Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think if you have dietary requirements you should stick to them?

61 replies

robertabrown · 08/12/2021 11:24

I recently hosted a dinner party for ten. So lots of cooking.

One guest let me know that they have dietary requirements, dairy and gluten free, and an allergy to another very common ingredient. Yikes I thought. So I spent a good chunk of time finding a recipe that she could eat. I sent it to her to check and she said great thanks yes I can eat that. She did offer to help cook, but I personally find having new people around the kitchen to be a faff. So I pre prepared the dish.

On the evening I served it to her and she appreciated that we had gone the extra mile and even bought in a separate starter and separate pudding for her. This was because her dietaries made it impossible to find dishes that we all wanted.

She then questioned me why she wasn’t having the roast lamb. I explained it was because we had used flour (gluten) in the making, and cooked it in a jus that contained the other ingredient she was allergic too. Following her eating this, she then tucked in to every single dish that contained the ingredients she said she couldn’t eat. She ate cake made with butter and milk and flour.

She said oh it’ll be fine, I might get a bit of tummy upset.

So I realised that I had bent over backwards to prepare a meal that she could eat, when she could eat what we were all eating anyway. This came at a financial cost, and a time one. Plus we only have one small oven so was hard to time the other dishes around hers.

Aibu to think that if you say you have a dietary requirement that you stick to it?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Daisydoesnt · 09/12/2021 08:52

Your friend was very annoying OP - I totally get that. HOWEVER, I'd be a bit Hmm if I was gluten free and everyone was having roast lamb and I was served something else. Roast lamb is a pretty special main course to be missing out on. I know you said that there was another ingredient that she was allergic to; what was it? You could have bought some GF flour or used cornflour (I'm guessing the flour was to thicken the gravy??)

Letsallscreamatthesistene · 09/12/2021 08:39

I agree this particular situation sounds extremely annoying, but it does need to be remembered that just because someone says they are allergic or intolerant to a particular food but does on occasion eat it, it doesn't mean they are making stuff up.

Its irrelevant if shes making it up/doing a fad diet/whatever.

Its the total lack of awareness, selfishness and lack of consideration on her part.

Onairjunkie · 09/12/2021 08:15

Ugh. I had someone like this at my wedding. no meat, some fish ok, no seafood, no dairy, no refined sugar, no gluten… cost an absolute fortune getting the chef to make her a special menu. On the day, I saw her eating everything. And her Insta was rapidly full of her scarfing down lamb roasts with lots of comments saying “thank god you’ve given up the diet!”

mumda · 08/12/2021 22:32

I know a couple who ate vegan. Right up until there was steak on the BBQ. Oh they stuffed their faces with free steak.
They'd had a completely separate BBQ for their vegan stuff which they'd guarded even though there was plenty for anyone who wanted it. The host had bought all the food to ensure it was managed right for the gluten free bloke who is ultra strict.

christmaspavlova · 08/12/2021 22:07

She sounds awful, completely oblivious and on her own planet. Unacceptable behaviour.

AgeingDoc · 08/12/2021 14:29

I agree this particular situation sounds extremely annoying, but it does need to be remembered that just because someone says they are allergic or intolerant to a particular food but does on occasion eat it, it doesn't mean they are making stuff up.
People who have non IgE mediated allergies or intolerances that are not immune mediated can often tolerate small quantities of their "forbidden" foods, especially if it is cooked or heavily processed. Indeed they may be medically advised to eat what they can tolerate and try to build up exposure gradually.
One of my sons has multiple allergies, some IgE mediated some non IgE mediated, plus a rare gastrointestinal disorder that is triggered by certain foods, but in a dose dependent/cumulative kind of way. So his dietary restrictions are quite complicated. We tend just to tell people he is allergic to XY and Z and leave it at that, rather than trying to explain the minutiae to everyone.So as far as school are concerned all his allergens are completely forbidden, to minimise the risk of errors. The school catering system won't allow him to buy anything with any trace of any of his allergens present. We need that system to fail safe. However we can make our own risk assessments and in some circumstances he does eat food that contains some of his non IgE mediated allergens. That has led to people accusing him of making his allergies up, attention seeking behaviour etc. We aren't liars, he is allergic to all the things we say he is, but not all in the same way. It's a lot more complicated than most people appreciate, and I am prepared to make judgements that it would be totally unreasonable to expect others to be responsible for.
That said, if we went somewhere and the host had prepared something special for him then he would eat it and express gratitude even if everything else on the table was actually safe for him. If someone has made an effort it's really rude not to be appreciative of that.

