Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to have requested single sex rape crisis therapy?

564 replies

IamSarah · 08/12/2021 13:56

My local rape crisis centre offers a dedicated support group for trans and non-binary survivors and a women's group open to anyone who identifies as a woman.

After a male (presenting as male) turned up in the women's group I requested an additional group for women who were born women. This request was turned down and I was told that group support isn't for me. AIBU?

YABU: You shouldn't need an additional, exclusive group for biological women

YANBU: Under these circumstances, a single sex group just for biological women was a reasonable request

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
HoardingSamphireSaurus · 08/12/2021 16:17

I'm sure you can google this.

Google what?

You may disagree with supporting the rights of trans people, but the reality is that the majority of people support the rights of minority groups, and the law is also in support of equality based of gender identity.

Stop it. You know that is twaddle.
What rights do trans people not have?
The law is based on sex equality. gender is nothing to do with it
And, as I have said here, set up, ensure funding, for a support group for both transmen and transwomen. What do YOU do?

Only on mn is it a far out belief to say it is OK to be trans.

Again utter balderdash. You can repeat that cant all you like. But you know full well it simply is not true. It's just a facile attempt to demonise the women here who support women's rights.

It is transparent in its falsehood.

Midlifemusings · 08/12/2021 16:15

@IamSarah

I should add, I hope you were able to find another support group somewhere else or get 1:1 counselling. It looks like there is also the Saturn Centre in your area. They also have services specifically for male victims so hopefully they can offer 1:1 or single sex

LostForIdeas · 08/12/2021 16:13

@Stompythedinosaur could you clarify if you think that the needs or transwomen (and transmen) are the same women (and men) when it comes to rape?

Do you think their experiences are the same?

Could you also explain why, if transwomen are women and should be included in a women’s group, there is still a need for a transwomen specifically?

Also if transwomen are women I assume that women are the same than transwomen . Would it be ok, in your opinion, for a woman to attend a transwomen group?

IamSarah · 08/12/2021 16:13

[quote Midlifemusings]@IamSarah

I don't think you can presume they identified as a woman. That is a leap.[/quote]
It was a women's group and in the introductory call we got asked for our pronouns and gender identity.

OP posts:
VestofAbsurdity · 08/12/2021 16:13

@MaryAndGerryLivingInDerry

It actually is almost vomit inducing how wilfully blind people are being to this shit. Telling a rape survivor that they can’t access female only support services is fucking abhorrent.
It is.
ForbiddentoForbid · 08/12/2021 16:13

I don't consider a transwoman to be a man pretending to be a woman, and I also don't consider it to be the same issue as sexual orientation.

You may not "consider" that to be the case. But realistically and scientifically a person with a penis is biologically male.

SilverDragonfly1 · 08/12/2021 16:12

Generally I am very pro trans inclusion and have little patience for the paranoia about the intents of trans people. BUT- the experience of rape is going to be different for different biological sexes. Partly because of the biology of genitalia including post surgery but largely because someone who was raised as a male will have had very different messages around power and sexuality from birth. Women raised as female and trans women need different groups, not because transwomen aren't women but because they have different therapeutic needs. Currently neither group are getting a worthwhile service. Pursuing this angle might help make your point further, because you're certainly not being unreasonable.

Midlifemusings · 08/12/2021 16:10

@IamSarah

I don't think you can presume they identified as a woman. That is a leap.

Stompythedinosaur · 08/12/2021 16:10

@HoardingSamphireSaurus

I don't consider a transwoman to be a man pretending to be a woman

So, if you have a logical answer, HOW are they women?

I'm sure you can google this.

You may disagree with supporting the rights of trans people, but the reality is that the majority of people support the rights of minority groups, and the law is also in support of equality based of gender identity.

Only on mn is it a far out belief to say it is OK to be trans.

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 08/12/2021 16:08

I don't consider a transwoman to be a man pretending to be a woman

So, if you have a logical answer, HOW are they women?

IamSarah · 08/12/2021 16:07

That doesn't have much to do with the male victim who attended your group. You said this was a man presenting as a man. He also wouldn't be a fit for a trans/non binary group.

Presumably the person identified as a woman. To me they appeared to be a typical male with no sign of transitioning.

OP posts:
HoardingSamphireSaurus · 08/12/2021 16:06

[quote Midlifemusings]@IamSarah

Thanks Op, it looks like it no longer runs due to funding.

That doesn't have much to do with the male victim who attended your group. You said this was a man presenting as a man. He also wouldn't be a fit for a trans/non binary group.[/quote]
Ah ah ah! That is transphobic remember. Passing, dressing as, etc has nothing to do with a trans or non binary identity.

Tsk! Tsk!

MothershipG · 08/12/2021 16:05

@Stompythedinosaur
But the issue here is ultimately a trans identity issue.

