Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Labour are shite. Discuss

183 replies

Effibreast · 08/12/2021 13:52

Stock answer to defend the tories is 'Labour are shite, Keir Starmer is rubbish, there's no opposition'.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RepentMotherfucker · 10/12/2021 15:29

@ilovesooty

I asked you that question because of the nature of your remarks. You answered it in the way that I expected. Hence my seeing little point in any further engagement with you.

Have a pleasant day.

You too, go well.
ilovesooty · 10/12/2021 12:45

I asked you that question because of the nature of your remarks. You answered it in the way that I expected. Hence my seeing little point in any further engagement with you.

Have a pleasant day.

RepentMotherfucker · 10/12/2021 12:21

@ilovesooty

I'm not prepared to engage in an argument *@RepentMotherfucker*.

I believe that Labour would be a far better option for the people of this country than this government which has consistently screwed over the most vulnerable, including women and children.
And women have not been protected or safeguarded by the Tories anyway.

I'm not arguing. I'm answering a question you asked me!
Flapjacker48 · 10/12/2021 11:04

Discuss this: Biscuit

ilovesooty · 10/12/2021 11:02

I'm not prepared to engage in an argument @RepentMotherfucker.

I believe that Labour would be a far better option for the people of this country than this government which has consistently screwed over the most vulnerable, including women and children.
And women have not been protected or safeguarded by the Tories anyway.

LakieLady · 10/12/2021 10:38

I'm diehard Labour and joined the party over 50 years ago and even I think they're a bit shite.

Starmer has done a bit better at calling the Tories to account over the last few weeks, but most of us could have done just as well, I reckon, given the scale of the latest Tory awfulness.

They've wasted too much energy on fighting their own members instead of fighting the Tories imo.

FOJN · 10/12/2021 10:00

I reached peak trans a couple of years ago and was swayed a lot by MN posters on how womens rights were being threatened by TRAs to the point I got into a massive argument one Christmas Day with my ‘right on’ DB and DH over it who accused me of being an anti trans bigot for expressing my concerns.

However, recently I’ve started to peel back the other way ironically also by MN. This is because not matter the topic, some posters have to turn it to a trans debate. It’s obsessive and is starting to feel very uncomfortable and sinister. There are some posters who will side with anyone or cause no matter how nasty if that person or cause is anti trans.

I'm struggling to believe you were ever convinced self ID threatened women's rights because you have characterised the discussion as anti trans. Women and specifically feminist who have experience of setting up single sex services have offered to share their expertise with TRA's to make sure trans people have access to services but that help has been rejected. As far as TRA's are concerned the only solution is for women to budge over and make room even when that approach goes against our interests.

I think the ability to accept you may agree with a person on one issue whilst you may not even like them or agree with them on anything else is a sign of maturity. I don't take an oppositional stance on an opinion because I don't like the person expressing it.

You have a government engaging in culture wars, putting minority lives under threat, ruining industries, cutting back welfare, large scale corruption . Things that statistically negatively impact women the most but none of this matters because ‘at least Boris knows what a woman is’.

I think the Conservative government is sitting back and letting all the left leaning parties destroy themselves over identity politics. I've no doubt they are very satisfied with what they are seeing but I don't think you can blame them for the divisive purity politics. This particular conservative government appear to be quite libertarian.

These are the same type of voters like Susan Sarandon who refused to vote for Hilary because she wasn’t pro-woman enough, allowing Trump to win so he could pack the Supreme Court with anti-abortionist Gilead wannabes.

Should she have voted for Hilary to prevent a potential challenge to Roe Vs Wade? If you think she should have voted a particular way because of one issue why do you think it's unreasonable for other people to be single issue voters?

This bullshit does real damage to women not a few nutty TRAs which nobody in real life would mistake for women. No laws would ever be passed to erase women. I’m totally over this anti-trans shit. I can’t be the only one who’s changed their views and become more disturbed by the zealots on MN.

Real damage is already being done to women because the legal definition of women is being eroded; the woman posting here about being unable to access single sex rape survivor support, the women in prison being raped by male born inmates, the teenage girl in the US raped in the school toilets, the woman who posted in feminism about living in a tent because she couldn't find a single sex DV shelter, the women being hounded out of their jobs, the prison inmate in the states who had learning disabilities and was repeatedly raped by her cellmate for a week before anyone noticed, the ND teenagers being convinced that a trans identity explains their social difficulties and being led down a path towards irreversible harm in the hope it will fix everything.

I could go on and on... Are these people not vulnerable enough for you or do you just see them as collateral damage?

RepentMotherfucker · 10/12/2021 09:30

@ilovesooty

I've stayed consistently that I don't think this issue is my primary consideration when deciding who to vote for and I cannot comprehend "at least they know what a woman is" as a justification for voting Tory.

Is that what you mean by posting "in support of trans activism"?

If that's what you mean you could say so instead of making snide comments about rodeos.

And no need for the his/ her jibe either.

A poster said, to me, that we didn't know where you stood on that. It's quite clear where you stand on that from many other threads.

And don't know if you are a man or a woman. How would I? Hmm

Tabbacus · 09/12/2021 22:26

@ilovesooty

And I don't believe the Tories give a shit about women anyway.
I don't think they do either, but they understand and acknowledge what a woman is before they shit on them.
ilovesooty · 09/12/2021 22:03

And I don't believe the Tories give a shit about women anyway.

Ionlydomassiveones · 09/12/2021 21:54

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

ilovesooty · 09/12/2021 21:03

I've stayed consistently that I don't think this issue is my primary consideration when deciding who to vote for and I cannot comprehend "at least they know what a woman is" as a justification for voting Tory.

Is that what you mean by posting "in support of trans activism"?

If that's what you mean you could say so instead of making snide comments about rodeos.

And no need for the his/ her jibe either.

RepentMotherfucker · 09/12/2021 17:15

@ilovesooty

This is not his/her first rodeo

What is that supposed to mean @RepentMotherfucker?

That you are a person who posts in support of trans activism. A pp said that you hadn't actually stated your view on that aspect of Labour policy and I was pointing out that your views had been made clear on many many other threads.
Thelnebriati · 09/12/2021 11:15

I'm not voting for Labour, they are the party of choice for people who arent actually Socialist but dont want tbe be labelled as neoliberal or right wing.

  • They've embraced neoliberal policies such as identity politics to the point where they are now prepared to pretend they dont know what a woman is.
  • They had one job to do; be an effective left wing opposition. Instead they have supported the tories in policies including Univeral Credit and austerity, and self ID which has brought us to the point where we now have mixed sex prisons, school toilets, psychiatric units and hospital wards.
This is having a real effect on women and girls, right now.

That doesnt mean I'm voting tory. Thats not how this works.

KimmyKimdoo · 09/12/2021 10:58

I’m really bitterly disappointed with Labour at the moment. As a woman, I feel that they don’t represent me at all. I cannot vote for them at the moment.

DdraigGoch · 09/12/2021 09:48

You could vote for the green party if that's an option

@AliveAndSleeping what's the use of that? They won't acknowledge biological reality either, and just look at the mess they've made of running Brighton.

DdraigGoch · 09/12/2021 09:36

@Effibreast

To counter the bs that labour are crap I suggested that Lisa Nandy as minister for levelling up is far superior to Gove. That Emily Thornberry, Chris Bryant and Thangam Debonnaire are as good as, if not better than their opposites and are hardly loony lefties That Starmer may be dull and sensible but is as honest and decent as Theresa May of John Major. But the morally bankrupt shower in government at the moment, that has destroyed multiple industries - mining, fishing, steel, that has stripped the country's infrastructure to the bone, lied, fiddled millions, is somehow better than the Labour Party. If anyone bothered to do research, they'd see that the party was attempting to change and appeal to the aspirational w/c, business owners and young people too. Rather people just repeat tired old cliches.
Labour still won't admit to knowing what a woman is.
NdujaWannaDance · 09/12/2021 09:32

It's true though, there is no viable opposition at the moment.

