to an absolute intolerance of seeing female needs being met too .

EricCartmansUnderpants · 10/12/2021 11:18

as I said to pp, I was referring not to this specific situation but to how society in general excludes non-binary and trans folks. Not this situation specifically.

That's not true though is it. These groups of people are included in society. There is provision for them for their sex, and their trans status. They have human right protections. They have the same rights as anyone else in the UK. These groups do however exclude women from their own sex based services, by seeking to destroy them or make them mixed sex.

That's not fair or reasonable behaviour is it.

Artichokeleaves · 10/12/2021 11:16

This is a women's rape crisis service who feel very strongly about being accessible and indeed extremely sensitive to the needs of TW service users as women.

However they're not just less sensitive to other groups of women, they're flat out inaccessible to some groups of women and are ok with that .

And in other ways of terming this: they have prioritised and focused on diverse quality accessibility and rape service for male people at the expense of providing anything at all for female people. Although 99% of their clients will be female in a women's service.

Legally I think they're up a creek without a paddle, it's indefensible. They need to become what they are in defacto now: a trans support service who are accessible to some women: they have made it clear they are not actually able or willing to be a women's service.

The LA need to be providing accessible services for women that actually are able to focus on women. Without pushing anti-women exclusionary and discriminatory political policies.

bloodycoldagain · 10/12/2021 11:15

Attached is part of a message from a 'friend' who clocked that it was me who had dared to ask the rape crisis centre for a single sex group. Women are punished, severely punished, for asserting ourselves, speaking up and voicing our needs

I do think it is a sign of the weakness of their arguments that they get so angry. They can't answer our points. They just can't. So they call names and get angry instead. I guess its quite similar to the mentality of a man who wife suspects him of cheating so he calls her crazy. He can't actually refute what she says with reason or logic, and that makes him uncomfortable, so he has to silence her and call her names instead.

IamSarah · 10/12/2021 11:10

While Mizz is thinking of a reply thought I would share all the spaces I am now excluded from because I didn't want to share my rape crisis counselling with a male.

  • Obviously that women's group, or any other female only rape crisis group in the county
  • The local women's centre - everything on offer is for self identifying females
  • All the local female mental health groups
  • All my local women's bars. Now with angry 'no t3rfs' signs on the door
  • The supportive whatsapp group I was in with others from the centre and any online support

Attached is part of a message from a 'friend' who clocked that it was me who had dared to ask the rape crisis centre for a single sex group.

Women are punished, severely punished, for asserting ourselves, speaking up and voicing our needs.

With the level of bullying it's very tempting not to bother.

AIBU to have requested single sex rape crisis therapy?
OP posts:
bloodycoldagain · 10/12/2021 11:06

@IamSarah

no we don't offer a safe space for recovery, no we don't offer inclusive services for all women from all communities, no we don't seek to prevent predatory males from entering our services

They acknowledge all this but for some reason are unwilling / unable to provide the very simple solution of a single sex group. Even though the trans people they surveyed would prefer their own group. It's baffling.

Because to do that they would have to admit two things.
  1. That TW aren't women in all and every regard
  2. That some men will say they are trans when they are not in order to access women's spaces when women are vulnerable.

Well, that do admit that the latter may happen, though they minimise the likelihood of it, but they believe that subjecting women survivors of sex abuse to this when they are in trauma recovery services is acceptable for the wider aim of treating TW as W in all regards and at all times.

Their position isn't baffling within their own belief system. Its inevitable. Once you believe TW are literally women in every way and anyone can claim this no matter how they present, and respecting that is more important than respecting any other group of women, it follows quite logically.

Its inherently misogynistic to female-women, yes, as it makes us secondary humans, but within its own belief system its completely consistent.

Helleofabore · 10/12/2021 10:52

X post with Eresh!

Helleofabore · 10/12/2021 10:52

MizzFizz

Can you post instances where you think that people under the trans umbrella are excluded in society apart from the area's feminists are asking for sex to be prioritised over gender?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 10/12/2021 10:49

how society in general excludes non-binary and trans folks

How does it? What are they being excluded from?

IamSarah · 10/12/2021 10:44

no we don't offer a safe space for recovery, no we don't offer inclusive services for all women from all communities, no we don't seek to prevent predatory males from entering our services

They acknowledge all this but for some reason are unwilling / unable to provide the very simple solution of a single sex group. Even though the trans people they surveyed would prefer their own group. It's baffling.

OP posts: