Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to have requested single sex rape crisis therapy?

564 replies

IamSarah · 08/12/2021 13:56

My local rape crisis centre offers a dedicated support group for trans and non-binary survivors and a women's group open to anyone who identifies as a woman.

After a male (presenting as male) turned up in the women's group I requested an additional group for women who were born women. This request was turned down and I was told that group support isn't for me. AIBU?

YABU: You shouldn't need an additional, exclusive group for biological women

YANBU: Under these circumstances, a single sex group just for biological women was a reasonable request

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
Runningupthecurtains · 11/12/2021 13:12

@DdraigGoch

Can someone explain to me in what way transwomen are women? Other than in name.

Fairydust. Or something.

Because woman ceases meaning "adult, human, female" but know one can actually tell you want the word means instead because It's complicated any definition will amount to tired clichés, out dated stereotypes and will undoubtedly exclude some women from the definition of women.
DdraigGoch · 11/12/2021 12:57

Can someone explain to me in what way transwomen are women? Other than in name.

Fairydust. Or something.

SolasAnla · 11/12/2021 12:43

@PurgatoryOfPotholes

SolasAnla

Purgatory is a very civil poster, I tend to get snarky.
SoMizzFizzyou also appear to be attributing my post to Purgatory.

Aww, thank you! I confess I did feel rather confused, and then rather hard done by, when I read MizzFizz's responses to me. Thank you for trying to clear it up.

I believe the expression is punching down.

I hate the expression punching down in most context, but use it here as a Trojan horse to the next paragraph.

When it comes to violence one of the first lessons females women and girls learn is that they are more physically vulnerable to it than males men and boys. Not the final outcome; but that the physical risk of being harmed in return can act as a deterrent, so the counter-threat is so much less if the victim is -female a woman or girl.
With rape or sexual assault when it's a female woman or girl of reproductive age attacked by a male man or boy there are additional fear around reproductive issues pregnancy/sexual health.
Historic female women and girl socialisation blamed the -female woman or girl for her own attack. Excusing the male's man's or boy's actions support the self protection chant it can't happen to me and anyway males men and boys I know aren't like that.

There are so many layers around social expectation many encapsulated in that short text from IamSarah's "friend".
Women use words as a subistute to being violent and as a defence against violence. If you change the meaning of an important word that line of defence falls. Did the edits female v women and girls male v men and boy tweek how you read the paragraph?
When the Trojan horse succeeds your home is in flames, useful women and children enslaved in foreign lands, the survivors bury the men, women and children who got in the way.
Would insert a high horse comment be OTT??

Anyway I think it is important to point out when there is an attempt to undermine someone who posts from a IMO a very neutral position.
It's DARVO (by excuse the example) trying to pick out the weakest Filly* in a herd as you remained neutral in your counter argument.
(*Note I avoided Mare as it's used as both to complement or insult women)

@MizzFizz was able to successfully directly @ people before the "generic tearful" statement.
Then
@Feelingoktoday's question at 23:48 gets ignored.

@EricCartmansUnderpants's post at 23:56 is totally ignored.

@AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken at 00:31 ignored.

@Ereshkigalangcleg gets a no silly, I am not posting here about IamSarah's situation reply.

And (conveniently IMO) the misdirected post undermines your post about it being lawful to exclude males from a survivor group because the service did nothing "wrong" except not doing the research.

Perhaps I am doing MizzFizz disservice, if so I am happy to correct any misstatement.

Thank you IamSarah and others who have explained why their pain should be recognised within the provision for services.

Thank you to those who work and provide services to help heal the pain.

And thank you for those who posted to explain why they voted no or believe in TWAW. I don't agree with some or all of the beliefs expressed but a civil discussion is very much appreciated.

Runningupthecurtains · 11/12/2021 10:06

Thanks I will have a look later.

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 11/12/2021 09:56

[quote Runningupthecurtains]@HoardingSamphireSaurusoard
Let's just say I probably live near IamSarah so giving local is problematic.[/quote]
That would be a problem Smile

I am many miles away.

You could look at DASH. They, to the best of my knowledge, are quite like us. Set up to help men, women and children as they, the client, need, are user centred/responsive as part of their remit.

Helleofabore · 11/12/2021 09:49

I would like to commend IamSarah for starting this thread. 2000 votes and still 3% disagree. But 97% agree.

I have noticed in general lately that the narrative pushed, even 6 months ago on this AiBU board, of ‘you are all just extremists and not representative at all of the mainstream view’ has almost disappeared. It must be very hard for some people to realise that they, themselves, are the minority but cannot use that projection of old anymore to validate their own extreme point of view.

Thank again for your bravery Sarah. What you will achieve hopefully, is a system that provides better care (suited to group’s needs) for all.

Runningupthecurtains · 11/12/2021 09:35

@HoardingSamphireSaurusoard
Let's just say I probably live near IamSarah so giving local is problematic.

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 11/12/2021 08:55

[quote Runningupthecurtains]@HoardingSamphireSaurus how can I make a donation to your service?[/quote]
The best way would be to look at provision near you, Read their remit, see what you think. Support them, challenge them... make them better!