It's says a lot about the state of British politics that this government is the best we can do right now. And I'm a Tory.

littledrummergirl · 09/12/2021 09:30

I watched pmq yesterday, keir kicked off but didn't really push the issue. Ian Blackford did brilliantly though.
I should be a natural Labour supporter- historically my family have been Labour, I've been a union rep ensuring workers rights have been included but right now I feel politically homeless.

I believe that it's important to stop the degradation of women's rights and safe spaces. Labour are not aligned with me on this.
I don't like the idea of vaccine passports and having no go areas if you don't have the correct vaccination status. Although the cabinet are pushing this through the back benchers are providing opposition. Labour are much more vocal about wanting restrictions on our lives. Again, not aligned with me.

I hope that either Labour as a party grow up or thar the conservatives reclaim their party. Someone needs to hold the government to account for bringing in measures that haven't been given parliamentary consent.

Sadly Labour aren't up to the challenge.

sst1234 · 09/12/2021 00:26

OP is a double bluffing plant from Tory HQ, doing a grand job of turning people further away from the left with their sneering, patronising, attitude.

TheABC · 08/12/2021 23:54

@thecatfromjapan

The problem with distinguishing the politicians that act with probity from those who don't is that there's no effective outside mechanism for disciplining them. It's dependent on the leader of the Party and if that leader does not want to withdraw the whip, that person is effectively unsackable. The police rarely want to investigate complaints against MPs - which is understandable - but it means they get away with rampant cronyism, nepotism and corruption. That's before we look at the problems of running MP's offices, (no central HR?) their working hours, pay or expectations in the constituency. Everything is run on a gentleman's agreement and the assumption that people 'will do the right thing.' It's a complete mess.

Look at how many times Johnson has lied to Parliament and got away with breath-taking breaches of privilege. Everyone calls him Teflon-coated, but the truth is, we are stuck with him for another two years. The only thing that can dislodge him before then is the 1922 committee or criminal proceedings. I can't actually think of another job with the same tenured security.

SexyNeckbeard · 08/12/2021 23:04

[quote Effibreast]@SexyNeckbeard lefty propaganda ? Ok Hmm Monbiot explains it far better than I ever could. Why would I paraphrase it ? I agree with him.[/quote]
Took an awful lot of effort to drag any sort of source out of you while you freely presented his opinions as your own. I suggest you don't paraphrase because you don't understand.

Anyway this is going the way it always does with an ill informed labour supporter and I can't be arsed any more.

Effibreast · 08/12/2021 23:03

What's he said that's embarrassing ? More embarrassing than Johnson ? Surely Johnson is more clueless, he's a laughing stock now ?
Have you noticed how much the left hate him for getting rid of Corbyn, expelling various far left groups, sacking Corbyn acolytes ? Even the Mail like him now, recently did a comment in the daily star or the sun.
I'm no fan boy of him but he and his new shadow cabinet are better than Johnson, Raab, Patel...which isn't difficult

OP posts:
SwumMum · 08/12/2021 23:01

I voted Labour in multiple elections and felt strongly I always would....

I then heard about and saw their policies around self id and women's rights, and thought again. I've since watched as MPs like Ben Bradshaw support the students in the Sussex scandal, and argue against the BBC publishing an article about lesbians being raped. And as John McDonnell applauded Ellie Mae O Hagan for her clarity and delivery when stating, "no one knows what a man or woman is." And as Taiwo Owatemi wrote that ridiculous letter ..

I'm no Tory voter, never will be. But I'm afraid I won't vote Labour either.

I am a women. I care about women. I need a party who understands the fundamental importance of biological reality in life and law. There isn't one. I am politically homeless.

thecatfromjapan · 08/12/2021 22:56

Sorry.
That was a real thread de-rail.

But I have a real bee in my bonnet about this.

Swipe left for the next trending thread