Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to have requested single sex rape crisis therapy?

564 replies

IamSarah · 08/12/2021 13:56

My local rape crisis centre offers a dedicated support group for trans and non-binary survivors and a women's group open to anyone who identifies as a woman.

After a male (presenting as male) turned up in the women's group I requested an additional group for women who were born women. This request was turned down and I was told that group support isn't for me. AIBU?

YABU: You shouldn't need an additional, exclusive group for biological women

YANBU: Under these circumstances, a single sex group just for biological women was a reasonable request

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
MothershipG · 08/12/2021 19:26

@Stompythedinosaur

Most services don't offer a cis only group for the same reason they don't offer white only groups, straight only groups or men only groups. Because private space is generally reserved for the oppressed group.
In this case the oppressed group is woman who have been raped who need a space that excludes the group of people with a penis.

How do you not see this?

Antsgomarching · 08/12/2021 19:26

Transwomen are not going to experience rape in the same way women do. If they are sexually assaulted it will be in a different way and for different reasons than a woman. The literally will not be able to connect with that experience in the same way women can try to imagine what it’s like for a male to experience rape but not in a way that other males would understand. Transwomen should have spaces to talk about therir experiences but don’t need to invade womens spaces to do it.

Can’t help but to think that guy (sorry not sorry, its a bloke who is making sure everyone knows there is a bloke in the room while women are expected to carry on talking about being raped) was there to get his kicks.

IamSarah · 08/12/2021 19:26

@Stompythedinosaur

Most services don't offer a cis only group for the same reason they don't offer white only groups, straight only groups or men only groups. Because private space is generally reserved for the oppressed group.
Please can you explain exactly how the trans woman with multiple groups to choose from is more oppressed than me with 0 groups?
OP posts:
BoreOfWhabylon · 08/12/2021 19:25

@Stompythedinosaur

Many women (and men) find the term 'cis' offensive. Please don't use it.

IN LAW services can be segregated by sex, not gender.

Redshoeblueshoe · 08/12/2021 19:25

You are so nearly there Stompy - the oppressed group

That'll be women then

NeedsCharging · 08/12/2021 19:24

Transwomen aren't excluding others by existing

Not by existing no but when a TW enters a woman only space at least 1 woman will be excluded because now that woman only space has a male in it.
Why is that difficult to grasp?

RedToothBrush · 08/12/2021 19:24

Black women are not physically different to white women.

Transwomen are. Whether they are pre op or post op.

When you are talking about rape and sexual violence thats relevant.

Suggesting that transwomen are women because black women are different to white women is frankly just fucking racist.

Stompythedinosaur · 08/12/2021 19:21

Most services don't offer a cis only group for the same reason they don't offer white only groups, straight only groups or men only groups. Because private space is generally reserved for the oppressed group.

BoreOfWhabylon · 08/12/2021 19:20

Oh, if only an organisation such as Stonewall had the funds to provide dedicated services for trans and non-binary people.

Oh, wait...

IamSarah · 08/12/2021 19:17

A trans woman may need a space to explore issues regarding being trans as well as issues regarding being a woman.

Of course. And that trans woman can go to the women's group or the trans group at my local centre.

Why does that trans woman also need to attend the ADDITIONAL group I requested just for women born female?

OP posts:
Stompythedinosaur · 08/12/2021 19:17

[quote MothershipG]@Stompythedinosaur

So trans rights trump woman's rights to single sex spaces for rape support? Is that what you are saying?

I have asked this in a variety of ways and you have yet to answer.

And following from that you believe that trans rights should see them in Women's refuges, prisons & toilets? [/quote]
Of course they don't. But the op hasn't suggested any transwomen have attempted to exclude others from the group.

Transwomen aren't excluding others by existing.

I would say that if an individual can't access group support alongside the other woman using the service then it is reasonable to offer 1:1 support as an alternative.

urbanbuddha · 08/12/2021 19:17

To claim trans women are privileged because they have to content with multiple different ways of being oppressed is ridiculous.

Sorry, missed that. Who claimed that?

LostForIdeas · 08/12/2021 19:16

Also your example with women of colour…

I don’t think anyone would ever suggest they have to be supported both in a group for women of colour AND with a group where there will be white women. As of somehow, white women can bring some experiences that other women of colour can’t?? That would be the only reason why there was an advantages to being in two groups.

Helleofabore · 08/12/2021 19:16

So, being asked to clarify your reasons, and to provide evidence is still being framed as 'attacks'?

If any poster on this thread is attacking anyone, please report it.

It is appropriate for them to have additional support in my view.

Is anyone disagreeing that any trans people should have their unique and specific needs supported in support groups specifically catering to their needs?

I have not seen one person state this. If they have, please name and shame them.

Why do you continue with the hyperbolic claims?

HollowTalk · 08/12/2021 19:15

I think the only people who think women shouldn't have the right to female only support are handmaidens or dodgy fuckers.

LostForIdeas · 08/12/2021 19:14

A trans woman may need a space to explore issues regarding being trans as well as issues regarding being a woman.

If a transwoman is a woman, why can’t she address issues associated with rape as a woman in the group for transowmen? She will be surrounded by women so should get the support she needs as a woman.

urbanbuddha · 08/12/2021 19:13

A trans woman is very different than a man turning up.

Not in this case. For the reasons explained above. At length and in detail. Have a read.

Helleofabore · 08/12/2021 19:12

I think you'll find most NHS employees support trans rights.

Not sure why you have continued to frame this as not supporting trans rights.

What part of supporting trans rights means that males should not respect female's needs to have single sex spaces? I think that you seem to be pushing your own agenda here stompy.

We also know that there are many trans people, including males who identify as trans, who support women needing to have these spaces. And constantly told that trans people are no longer denying that they remain the sex they were born.

Did you also miss Nancy Kelley, the CEO of Stonewall, the other week stating that women should be able to receive trauma services such as this that suits their needs? Even if that means excluding males from these spaces.

I really think that you are not quite up to date on the latest developments here.

Stompythedinosaur · 08/12/2021 19:12

@titchy

Op, nor anyone else, has asked for the group for TW to be closed down.

While we're at it stumpy any chance of letting us know how fair it is that TW have two groups to choose from and natal women just one. And those that need single sex have non.

Or are you going to continue to ignore the question?

I'll answer this one, though I'm just about done with being personally attacked for voicing views on a thread where several posters specifically asked for people to explain why they thought differently.

A trans woman may need a space to explore issues regarding being trans as well as issues regarding being a woman. Just like a woman of colour might need a group to look at experiences of being a woman and experiences of being a person of colour.

To claim trans women are privileged because they have to content with multiple different ways of being oppressed is ridiculous. It is appropriate for them to have additional support in my view.

urbanbuddha · 08/12/2021 19:10

It's not trans rights that's the issue here though, is it?

What about the OP's right not to be triggered by a male body when she needs support?

Absolutely.

Pixiedust138 · 08/12/2021 19:08

@Stompythedinosaur

But the issue here is ultimately a trans identity issue.

I believe that a trans woman is a woman, so should be able to attend a woman's group. The reality of that we have no idea and no need to know what is in anyone else's underwear.

I want everyone to to able to access appropriate support after rape. But what do you expect services to do when you decline to share space based on a prejudice? They are hardly going to exclude another woman who also needs support due to such feelings.

I have an experience of running a MH support group where a member didn't want a gay woman to be able to join as this made her uncomfortable and her belief was that homosexuality is wrong. Clearly we did not go along with that. I think the situation being described here is very similar.

That said, if the situation described by the op (an attender who was a man, rather than a trans woman) happened then I think they have been very poorly treated and should complain.

I agree with you. A trans woman can also be raped and might feel equally comfortable in a men's or mixed group. But I appreciate that this is an extremely difficult and sensitive subject with lots of trauma linked to it. A trans woman is very different than a man turning up.
AnyFucker · 08/12/2021 19:07

I think you'll find most NHS employees support trans rights

What “rights” are you talking about ?

titchy · 08/12/2021 19:06

@SolasAnla

Next up, how NHS staff support lying to women in single sex wards and informed consent is "racist".
Well the inter-sex card has been played so it's only a matter of time before the racist one is.
WhenSepEnds · 08/12/2021 19:06

@beastlyslumber

YANBU. It makes me so angry that women are being excluded from much-needed services that WE set up! For women!

Great that there's a men's group and a trans group. Fab. But why isn't there a group for women?

I really don't understand why this is the case either?
MothershipG · 08/12/2021 19:06

@Stompythedinosaur

So trans rights trump woman's rights to single sex spaces for rape support? Is that what you are saying?

I have asked this in a variety of ways and you have yet to answer.

And following from that you believe that trans rights should see them in Women's refuges, prisons & toilets?