Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to have requested single sex rape crisis therapy?

564 replies

IamSarah · 08/12/2021 13:56

My local rape crisis centre offers a dedicated support group for trans and non-binary survivors and a women's group open to anyone who identifies as a woman.

After a male (presenting as male) turned up in the women's group I requested an additional group for women who were born women. This request was turned down and I was told that group support isn't for me. AIBU?

YABU: You shouldn't need an additional, exclusive group for biological women

YANBU: Under these circumstances, a single sex group just for biological women was a reasonable request

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
Helleofabore · 08/12/2021 20:47

Until legislation decides what the rules are going to be

The Act already has a provision for these scenarios. this is specifically listed as an example.

Why do you think that this requires further legislation?

It requires organisations to enact the legislation. And it requires funding that is based on the removal of this clause to be called out for being harmful to women. Because it is.

Pixiedust138 · 08/12/2021 20:47

@NeedsCharging

decisions to be made on a case by case basis and for women to be asked what their preference is

But women are not being asked. We are being told to accept it or leave women only spaces!

That I don't agree with.
PaleGreenGhost · 08/12/2021 20:47

At every fucking stage of this women are disadvantaged.

*more likely to be raped

*less likely to be able to fight off attacker
*chance of pregnancy
*socialised to feel shame & blame self
*potentially lifelong issues with being around males in vulnerable situations eg healthcare
*if hetero, potentially lifelong issues with intimacy
*if able to report to police, face re traumatising interviews and physical examinations
*if case gets to court, face having private life, personality and appearance torn apart, for a very low chance of conviction.

*And now, in 2021, the near impossibility of finding solace in single sex support (or single sex swimming, bookclubs, exercise classes, craft clubs, breastfeeding & maternity clubs - you name it, they've ALL been colonised).

Every single issue on this list is a problem created by males and the misogynist systems they have built.

I refuse to believe all transwomen support this disgusting degradation of women. Those of you who say transwomen need to do this to women are doing trans rights no favours at all by painting transwomen as selfish, out of control misogynists.

NeedsCharging · 08/12/2021 20:45

decisions to be made on a case by case basis and for women to be asked what their preference is

But women are not being asked. We are being told to accept it or leave women only spaces!

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 08/12/2021 20:45

@Helenluvsrob

I would ask if there are make only rape survivors groups ,
Yes, of course there are.

Do you also want to know who sets them up, who finds funding for them? Who ensures they get staffed, supported and continue to run?

Women who set up the female services.

Men start them off, may staff them, be the public face of them etc, But women like me do the funding work, the nitty gritty either directly or because we are asked to give our time and expertise as support in setting them up... and then we never bloody leave!

Not all of them obviously. But of the 4 I am directly aware of... I have supported 3 of them as far as funding and policy remits go. The organisation I work for supports 2 of them, financially and with training, and all of them have, or had, a woman from one of the womens services as board member for years.

Many men set up similar services. But there just aren't as many men willing to continue them in the long term, or come forward to use them. There are many studies into this and a lot of support waiting for when the need is clarified. far more good will than I have seen for expanding, or even maintaining, single sex female services.

To steal a thought - google it Smile

Survivors UK
National Male Survivors Helpline
Lost of local county level sevcies
Mankind and Men's Advice Line
Male - Rape Org

The government's Male Rape Support Fund kick started a lot of services.

And it is a very different kind of service to that for women.

RedToothBrush · 08/12/2021 20:45

@Ereshkigalangcleg

Rape and sexual assault are overwhelmingly sex based problems, which women and girls experience more. I'd like to see the wishes of most survivors (when research has been done) taken into account and a legal obligation for local authorities and government to fund a female only space as well as anything additional.
It would be dead interesting to do anonymous surveys for service users.

I think the fact no one asks service users and its people in privileged positions and lgbt lobby groups who are making the funding decisions in the absence of this thats telling in terms of oppression.

Pixiedust138 · 08/12/2021 20:45

@ArabellaScott you'll see from my comments above I'm in no way suggesting that the trans woman is priority over a cis woman.

Pixiedust138 · 08/12/2021 20:43

@Ereshkigalangcleg

Rape and sexual assault are overwhelmingly sex based problems, which women and girls experience more. I'd like to see the wishes of most survivors (when research has been done) taken into account and a legal obligation for local authorities and government to fund a female only space as well as anything additional.
This is such a difficult and emotive subject. It's going to depend who you have in the room and on their own views. Some women would feel extremely uncomfortable sharing a space with a trans woman, other would feel differently. Until legislation decides what the rules are going to be then maybe the only fair option is for decisions to be made on a case by case basis and for women to be asked what their preference is?
Helleofabore · 08/12/2021 20:43

[quote Pixiedust138]@Helleofabore gender identity. That's the thing isn't it. If you ask a trans person what makes them a woman they will say that it's their gender identity rather than about their sexual organs. Sex is male or female. Gender identity is man, woman, trans, non binary etc.[/quote]
And Pixie, does 'gender identity' mean that that person has the same experiences as the opposite sex?

And you know that there are a small group of males who like to breach the boundaries, sex and other boundaries, of females. Or do you think that transitioning reduces this in any way?

Plus why is it that women need to give up their need for privacy away from males because one might say they are a woman?

ArabellaScott · 08/12/2021 20:42

[quote Pixiedust138]@Helleofabore gender identity. That's the thing isn't it. If you ask a trans person what makes them a woman they will say that it's their gender identity rather than about their sexual organs. Sex is male or female. Gender identity is man, woman, trans, non binary etc.[/quote]
Yes. 'Gender identity' is a feeling. 'Sex' is a fact.

ArabellaScott · 08/12/2021 20:41

@CombatBarbie

Wow, I don't understand anyone thinking that this wouldn't be an issue!!?? WTF so I'm guessing all men identifying as females can go to breastfeeding groups.....
It depends what the options are really doesn't it. If there is a trans group option available then that seems like the better fit but if it's the choice between a male group or a female group and you're a trans woman you'd probably want to opt for the female group because you believe you're a woman, not a man.

Yes, but why should one male's belief that they are a woman be taken seriously, but the women's belief that the transwoman is male not be taken seriously?

I mean, a transwoman can't be anything other than male, that's what the word 'transwoman' means. Someone born male. So this is quite simply one person's belief trumping the belief of another's.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/12/2021 20:38

Rape and sexual assault are overwhelmingly sex based problems, which women and girls experience more. I'd like to see the wishes of most survivors (when research has been done) taken into account and a legal obligation for local authorities and government to fund a female only space as well as anything additional.

Helleofabore · 08/12/2021 20:38

you're a trans woman you'd probably want to opt for the female group because you believe you're a woman, not a man.

So, if we changed the language to male only and female only group, that would mean those males would go to the male only groups if no trans groups were available?

Because, to repeat, we are constantly told that trans people are no longer denying their sex.

VestofAbsurdity · 08/12/2021 20:37

Also note that I have not mentioned any official request to explain what we do for transmen. Because we have never, ever been asked. Isn't that mad? We have never, as a single ex service, been asked how we cater for part of that cohort!

Transmen the group that rarely, if ever, gets mentioned or thought about reason being that they are of the female sex. Yet, those of the male sex always, always front and centre.

Pixiedust138 · 08/12/2021 20:37

@Helleofabore gender identity. That's the thing isn't it. If you ask a trans person what makes them a woman they will say that it's their gender identity rather than about their sexual organs. Sex is male or female. Gender identity is man, woman, trans, non binary etc.

Helleofabore · 08/12/2021 20:36

WTF so I'm guessing all men identifying as females can go to breastfeeding groups.....

Well... I hate to disappoint you. But that is a different thread altogether. But you might start with this thread.

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/4410394-La-Leche-League-are-consulting-to-remove-the-words-Womanly-Art-and-Breastfeeding-from-their-book-The-Womanly-Art-of-Breastfeeding

urbanbuddha · 08/12/2021 20:36

Figures available are that over 80% retain their fully functional male genitalia.

Secondly, how would you know whether or not they had had gender reassignment surgery?

Thirdly, are you really saying that a woman is merely a man without a penis?

I think there needs to be a much more nuanced discussion and debate around these questions. I am worried by the erosion of safe places and sports for girls particularly, but the either/or playground shouting will get us nowhere.

To answer your questions

i) I think it's more than 80% actually.

ii) I would expect the group leader to know and to have had confirmation from the hospital that performed the surgery. Or something equally rigourous.

iii) I don't think a person who has elected to

have surgery to remove their penis and to have female surgery can be counted as a man. I would see her as a woman.

I'm sorry I can't discuss this more fully just now but it's drinks at a neighbour's and I'm already late.

RedToothBrush · 08/12/2021 20:34

So I am wondering what are those transwomen gaining from a women (sex) only group? What shared experience do they have?

You mean other than power over women in the group and those excluded from the group or self excluded from the group.

Actively chosing a women's group over a trans one is an assertion of power. Often over the powerless.

Menofsteel · 08/12/2021 20:34

Glinner published an essay written by a recent rape victim about this. It was regarding Rape Crisis Scotland. Maybe the people who don’t get it on this thread should read it?

MrsTerryPratchett · 08/12/2021 20:33

@Ereshkigalangcleg

I've heard on the quiet that is often the policy, Samphire. They can't say it explicitly, mostly.
In the olden days, ten or more years ago, we had a few shelters. I worked in one which was mainly male with a female floor. Trans women were welcome on that floor. There was also a women's shelter. Women and trans men were welcome there but not trans women. Everyone was accommodated.

Now all the women's accommodations welcome trans women and there is nowhere for traumatised, abused women to go if they are triggered. I genuinely cannot see how that's MORE inclusive. Everyone had somewhere before. Now some vulnerable women don't.

I just don't understand it.

Pixiedust138 · 08/12/2021 20:33

@LostForIdeas

Although I do agree that they should join a trans group if there is one available. Not because I believe in excluding them but because other trans people are more likely to be able to have shared experiences with them so a trans group is likely to be a better option for that reason.

@Pixiedust138, yes I agree with that.
The life experience of transwomen will be vastly different the one women have.
They’ve had to go through gender reassignment which will have been traumatic.
The rape itself will have been physically different (assuming they still have their penis which the vast majority of them).
The physical consequences will be different.
And that’s wo going into the fact experiences, beliefs etc… around who they are will have been affected by their previous life as a man.

So I am wondering what are those transwomen gaining from a women (sex) only group? What shared experience do they have?

It depends what the options are really doesn't it. If there is a trans group option available then that seems like the better fit but if it's the choice between a male group or a female group and you're a trans woman you'd probably want to opt for the female group because you believe you're a woman, not a man.
LostForIdeas · 08/12/2021 20:33

@HoardingSamphireSaurus, thank you!

VestofAbsurdity · 08/12/2021 20:33

You should never have been challenged, Samphire, you should not have to jump through those extra hoops, you should not have your funding subject to such whims.

Single sex female only rape crisis and trauma services are the very example used in the Equality Act as services where the exclusion of all males is protected, it is not discriminatory or prejudiced to do so - the fucking Law states this.

CombatBarbie · 08/12/2021 20:33

Wow, I don't understand anyone thinking that this wouldn't be an issue!!?? WTF so I'm guessing all men identifying as females can go to breastfeeding groups.....

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 08/12/2021 20:32

It doesn't feel good at the moment @Pixiedust138 It feels precarious.

Having had this group, having supported the male service may well have been a very wrong move. Both could be used as leverage to prove we should be open to both sexes and all genders. Just as remaining single sex lost us funding anyway!

Its a can of worms I can't get my head round. But the official letters telling us bluntly that we should accept men, cater for them within our single sex service have been alarming - note men. Not transwomen, men. That is how far some streaming funds have gone already!

Also note that I have not mentioned any official request to explain what we do for transmen. Because we have never, ever been asked. Isn't that mad? We have never, as a single ex service, been asked how we cater for part of that cohort!

We do, obviously. But nobody seems to care enough to ask about it!

Swipe left for the next trending thread