Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to have requested single sex rape crisis therapy?

564 replies

IamSarah · 08/12/2021 13:56

My local rape crisis centre offers a dedicated support group for trans and non-binary survivors and a women's group open to anyone who identifies as a woman.

After a male (presenting as male) turned up in the women's group I requested an additional group for women who were born women. This request was turned down and I was told that group support isn't for me. AIBU?

YABU: You shouldn't need an additional, exclusive group for biological women

YANBU: Under these circumstances, a single sex group just for biological women was a reasonable request

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
14
DrBlackbird · 12/12/2021 22:03

Rationalising that women (e.g. from minority groups who are also very vulnerable due to cultural views on "honor" etc) would self exclude is an acceptable cost their inclusion policy is a very fixed mindset

Yes. I’ve found work colleagues, intelligent ‘feminist’ women, are completely resistant to thinking about this issue in any way than we must all be inclusive at all times and in all places (even if it means excluding some women). I just can’t fathom it.

SolasAnla · 12/12/2021 13:09

ArabellaScott
Some people do still try to insist that Mumsnet is an outlier, not reflective of the vast majority of people.

I can't help but think that is an opinion often coming from people who don't count women as people ...

Of course your use of the word people would be turned back on you, claiming you don't recognise women as people, that a people's service is therefore exactly the same as woman's service.

Hont1986
The old racist trope.

Are we discussing economic migration in the City of eye watering salary and bonus or those working on the margins in low paid jobs?

Or implying that an Afghan, Polish, or Sudanese woman is different to a British /Welsh /Scotish /Irish woman.
Because these UK women can only be White?
Because these White women are all racist for failing to condemn the idea than a male (with or without penis) free space can help a women heal?

The immigration argument is so interesting.

Clearly the well educated financial secure economic migrant can afford to self fund their own legal entry, securing work permits, accommodation etc. The ability to access education and family wealth can be dependant on the culture of the original country. Should we examine if women tend to be under represented due to socioeconomic factors?
Where are all the single women traveling on their own with no education, no money, no family support originally from?
Would there be any reason why daughters from economic disadvantaged homes in Afghanistan are not following their brothers example and traveling to the UK for a better life?

On arrival should all those seeking asylum be treated as a homogeneous group,
be housed in mixed sex accommodations, with no provision for cultural nuance?

Could some of them also need services to recover from sexual assaults?
Would it still be racist if a foreigner asks for a single sex service?

IamSarah I suspect the polls will not matter to the managers of the service when they know their inclusion of males exclude women.
Rationalising that women (e.g. from minority groups who are also very vulnerable due to cultural views on "honor" etc) would self exclude is an acceptable cost of their inclusion policy is a very fixed mindset.

OhWhyNot · 12/12/2021 12:46

I’ve never ever known MN to get things right politically. Never

Boris Johnson has been about to resign many times in the last few years … a clock is correct twice a day

Ereshkigalangcleg · 12/12/2021 12:27

What are you trying to imply here? That the Daily Mail readers' views are irrelevant and should be ignored?

Hate to break it to this poster, but Daily Mail readers are in many of the positions of local and national influence as it is a popular newspaper, and MN is also a better barometer of the national mood on many topics than Twitter.

Artichokeleaves · 12/12/2021 12:19

Considering this affects half the voters of the UK in an already misogynistic, negative manner and does really require of them accepting subordination to males and being vanished in law/being stripped of existing rights to give males more -

this damn well should be the subject of a referendum. With both sides freely debating and setting out their stalls before hand. Without one side frantically trying to gag the other and tie its hands behind its back to avoid the general public knowing the realities of what they're being signed up to until it's (hopefully) too late.

Of course this also banks on female humans just going along with it instead of getting exceptionally pissed off, digging their heels in and refusing to enable this utopia for others at their own expense.

PaleGreenGhost · 12/12/2021 12:08

Daily Mail readers AND Donald Trump believe in gravity. Suggest we all jump off a cliff together to show we're not racist!

Am I socialisting right?

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 12/12/2021 11:34

I polled the Daily Mail comments section and it showed overwhelming support for ending immigration, how do I inform the government about this?

What are you trying to imply here? That the Daily Mail readers' views are irrelevant and should be ignored?

Have fun explaining this to the government, because they are well aware that many people are opposed to immigration. Did you miss the EU referendum, and the 51:49 ratio in favour of leaving the EU?

I am very certain that a referendum would reach a far more decisive result if the UK populace were asked whether women and girls raped by men should be able to access single sex group rape support without the presence of men or males who didn't identify as men. I think you'd find men voting such a proposal down, too!

So, you don't value the opinions of female rape survivors.

You don't value the democratic will of the people if it disagrees with you!

You don't seem to value reasoning.

What does guide you?

IamSarah · 12/12/2021 11:25

Thank you Hont and Artichokeleaves for confirming I'm not being unreasonable.

But what you mean is that female people, wanting access to needed resources - and you're talking about women who have been rape victims here, let's remember that part - are unpleasant, racist fools who should be ignored by their betters. For wanting access as well as males, and in their crisis following their rape, not serving the interests of male people. Who do not care about them, their needs, their inclusions, and apparently have no values of any kind.

OP posts:
YouSetTheTone · 12/12/2021 10:50

Hont1986
I polled the Daily Mail comments section and it showed overwhelming support for ending immigration, how do I inform the government about this?

I think you’ll find the government acted on this when the majority vote for Brexit was taken forwards. Funnily enough the (narrow) majority margin was considered important then.
Don’t you consider how the majority feel about supporting female victims of rape is important? If not, why not?

Helleofabore · 12/12/2021 10:34

I think you have covered it Artichokeleaves. You are very kind to have done so.

Artichokeleaves · 12/12/2021 10:32

@Hont1986

I polled the Daily Mail comments section and it showed overwhelming support for ending immigration, how do I inform the government about this?
Well I'd write to your MP. If you were seriously interested.

But what you mean is that female people, wanting access to needed resources - and you're talking about women who have been rape victims here, let's remember that part - are unpleasant, racist fools who should be ignored by their betters. For wanting access as well as males, and in their crisis following their rape, not serving the interests of male people. Who do not care about them, their needs, their inclusions, and apparently have no values of any kind.

That says a very great deal about what you think of women, and illustrates very well what is rotten at the heart of this situation. And why making women's services a mixed sex thing will never be able to work. (clue: it won't be because of the females using it.)

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 12/12/2021 10:25

@Hont1986

I polled the Daily Mail comments section and it showed overwhelming support for ending immigration, how do I inform the government about this?
How tiresome.

And how restricting? Just imagine having to always think in outdated and / or debunked tropes.

Try critical thinking, Hont You might surprise yourself and like it!

lifeturnsonadime · 12/12/2021 10:16

I also hope Hont carries on posting. They are showing the TRA anti woman agenda for exactly what it is.

IamSarah · 12/12/2021 09:58

@Hont1986

I polled the Daily Mail comments section and it showed overwhelming support for ending immigration, how do I inform the government about this?
Good for you. My research had nothing to do with Daily Mail comments so not sure why that's relevant.
OP posts:
Helleofabore · 12/12/2021 09:57

@Hont1986

I polled the Daily Mail comments section and it showed overwhelming support for ending immigration, how do I inform the government about this?
This is tired old trope and your comparison has been debunked so often on MN. It is incredibly offensive.

Please do keep posting though, because people reading posts like this see the lack of critical thinking that goes into them. It certainly isn’t the clever ‘gotcha’ you think.

Hont1986 · 12/12/2021 09:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

IamSarah · 12/12/2021 09:39

I've had nearly 3,000 votes now across here and Twitter.

Overwhelmingly people support my request for a female only group.

I'm wondering whether to approach the centre one last time comparing the 'evidence' the CEO submitted in parliament in January (saying trans women should be actively encouraged into women's only spaces) with the results of my polling? Giving the centre one last opportunity to put it right.

Or whether to stop trying to engage with them and pursue the legal challenge.

Hmmm.

AIBU to have requested single sex rape crisis therapy?
AIBU to have requested single sex rape crisis therapy?
OP posts:
DdraigGoch · 11/12/2021 14:43

I currently feel more angry and upset with them than my perpetrators which I know is irrational.
It's perfectly rational. The perpetrators didn't stab you in the back.

Throckmorton · 11/12/2021 14:24

Ignore that second post - I thought my first post hasn't posted.

Throckmorton · 11/12/2021 14:23

We should probably stop colluding in all that, and refer instead to transgender people

Artichokeleaves · 11/12/2021 14:10

Another pernicious aspect of this: females are forced to collude in their own oppression to quite an extent, in order to be permitted to discuss it at all. If they do not so collude they may not speak at all.

This is not an equal burden by any means.

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 11/12/2021 13:54

@Throckmorton

So why are we colluding with it in calling people transwomen and transmen? Why not just transgender person?
Here? In part because of the terminology that is and is not allowed by MNHQ.

In real life? I am self employed and work with charitable organizations that might be affected. It's taken me about 10 years to type here that the volunteer work I do is not only in a food bank. I wanted to prevent any fallout.

It pervades network meetings and groups and is just bloody everywhere!

ArabellaScott · 11/12/2021 13:19

@Throckmorton

So why are we colluding with it in calling people transwomen and transmen? Why not just transgender person?
These two groups are, obviously, very different. Despite everything, most people understand we do still need to differentiate by sex.
ArabellaScott · 11/12/2021 13:18

@Helleofabore

I would like to commend IamSarah for starting this thread. 2000 votes and still 3% disagree. But 97% agree.

I have noticed in general lately that the narrative pushed, even 6 months ago on this AiBU board, of ‘you are all just extremists and not representative at all of the mainstream view’ has almost disappeared. It must be very hard for some people to realise that they, themselves, are the minority but cannot use that projection of old anymore to validate their own extreme point of view.

Thank again for your bravery Sarah. What you will achieve hopefully, is a system that provides better care (suited to group’s needs) for all.

Some people do still try to insist that Mumsnet is an outlier, not reflective of the vast majority of people.

I can't help but think that is an opinion often coming from people who don't count women as people ...

Throckmorton · 11/12/2021 13:18

So why are we colluding with it in calling people transwomen and transmen? Why not just transgender person?

Swipe left for the next trending thread