I believe that a trans woman is a woman, so should be able to attend a woman's group. The reality of that we have no idea and no need to know what is in anyone else's underwear.

Your beliefs are not relevant here.
Reality is that Sarah was traumatised by a person with a penis and so of course does not want to put herself in a vulnerable position around people with penises.
How is this in anyway unreasonable?

Do you also think that if men who have been convicted of sexual offences against women or children decide that they are now women they should be held with vulnerable women in prisons?

Do you think that if a man identifies as a woman he should be allowed to be naked in front of women & girls? Like at the WiSpa? Maybe you think that the girls should avert their eyes?

Stompythedinosaur · 08/12/2021 16:04

@AnyFucker

I think the situation being described here is very similar

It’s not even remotely similar. Unless you consider men pretending to be women to be an expression of sexuality. Which apparently it isn’t…according to the trans rights movement. Nothing to do with how you get your sexual kicks…no sirree.

I don't consider a transwoman to be a man pretending to be a woman, and I also don't consider it to be the same issue as sexual orientation.

The similarity is an individual claiming to be excluded from a group due to the group not being willing to exclude another member based on their own unreasonable prejudice.

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 08/12/2021 16:03

@Stompythedinosaur

And in response to pps asking why people who think differently about this issue don't post - it is because voicing acceptance of trans women as women on mn tends to be met with a barrage of abuse rather than a helpful conversation.
That abuse is because that's how you label anything that does not agree with your ideology about men being women.
Midlifemusings · 08/12/2021 16:03

@IamSarah

Thanks Op, it looks like it no longer runs due to funding.

That doesn't have much to do with the male victim who attended your group. You said this was a man presenting as a man. He also wouldn't be a fit for a trans/non binary group.

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 08/12/2021 16:02

@Stompythedinosaur

But the issue here is ultimately a trans identity issue.

I believe that a trans woman is a woman, so should be able to attend a woman's group. The reality of that we have no idea and no need to know what is in anyone else's underwear.

I want everyone to to able to access appropriate support after rape. But what do you expect services to do when you decline to share space based on a prejudice? They are hardly going to exclude another woman who also needs support due to such feelings.

I have an experience of running a MH support group where a member didn't want a gay woman to be able to join as this made her uncomfortable and her belief was that homosexuality is wrong. Clearly we did not go along with that. I think the situation being described here is very similar.

That said, if the situation described by the op (an attender who was a man, rather than a trans woman) happened then I think they have been very poorly treated and should complain.

Allow me...

No. The issue here is the rights of women. That's the very root of the isue. It is NOT about inclusivity, being nice to some people. It is about making it impossible for many women to access suport after they have been sexualy assaulted.

You can believe what you want. But what you cannot do is demand that anyone/everyone else join in. A transwoman is a male bodied individual. Every woman, especially one who has been traumatised by male violence, is very sensitive to the physical differneces. Even if yiu wish to suppress that knowledge you wil notice the diffence in gait, comparative limb length, hand size, general posture etc. Try wtaching the next group of cycist that pass you - you will know which are women by the angle of their knees. Or a group of people walking away from you. The hip/spine movement will tell you which is female.That CANNOT be masked

A prejudice? You call the visceral reaction of a recently raped women to the close presence of a man, maybe even an unexpected man a prejudice? How, why?

I don't care what youe experience of running anything is. Your rush to inclusivity hurts women. And no, a gay woman and a male bdied person are not similar.

You also do a great disservcie to transwomen, astheir needs from a rape crisis centre are entirely different form that of women - THINK ABOUT THAT! The physical trauma experienced is as different from the psychological trauma.

Transmen? Have you even considered them? Because I can assure you I have. And I know that they too have entirely different needs from any transwomen. And also from women - mainly because transmen usually have a lot more surgery than transwomen, their end desire being totally different. How do you suggest we accommodate their specific needs in an essentially Open Category rape crisis group?

You may think you are being inclusive and nice. But your desire to ignore the reality of sex only hurts EVERYONE involved.

IamSarah · 08/12/2021 16:00

[quote Midlifemusings]@LostForIdeas

I just checked their website as OP posted the organization and they only list one peer support group and it says it is for self-identifying women. It doesn't mention the trans/non-binary group that OP mentioned or any services specifically for male victims at all.

Possibly the man who attended might prefer a single sex support group as well but maybe felt that some peer support was better than none since they didn't have support groups for male victims.

It looks like the support group has been online during the pandemic so maybe they took a different approach since people aren't in a space together and its just people's heads on camera? Who knows. I don't think many places have male and female victims together so this seems very unusual and the man attending goes against the criteria this organization itself has posted as to who the group is for (self-identifying women).[/quote]

This group was running at the same time as the women's group I went to:

survivorsnetwork.org.uk/workshops-groupwork-posts/tnbi-online-group/

OP posts:
Beowulfa · 08/12/2021 16:00

@Stompythedinosaur

But the issue here is ultimately a trans identity issue.

I believe that a trans woman is a woman, so should be able to attend a woman's group. The reality of that we have no idea and no need to know what is in anyone else's underwear.

I want everyone to to able to access appropriate support after rape. But what do you expect services to do when you decline to share space based on a prejudice? They are hardly going to exclude another woman who also needs support due to such feelings.

I have an experience of running a MH support group where a member didn't want a gay woman to be able to join as this made her uncomfortable and her belief was that homosexuality is wrong. Clearly we did not go along with that. I think the situation being described here is very similar.

That said, if the situation described by the op (an attender who was a man, rather than a trans woman) happened then I think they have been very poorly treated and should complain.

Rape specifically requires a penis in English & Welsh law.

All transwomen are male (XY), and the majority retain their genitals (and sense of male entitlement).

Is it really "prejudice" for raped women to not want to talk about the trauma inflicted upon them by a penis, in front of people with penises?

Legoninjago1 · 08/12/2021 15:57

Yanbu OP. I'd be livid. When will this lunacy end.

urbanbuddha · 08/12/2021 15:57

I want everyone to to able to access appropriate support after rape. But what do you expect services to do when you decline to share space based on a prejudice? They are hardly going to exclude another woman who also needs support due to such feelings.

I have an experience of running a MH support group where a member didn't want a gay woman to be able to join as this made her uncomfortable and her belief was that homosexuality is wrong. Clearly we did not go along with that. I think the situation being described here is very similar.

No, you don't want everyone to be able to access appropriate support after rape. You want to exclude women who have been so severely traumitised by an act of violence, where the penis is used as a weapon, to the point where they do not feel able to be comfortable with a male, however that person identifies. Any women would recognise this. The situation is much more visceral than a belief that homosexuality is wrong and your belief that there are grounds for comparison clearly demonstrates your lack of understanding.

Midlifemusings · 08/12/2021 15:55

@LostForIdeas

I just checked their website as OP posted the organization and they only list one peer support group and it says it is for self-identifying women. It doesn't mention the trans/non-binary group that OP mentioned or any services specifically for male victims at all.

Possibly the man who attended might prefer a single sex support group as well but maybe felt that some peer support was better than none since they didn't have support groups for male victims.

It looks like the support group has been online during the pandemic so maybe they took a different approach since people aren't in a space together and its just people's heads on camera? Who knows. I don't think many places have male and female victims together so this seems very unusual and the man attending goes against the criteria this organization itself has posted as to who the group is for (self-identifying women).

ForbiddentoForbid · 08/12/2021 15:55

@Stompythedinosaur

But the issue here is ultimately a trans identity issue.

I believe that a trans woman is a woman, so should be able to attend a woman's group. The reality of that we have no idea and no need to know what is in anyone else's underwear.

I want everyone to to able to access appropriate support after rape. But what do you expect services to do when you decline to share space based on a prejudice? They are hardly going to exclude another woman who also needs support due to such feelings.

I have an experience of running a MH support group where a member didn't want a gay woman to be able to join as this made her uncomfortable and her belief was that homosexuality is wrong. Clearly we did not go along with that. I think the situation being described here is very similar.

That said, if the situation described by the op (an attender who was a man, rather than a trans woman) happened then I think they have been very poorly treated and should complain.

There is a separate group for transwomen. They are able to access support.

There absolutely should be a group for biological women only.

Not everyone supports self ID or that gender is more important than sex.

Male bodied people will never understand the experience of sexual assault of a female bodied person. Because they do not have female genitalia.

titchy · 08/12/2021 15:52

@Stompythedinosaur

But the issue here is ultimately a trans identity issue.

I believe that a trans woman is a woman, so should be able to attend a woman's group. The reality of that we have no idea and no need to know what is in anyone else's underwear.

I want everyone to to able to access appropriate support after rape. But what do you expect services to do when you decline to share space based on a prejudice? They are hardly going to exclude another woman who also needs support due to such feelings.

I have an experience of running a MH support group where a member didn't want a gay woman to be able to join as this made her uncomfortable and her belief was that homosexuality is wrong. Clearly we did not go along with that. I think the situation being described here is very similar.

That said, if the situation described by the op (an attender who was a man, rather than a trans woman) happened then I think they have been very poorly treated and should complain.

But the TW already has a group to go to. That's the point. Women like Sarah who would be traumatised by a male presence have nowhere to go, yet TW - a far smaller number than natal women, apparently have the choice of two groups.

You'd have a point if there was no group for TW - but there is!

IamSarah · 08/12/2021 15:52

@LostForIdeas

I have to say I am Hmm at the idea that trans people need a special group but somehow women aren’t allowed their special group….

Are transpeople so special then?

Clearly the people interviewed have never had a smear test or vaginal ultrasound!
AIBU to have requested single sex rape crisis therapy?
OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread