Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Labour are shite. Discuss

183 replies

Effibreast · 08/12/2021 13:52

Stock answer to defend the tories is 'Labour are shite, Keir Starmer is rubbish, there's no opposition'.

OP posts:
thecatfromjapan · 08/12/2021 22:55

I honestly don't think Starmer is a buffoon.

And he's not in the same (terrible) class as Johnson.

I think most politicians are not in the same (awful) class as Johnson.

That is why I posted the link to Dominic Grieve. What Grieve is saying is incredibly important.

He says that Johnson traduces the role of Prime Minister and makes a travesty of government - and diminishes trust and respect.

This is absolutely my view.

I think Johnson is a corrosive toxin. He is profoundly damaging.

Most politicians - of all parties - are not like Johnson.

He is profoundly damaging.

I find it worrying when anyone would lump Starmer in with Johnson.

They are not alike.

Frankly, many Conservatives are nothing like Johnson.

I agree wholeheartedly with Grieve on this - he's a damaging, damaging class apart. He should never, ever have been allowed to become PM.

Anyway, if that sounds like, 'But the Tories ...', I'm sorry.

I don't mean, 'But the Tories ...'
I mean, 'Johnson is something quite damaging and different. It's a tragedy he became PM.'

Please don't judge all politicians by his standard. Many politicians, from all Parties, are radically different to Johnson.

And most are not 'buffoons'. They are often very qualified people. Many of whom are committed, dedicated and have acquired high levels in the fields they worked in before entering politics.
Which many of them entered because of a notion of public service.

That's true across the House.

And I find it bizarre that there is so very little respect for politicians.

It's a job that affects lives.

If you hold those people in so little regard, then enter politics yourself. Act to effect better.

I suspect contact with politicians and politics might change your perspective.

I find this cynicism, this willingness to trivialise, terribly, horribly corrosive.

I do feel Johnson has contributed to this - and I despair.

But politics is just far, far too important to allow judgment to evaporate in an all-encompassing cynicism. Or to mask a fundamental laziness as regards political knowledge and engagement behind a mask of ridicule.

It's damaging. And at its very worst, it ends with inviting violence against our MPs.

We have to change that culture. And that begins with very firmly distinguishing between those who behave with probity and seriousness when in office and those who don't - and saving our deepest opprobrium for those that don't act with the standards we deserve to see followed.

Effibreast · 08/12/2021 22:55

@SexyNeckbeard lefty propaganda ? Ok Hmm Monbiot explains it far better than I ever could. Why would I paraphrase it ? I agree with him.

OP posts:
portandchocolate · 08/12/2021 22:46

[quote Effibreast]@portandchocolate If he's a buffoon why would you cheer him on getting one over on Starmer ? A liar, cheat, spaffer of millions and you are thrilled by him showing Starmer up ? And your family criticise Starmer for doing his job...Hmm[/quote]
Because Starmer is as clueless and embarrassing. If for one incredible moment he actually had to make a decision or demonstrate the leadership he keeps bleating on about he'd run a mile

Maybe he could start by sorting out his deputy?

Effibreast · 08/12/2021 22:43

Lol thought not. Might be a tad more au fait with public opinion.

OP posts:
Effibreast · 08/12/2021 22:42

@portandchocolate If he's a buffoon why would you cheer him on getting one over on Starmer ? A liar, cheat, spaffer of millions and you are thrilled by him showing Starmer up ? And your family criticise Starmer for doing his job...Hmm

OP posts:
portandchocolate · 08/12/2021 22:39

[quote Effibreast]@portandchocolate listen to PMQs maybe ?[/quote]
Yep. Always. Thanks

SexyNeckbeard · 08/12/2021 22:38

So you really don't have any actual opinions of your own? When I ask you why, in your opinion, this is the most oppressive piece of legislation since "the war" you can't answer. I mean you said it, you should be able to explain why, right?

Just lapping up the lefty propaganda and spitting it straight back out on MN without an original thought of your own.

Effibreast · 08/12/2021 22:36

@portandchocolate listen to PMQs maybe ?

OP posts:
portandchocolate · 08/12/2021 22:35

[quote Effibreast]@portandchocolate he doesn't oppose everything. He's agreed with some things and been lambasted by the left for that. Again he's the opposition, it's his job. He also suggested things during lockdown which were later implemented but mocked by Johnson initially.
'I'd love boris to ask him wtf he'd do' oh yes good old competent 'Boris'. Says no one. Think we'll be waiting a while for that. Sadly you are pretty much alone in your 'love' for 'Boris' at the moment Grin[/quote]
Not sure how you leapt to the conclusion that I loved Boris.. he's a buffoon.

Sadly Starmer is too. 🤷‍♀️

thecatfromjapan · 08/12/2021 22:34

I was replying in depth to the poster who mentioned Momentum.

Plus I think it's important to talk about what happened with regard to the Conservative Party. It does, actually, matter.

People don't just think about Labour in a vacuum. There's an element of comparison going on.

More interestingly, I often wonder if, really, the point of threads like this should be about increasing awareness generally.

My feeling is that a lot of people who follow politics closely have changed their feelings about Labour. Quite a lot of those have switched for the reasons I've outlined above - they don't feel the Conservative Party is their Conservative Party any more.

And others quite like the changes they've seen the Labour Party making.

(And, of course, some former Labour supporters don't like the changes.)

