Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To pull my DC out of school for the rest of term?

138 replies

RiverOrla · 08/12/2021 13:03

Rates are skyrocketing at the DC’s primary. We have lots of Christmas plans with extended family (Christmas is a huge deal to us, celebrations relating to several different cultures) and I don’t want to risk it being ruined by covid. If I take them out for the rest of this week and next week (last week of term) this would seriously reduce the risk of them having it for Christmas.

Anyone else doing this?

YABU - keep them in school
YANBU - take them out to safeguard family Christmas.

OP posts:
DeepaBeesKit · 08/12/2021 14:07

Why do people think that school is the ONLY place that children can be educated? If OP wants to remove her children from an unsafe situation and she has the means to do it, who are any of you to guilt her into "oh but they'll miss precious school!". There is a world for children outside of 9-3. Have fun with your kids OP

Because picking and choosing when you want to send kids isnt fair on the school. Those teachers have to make up gaps, they are held to account on progress. If you don't want to part of that, you are free to home educate, but you can't just have your cake and eat it too and partake of it only when it suits you. Its disruptive to the rest of the class.

writingabout · 08/12/2021 14:06

Children have missed so much school over the last year and a half. The last thing I'd want is for mine to miss even more. There's been so much written about this, not just the affect on educational levels, but also on children's emotional development, mental health and social skills. It's also extra pressure on teachers who are already dealing with lots of absences and having to help children catch up when they've been absent for genuine reasons. That takes teachers' time away from the rest of the class too, so it's not even just your own children who are affected. YA definitely BU.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 08/12/2021 14:05

Hope you weren’t one of the people moaning about home schooling. I know it’s hard to believe after the last yr but school isn’t optional

DeepaBeesKit · 08/12/2021 14:05

Is a school play (without an audience) worth missing family Christmas?

But it doesnt mean missing immediate family Christmas. It means missing a bigger Christmas with extended family & extra activities, not everyone does that anyway.

Lovethedogg · 08/12/2021 14:03

@bofski14

Oh for crying out loud! Why do people think that school is the ONLY place that children can be educated? If OP wants to remove her children from an unsafe situation and she has the means to do it, who are any of you to guilt her into "oh but they'll miss precious school!". There is a world for children outside of 9-3. Have fun with your kids OP.
Well the OP did ask for opinions?? I don’t think school is the ONLY place children can be educated or it’s the be all and end all - no-one has said that! I just think, in the OPs circumstances, it would be unreasonable to keep them off. I’d probably think differently if she was keeping them off next week because it was the only chance to see family (and they were actually going to have some fun) but I’d still think lying about symptoms isn’t right.
MarshaBradyo · 08/12/2021 13:58

@Heartdogs

Don't deprive your kids of any more school, any more playing with friends, any more education so you can have a big Christmas. .
It’ll probably fall on deaf ears but I agree.
Arethechildreninbedyet · 08/12/2021 13:57

I'd keep him in until the end of the week and then take him out if you deem it necessary.

At the end of you day he's your son, it's your choice. He's under eleven and it's the last week before Christmas - its not a big deal.

You're removing him to limit transmission and keep him and elderly relatives safe. Contact them and say you have concerns with clinically vulnerable family members and see what they say.

My sister's school have always continued online lesson plans. Any children who cannot attend can access work, homework etc.

7eleven · 08/12/2021 13:56

[quote User2638483]@7eleven taking a holiday is a bit different to imposing isolation on them[/quote]
Not for the argument that school is really important it isn’t (which obviously I think it is 😀)

Indecisivelurcher · 08/12/2021 13:55

I see where you're coming from op, but mine would be gutted to miss all the Christmas fun at school. They've got the nativity, Christmas jumpers, Christmas lunch, a film night. That's part of Christmas too.

RiverOrla · 08/12/2021 13:54

It’s only one week, not two.

I do take the point that there is more to school that school work and the importance of the fun bits too. This isn’t a flippant decision I’m trying to make.

Is a school play (without an audience) worth missing family Christmas?

We live in the countryside, when not at school their chances of catching it elsewhere are vanishingly small.

OP posts:
DeepaBeesKit · 08/12/2021 13:52

Also the message you are sending to your kids will really stick with them at those ages. Do you really want that message to be "skip school the stuff you need to do it's more important to have fun?"

