Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to have requested single sex rape crisis therapy?

564 replies

IamSarah · 08/12/2021 13:56

My local rape crisis centre offers a dedicated support group for trans and non-binary survivors and a women's group open to anyone who identifies as a woman.

After a male (presenting as male) turned up in the women's group I requested an additional group for women who were born women. This request was turned down and I was told that group support isn't for me. AIBU?

YABU: You shouldn't need an additional, exclusive group for biological women

YANBU: Under these circumstances, a single sex group just for biological women was a reasonable request

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
NeedsCharging · 08/12/2021 20:00

That's just not accurate. Some trans women have had gender reassignment surgery and therefore do not have penises.

Not anymore but they did for many years and even though they have had it removed it doesn't make them women.

Women are not just men without a penis ffs!

Pixiedust138 · 08/12/2021 19:59

[quote EmmaWoodhousestreehouse]@Pixiedust138. A trans woman is very different than a man turning up.

A trans woman is actually no different to man turning up. They both have a penis. Female rape victims to not want to talk about their rape experiences with people with a penis. Calling themselves a woman does not make them a woman. They should be in the trans support group and learn some sentivity.[/quote]
Although I do agree that they should join a trans group if there is one available. Not because I believe in excluding them but because other trans people are more likely to be able to have shared experiences with them so a trans group is likely to be a better option for that reason.

LimpLettice · 08/12/2021 19:57

You are absolutely not BU in any way, @IamSarah. I do not believe any man, presenting (what does that mean, I thought it wasn't just gold lame purses) in whatever way, belongs in those spaces, and the fact that you wanted to set up an additional group and were still refused makes the whole issue very clearly not about rape support for those people. It's about forcing women to accept this delusion in every possible space, with no dissent allowed whatsoever.

I have a Muslim friend who would absolutely 100% been excluded by this if it had been her support group; that group was a lifeline for her for many reasons which aren't mine to tell, but talking about her rape in front of a man? No.

Lots of women from minority backgrounds will end up self excluding, as will the most traumatised, those who may have learning difficulties or autism spectrum disorders and are unable to process an identity being more important than reality. The people who really actually are the most marginalised. Why are their needs so much further down the ladder that an ADDITIONAL group is not allowed?

Pixiedust138 · 08/12/2021 19:57

[quote EmmaWoodhousestreehouse]@Pixiedust138. A trans woman is very different than a man turning up.

A trans woman is actually no different to man turning up. They both have a penis. Female rape victims to not want to talk about their rape experiences with people with a penis. Calling themselves a woman does not make them a woman. They should be in the trans support group and learn some sentivity.[/quote]
That's just not accurate. Some trans women have had gender reassignment surgery and therefore do not have penises.

Thefartingsofaofdenmarkstreet · 08/12/2021 19:56

@Stompythedinosaur

At no point did I say "cis women" are a privileged group. Cis people are privileged in comparison to trans people. Men are privileged in comparison to women. We can have multiple roles.
Cis people are privileged in comparison to trans people.

Says who? Who says that women are privileged compared to men who say they are women?

As has been said before: only men could opppress women for millenia, then decide that they want to insert themselves into the group they have been oppressing and then claim that they are more oppressed than that group.

What a load of bollocks. Literally.

NeedsCharging · 08/12/2021 19:53

There is some line between male who has experienced sexual violence and another male who has also experienced sexual violence.

Whats the line?

SolasAnla · 08/12/2021 19:52

@NeedsCharging

Stompy do you think males any male regardless of gender should be welcomed in to a female rape support group?
Per prior posts that would be no.

There is some line between male who has experienced sexual violence and another male who has also experienced sexual violence.

For funding purposes there would be a pyramid of provision which has males both at the top and somewhere down the bottom.

Eddielzzard · 08/12/2021 19:50

Totally agree Skysblue

Skysblue · 08/12/2021 19:49

Rape crisis centres were created to give BIOLOGICAL WOMEN a safe space away from BIOLOGICAL MEN.

If they aren’t going to do that anymore then they should return all of their funding to the donors, asap.

OhWhyNot · 08/12/2021 19:46

YANBU

I’m sorry for what has happened and what you are going through

I feel so angry about this girls and women need spaces that are for females only

titchy · 08/12/2021 19:45

A trans woman may need a space to explore issues regarding being trans as well as issues regarding being a woman.

So the person leading the group dedicated to TW can't possibly explore issues regarding the TW being a woman then? Why on earth not? Why would the TW need an additional group?

Would it be because they also need validation as well as trauma counselling, and providing that validation is more important than providing trauma counselling for a natal woman who wants to explore issues regarding being a natal woman.

Got it.

EmmaWoodhousestreehouse · 08/12/2021 19:44

@Pixiedust138. A trans woman is very different than a man turning up.

A trans woman is actually no different to man turning up. They both have a penis. Female rape victims to not want to talk about their rape experiences with people with a penis. Calling themselves a woman does not make them a woman. They should be in the trans support group and learn some sentivity.

Stompythedinosaur · 08/12/2021 19:44

At no point did I say "cis women" are a privileged group. Cis people are privileged in comparison to trans people. Men are privileged in comparison to women. We can have multiple roles.