But I sense that a lot of that finer detail hasn't worked its way into the mainstream yet.

Which is what you'd expect.

We live busy lives, with many demands. We often don't have time to follow politics in minute detail.

I'm quite sure most people missed Prime Minister's Questions - and that's to be expected.

And knowing the ins and outs of Labour's new front bench - that's also necessarily niche.

Anyway, I tend to read threads like this to discover things I didn't know and to share opinions.

Ultimately, this is a chat forum. Things we write and share here are unlikely to bring any radical change. So it's just nice to share and read information and opinions.

Hopefully, in a kind and thoughtful manner. 🤷‍♀️

Effibreast · 08/12/2021 22:33

Lol try George Monbiot but doubt you read the Guardian.

OP posts:
Effibreast · 08/12/2021 22:32

@portandchocolate he doesn't oppose everything. He's agreed with some things and been lambasted by the left for that. Again he's the opposition, it's his job. He also suggested things during lockdown which were later implemented but mocked by Johnson initially.
'I'd love boris to ask him wtf he'd do' oh yes good old competent 'Boris'. Says no one. Think we'll be waiting a while for that. Sadly you are pretty much alone in your 'love' for 'Boris' at the moment Grin

OP posts:
SexyNeckbeard · 08/12/2021 22:29

[quote Effibreast]@SexyNeckbeard read commentaries written by people independent of the government, not just copying and pasting stuff from Gov.uk Hmm[/quote]
I asked you to share what you've read so I could read it too and you couldn't be bothered. I'm not trawling round the Internet looking for stuff to back up YOUR argument, just because you don't have a clue what you're talking about.

And this is what it's like trying to drill down into what labour supporters think or what the argument is. I was genuinely interested in reading new information about the issue, I went off and looked for solid facts about what this bill is (including reading the bill itself), but reading facts isn't what I'm supposed to do. I'm supposed to look up people's opinions and swallow them as gospel like you have. No thanks.

You should try developing critical thinking skills, it'd probably serve you well

portandchocolate · 08/12/2021 22:26

[quote Kendodd]@portandchocolate
Actually Labour have been very supportive of Tory measures re covid.
Surely anyone who'd been paying attention would know that?[/quote]
In our house we all say.. 'And here we go with just the opposite' every time Starmer is about to open his mouth...

ilovesooty · 08/12/2021 22:24

This is not his/her first rodeo

What is that supposed to mean @RepentMotherfucker?

Kendodd · 08/12/2021 22:24

@portandchocolate
Actually Labour have been very supportive of Tory measures re covid.
Surely anyone who'd been paying attention would know that?

portandchocolate · 08/12/2021 22:21

Opposing everything makes him sound ridiculous. Like all he's there for is to say the opposite. If he offered a more balanced view then maybe he'd appear to have even the tiniest clue.

I'd love Boris to ask him wtf he'd do instead.

ScreamingMeMe · 08/12/2021 22:20

catfromjapan

You're doing "but the tories".

What's my 'idealogy'? I'm not a Tory and I don't think they're great either. But this is a thread about why Labour are (supposedly ) shite.

Effibreast · 08/12/2021 22:06

'aimlessly criticising' well he is supposed to oppose and yet others say he doesn't oppose enough.
I actually thought he played a blinder in pmqs today but doubt many on here listened to it.

OP posts:
Effibreast · 08/12/2021 22:03

@SexyNeckbeard read commentaries written by people independent of the government, not just copying and pasting stuff from Gov.uk Hmm

OP posts:
thecatfromjapan · 08/12/2021 21:51

You know, that whole Brexit period was ... strange. Both Labour and the Conservatives changed. Became more ideological.
But Labour are moving away from that.

The Conservatives really aren't. Not at the moment.

I think the Conservative Party is still in a kind of hostage situation to a minority who have taken it over.

I hope the more moderate members can get their Party back.

Here's Dominic Grieve. Suspect he was a member of the Conservative Party longer than Johnson and co. Arguably he and his ilk have more right to the Conservative Party than the new cuckoos in the nest.

twitter.com/ukiswitheu/status/1468648403601174541?s=21

Kendodd · 08/12/2021 21:48

Its absolutely laughable (if it wasn't so tragic and damaging) seeing the Tories as caring about womens rights.
How many women did Tory austerity kill? 70,000?
Have you seen the convicted rates for rape under the Tories? They might have well as legalised it through there cuts to the CPS and policing.
And as for male bodied people held in women's prisons and the huge increase in trans children. This has happened under the TORIES ffs.

Outlyingtrout · 08/12/2021 21:47

@FOJN that makes a lot of sense. Thank you for explaining. I don’t think I could “hold my nose” and vote Tory because I live in an area where the genuinely life-threatening impact of Tory policy on the poor and vulnerable is evident every single day. We also have an ongoing family situation which is a direct result of Tory policy and cuts. But I can understand your viewpoint and it’s something to think about.

What a fucking dismal choice to be faced with.

Dontgetyerknicksinatwist · 08/12/2021 21:42

I wouldn’t vote Labour because 1. Momentum. They have Starmer in as the “acceptable face” of the party but Momentum are still on the scene 2. I can’t accept Labours stance on identity politics. As a mum to a little girl I can’t vote for a party that does not uphold her right to safe space and identity as a woman.

worriedatthemoment · 08/12/2021 21:41

Well clearly they are hence why they haven't got in and many people won't vote for them regardless