Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to have requested single sex rape crisis therapy?

564 replies

IamSarah · 08/12/2021 13:56

My local rape crisis centre offers a dedicated support group for trans and non-binary survivors and a women's group open to anyone who identifies as a woman.

After a male (presenting as male) turned up in the women's group I requested an additional group for women who were born women. This request was turned down and I was told that group support isn't for me. AIBU?

YABU: You shouldn't need an additional, exclusive group for biological women

YANBU: Under these circumstances, a single sex group just for biological women was a reasonable request

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
Helleofabore · 08/12/2021 17:40

And in response to pps asking why people who think differently about this issue don't post - it is because voicing acceptance of trans women as women on mn tends to be met with a barrage of abuse rather than a helpful conversation.

Hyperbole Alert!!

No. People who voice acceptance of transwoman as women are asked questions and to support many of their claims as to why this subset of males should be allowed access into female single sex spaces, sports and the opportunities needed by females to progress due to a millennia of sexist discrimination.

If you cannot actually provide this support, evidence driven support and not mantras and blog posts. That will be pointed out.

And if you don't like that it is pointed out, then that is on you.

We are always happy to engage in looking at new evidence, studies, and science. In fact, many of us enjoy it.

SolasAnla · 08/12/2021 17:40

@Stompythedinosaur

But the issue here is ultimately a trans identity issue.

I believe that a trans woman is a woman, so should be able to attend a woman's group. The reality of that we have no idea and no need to know what is in anyone else's underwear.

I want everyone to to able to access appropriate support after rape. But what do you expect services to do when you decline to share space based on a prejudice? They are hardly going to exclude another woman who also needs support due to such feelings.

I have an experience of running a MH support group where a member didn't want a gay woman to be able to join as this made her uncomfortable and her belief was that homosexuality is wrong. Clearly we did not go along with that. I think the situation being described here is very similar.

That said, if the situation described by the op (an attender who was a man, rather than a trans woman) happened then I think they have been very poorly treated and should complain.

@Stompythedinosaur you claim to have experience in running support groups.

If you actually do run a support group you will known that providers of services need written policy and procedures.

Your position is that it is appropriate to provide different services.

Can you please expand on what elements you would use to differentiate between
•a male presenting as a male who was sexually assaulted
and
• a male presenting as a woman who was sexually assaulted
when it comes to including or excluding them from groups providing support for people who were sexually assaulted?

IMO having a policy of "Google it" would not be an acceptable work practice for any competent support group.

Thanks

NecessaryScene · 08/12/2021 17:38

What do those who think "transwomen" should be in women's groups think the point of a dedicated "women"'s group is?

If excluding men who say they're women is "unreasonable prejudice", why isn't excluding men who don't say they're women "unreasonable prejudice"? What's your justification for excluding other men?

I understand our view very clearly - males are traumatising for most females who have been assaulted by a male, so it's best to have a female-only group. Especially as almost all service users will be females who have been assaulted by males. You obviously have to concentrate on the needs of the majority of your clients.

But I can't understand why you're discriminating against most males while permitting others.

IamSarah · 08/12/2021 17:21

Thanks @Anothernamechange3

I want people who chant the mantra 'trans women are women' to know what the consequences are for women like me who now can't access rape crisis.

I know TRAs are a lost cause and have zero empathy with female sexual violence survivors but I wish 'feminists' like Emma Watson would stop and think for a minute.

OP posts:
HoardingSamphireSaurus · 08/12/2021 17:07

[quote TheLovelinessOfBaublyDemons]@Stompythedinosaur I think we'd get on.[/quote]
Oh! So you might be able to answer the questins Stompy has faltered on?

How does a man become a woman? What is that science?

What is unfair about transwomen having multiple groups to access and women having none?

Anothernamechange3 · 08/12/2021 17:03

Also @IamSarah, thank you for having the courage to raise this in as many places as you can, presumably knowing what some people’s responses might be, and how horrible this might be for you to read. To be prepared to be exposed to that on top of the trauma you have already experienced shows a truly strong woman. Please know your actions are helping other people to feel strong enough to also speak out about this, whether anonymously or not. When people have received threats of sexual violence and lost their jobs or been arrested for challenging this it’s a scary thing to do. People like you are helping me articulate my arguments and become less scared.

TheLovelinessOfBaublyDemons · 08/12/2021 16:58

@Stompythedinosaur I think we'd get on.

DariaMorgendorffer · 08/12/2021 16:53

YADNBU

ForbiddentoForbid · 08/12/2021 16:52

So TW get 3 groups.

Women get 0 groups.

Disgusting.

Anothernamechange3 · 08/12/2021 16:48

@IamSarah I’m sorry you’ve had to go through through this, and can’t work out why some people think a male ‘presenting’ as a woman (how? Long hair, dress, shaved legs? Are females who have short hair, wear trousers and don’t shave their legs not women?) has a right to be included whereas a male ‘presenting’ as a man does not. I think all that gender ideologists state is that someone merely has to say they ‘identify’ as a woman to be included in what I think should be a single sex group. Surely whatever your views on whether transwomen are really women or not, you can see that this opens a massive loophole for predatory males (whether ‘genuinely transgender’ or not) to be able to access a group designed for females who have been traumatised by males. Surely there needs to be a female only space, and people who identify as trans should also receive support but in a group separate to this one. I genuinely don’t understand the debate on this. I really hope you can get the support you need Flowers

I’m trying to #bekind here to people who believe something different to me about gender and respect their beliefs. It’s a shame you haven’t been given the same respect, especially given what you have been through.

titchy · 08/12/2021 16:40

@Stompythedinosaur I notice you still haven't commented on the fact there was effectively two groups for TW to choose from, but only one for natal women (who I would guess far outnumber TW as victims) and none for a woman traumatised by the male presence.

Maybe that's too difficult for you answer 🤷‍♀️

Eyesofdisarray · 08/12/2021 16:39

People with DSD have repeatedly asked not be brought into this debate, Stompy Please respect that.
And do you think @IamSarah has "unreasonable prejudice" Really?????????

Marylou2 · 08/12/2021 16:38

@AnyFucker

A male presenting as a male, female or as a fucking teapot should not be in a women’s rape therapy group
This x a million
AnyFucker · 08/12/2021 16:37

"Scientifically" I think it is a bit more complex than that

Science tells us quite clearly that men cannot turn into a woman because he says so. Intersex is something completely different and people with intersex conditions on the whole completely resent your rubbish attempted equivalence (I am not including those people who exploit their condition for sporting “success”)

TracyLords · 08/12/2021 16:33

And @IamSarah. I am so sorry that you have to go through this

TracyLords · 08/12/2021 16:31

YABU: You shouldn't need an additional, exclusive group for biological women

Because the group should only be for biological women in the first place!!!!! Jeezey fucking peeps. It’s horrendous that women who are in crisis are having to go through this

VestofAbsurdity · 08/12/2021 16:30

Scientifically" I think it is a bit more complex than that due to issues around being intersex.

Don't drag intersex in to try and shore up your argument, people with DSD's are still either one or the other sex and have repeatedly asked not to be used by TRAs as some kind of gotcha, why don't you respect them enough to do that?

Ultimately the law supports people's right to identify their own gender.

Ultimately the law does not.

Eyesofdisarray · 08/12/2021 16:29

A man should not be in women's group; it's not appropriate in any way.
Why are they afraid to say " no"? Self ID isn't in yet .. is it?????? But this is what would happen if it was. The MRA/TRA must be laughing up their sleeves.
Trans people should have their own group- I think it's a specialised area.
And objecting to men in what should be a women's group is in No Way similar to homophobia
Why can't women see what's happening here? Take your "be kind" rainbow spectacles off ffs

MothershipG · 08/12/2021 16:26

@Stompythedinosaur

So you do think that any male who identifies as a woman should be allowed into women's refuges, woman's prisons & woman's toilets despite the growing amount of evidence of the harm this causes to natal women?

Why are you so keen to sacrifice all women's hard won protections for bepenised people?

TheKeatingFive · 08/12/2021 16:24

That is quite different from a trans woman attending a women's group, which I think is fine.

Why would that be ok?

The truth is you can't change sex. It's biologically impossible.

A male body will always be a male body (however they choose to identify) and always runs the risk of triggering a woman seeking a safe space to work through trauma.

Why should her needs be disregarded?

VestofAbsurdity · 08/12/2021 16:24

You may disagree with supporting the rights of trans people, but the reality is that the majority of people support the rights of minority groups, and the law is also in support of equality based of gender identity.

No-one disagrees with supporting the rights of trans people. The law does not support gender identity and certainly not self-id, the law does, however, support the equality and rights of sex. The Equality Act specifically lists Rape Crisis Counselling and Centres as being places where TW, whether or not they have a GRC, can be excluded to ensure female only provision.

Furthermore trans people had equality of provision in the case the OP details, the only people who do not have equality of provision are females who require female only services.

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 08/12/2021 16:22

"Scientifically" I think it is a bit more complex than that due to issues around being intersex.

Nope. Science manages that quite easily. And stop dragging a whole cohrt of eople who have, across social media, across the world, idividually and as groups, asked to be left out of this. They have NOTHING WHATSOEVER to do with being trans.

Ultimately the law supports people's right to identify their own gender.

What does that have to do with sex based services and protections?

urbanbuddha · 08/12/2021 16:20

The similarity is an individual claiming to be excluded from a group due to the group not being willing to exclude another member based on their own unreasonable prejudice.

It's NOT prejudice. Try and get your head around this very fundamental fact. It's an instinctive and involuntary reaction. Imagine you were stabbed in the scrotum with a six inch blade. You would have an innate fear of knives from then on. So like that. Not prejudice. Fear. Fear of the penis.

Stompythedinosaur · 08/12/2021 16:19

@ForbiddentoForbid

I don't consider a transwoman to be a man pretending to be a woman, and I also don't consider it to be the same issue as sexual orientation.

You may not "consider" that to be the case. But realistically and scientifically a person with a penis is biologically male.

"Scientifically" I think it is a bit more complex than that due to issues around being intersex.

Ultimately the law supports people's right to identify their own gender.

MrsTerryPratchett · 08/12/2021 16:19

I have an experience of running a MH support group where a member didn't want a gay woman to be able to join as this made her uncomfortable and her belief was that homosexuality is wrong. Clearly we did not go along with that. I think the situation being described here is very similar.

If a client came to a group and said they didn't want to participate because x protected characteristic is 'wrong' that's their issue.

If they came to a group and said that they lived in a fictional world where lesbians were in charge of the judiciary, the police, the government and every conceivable institution, that lesbianism was the overarching system of their oppression and that they had been molested by a lesbian and were triggered by their presence and couldn't help their reaction because of PTSD, and every other person in the room had also been molested by lesbians as well, I think I'd have at least a little chat about what support they needed to receive counselling and groupwork. And make sure everyone received appropriate therapeutic input.

Swipe left for the next trending thread