AbandonedCharacter · 08/12/2021 19:43

I see the usual references to DSDs and outright racism have been deployed. How disappointing and yet unsurprising.

Stompythedinosaur · 08/12/2021 19:43

*men

Stompythedinosaur · 08/12/2021 19:42

@IamSarah

I've also noticed every trans woman survivor claims their perpetrator was a woman. I'm sure this is equally traumatic to my experiences but nonetheless very, very different.
That is not my experience at all. Male are the perpetrators in nearly all rapes, whoever the victim is.
Stompythedinosaur · 08/12/2021 19:40

@SolasAnla

Hi *@Pixiedust138*

As you views and Stompythedinosaur's views appear to align perhaps you can have start at writing the policy document to be used by the service?

Per the copied post below

@Stompythedinosaur you claim to have experience in running support groups.

If you actually do run a support group you will known that providers of services need written policy and procedures.

Your position is that it is appropriate to provide different services.

Can you please expand on what elements you would use to differentiate between
• a male presenting as a male who was sexually assaulted
and
• a male presenting as a woman who was sexually assaulted
when it comes to including or excluding them from groups providing support for people who were sexually assaulted

IMO having a policy of "Google it" would not be an acceptable work practice for any competent support group.

Thanks

I have literally no idea why you'd imagine I'm obliged to write a policy document for you. For what? I don't believe you are involved in running the Centre.

I suspect I have more lived experience in providing support to rape victims than the majority of posters on this thread. Maybe direct some of your passion into helping rather that whatever this thread is.

Thefartingsofaofdenmarkstreet · 08/12/2021 19:38

@Stompythedinosaur

Most services don't offer a cis only group for the same reason they don't offer white only groups, straight only groups or men only groups. Because private space is generally reserved for the oppressed group.
Ok, if you insist on appropriating race as a comparison.....Would it be OK for a white person to paint their face black, dress and act according to society's stereotypes about what black people dress and behave as, and then that white person claim that they are more oppressed than black people, because black people are 'cis black' and therefore more privileged?

Because that it what you are doing when you say that 'cis women' are a 'privileged group'. It's really offensive, please don't do it.

Helleofabore · 08/12/2021 19:37

Transwomen aren't excluding others by existing.

I think that is splitting hairs right there. By 'existing' in that group they are making that group a mixed sex group and they are thereby excluding women that need single sex spaces.

I would say that if an individual can't access group support alongside the other woman using the service then it is reasonable to offer 1:1 support as an alternative.

Excellent. But when there is no 1:1 available for 18 months, that is again effectively excluding a woman from care particularly when there are specific groups already available for that male.

So, this is an instance when sex should be prioritised over gender. Prioritising gender here does lead to the harm of any woman requiring a single sex service. And by the way, this is allowed for, and specifically listed, in the EA10.

Why would anyone continue to try to shame a woman seeking care when the Act allows exactly that, yet, funding models have been allowed to develop where services have had to allow males into female services to receive funding?

HollowTalk · 08/12/2021 19:35

@IamSarah

I've also noticed every trans woman survivor claims their perpetrator was a woman. I'm sure this is equally traumatic to my experiences but nonetheless very, very different.
Are they actually saying that the abuse from a woman is sexual abuse? I wonder whether they are just talking about women who perhaps are married to them who say that they - the TW - are not actually women. Literal violence.
SolasAnla · 08/12/2021 19:33

Hi @Pixiedust138

As you views and Stompythedinosaur's views appear to align perhaps you can have start at writing the policy document to be used by the service?

Per the copied post below

@Stompythedinosaur you claim to have experience in running support groups.

If you actually do run a support group you will known that providers of services need written policy and procedures.

Your position is that it is appropriate to provide different services.

Can you please expand on what elements you would use to differentiate between
• a male presenting as a male who was sexually assaulted
and
• a male presenting as a woman who was sexually assaulted
when it comes to including or excluding them from groups providing support for people who were sexually assaulted

IMO having a policy of "Google it" would not be an acceptable work practice for any competent support group.

Thanks

IamSarah · 08/12/2021 19:33

I've also noticed every trans woman survivor claims their perpetrator was a woman. I'm sure this is equally traumatic to my experiences but nonetheless very, very different.

OP posts:
NeedsCharging · 08/12/2021 19:32

Stompy do you think males any male regardless of gender should be welcomed in to a female rape support group?

urbanbuddha · 08/12/2021 19:28

Transwomen aren't excluding others by existing

Of course they're not.
But in a service dedicated to the traumatised female victims of rape it would be helpful if transwomen could show empathy and understanding and absent themselves from the group which is female only and in this case has to be female born only. The rapist has a penis. This has been weaponised to attack the woman. She needs space to start to recover, away from people with penises.
You have a tendency to spout dogma but I don't doubt you're sincere. It's time to start listening to what you're hearing.

RedToothBrush · 08/12/2021 19:26

@Stompythedinosaur

Most services don't offer a cis only group for the same reason they don't offer white only groups, straight only groups or men only groups. Because private space is generally reserved for the oppressed group.
White rape victims aren't oppressed enough. Is that what you are saying? Just trying to clarify what you just said.

So you would be fine with a service for black women that excluded transwomen then? Cos they are oppressed enough.