Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to have requested single sex rape crisis therapy?

564 replies

IamSarah · 08/12/2021 13:56

My local rape crisis centre offers a dedicated support group for trans and non-binary survivors and a women's group open to anyone who identifies as a woman.

After a male (presenting as male) turned up in the women's group I requested an additional group for women who were born women. This request was turned down and I was told that group support isn't for me. AIBU?

YABU: You shouldn't need an additional, exclusive group for biological women

YANBU: Under these circumstances, a single sex group just for biological women was a reasonable request

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
Helleofabore · 08/12/2021 20:32

@AnyFucker

and therefore do not have penises

So what ? Still a man. Like I am still a woman if I have a hysterectomy.

Quite.

It needs to be said, over and over again.

Because there are also many males out in the world without a penis who are not identifying as women. So, what sets those men apart from those who do identify as women. Artificial Estrogen?

LostForIdeas · 08/12/2021 20:30

Although I do agree that they should join a trans group if there is one available. Not because I believe in excluding them but because other trans people are more likely to be able to have shared experiences with them so a trans group is likely to be a better option for that reason.

@Pixiedust138, yes I agree with that.
The life experience of transwomen will be vastly different the one women have.
They’ve had to go through gender reassignment which will have been traumatic.
The rape itself will have been physically different (assuming they still have their penis which the vast majority of them).
The physical consequences will be different.
And that’s wo going into the fact experiences, beliefs etc… around who they are will have been affected by their previous life as a man.

So I am wondering what are those transwomen gaining from a women (sex) only group? What shared experience do they have?

Helenluvsrob · 08/12/2021 20:30

I would ask if there are make only rape survivors groups ,

ArabellaScott · 08/12/2021 20:29

Thanks for all that you do, Samphire. It must be a challenging role at the best of times. Your service should be showered with money. Flowers

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/12/2021 20:28

I've heard on the quiet that is often the policy, Samphire. They can't say it explicitly, mostly.

Pixiedust138 · 08/12/2021 20:26

@HoardingSamphireSaurus

If I worked for the organisation and it was my role to do so then I would

As I have said, I do. I can, And I know that much of what has been said here is so far from the truth it is insulting.

Can you please expand on what elements you would use to differentiate between
^• a male presenting as a male who was sexually assaulted
and^
^• a male presenting as a woman who was sexually assaulted
when it comes to including or excluding them from groups providing support for people who were sexually assaulted^

In my case neither would be invited to the groups we have run for decades.

The male presenting as a male would be sent to A N Other organisation who specifically cater for male victims. It is very small and, as it doesn't draw a lot of funding, we allocate some to them every year - yes, it helps us with our diveristy issues. But we did this before we were challenged so, meh!

The transwoman would be too. Mainly because that group has all the signposting, partnerships, trained staff, medical advice etc aimed at helping male rape victims. And they have transgender sessions.

Once, just once, we have had a transwoman insist on using the womens service. We refused. We asked the cohort of women already in service and they said no. 100% of them said no. So we did not accommodate that person. The male service provider came and spoke to them and they went off to them.

After that we realised we had been lucky and my journey to try and reduce thepossible harm our being resolutely female could cause us.

So now we have a trans and non binary group session. Run in a different buidling, open to anyone who wants to come in and discuss their issues, man, woman, trans, non binary, anyone, everyone. Obviously it is a completely different kind of group, but it has cost us a bloody fortune to set up and, perhaps not surprisingly, is not all that well attended. We may have to close it next year, after collecting all possible proof that we tried really hard to keep it going - and yes, we will inevitably lose funding over and above what was allocated to it.

And we are not unusual in all we have done or been challenged with. 2 other organisations in this county and 3 from nearby have had the same. We are tiny grass roots entities that have been too small for notice for decades.

Long may that continue!

That sounds great, good for you guys that's good work and I'm sure it was appreciated by those that did attend!
HoardingSamphireSaurus · 08/12/2021 20:26

@SolasAnla That was me. I do work for a crisis centre/refuge.

Stompy has mistaken which poster was being repsonded to!

AnyFucker · 08/12/2021 20:26

and therefore do not have penises

So what ? Still a man. Like I am still a woman if I have a hysterectomy.

RedToothBrush · 08/12/2021 20:25

Validating a transwomans womanhood is more important than recognising the source of a woman's trauma from a penis.

I think we've all got the message loud and clear by now.

Women are undeserving of a service which recognises their trauma, things that trigger their trauma and any potential issues over their religious beliefs.

Meanwhile transwomen who have a trans group they can use, should have their identity validated without anyone complaints.

Even though the physical form of women and transwomen is different. As are the power and control dynamics at play.

Transwomen need specialist services as a result of their unique oppression social status but women dont. Is that because their abuse is more simplistic or lesser or something? Or just because they matter less than males?

Sorry but its very easy to see through how males get gold star service whereas women are supposed to put up with a lesser service because they are the wrong sex.

We see through this shit and are calling it out.

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 08/12/2021 20:23

If I worked for the organisation and it was my role to do so then I would

As I have said, I do. I can, And I know that much of what has been said here is so far from the truth it is insulting.

Can you please expand on what elements you would use to differentiate between
^• a male presenting as a male who was sexually assaulted
and^
^• a male presenting as a woman who was sexually assaulted
when it comes to including or excluding them from groups providing support for people who were sexually assaulted^

In my case neither would be invited to the groups we have run for decades.

The male presenting as a male would be sent to A N Other organisation who specifically cater for male victims. It is very small and, as it doesn't draw a lot of funding, we allocate some to them every year - yes, it helps us with our diveristy issues. But we did this before we were challenged so, meh!

The transwoman would be too. Mainly because that group has all the signposting, partnerships, trained staff, medical advice etc aimed at helping male rape victims. And they have transgender sessions.

Once, just once, we have had a transwoman insist on using the womens service. We refused. We asked the cohort of women already in service and they said no. 100% of them said no. So we did not accommodate that person. The male service provider came and spoke to them and they went off to them.

After that we realised we had been lucky and my journey to try and reduce thepossible harm our being resolutely female could cause us.

So now we have a trans and non binary group session. Run in a different buidling, open to anyone who wants to come in and discuss their issues, man, woman, trans, non binary, anyone, everyone. Obviously it is a completely different kind of group, but it has cost us a bloody fortune to set up and, perhaps not surprisingly, is not all that well attended. We may have to close it next year, after collecting all possible proof that we tried really hard to keep it going - and yes, we will inevitably lose funding over and above what was allocated to it.

And we are not unusual in all we have done or been challenged with. 2 other organisations in this county and 3 from nearby have had the same. We are tiny grass roots entities that have been too small for notice for decades.

Long may that continue!

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/12/2021 20:19

Cis people are privileged in comparison to trans people

Again, in what sense are MTF trans people oppressed so their feelings should take precedence in relation to women, a traditionally oppressed group. Please evidence this.

we all know you can't

SolasAnla · 08/12/2021 20:18

@NeedsCharging

There is some line between male who has experienced sexual violence and another male who has also experienced sexual violence.

Whats the line?

That is the question is it not?

If gender is the gatekeeper for a service, the organisation should be transparent for how the decision making process is applied.

VestofAbsurdity · 08/12/2021 20:18

@urbanbuddha

That's just not accurate. Some trans women have had gender reassignment surgery and therefore do not have penises.

You'll get different responses to this here because MN is widely varied in its make-up. Speaking only for myself, I would not be disturbed by someone who had had gender reassignment surgery being present but that's far from the majority of transwomen though.

Figures available are that over 80% retain their fully functional male genitalia.

Secondly, how would you know whether or not they had had gender reassignment surgery?

Thirdly, are you really saying that a woman is merely a man without a penis? Seriously? There are no other differences?

ArabellaScott · 08/12/2021 20:18

Stompy, also, I wanted to say I really do appreciate you coming back to discuss your reasoning. It's very hard, as you can see from the poll, for most women to understand your point of view, so it's really good to get to ask questions and have them answered. Thank you for engaging.

ArabellaScott · 08/12/2021 20:16

A trans woman may need a space to explore issues regarding being trans as well as issues regarding being a woman. Just like a woman of colour might need a group to look at experiences of being a woman and experiences of being a person of colour

Okay. So why can't a woman have a space to explore issues regarding being a woman? I don't want to do that with a male present, however that male feels inside.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/12/2021 20:16

A trans woman is very different than a man turning up.

In what sense? Could you elaborate on the difference?

VestofAbsurdity · 08/12/2021 20:13

AnyFucker It is really concerning that someone with stompy’s views runs a MH support group

Stompythedinosaur I think you'll find most NHS employees support trans rights.

Which includes placing male paedophile rapist who stated they were a TW into a locked psychiatric ward with a woman, said male paedophile rapist who stated they were a TW then went on to rape the woman repeatedly and caused so much damage to the woman internally that said woman will never be able to have children. Said paedophile rapist is still claiming they are TW and as the mantra chanters would have it TWAW and that includes said person.

Said woman will not be able to access any rape support services that are not female only, so great inclusion, great kindness, great empathy. Full marks TWAW chanters - this is what you are condoning and supporting.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/12/2021 20:12

Stompy

So I guess you think the trans only group should be shut down, right? It's exclusionary.

Pixiedust138 · 08/12/2021 20:12

@urbanbuddha

That's just not accurate. Some trans women have had gender reassignment surgery and therefore do not have penises.

You'll get different responses to this here because MN is widely varied in its make-up. Speaking only for myself, I would not be disturbed by someone who had had gender reassignment surgery being present but that's far from the majority of transwomen though.

Oh absolutely. I'm just pointing out that some have had the surgery as person I was relying to implied that all trans women have penises which isn't the case.
HoardingSamphireSaurus · 08/12/2021 20:11

OMG! Where do I start?

Personally I haven't experienced what you have so I know know how you feel but more generally a group for rape survivors for instance isn't sex specific

So I have wasted 2 years of my volunteering life searching for, re-writing bids for funding for our single sex groups because TWO YEARS AGO the requirements changed. Until then single sex groups were fine and all we had run for just short of 30 years!

And then Stompy

I'll answer this one, though I'm just about done with being personally attacked for voicing views on a thread where several posters specifically asked for people to explain why they thought differently.

Oh! Did anyone promise to accept what you said without a word of reply?

A trans woman may need a space to explore issues regarding being trans as well as issues regarding being a woman. Just like a woman of colour might need a group to look at experiences of being a woman and experiences of being a person of colour.

Just stop! To compare the issues of a man vs. a woman with a black woman vs a woman is, as ever, ludicrous, insulting and nonsensical!

To claim trans women are privileged because they have to content with multiple different ways of being oppressed is ridiculous. It is appropriate for them to have additional support in my view.

Ah! So now you parrot back to me what I typed earlier. OK! Those differences are what require separate provision. An idea I asked you to contemplate much much further up thread!

But the op hasn't suggested any transwomen have attempted to exclude others from the group. Transwomen aren't excluding others by existing.

Erm... I think yopu will find that OP WAS excluded from that group purely because their was a man in it! And has been dropped by the service as a whole for saying so.

I would say that if an individual can't access group support alongside the other woman using the service then it is reasonable to offer 1:1 support as an alternative.

And you couldn't read the information about the 18 month waiting list?

Most services don't offer a cis only group for the same reason they don't offer white only groups, straight only groups or men only groups. Because private space is generally reserved for the oppressed group.

Just stop it. That is so bloody offensive and utterly incorrect. For decades female services have existed. Many women fought hard for them, paid for them, built them from the ground up. Your stupid, stupid vacuous twaddle is insulting to the many women who worked hard to get some kind of safe spaces and therpaapy for women who had been badly abused.

