Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To pull my DC out of school for the rest of term?

138 replies

RiverOrla · 08/12/2021 13:03

Rates are skyrocketing at the DC’s primary. We have lots of Christmas plans with extended family (Christmas is a huge deal to us, celebrations relating to several different cultures) and I don’t want to risk it being ruined by covid. If I take them out for the rest of this week and next week (last week of term) this would seriously reduce the risk of them having it for Christmas.

Anyone else doing this?

YABU - keep them in school
YANBU - take them out to safeguard family Christmas.

OP posts:
BoredZelda · 09/12/2021 00:13

Primary school? Meh, I’d do it. The last week is rarely important. They will be gutted if they get covid over Christmas.

My daughter missed 3 weeks of school in the run up to Christmas one primary school year. There was no work sent home and yet she is still managing to get great marks in high school.

Pensieve · 08/12/2021 23:45

“It's not 'im alright jack' attitude, its working within the choices available to me to minimise the risk”

As I’m sure you know OP unless you lie, taking them out is only a ‘choice’ so much as you’re doing an unauthorised absence. School is mandatory unless the government dictates a lockdown again which they have not and 1 positive DC does not necessarily dictate isolation of other DC.

Warmduscher · 08/12/2021 23:35

I agree. Education can be as good at home. You know what is best op. I’m in a similar quandary.

If the OP agreed with you on this, her DC would be homeschooled full-time. But they’re not - she’s talking about taking them out for ten days to please the adults (her DH, the grandparents).

Pensieve · 08/12/2021 23:29

I understand your concern as there in an outbreak in my DC class currently.

However as both a parent and school governor who’s seen the stats on dropping of average performance and pressure teachers are under to catch up - I don’t agree with your attitude. You expect school to be there when you want it but feel you don’t have to show the same commitment back. So you and all the family will isolate for 2 weeks will you - no shopping or mixing and you’ll do homework on your own initiative? You’ll not let the children do any clubs, see friends for 2 weeks and overall have them off school and entertained for what 4 weeks.

Jumanji89 · 08/12/2021 23:21

OP this comment isnt just aimed at you as it is common on MN but I genuinely don't understand why you've posed the question here as you've made your mind up regardless of any of the responses here.

Do what you think is best for you and your family is my opinion fwiw

Covidworries · 08/12/2021 23:16

Totally understand @riverorla

Debating this ourselves. As an adult, the having to cancel christmas plans with wider family would be disapointing, but it would be ok. The 4 children would be distraught. For different reasons the elder 2 would be unable ti come home if one of us test positive before xmas. They are all desperate to be together. One child is CEV and vunerable so in a worst case situation this could be xmas in hospital too.

So yes removing from school is very tempting right now. Im watching data closely and hoping we can get some of the activities they are looking forward to done before cases rise too much whilst praying that we dont leave it too long.

flumposie · 08/12/2021 23:02

Don't lie about them having symptoms. Imagine if I did that as a teacher to try to protect my Christmas.

FlorenceWintle · 08/12/2021 22:48

I am just so fed up if covid ruling our lives!!

Keeping them out of school is letting Covid rule their lives though. They’ll be missing out! Carrying on as normal would be the way to not let covid rule your lives.

chillied · 08/12/2021 22:45

I would do it OP.

We are being very cautious in what we do in the run up to Christmas so that we minimise the chances of having to tell GPs they can't visit because we're positive or waiting to find out if we're positive.

In our case DC are secondary school age, they are vaccinated, and at least one has had covid. So they can stay in school.

Your kids are presumably unvaccinated due to their ages. You don't say that you've had covid already. There are so many families I know who avoided covid for so many months until just recently. You will kick yourself if they pick it up next week and there goes Christmas.

FlorenceWintle · 08/12/2021 22:44

Absolutely not. They’ve missed so much already, the social side as well as educational. They need some stability, not this constant in/out of school.

Sodullincomparison · 08/12/2021 22:35

I discussed removing DC from school for the next four days as cases are escalating rapidly In her class. Whilst she is negative we have childcare options, if she becomes positive we would have to take unpaid leave.

Imperfect solutions all around.

Sh05 · 08/12/2021 22:27

I don't think school CAN demand a PCR test or its result. Ours doesn't anyway. They advise parents that a test should be done and ask that parents keep the school updated but other than that I don't know anyone who has had to show proof of a PCR.
That being said I completely understand where the op is coming from and if I had the choices they do, I would pull my youngest for the last week as well.
We're not Christian, we don't celebrate Christmas but if staying in school meant risking the holidays and a long awaited family get together then the kids would stay home.
Just don't lie OP, tell the office staff why you're taking them out, I doubt you'll be the only one.

