Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Labour are shite. Discuss

183 replies

Effibreast · 08/12/2021 13:52

Stock answer to defend the tories is 'Labour are shite, Keir Starmer is rubbish, there's no opposition'.

OP posts:
Bunnyfuller · 08/12/2021 21:33

Fuck off, Putin

portandchocolate · 08/12/2021 21:33

Starmer as PM?

If he ever had to have an idea or a plan rather than just aimlessly criticise he'd not have a word to say.

He makes me wince.

JackieWeaverHandforthCouncil · 08/12/2021 21:28

I reached peak trans a couple of years ago and was swayed a lot by MN posters on how womens rights were being threatened by TRAs to the point I got into a massive argument one Christmas Day with my ‘right on’ DB and DH over it who accused me of being an anti trans bigot for expressing my concerns.

However, recently I’ve started to peel back the other way ironically also by MN. This is because not matter the topic, some posters have to turn it to a trans debate. It’s obsessive and is starting to feel very uncomfortable and sinister. There are some posters who will side with anyone or cause no matter how nasty if that person or cause is anti trans.

You have a government engaging in culture wars, putting minority lives under threat, ruining industries, cutting back welfare, large scale corruption . Things that statistically negatively impact women the most but none of this matters because ‘at least Boris knows what a woman is’.

These are the same type of voters like Susan Sarandon who refused to vote for Hilary because she wasn’t pro-woman enough, allowing Trump to win so he could pack the Supreme Court with anti-abortionist Gilead wannabes.

This bullshit does real damage to women not a few nutty TRAs which nobody in real life would mistake for women. No laws would ever be passed to erase women. I’m totally over this anti-trans shit. I can’t be the only one who’s changed their views and become more disturbed by the zealots on MN.

SexyNeckbeard · 08/12/2021 21:25

[quote Effibreast]**@FOJN* if you knew anything about the police, crime and sentencing bill and proposed backdoor amendments, you would be worried about the possible curtailment of everybody's* democratic right to protest with some of the most oppressive legislation since the war.[/quote]
www.gov.uk/government/publications/police-crime-sentencing-and-courts-bill-2021-factsheets/police-crime-sentencing-and-courts-bill-2021-protest-powers-factsheet

Which part of this is oppressive enough to draw your hyperbole?

Triphazards · 08/12/2021 21:25

So are Labour actually scum?

thecatfromjapan · 08/12/2021 21:22

ScreamingMeMe

Have you honestly not seen Labour people running this country down and calling it a racist shit hole. The vitriol towards the people of Hartlepool for daring to vote Conservative was something to behold. '

I think you have selective hearing.

You see, I hear people on the Right pulling this country down all the time.

Apparently we're 'overrun with immigrants', there are 'no go areas' in the U.K., 'all our politicians are lying sociopaths', our modern culture is shit, our cities are shit ...

I could go on.

And I always say: The U.K. has a proud history of democracy and tolerance - let's be proud of that and cherish if; our cities are world class and remarkably safe; our social and legal systems are remarkably free of corruption (you don't have to pay solicitors under the table when you buy a house; you don't have to pay a bung to the electrician or local dignitary to get connected to mains electricity) - I am bloody grateful for that, let's keep it that way; our universities are world-class ...

I could go on.

And, yes, there are people on the Left who run down the U.K.

But I'm not so blinded by ideology that I choose only to hear them.

And, similarly, I'm wise enough to know that the people on the Right continually spreading lies, misinformation and fear about the U.K. - running the U.K. down - aren't the only voices.

As I keep on saying, the reason Johnson grieves me so very, very, very much is precisely because I love the U.K. and I don't just believe, I know, we deserve better.

FOJN · 08/12/2021 21:08

FOJN if you knew anything about the police, crime and sentencing bill and proposed backdoor amendments, you would be worried about the possible curtailment of everybody's democratic right to protest with some of the most oppressive legislation since the war.

Is there a reason you think I don't know about this or are you indulging in a bit of whatabouttery?

I'd recommend writing to your MP or better yet meeting them in their constituency surgery to discuss your concerns. It doesn't matter if you don't like them and didn't vote for them, they work for you.

ScreamingMeMe · 08/12/2021 21:01

I'm not sure it's Labour who think 'you people are scum.

I've been called scum and a bigot a number of times by Labour party supporters, members and even local councillors. I was called "Tory scum" earlier today by another poster on here earlier today (and I'm not even a Tory!)

Have you honestly not seen Labour people running this country down and calling it a racist shit hole. The vitriol towards the people of Hartlepool for daring to vote Conservative was something to behold.

Granted, Labour MPs are a bit better behaved than those lower down the hierachy, but a number of them are quick to label people bigots for having different views. Or calling the Tories scum.

I think that a lot of this shitty attitude is down to Momentum. Momentum I think has had quite a large part to play in Labour's downfall - the angry, shouty, name-calling behaviour and the Identity Politics. I had hopes that Kier would sort them out, but he hasn't.

Effibreast · 08/12/2021 20:47

@FOJN if you knew anything about the police, crime and sentencing bill and proposed backdoor amendments, you would be worried about the possible curtailment of everybody's democratic right to protest with some of the most oppressive legislation since the war.

OP posts:
lazylinguist · 08/12/2021 20:45

Why does the green party not know what a woman is?

Your guess is as good as mine. After all, people have known what a woman is since the dawn of humankind, but apparently some people (including the Green Party, judging by their policies) have forgotten:

Trans rights
RR530 The Green Party recognises that there are many gender identities that are within, and outside of, the traditional gender binary of man and woman. The Green Party recognises that trans men are men, trans women are women, and that non-binary identities exist and are valid.

Charley50 · 08/12/2021 20:43

I am very unhappy with Labour's insistence that gender trumps biology; however I'm at the stage where I want it all out in the open now, so even more eyes are opened to this anti-women crap.

Baguettee · 08/12/2021 20:42

Labour seem to have a very tenuous grasp of Safeguarding, and if they can put out a MP saying in all seriousness that a male rapist belongs in women’s prison what next will they come out with.
Will we have a Labour MP coming out with paedophilia is a legitimate sexuality, and calling people bigots and dinosaurs for not accepting it.
They seem easily captured by any shiny new bandwagon regardless of what it means for women and children.

RepentMotherfucker · 08/12/2021 20:41

[quote Outlyingtrout]**@RepentMotherfucker* unless I've missed a post, @ilovesooty* hasn't actually said whether they support the Labour and gender ideology. This was the initial premise of the thread. That thinking Labour are a shower of shite is a defence of the Tories. In actual fact, Labour being a shower of shite has left many of us politically homeless. It's not an 'either or' situation. I don't have to support Labour or the Tories. I really hate the fact that voicing disapproval of Labour is interpreted to signal automatic support for the Tories, so I wouldn't assume the opposite for someone else.

Like @ilovesooty, I cannot make sense of people who reject Labour based on the way they have thrown women and children - and especially vulnerable women - under the bus, but who will vote Tory as an alternative. I don’t understand how you can care about vulnerable women when it’s Labour trampling all over them, but be prepared to vote for the Tories who do the same thing anyway just dressed up differently (and a whole lot more to disadvantage poor and vulnerable people besides).[/quote]
This is not his/her first rodeo @Outlyingtrout Wink

thecatfromjapan · 08/12/2021 20:40

And Rosie Duffield is Chair of the Women's Parliamentary Labour Party.

The issue is divisive. I'd like to see some stronger action taken in support of Rosie Duffield's right to speak.

But painting Lsbour as the most pressing threat to wimen's rights is way off.

RepentMotherfucker · 08/12/2021 20:39

Outs self! GrinGrinGrin

RainbowCrossing · 08/12/2021 20:38

@FOJN

If I even spoil it. I might just vote for my sitting Tory. And I would have categorically told you, even two years ago, that that would never happen.

I've spoilt my ballot at the last two elections (I did pop a woman: adult human female sticker on the last ballot) but I'm fed up of sitting it out so I may also vote Tory having never done so or thought I would.

RepentMotherfucker your username makes me laugh every time I see it.

Grin
RainbowCrossing · 08/12/2021 20:36

Why does the green party not know what a woman is?

It's a mystery alright.

thecatfromjapan · 08/12/2021 20:36

Labour has no pledge to change it's previous manifesto position on gender issues.

I don't know where this has come from.

It was the Conservatives who began the push to bring in the GRA, with a customary drive for popularity over due diligence.

The Labour Party has a lot of members who have a strong desire for radical change - and a very sensible leadership who know that the electorate, as a whole, don't want that change.

The manifesto position has, therefore, not been altered.

And I am willing to bet that if won't be.

🤷‍♀️

AliveAndSleeping · 08/12/2021 20:35

@lazylinguist

You could vote for the green party if that's an option Smile

Not unless they know what a woman is. And, as far as I'm aware, they don't. I actually joined the Green Party in order to be able to vote in their leadership election (and hopefully then be able to vote Green), but the candidate I wanted didn't get in.

Why does the green party not know what a woman is?
FOJN · 08/12/2021 20:31

I cannot make sense of people who reject Labour based on the way they have thrown women and children - and especially vulnerable women - under the bus, but who will vote Tory as an alternative.

I'm happy to explain why I'm thinking about voting Tory at the next election having never done so previously.

The legal distinction between men and women is central to women's rights existing. Those rights cease to exist in a meaningful way if anyone can identify as a woman but the realities of being born female will not change even if we claim to believe men can be women because the biology which leads to female oppression will remain the same. We will end up in a situation where women are as disadvantaged as they ever were but we will not have specific language to identify the source of the problem. If women's rights are eroded then children, by extension, will also be affected.

As long as the conservative party have put self ID on the back burner we have time to campaign for women's rights. We currently have an almost defacto self ID which means we can gather data about the impact on women to make an irrefutable and evidenced arguement for why it is a bad idea. It will be almost impossible to reverse if it is passed into law and therefore we need to keep any party, who supports self ID out of power, until a little common sense and consideration for women returns.

Do I like the conservative party? No
Am I prepared to watch womens rights be rolled back? No

My choice is about buying time to prevent a catastrophic reversal of women's rights.

thecatfromjapan · 08/12/2021 20:31

@ScreamingMeMe

Have a meme as well.
Hmm.

I'm not sure it's Labour who think 'you people are scum.'

And, for what it's worth, I don't think many members of any political Parties think the U.K. is awful and the people are scum.

I'm tired of these lazy jibes.

As I repeatedly say, I really like the U.K. I love the people I live with. I respect them.

And that is why - precisely why - Johnson actually causes me grief.

I think we deserve better.

Effibreast · 08/12/2021 20:29

@Outlyingtrout agree. I've actually said this before but you've said it better. Many of the worst tory policies hit poor wc women and their families the most like the loss of £20 universal credit or the loss of legal aid, cuts to public services. Tbf if you listen to people, esp women, on the radio today, they are condemning Johnson and the Tories. Former tory voters no longer many of them. No one is mentioning Labour's stance on trans issues.

OP posts:
Kendodd · 08/12/2021 20:28

I won’t vote labour because I will be worse off under their government. Simple as that. My taxes will rise. I will have to pay 20% more for my childrens education (because I had to pull her out of her state school due to her being inadequately taught)

What a shame the state schools are so shit under the Tories that you have to spend so much on private schooling.
Anyone with half a brain would vote them out so we can have better schools for our children. They're clearly doing a terrible job looking after education.

thecatfromjapan · 08/12/2021 20:24

For those saying Labour = more tax ... do they?

I'd say indirect taxes have risen under the Conservatives. For a start, we're paying for Brexit.

Real-terms investment in many things has been cut - so you end up supplementing depleted public services from your own income - often inadequately.

And social care will take your home.

The great thing about tax and a public sector is that the costs of things like health, education and social care are shared and end up being cheaper.

I suspect Labour will approach the next GE with a pledge to keep taxes low - and they'll be so worried about the electorate, they'll stick to that.

But investment will go into public services - not dodgy contracts to cronies. And I'll point out that those dodgy contracts have often been awarded because of a commitment to an ideology of privatisation over pragmatism, and a desperate desire to keep donors on board.

Outlyingtrout · 08/12/2021 20:15

@RepentMotherfucker unless I've missed a post, @ilovesooty hasn't actually said whether they support the Labour and gender ideology. This was the initial premise of the thread. That thinking Labour are a shower of shite is a defence of the Tories. In actual fact, Labour being a shower of shite has left many of us politically homeless. It's not an 'either or' situation. I don't have to support Labour or the Tories. I really hate the fact that voicing disapproval of Labour is interpreted to signal automatic support for the Tories, so I wouldn't assume the opposite for someone else.

Like @ilovesooty, I cannot make sense of people who reject Labour based on the way they have thrown women and children - and especially vulnerable women - under the bus, but who will vote Tory as an alternative. I don’t understand how you can care about vulnerable women when it’s Labour trampling all over them, but be prepared to vote for the Tories who do the same thing anyway just dressed up differently (and a whole lot more to disadvantage poor and vulnerable people besides).