Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think if you have dietary requirements you should stick to them?

61 replies

robertabrown · 08/12/2021 11:24

I recently hosted a dinner party for ten. So lots of cooking.

One guest let me know that they have dietary requirements, dairy and gluten free, and an allergy to another very common ingredient. Yikes I thought. So I spent a good chunk of time finding a recipe that she could eat. I sent it to her to check and she said great thanks yes I can eat that. She did offer to help cook, but I personally find having new people around the kitchen to be a faff. So I pre prepared the dish.

On the evening I served it to her and she appreciated that we had gone the extra mile and even bought in a separate starter and separate pudding for her. This was because her dietaries made it impossible to find dishes that we all wanted.

She then questioned me why she wasn’t having the roast lamb. I explained it was because we had used flour (gluten) in the making, and cooked it in a jus that contained the other ingredient she was allergic too. Following her eating this, she then tucked in to every single dish that contained the ingredients she said she couldn’t eat. She ate cake made with butter and milk and flour.

She said oh it’ll be fine, I might get a bit of tummy upset.

So I realised that I had bent over backwards to prepare a meal that she could eat, when she could eat what we were all eating anyway. This came at a financial cost, and a time one. Plus we only have one small oven so was hard to time the other dishes around hers.

Aibu to think that if you say you have a dietary requirement that you stick to it?

OP posts:
Sarahplane · 08/12/2021 12:15

YANBU. My DH is lactose intolerant so dairy free but a lot stricter with some things than others because he knows what will make him suffer and what won't (a small amount of butter baked into a cake would be OK for example) but he'll also sometimes have a small amount of icecream or cheese on pizza because he feels its worth suggesting for. He will suffer for it but sometimes chooses to have a small amount of something he really likes. He also knows how much he can get away with before he would feel really ill. He is mostly pretty strict though. Choosing to suffer for something at home is one thing but when someone else has made the effort to make him something dairy free would be totally taking the piss. He did this at a wedding once tasted a bit of my pudding when he'd been given fruit salad. We had words, it's just so embarrassing and then people think you are taking the piss when he really is lactose intolerant.

Hillarious · 08/12/2021 12:09

@gogohm

Though in this case I'm unsure why the lamb couldn't be gf, I've never used flour myself. Separate gravy (from a packet is fine or use gf stock cube and some red currant jelly
Plus cornflour can be used.
Glentheredbeakbattleostrich · 08/12/2021 12:03

I prefer to be gluten free as it triggers my ibs and eczema but i would never ask others to go out of their way because of my preference. i either bring my own or eat what im given.

Negligee · 08/12/2021 11:58

@Mumdiva99

My aunt is coeliac and does this. But.....she spend her life restricting her food.....just occasionally she'll eat a piece of the gluten containing cake and suffer for it later. We make sure there are GF choices, but I turn a blind eye if she deviates as it's ultimately her choice.
Which is her decision, obviously, but if you're being hosted by someone who has gone to a lot of trouble to source ingredients and cook food you can eat, it's a pretty 'fuck you' move. Not to mention deeply unhelpful to those people who don't/can't deviate from their allergy-free diets, vegetarians who don't, ever, eat meat or fish etc.

I remember once staying at a country house hotel and the owners saying that they had once been asked to provide a special dinner for a group of people staying that had needed to cater for a specific set of allergies and be vegetarian , and they'd gone to a lot of trouble to get it right and to make it as special as their usual food offerings. Only to find the next morning that the same people were horsing into the sausages, eggs etc on the breakfast buffet.

Shedmistress · 08/12/2021 11:52

@Marvellousmadness

What a fkn bitch move
This.

Having been that person that genuinely couldn't eat dairy for a decade, I'm livid at her and thank you for taking the time and expense and say 'don't host her again'.

gogohm · 08/12/2021 11:52

Though in this case I'm unsure why the lamb couldn't be gf, I've never used flour myself. Separate gravy (from a packet is fine or use gf stock cube and some red currant jelly

Mumdiva99 · 08/12/2021 11:51

My aunt is coeliac and does this. But.....she spend her life restricting her food.....just occasionally she'll eat a piece of the gluten containing cake and suffer for it later. We make sure there are GF choices, but I turn a blind eye if she deviates as it's ultimately her choice.

MangoM · 08/12/2021 11:51

@MaskingForIt

YANBU. See also pescatarians who claim to be vegetarian and then eat fish.
Even worse, I had a friend at uni that said she was vegetarian but ate chicken on occasion Hmm
gogohm · 08/12/2021 11:48

Annoying isn't it - vegans who magically eat cheesecake was my experience, my own dd will be at desserts containing gelatine especially after drinking and never checks alcohol to see if vegetarian (that said I've been known to fish the chorizo out of her portion of paella!)

Fairyliz · 08/12/2021 11:47

This reminds me of the time when I worked at a primary school.
We used to arrange for Santa to come around and give all of the children a bag of chocolate during the last week.
I was aware that a couple of children couldn’t have dairy, so when I was sorting everything out (in my own time) I made sure we had dairy free chocolate clearly marked for these children.
At the end of the day I had one of the dairy free mums screaming at me because her daughter was upset to have different chocolate to her friend. When I tried to explain mum said ‘oh chocolate won’t hurt her when she eats it with her friends’ Hmm

thenightsky · 08/12/2021 11:46

@MaskingForIt

YANBU. See also pescatarians who claim to be vegetarian and then eat fish.
DH does that. Drives me fucking nuts.
StepAwayFromGoogling · 08/12/2021 11:46

@galacticpixels

That's ridiculous. Her kind of attitude also makes it hard for people with genuine allergies to be taken seriously.

A coworker of mine always causes a big fuss any time we're going out to eat... Has to be somewhere with a gluten free menu, spends ages at the restaurant confirming what's gluten free. But then when they say something she wants can't be made gluten free she just says "ah that's okay I'll have it anyway".

My sister is a coeliac who gets incredibly sick from even just a tiny bit of cross contamination so it really annoys me.

This with bells on. My DP and MIL are both coeliac and they'd be horribly ill if they ate wheat. Did you call her out on it at the time?
Hillarious · 08/12/2021 11:46

But in the OP's case, the friend could not eat (or said she couldn't) gluten, dairy, and another common ingredient. It sounds as if it would be far more difficult to find something omitting all these things that was still reasonably appealing to the other guests.

@Negligee - but not impossible. I just find it a bit weird to serve a different dish for one person. I would instead go for the lowest common denominator and put the effort into making that nice for everyone. If there's a vegetarian, I'd probably do a range of mostly vegetable curries. There are loads of vegan alternatives to dairy, but I'd avoid the cheese. It would be interesting to know what the "allergy to another very common ingredient" is.

FreedomFaith · 08/12/2021 11:46

She likely is one of those that doesn't have issues, just thinks they do. More likely they eat too much food, have a belly ache then blame the type of food.

I wouldn't bother again for her. Doesn't need it. She's just greedy.

TractorAndHeadphones · 08/12/2021 11:45

@Shiningpath

Very cheeky when she’d specifically flagged the allergy and intolerances.

However, sometimes people with quite mild intolerances choose to eat food that makes them feel unwell, as is their right.

Right to be an arsehole I’d have shamed her in front of everyone else but then again I’m quite vocal and not afraid of confrontation.
RuggerHug · 08/12/2021 11:44

She's a dick.

EMotion · 08/12/2021 11:43

Similar to a colleague who insisted on a venue which also had a vegan menu. Then had a dairy cappuccino- as they don’t like the taste of it on soy….

Marvellousmadness · 08/12/2021 11:43

*Very cheeky when she’d specifically flagged the allergy and intolerances.

However, sometimes people with quite mild intolerances choose to eat food that makes them feel unwell, as is their right.*

Not cheeky just rude and rediculous!!
And of course you can choose to to eat food that make you unwell BUT NOT AFTER doing this big " oh I am allergic to this; cant eat this; def can eat that" kinda sherades...

I would never invite her over for a meal anymore. This lady should be very embarrassed by her actions

Marvellousmadness · 08/12/2021 11:40

What a fkn bitch move

MrzClaus · 08/12/2021 11:40

I have a "gluten free" acquaintance - who happily tucks into a bacon sandwich, cheeky pork pie, cake etc when out and about but when coming to my / my families home will mention being gluten free. Winds me up no end!!

Shiningpath · 08/12/2021 11:39

Very cheeky when she’d specifically flagged the allergy and intolerances.

However, sometimes people with quite mild intolerances choose to eat food that makes them feel unwell, as is their right.

Negligee · 08/12/2021 11:38

@Hillarious

Annoying. But when my coeliac friend comes to dinner, we all eat the same thing and there's nothing served that she can't eat.
But in the OP's case, the friend could not eat (or said she couldn't) gluten, dairy, and another common ingredient. It sounds as if it would be far more difficult to find something omitting all these things that was still reasonably appealing to the other guests.
MaskingForIt · 08/12/2021 11:38

YANBU. See also pescatarians who claim to be vegetarian and then eat fish.

InTheLabyrinth · 08/12/2021 11:38

This still rankles 15 years on.
Dairy and gluten free. Didn't tell me till we were already at the holiday cottage (DHs mates new gf) panic, cobble something together. THEN SHE FECKING TUCKS INTO APPLE CRUMBLE AND CUSTARD.

I have no issues with catering for dietary requirements, but

  1. please give me some warning and
  2. stick to it
Hillarious · 08/12/2021 11:34

Annoying. But when my coeliac friend comes to dinner, we all eat the same thing and there's nothing served that she can't eat.

Swipe left for the next trending thread