Cissyandflora · 08/12/2021 22:22

@bofski14

Oh for crying out loud! Why do people think that school is the ONLY place that children can be educated? If OP wants to remove her children from an unsafe situation and she has the means to do it, who are any of you to guilt her into "oh but they'll miss precious school!". There is a world for children outside of 9-3. Have fun with your kids OP.
I agree. Education can be as good at home. You know what is best op. I’m in a similar quandary.
Flobbertybillop · 08/12/2021 22:18

They will miss a lot, they will miss their Christmas show, and all the other fun things kids do in the last week or so.
They’ve missed way too much education already.

Grumpyosaurus · 08/12/2021 22:14

@Lulu1919

Pity all the school staff can't do they same !!! I'm a TA ...so much covid in staff and children ...but I have to keep going in ...just hoping I don't get it so it spoils my Christmas..my children are adults so if I'm isolating I won't be seeing them !!!!
I also work in a school.

I am masking up and crossing my fingers. After not being able to see all my DC last Christmas, I'll be gutted if I end up having to isolate this time around. I'm also quite keen to be able to see a couple of elderly relatives and friends (aged 90+) this year.

We have families in the school who refuse to test their kids. It's just as well that I don't have to deal with them personally.

anne2650 · 08/12/2021 22:11

YABU

JustLyra · 08/12/2021 22:10

I think it depends if you actually know what they’ll be missing.

I’m keeping DD3 off the last week, but that’s because her HT gave me a heads up that they are planning a week of show rehearsal (she refuses to be in the show) and Christmas parties (which she hates). They think between numbers falling and people pulling them out doing work will just cause disruption after Christmas. So it’ll be some revision and then fun stuff.

The HT also knows that DD4 is extremely vulnerable so school for the bigger two has been a terrifying thing for us as it was balancing the needs of DD3 and DS2 with the risk to DD4.

DS will go to school until the middle of the last week as he is in the school panto, but doesn’t want to do the chill out days they are doing for the last few days.

2WeeksTillChristmas · 08/12/2021 22:07

I think a hell of alot of parents will do this,
But ofcourse not mumsnetters Grin

GrandDuchessRomanov · 08/12/2021 22:05

No I wouldn't do this either and I'm pretty relaxed about taking time out for very special occasions but not such a long time.

Also what if they do catch it after Christmas, more missed education.

Largethighsbadeyes · 08/12/2021 22:03

The most memorable day of my school days was when I picked up my GCSE results and walked down the drive knowing I would never have to go back 🤷‍♀️

What I remember from primary school in the few days before Christmas...nothing really

I get that alot of people on mumsnet will not agree with OPS choice but it is her choice to make.

The whole "you are depriving your child of precious memories" stuff, falls a bit short for me

The bottom line is cases are going up and a whole bunch of children are going to end up isolating over Christmas because of that.

OP and myself will not be the only ones deciding to pull kids out early. Look at the poll. In the minority yes, but not the only ones

twinkletoesimnot · 08/12/2021 22:03

As a PP said... ( sorry for typos!)

twinkletoesimnot · 08/12/2021 22:01

Also a teacher and if I'm considering doing this from next Tuesday.
I'd do it tomorrow if I could.
It's creeping up in dds class, and in my own class I have children in with positive siblings.
It seems like a ticking time bomb.
I have lots of animals to care for that are not based at home and a self employed dh - whose wage we rely on.
As a op said , I will be teaching as well as having fun, but I'm able to help my dd learn.
As for missing out on the fun - catching Covid isn't exactly fun!

meh12 · 08/12/2021 21:47

The most memorable days of my school life were those days before school broke up at Christmas, no I wouldn't deprive my kids of that, you're bring precious.

Crunchymum · 08/12/2021 21:41

@RiverOrla

You never answered my question about PCR tests.

What will you tell the school when you are unable to provide 3 PCR test results?

RiverOrla · 08/12/2021 19:41

I have revised my thinking to just next week rather than this week too.

yes i do have a choice. i realise I'm lucky to have that choice. i do realise the teachers do not have that choice. but me not exercising my choice (in this or any other things i'm privileged enough to have a choice in) doesn't change things for those who dont have the choice.

It's not 'im alright jack' attitude, its working within the choices available to me to minimise the risk.

So they will definitely go the rest of the week. will continue to consider about next week.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread