Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Labour are shite. Discuss

183 replies

Effibreast · 08/12/2021 13:52

Stock answer to defend the tories is 'Labour are shite, Keir Starmer is rubbish, there's no opposition'.

OP posts:
Forion · 08/12/2021 16:17

I'm not claiming that Labour can't be mixed or are there just to represent the downtrodden, but the class divisions in this country are getting worse and it's blighting peoples lives. I want to see a fairer society where workers can afford heating whilst they work from home, a safe delivery of their baby and trains that are affordable and reliable buses. Instead, we're all fighting like rats in a sack over GP appointments. I also want womens rights and single sex spaces upheld and young peoples bodies protected from hormone blockers and life changing surgeries because they'll get to 30 and totally regret their previous choices, but it'll be too late. And I don't want rapists in female prisons.

Labour can't manage this, so I'm out.

AliveAndSleeping · 08/12/2021 16:17

@lazylinguist

Stock answer to defend the tories is 'Labour are shite, Keir Starmer is rubbish, there's no opposition'.

Lots of the people who are saying that Labour and Keir Starmer are rubbish aren't defending the Tories at all though. Many of them loathe the Tories, and the reason they are so furious about Labour being shit is that they desperately want to be able to vote for a Labour party that isn't shit. I won't vote Tory, but I won't vote Labour (or Lib Dem) either. I'll be spoiling my ballot paper for the first time.

You could vote for the green party if that's an option Smile
girlmom21 · 08/12/2021 16:16

IMO Kier is good at pointing out other peoples mistakes but struggles to explain what he'd do differently or better.

He doesn't seem to have any passionate views which doesn't bode well in a leader.

lazylinguist · 08/12/2021 16:14

Stock answer to defend the tories is 'Labour are shite, Keir Starmer is rubbish, there's no opposition'.

Lots of the people who are saying that Labour and Keir Starmer are rubbish aren't defending the Tories at all though. Many of them loathe the Tories, and the reason they are so furious about Labour being shit is that they desperately want to be able to vote for a Labour party that isn't shit. I won't vote Tory, but I won't vote Labour (or Lib Dem) either. I'll be spoiling my ballot paper for the first time.

DerTrotzkopf · 08/12/2021 16:11

Who said labour supporters wanted the government to support them ?
So we are all benefit scroungers
then ? How can a party full of middle class educated liberal lefty professionals be at the same time full of benefit claiming layabouts who can’t support themselves ? Confused make your mind up

DerTrotzkopf · 08/12/2021 16:04

@Forion well give us an idea what you want ? Corbyn 70s dinosaur steeped in Socialism didn’t win any elections, ridiculed by most but a minority. Blair blue labour, won 3 elections, many progressive policies like minimum wage etc. What do you want labour to be ? It can’t be what it used to be because the industrial unionised working class doesn’t really exist. People are aspirational, see tories as representing that. Labour can’t just represent the downtrodden. And as far as I know the Tory party has members of all types, poshos, salt of the earth w/c and m/c too. Why can’t labour have a mix ? What on earth is wrong with having educated mc types, idealistic youth and aspirational wc and the left behinds. Fwiw I’m as wc as they come. Live in a red wall area.

DramaLlllama · 08/12/2021 16:04

I won’t vote labour because I will be worse off under their government. Simple as that. My taxes will rise. I will have to pay 20% more for my childrens education (because I had to pull her out of her state school due to her being inadequately taught). And plus I’m more in line with the centre right ethos of working for a living as opposed to the government doing everything for you.

Do I like Boris? No. I think he’s a bit crap and needs to resign. Do I think labour would have steered us better through this pandemic? No. I think whoever was in charge would have struggled to steer the country through this pandemic.

But I will vote for reasons of which governement party would serve my needs best. As I’m sure every single person in this country would.

vodkaredbullgirl · 08/12/2021 15:33
Hmm
Forion · 08/12/2021 15:32

Oh and @Effibreast I come from Newcastle, I'm in my 50s. I absorbed socialism along with my baby food and Labour aren't the party I recognise any longer. They are indeed a shower o' shite.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 08/12/2021 15:30

@PronounssheRa

Id vote for a pig if it was wearing a red rosette.

It's much like that where I live. As a consequence Labour neglect the city and engage in some very questionable behaviour because they know they will remain in power regardless, and the tories neglect the city because there is nothing to play for.

Which is a function of our shit electoral system
PronounssheRa · 08/12/2021 15:28

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/4360464-Labours-batshit-opinions-on-womens-rights

Things Labour MPs have said around the issue of womens rights in just the last few months. They don't need a manifesto for us to understand where their priorities are.

Forion · 08/12/2021 15:22

@Effibreast you've not heard that Labour believe in men turning into women and demanding lesbians have sex with them?

Skeumorph · 08/12/2021 15:17

‘Discuss’

🖕🏻

girlmom21 · 08/12/2021 15:17

Did you know there are more than 2 political parties?

MorningStarling · 08/12/2021 15:16

Labour are shite. That's pretty much the end of discussion right there, but there are lots of reasons why.

  1. They can't elect an electable leader. Either they don't have any electable leaders or their voters are idiots.
  2. They're massive hypocrites. For everything the Tories do wrong, there is something on the Labour side that is just as bad. Tories have second jobs, people elected as Labour MPs have to be expelled for being convicted of harassment. The fact they expel MPs doesn't wipe the slate clean - their selection procedure must be appalling for them to have been elected in the first place.
  3. Tony Blair did more damage to the country than any PM before or since. It's hard to forget shit like that.
  4. Leadership again. Sir Kier Starmer does not come across well AT ALL. Labour is supposed to be for ordinary people, not knights of the realm or hotshot lawyers.
  5. Jess Phillips, Dianne Abbott - the Labour MPs you recognize come across as deeply unpleasant people. The deputy leader repeatedly calls her opponents scum. They don't seem like reasonable people. At least the Tories are polite to you and just shaft you behind your back. Labour look like they want to kick the shit out of you.
  6. Iraq war.
  7. Antisemitism.
  8. Labour scrapped student loans and introduced tuition fees.
  9. What are their actual policies? I mean, Corbyn was hard left, but what does Starmer actually propose to do? He is always wise after the event but never puts forward constructive, workable plans. You might say "they're opposition innit" but if they want to be elected they simply have to demonstrate how they would run the country better - how can we have all the services we need properly funded without tax hikes or borrowing.
  10. The constant focus on distractions and irrelevancies. Barnard Castle, lockdown party, who paid for redecorating - none of these things matter in the grand scheme of things. Constantly harping on about them just shows that Labour are unable to pick valid faults in the things that really matter.
  11. Today at PMQs Starmer was trying to imply that the Tories laugh at Covid patients dying. Either he's deliberately being rather sick and twisted, or he is so incompetent he doesn't realise how bad he looked.

To those who ask why "Labour are shite" is an acceptable answer to "how do you still support the Tories" there are two key points. One, you don't have to support the Tories to think they are the best of a terrible bunch. If the Tories are like someone shitting on your doorstep, Labour are like someone with diarrhoea doing it. I don't want either but ones easier to deal with. Two, it makes zero sense to argue people should vote Labour because the Tories are awful when not accepting that Tories persist in voting Tory because Labour are terrible.

Unsure1983 · 08/12/2021 15:11

Thangam Debbonaire. What a fantastic name.

Effibreast · 08/12/2021 15:09

@SexyNeckbeard you don't know ? Look it up.
@Forion woke misogyny ? Bit of an oxymoron. If you are using the term woke pejoratively doubt you ever voted labour.
@PronounssheRa 80% of pit jobs lost under thatcher. Communities left to rot without doubt.

OP posts:
Nothinbut · 08/12/2021 15:09

@DrDinosaur

If they’re stupid enough to believe men can become women they’re too stupid to be trusted with running the country.
Yep. Also no idea what they stand for these days really, doesn't seem to be the working class, but also not for the vulnerable or the rich. Seem to slip into the background. Of course more integrity and no doubt would be better than the shitshow we have, but they need to remember what they're about.
PronounssheRa · 08/12/2021 15:08

Id vote for a pig if it was wearing a red rosette.

It's much like that where I live. As a consequence Labour neglect the city and engage in some very questionable behaviour because they know they will remain in power regardless, and the tories neglect the city because there is nothing to play for.

donquixotedelamancha · 08/12/2021 15:08

To counter the bs that labour are crap I suggested that Lisa Nandy as minister for levelling up is far superior to Gove.

I'm assuming you've not spent any time with Lisa Nandy? Gove has no clue about working people's lives but he's competent; from direct experience Nandy is only capable of paroting what she thinks is most popular.

That Starmer may be dull and sensible but is as honest and decent as Theresa May of John Major.

TM was arguably the worst PM this country has ever seen, you aren't really selling him.

I can't see me ever voting Tory and I certainly wouldn't defend the current cabinet but 'Labour- not as shit as you think' is not a slogan to win elections.

inmyslippers · 08/12/2021 15:06

UsernameInTheTown
Until Labour re learn what constitutes a woman they can fuck off. As can your 'discuss'.
Yep.

^^ here here

Warmduscher · 08/12/2021 15:05

@Effibreast

Evidence re w/c being despised by labour ? Just a cliched trope. That's the problem. Every thread ends up being the same old stuff.
OP, what’s your response to the many posts saying Labour despise women and Lisa Nandy was unable to say what a woman is when asked during the Labour leadership contest.

That’s 51% of the population Labour doesn’t give a shit about.

And I’m not voting Labour despite doing so all my life but neither am I voting Tory. I will probably spoil my ballot.

5128gap · 08/12/2021 15:04

I'd vote for a pig if it was wearing a red rosette. But lately I've reluctantly started to conclude that my main reason for doing so is because the Tories are shite.

Forion · 08/12/2021 15:00

Just because someone doesn't want to vote Labour doesn't mean they have to vote Tory. I'm a previous Labour voter, but I'll now have nothing to do with their woke misogyny. And they despise the working class and the WC know this hence the stalemate.

Until Labour realises who their core voter base is and learns to listen to and respect their views they'll get nowhere.

PronounssheRa · 08/12/2021 14:57

Who shut down whole industries, left the north to rot ?

I'm confused with this, your thread started out as a criticism of the current tory government but if you want to talk about mining, steel works etc you need to go back much further than the current gvt. For example Labour under Wilson closed more mines than thatcher.