Oh, and cis is offensive to most here. Is on the list of terms MNHQ delete posts for. I feel marginally tempted to report your post, but only because someone targetted me earlier in the week for trying to speak clearly!

I suspect I have more lived experience in providing support to rape victims than the majority of posters on this thread.

Nope! You said you had some experience of running a mental health group. Have you completely forgotten that you have replied to my posts? You know, the ones where I explain where I volunteer, what I do and how long I have done it for? Or do you think that a specialised funding researcher just sits in a remote office and never meets staff or client groups?

I spend about 8 hours week in week out inside a refuge. I talk to the women and kids in there, Ask them what they need, what we could provide that would make their lives easier, listen to their stories. I was safeguarding officer in my previous job and have had a lot, and I mean a lot, of 'listening as a therapy' training - under many ridiculous names.

What do you do?

Besides deride a woman, the OP for speaking out about the additional trauma heaped upion her by a centre that is funded to help her.

Maybe direct some of your passion into helping rather that whatever this thread is

You must see just how poisonously vile that sounds!

And ONLY MALES can rape in England and Wales. Bar some extremely rare and very specific circumstances. It requires a penis. SO men, inclduing transwomen, are the only human beings who can rape. Which is why we, and most centres, also specifically serve women who have been sexually assaulted.

But hey! You'd know that had you ever actually helped provide succour and support for a woman who had been raped.

SolasAnla · 08/12/2021 20:09

@Stompythedinosaur
I have literally no idea why you'd imagine I'm obliged to write a policy document for you.
I never requested you do that.

For what?

You are the one arguing for the exclusion of some males from the service on the belief that a second group of males should be prioritised.

You are also arguing that females should be given less priority that this second group of males.

I am very curious at how you expect a service to classify these groups which are ranked in terms of the services they should be given.
As I said before it was a request to expand on what elements you would use to differentiate between clients.

I don't believe you are involved in running the Centre.
You must be mistaking me for another poster.
I never made any reference to any centre

urbanbuddha · 08/12/2021 20:09

That's just not accurate. Some trans women have had gender reassignment surgery and therefore do not have penises.

You'll get different responses to this here because MN is widely varied in its make-up. Speaking only for myself, I would not be disturbed by someone who had had gender reassignment surgery being present but that's far from the majority of transwomen though.

Helleofabore · 08/12/2021 20:08

That's just not accurate. Some trans women have had gender reassignment surgery and therefore do not have penises.

less than 5% apparently have their penises removed. And gender reassignment surgery can also merely refer to facial feminisation and breast enlargement (ie. cosmetic surgery).

In addition, as has been pointed out, there is absolutely no way to tell which male has a penis still vs one that does not. So, what are you suggesting pixie to ensure that only those without a penis is in the group?

And please also tell us why a female should be gaslit at a time when they are needing to have trust in the group they are with to help them deal with trauma?

Gaslighting females that they should question their instinct that a person is male? How does that benefit any female exactly?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/12/2021 20:07

YANBU. Obviously.

Pixiedust138 · 08/12/2021 20:01

@SolasAnla

Hi *@Pixiedust138*

As you views and Stompythedinosaur's views appear to align perhaps you can have start at writing the policy document to be used by the service?

Per the copied post below

@Stompythedinosaur you claim to have experience in running support groups.

If you actually do run a support group you will known that providers of services need written policy and procedures.

Your position is that it is appropriate to provide different services.

Can you please expand on what elements you would use to differentiate between
• a male presenting as a male who was sexually assaulted
and
• a male presenting as a woman who was sexually assaulted
when it comes to including or excluding them from groups providing support for people who were sexually assaulted

IMO having a policy of "Google it" would not be an acceptable work practice for any competent support group.

Thanks

If I worked for the organisation and it was my role to do so then I would. Neither applies to me. The OP was asking for different opinions, just giving mine. You don't have to agree with me.
Swipe left for the next trending thread