Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to have requested single sex rape crisis therapy?

564 replies

IamSarah · 08/12/2021 13:56

My local rape crisis centre offers a dedicated support group for trans and non-binary survivors and a women's group open to anyone who identifies as a woman.

After a male (presenting as male) turned up in the women's group I requested an additional group for women who were born women. This request was turned down and I was told that group support isn't for me. AIBU?

YABU: You shouldn't need an additional, exclusive group for biological women

YANBU: Under these circumstances, a single sex group just for biological women was a reasonable request

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
ShrillSiren · 08/12/2021 23:35

@SweetPetrichor

YABU for starting another thread. We’ve had this topic already.
Did you ever think you'd be telling a rape victim that she's talking about her trauma too much?

Bet you still think you're one if the good guys though?
Hint: you're not.

Feelingoktoday · 08/12/2021 23:32

@Midlifemusings

Why is everyone focused on trans? The scenario here is a man presenting as a man. Men can also be victims of rape.

Men and women can also be victimized by a same sex attacker / perpetrator. Not all women who are raped have the same physical experience.

OP doesn't mention a men's group so it sounds like perhaps someone suggested he attend the women's group? I agree that could be uncomfortable for everyone but a very different issue than being trans. Sounds like they need a men's group as well so that those who want a single-sex group can all access service.

Rape centres were set up and initially funded by women. They filled on the grant forms, set the care up blah blah. How about men set up their own rape centres?
Overthinkingx3 · 08/12/2021 23:30

In Scotland amd Canada - there are currently cases whereby rape crisis support is run by transgendered people … anyone who doesn’t want that support, and prefers natal women to provide it is told they are prejudiced and need to leave …

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/12/2021 23:28

I completely agree.

VestofAbsurdity · 08/12/2021 23:26

@Ereshkigalangcleg

Exactly. There is a problem with women setting boundaries around males, and that is in itself a red flag.
Yes, and those enabling males to break those boundaries are red flags too.
Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/12/2021 23:20

Exactly. There is a problem with women setting boundaries around males, and that is in itself a red flag.

Hapoydayz · 08/12/2021 23:16

My god how are women expected to put up with this. This is horrifyingly. The type of ex man who would expect to be in this type of group is exactly the type of predator that needs to be kept out.

EricCartmansUnderpants · 08/12/2021 23:13

Males should not be in rape survivor groups for women. Even if they identify as women, they're not women. But, just like changing rooms, toilets, they know that they shouldn't be there. But there's a thrill in being there anyway. And women not being able to stop that from happening makes it more exciting. So the only choices women and teen girls will have have is to put up with it or self exclude themselves and not get the support they should have. I can see at that centre they already have groups for transwomen so there is already a service in place for them. But that won't be enough. It's about time these organisations started centering women as part of their recovery, rather than using them as a validation tool for certain types of males.

ArrrMeHearties · 08/12/2021 23:12

I genuinely can't believe that some posters think you are being unreasonable to want a therapy session that is solely for women. The mind boggles

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/12/2021 23:12

Good point DdraigGoch, people who claim to do good should not be using some of the most vulnerable people in society to push their political agenda.

Carpetssss · 08/12/2021 23:06

Yanbu and if and when you are able to legally challenge this centre for excluding you and other women who are unable to use a mixed sex group and are not offered a single sex option, please come and tell us about it. I will support you however I can.

DdraigGoch · 08/12/2021 23:00

I suspect I have more lived experience in providing support to rape victims than the majority of posters on this thread.
Which says a lot @Stompythedinosaur, though not in the way you had intended. No wonder services are in such a state.

blackcurrantjam · 08/12/2021 22:40

Yanbu

DdraigGoch · 08/12/2021 22:38

A trans woman is very different than a man turning up.

But this was a transwoman. They may have looked like a man and talked like a man, but merely by uttering the words "I am a woman", Stonewall count them as a transwoman.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/12/2021 22:37

I mean, what if we put these female untouchables in a shed somewhere a few miles away from the centre and they met only at three am in the morning so as not to upset anyone? What if we make them go barefoot and ring a bell chanting unclean as they meet?

Might these TW and their allies grant those female rape victims just a tiny fragment of access to help and support then? Pretty please?

No, they wouldn't.

Flapjak · 08/12/2021 22:28

I think you will find @stompydinosaur that many NHS employees do know what a male and a female is, they just know they cant state it too publicly because of Stonewall. Similarly i think most people want single sex wards for privacy and dignity and safety.

ForbiddentoForbid · 08/12/2021 22:23

I'd have no problem sharing spaces with transmen aka biological women.

No problem at all.

Biological women account for a tiny minority (I believe approx 96%) of sexual or violent crimes.

Biological men (including transwomen) account for the vast majority of sex crimes.

That's the problem I have.

And you can tell a transwomen from a woman.

DrBlackbird · 08/12/2021 22:14

ii) I would expect the group leader to know and to have had confirmation from the hospital that performed the surgery. Or something equally rigourous

But how does this square with the mantra that what’s in someone’s pants is none of our business?

IamSarah · 08/12/2021 22:07

Isn't it technically indirect discrimination on the basis of sex? When put down in this way it does make it easier to see.

Yep. I do have lawyers looking at this.

OP posts:
RedToothBrush · 08/12/2021 22:05

@Artichokeleaves

TW users had three separate choices of provision.

Male only
Trans only
Mixed sex women's.

Three.

Female service users get only the mixed sex option.

Females who cannot access any of those options? Get nothing.

There is no way to make this ok. To add a group for females who need it to access help in no way takes anything away or affects the TW service users . They continue to have their three provisions over female users' much lesser offer. They continue to have their full range of choice. To refuse to permit female people's needs to be met even when it in no way affects or harms their much better quality provision?

It's sheer dog in the manger. It's absolute indefensible intolerance. It's just sheer misogyny. These are women's services that now are inaccessible to many women.

Isn't it technically indirect discrimination on the basis of sex? When put down in this way it does make it easier to see.
Redshoeblueshoe · 08/12/2021 22:04

Artichoke - you know that women are not allowed anything for themselves any more.
Sarah you are not annoying us. You are showing people the reality of what's happening.
Is this the world we want for our daughters ?

Artichokeleaves · 08/12/2021 22:04

I think those accusing them at this point have no remaining leg to stand on.

When it's no skin off your nose at all, and you have way better provision, all the provision, all the choices, all the centering,

what kind of an intolerant, heartless bigot do you have to be to insist that raped women must not have anything at all because you don't want them to?

2319inprogress · 08/12/2021 22:03

Someone was wondering about user's opinions on mixed sex v.s single sex services - there's some good stuff here albeit a bit dated now
mobile.twitter.com/caithness_pf/status/1102931852212559872

"99% (of the 297 women-only service users and providers asked) value women-only services"

[& HoardingSamphireSaurus 🍻 to you & all the other unsung women fighting to keep these services going]

VestofAbsurdity · 08/12/2021 22:00

Doubt it Artichokeleaves, they'd probably be accused of weaponising their trauma and making an unseemly fuss.

Artichokeleaves · 08/12/2021 21:52

I mean, what if we put these female untouchables in a shed somewhere a few miles away from the centre and they met only at three am in the morning so as not to upset anyone? What if we make them go barefoot and ring a bell chanting unclean as they meet?

Might these TW and their allies grant those female rape victims just a tiny fragment of access to help and support then? Pretty please?