We are all stronger if we are what we say we are and can build better facilities for all.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 11/12/2021 01:14

SolasAnla

Purgatory is a very civil poster, I tend to get snarky.
SoMizzFizzyou also appear to be attributing my post to Purgatory.

Aww, thank you! I confess I did feel rather confused, and then rather hard done by, when I read MizzFizz's responses to me. Thank you for trying to clear it up.

DdraigGoch · 11/12/2021 00:31

[quote ClaudiaJ1]**@Stompythedinosaur* I would say that if an individual can't access group support alongside the other woman using the service then it is reasonable to offer 1:1 support as an alternative.*

OR, if an individual can't access group support alongside the other women using the service because a male is present, then it is reasonable to offer a biological woman-only service as an alternative.[/quote]
Especially as I bet Sarah wasn't the only individual to walk out.

Runningupthecurtains · 10/12/2021 23:35

@HoardingSamphireSaurus how can I make a donation to your service?

Redshoeblueshoe · 10/12/2021 22:35

HoardingSamphireSaurus thank you for your posts. I'm finding them very informative.

C8H10N4O2 · 10/12/2021 22:32

I went to access essential health services with a mate who is poor, from an extremely excluded racial group, and disabled, and she didn't know how to fill the forms in. I mean seriously. I had to explain them so she could apply. Her response, "FFS of course I'm a fucking woman, why do they think I need [procedure]?" I assume they think they're being inclusive but she might have walked out if I hadn't been there

Yes I've had similar experiences accompanying women at the sharp end of this "inclusiveness". You assumption is a lot more charitable than mine has ever been, faced with virtue signalling professionals congratulating themselves on their righteousness - so much more important than pleb class women's right to healthcare.

SolasAnla · 10/12/2021 21:51

@IamSarah

I explained to them exactly what happened in the group and this is how they responded.

As you can see what I said wasn't addressed or taken seriously at all.

"compassionate and brave" in the extract ....

I am sure that reminds me of something??

Is it inclusively excluding nonbelievers using a mantra??

SolasAnla · 10/12/2021 21:43

MizzFizz
@ PurgatoryOfPotholes I don't know what I did to offend. I don't pretend to have the answer, doesn't make me a bad person.
I see you have a clear opinion, that's great! I was trying to understand the situation and that's is why I asked my original question, but I would need to learn more to have an opinion.
And sometimes there isn't an easy answer. Even if you try to bully people into thinking there is.

IMO you @MizzFizz owe PurgatoryOfPotholes one of two things:

Evidence, as in a quote of where Purgatory either calls you a bad person or where it is implied and a quote of where bullying happened.

Or

If this is not produced have the civility to apology for misrepresenting what Purgatory said and request MN remove the post.

Some may recognise this as tenet in the Gender ideology:
Acknowledge the mistake.
Correct the mistake.
Apologise.

Purgatory is a very civil poster, I tend to get snarky.
So MizzFizz you also appear to be attributing my post to Purgatory.

MizzFizz
@PurgatoryOfPotholes I don't think someone shouldn't be able to receive single-sex services...? I do think the group should have been explicit about what they were from the start... they should have done the work to research and understand the situation so they wouldn't have caused this in the first place.

This was me quoting your 23:48 post MizzFizz.

=>me ( SolasAnla ) at 23:59

SolasAnla
MizzFizz
@ PurgatoryOfPotholes oh right!
Yeah I guess that's the piece I was missing from the OP. It's a tough situation isn't it. We as humans don't trust people we don't know to begin with, then add the trauma experienced by those in a rape support group...and the trauma of being excluded for your gender identity. It's not an easy situation is it 😢

So you can recognise a human with a penis after all.
(What a surprise + shocked face emoji)

Are you trying to avoid typing it?
"Someone who has been sexually assaulted should not be given single sex provision.
Adding tear drop emoji"

....

See if you are going to play word games you will have to try a little harder.

You MizzFizz at 23:31 :
*so the => person

MrsTerryPratchett · 10/12/2021 20:50

They care not one jot for less disadvantaged women, they pretend to with their crocodile tears, hand-wringing and preaching but they don't, they are indeed happy to leave them to rot whilst they get all the high-fives, back-slapping, good-girl pats on the heads from the males they are schilling for.

I went to access essential health services with a mate who is poor, from an extremely excluded racial group, and disabled, and she didn't know how to fill the forms in. I mean seriously. I had to explain them so she could apply. Her response, "FFS of course I'm a fucking woman, why do they think I need [procedure]?" I assume they think they're being inclusive but she might have walked out if I hadn't been there. Weaponising my Karenness 🙄

IamSarah · 10/12/2021 20:31

There's a word for those who condemn other women to this on the basis that they'd rather have the 'rewards' from males and anyway it doesn't effect them and theirs, so they close their eyes and ears and look away.

There are words for their actions too, I would describe it as 'forced consent.'

It somehow feels so much worse coming from women working at a rape crisis centre.

I currently feel more angry and upset with them than my perpetrators which I know is irrational.

OP posts:
VestofAbsurdity · 10/12/2021 18:51

It always is. The victims of these policies are never the middle class wannabe liberals who promote them so vigorously and then virtue signal to death. Its always their less advantaged "sisters" who can rot.

Agree. They care not one jot for less disadvantaged women, they pretend to with their crocodile tears, hand-wringing and preaching but they don't, they are indeed happy to leave them to rot whilst they get all the high-fives, back-slapping, good-girl pats on the heads from the males they are schilling for.

Oddly the large local population who were often poor, second language speakers or otherwise disadvantaged didn't identify as cervix havers or menstruators and attendance has skewed toward white middle class again with drops in minority and poorer women.

Perfect case in point, there'll be lots of weeping and a-wailing about the increase in deaths from cervical cancer, they'll probably do a bit of virtue signalling fund raising BUT actually look at why and what would help that population oh, no, not if it reflects badly on their chosen special ones and their cause.

There's a word for those who condemn other women to this on the basis that they'd rather have the 'rewards' from males and anyway it doesn't effect them and theirs, so they close their eyes and ears and look away.

I have nothing but contempt for them.

Waitwhat23 · 10/12/2021 17:41

@HoardingSamphireSaurus I have found your posts very interesting from a perspective of a service fighting for the needs of their service users.

Waitwhat23 · 10/12/2021 17:39

@IamSarah I am so sorry that you received that message from a 'friend'. The lack of empathy by that person is astounding.

I just cannot believe that there are posters on this thread who are so 'inclusive' that they are OK with women being excluded from services fought for, set up by and fundraised for by women and say that Sarah (and the many others like her in the same situation) should wait 18 months for 1 to 1 counselling. Instead of the service using the exemptions they are legally allowed to use to provide a single sex service. Sarah has never asked for a reduction in the services available to transwomen or argued (as she could) that the women's group should not be for those 'who identify as women' given the myriad of other options available to them. Simply an additional group.

You'd think that a rape crisis centre, of all things would be safe from the extremes of this ideology.

Artichokeleaves · 10/12/2021 17:13

And this is where you see:

It is not 'inclusion'.

It is not 'kindness' or 'diversity'.

It is in fact male supremacism.

C8H10N4O2 · 10/12/2021 17:04

Women already on the very margins of society are deemed even more worthless, and are being pushed ever further out of society in order to pander to men

It always is. The victims of these policies are never the middle class wannabe liberals who promote them so vigorously and then virtue signal to death. Its always their less advantaged "sisters" who can rot.

Twisting the language to remove women centred language from health care and advice also excludes these women. Our main area hospital deliberately had signage and advertising for the womens health clinic rather than Obs and Gynae and ran successful walk in clinics with good reach to the community. When the local activists and some from the management who had been on "training" complained this was "excluding" language they were pushed into changing it back to medical terms.

Oddly the large local population who were often poor, second language speakers or otherwise disadvantaged didn't identify as cervix havers or menstruators and attendance has skewed toward white middle class again with drops in minority and poorer women.

But hey, they are stonewall champions so that's ok.

DrBlackbird · 10/12/2021 17:01

I’m glad that some posters have come on to explain why they disagree/voted YABU eg with this kind of comment the trauma of being excluded for your gender identity

As it helps to understand their thinking, which seems to be wholly sympathetic to TW. This is kind, but nevertheless frustrating in trans allies not seeing that when the rights of TW and women conflict, the rights of women are on the losing end. Enabled by other women being kind instead of standing up for women’s rights.

But then this is always what women have been conditioned to do. If we can’t have power, at least we’ll be liked? Is that what this is?

VestofAbsurdity · 10/12/2021 16:40

That response is a disgrace. It effectively says, 'no we don't offer a safe space for recovery, no we don't offer inclusive services for all women from all communities, no we don't seek to prevent predatory males from entering our services, and we have chosen to be unable to do those things as we have decided to prioritise the choices of males who identify as women over the needs of actual female-women.'

Disgrace is correct. So now here we have in black and white an admission from this service that women from certain cultures, backgrounds, religions and those who have suffered abuse at the hands of men that are the stuff of nightmares are wilfully and deliberately excluded from services that promote themselves, falsely and misleadingly as being there to help them.

Women already on the very margins of society are deemed even more worthless, and are being pushed ever further out of society in order to pander to men.

All those on here who keep blathering on about trans and non binary folks being excluded, how does this sit with you? You happy that these women are being sacrificed in the pursuance of this ideology?

Think about it, these women are not only excluded from rape and trauma services by the inclusion of males, they are excluded from every other purportedly female only space and service if males are allowed access. I do hope you don't hand-wring and preach about the plight of refugee women, trafficked women, women from strict religious backgrounds because if you do you are raging hypocrites, you are not kind and you are not empathetic, you are placing men's wants and wishes above women's needs.

C8H10N4O2 · 10/12/2021 14:14

Mridul Wadhwa and supporters appears to think it has a very different meaning

Well I guess that happens when your entire world view is ME!ME!ME! and fuck everyone else.

Fortunately there are other VAWG charities to support than theirs.