DeepaBeesKit · 08/12/2021 13:49

There's a reason the government changed the isolation rules to ensure children weren't kept home unless they were ill. They've missed so much school already and its causing huge problems.

It's not just about your children. They won't "only" be doing the show. Your kids will miss 2 weeks of reading, writing, maths, science, topic work, and it causes the teacher to have a lot of extra work to bridge the gap. Its especially bad when its followed with two weeks off anyway for Christmas, a 4 week chunk of time out of school really slows down their learning.

RiverOrla · 08/12/2021 13:48

Thanks bofski I agree school is not the be all and end all. Important of course but not the only thing that is.

OP posts:
Lovethedogg · 08/12/2021 13:48

@RiverOrla

DC won’t have to lie. No one will mention it come January. Or I just take it unauthorised. Their attendance has been 100%.

We wouldn’t go anywhere. All their clubs finish this week any way. Would go for walks but that is easy to avoid people. We have no events booked in the next 2 eeeks but have lots in between Xmas abc new year.

I just part of me wants to be selfish, we’ve stuck to all the rules and I just want to ensure a good Xmas for them this time.

It would be selfish and I think you’re doing for yourself and not the children. Keeping them off school and isolated for the next 2 weeks so you can attend family parties between Christmas and New Year? I don’t see how you can square that as being in their best interests. As someone else has said what if you or they get ill anyway or what if they end up having to have another 2 weeks off in January?
User2638483 · 08/12/2021 13:47

@7eleven taking a holiday is a bit different to imposing isolation on them

Nidan2Sandan · 08/12/2021 13:47

So instead of then being in school with their friends, doing christmas plays, singing, arts, crafts, games and other fun stuff they missed out on last year and, for children, is super super fun........

You want to lock them in the house for 2 weeks except for "walks". Jeez, after 2020 I bet they've had their fill of "walks".

kjdmnbxz54 · 08/12/2021 13:47

Sounds like you have already decided.

But, no you shouldn't do this. School is about more than learning, so you are completely incorrect to say they won't be missing anything because it is the end of term and therefore just practising for the Christmas show.

Things like the show are important! They learn self confidence, public speaking, and it's a big achievement for them. Some kids really thrive on it, but all get something out of it. Plus it's a fun time of term, and fun with friends is so important. Hanging out at home gets boring very quickly. It would be very wrong, and thoughtless to pull them out, and that's without considering the whole moral issue of lying to the school.

Cherrytart23 · 08/12/2021 13:47

@bofski14

Oh for crying out loud! Why do people think that school is the ONLY place that children can be educated? If OP wants to remove her children from an unsafe situation and she has the means to do it, who are any of you to guilt her into "oh but they'll miss precious school!". There is a world for children outside of 9-3. Have fun with your kids OP.
If its an unsafe situation then she should remove them full time not just when it suits her!
User2638483 · 08/12/2021 13:46

Sorry my response was to @bofski14

Heartdogs · 08/12/2021 13:46

Don't deprive your kids of any more school, any more playing with friends, any more education so you can have a big Christmas. .

User2638483 · 08/12/2021 13:46

Yes but she and their dad are going to be working! Not exactly dedicating their days to their child’s education.
Plus normally HE would involve going out and about but there’s not much point in missing school if they’re going to mix elsewhere!

7eleven · 08/12/2021 13:45

I wonder how many people who think you shouldn’t do it have taken a holiday in term time? Not really any different. I’m a teacher by the way, so don’t support term time holidays as a rule. Last week of autumn term though…

bofski14 · 08/12/2021 13:42

Oh for crying out loud! Why do people think that school is the ONLY place that children can be educated? If OP wants to remove her children from an unsafe situation and she has the means to do it, who are any of you to guilt her into "oh but they'll miss precious school!". There is a world for children outside of 9-3. Have fun with your kids OP.

RiverOrla · 08/12/2021 13:41

I have no intention of blaming the school for lack of progress or anything else, their school has done a fab job over the last 2 years.

If I said did they want the last week at school and risk not seeing grandparents, great grandparents, panto, ice skating and other family get togethers I think they’d choose to stay off.

I guess I’m being unreasonable then. I am just so fed up if covid ruling our lives!!

OP posts:
bumblefeline · 08/12/2021 13:41

No they have had enough time off.

How can you say they have symptoms for two weeks? Won't school wonder why there is no PCR results?

Swipe left for the next trending thread