Sceptre86 · 08/12/2021 14:15

Never cook for the annoyance again. This is why people with allergies don't get taken seriously.

YouGotThisKeepGoing · 08/12/2021 13:40

Is she doing low FODMAP for IBSI say that because she mentions the possibility of an upset tummy. If the common ingredient was onions or garlic I’d think it probably was.

Low FODMAP is more about not exceeding certain amounts of foods than avoiding them altogether. The thresholds very from person to person.

With that it really might be possible to have a little bit of most things as long as she didn’t have a large quantity of anything.

Some people are very strict with it, some aren’t. It can be very, very restrictive as there are lots and lots of foods to be monitored and some people kind of do it half heartedly because it’s so difficult to keep track of everything.

Still, she should have communicated with you a lot better about it.

BogRollBOGOF · 08/12/2021 13:25

The boundary for me is how honest people are.
I have a friend with an anphalyactic nut allergy. So that has to be strict. She does take a chance on "may contain nuts" for the sake of sanity.
She also has other intolerances that again for sanity she moderates consumption of. If cooking for her, it would be free from actively containing nuts, but checking her condidence level on her other trigger foods. Form and quantity matter.

I have a low tolerance to dairy and soya. Neat milk, and the effects would be unpleasantly clear within 30 mins, but cheese is tolerable. It's awkward to describe and get the balance between sudden illness and avoiding too much disruption to the host. When DS1 had allergies to several foods, a drizzle of butter had him in agony and blasting out of nappies for days. As he grew out of it and had food phased in, that nuance was far harder to explain than a clear no dairy/ eggs/ soya at all.

I wouldn't be stipulating dairy and soya free though. It would be worth checking that a sauce was not too creamy.

Letsallscreamatthesistene · 08/12/2021 13:15

Id be SO angry at her. Id also send her a message letting her know how upset I was considering all the extra effort id been too.

FreeBritnee · 08/12/2021 13:10

I’m not sure I’d be quite as cross unless the guest made out they were allergic enough to require an epipen. Then sat there and merrily ate the offending food.

She might have just not wanted to eat a quantity of gluten, so could tolerate a small amount of it in the meat for example but avoided it in the specially prepared sides and pudding.

I have a skin condition that flares when eating a million and one things so I try to keep my diet pretty plain. I can almost imagine falling into this territory if I were more sociable. I’d be eating my bland food and then if I didn’t have a flare, and something else looked delicious I could imagine saying I’d have a bit of that too. I wouldn’t be trying to be an arsehole, I’d be trying to join in with the food because my mood was elevated and if I paid for it later I’d probably accept that.

PegasusReturns · 08/12/2021 13:09

Your friend was rude.

But I do have some sympathy. As someone who loves food but has intolerances that make me feel quite unwell at times it can be very difficult to manage. Just because something makes you ill doesn’t stop you wanting it.

Like with any diet it’s easy to start with good intentions, but when beautiful food that I should not eat is laid in front of my sometimes the temptation is too great.

I always pay for it in the end but it often feels worth it at the time.

Pythonesque · 08/12/2021 12:59

I tend to ask what someone is planning to make, and then work out what substitutions or alterations might be helpful. So if I was told they were planning roast lamb, I'd probably offer to bring along some GF flour for the gravy, if they were happy with that.

I have to be strict with gluten (none of the coeliacs in my family tolerate so-called "gluten-free" oats either), but can get away with some dairy so usually take a risk on it. Occasionally that may backfire if presented with a very dairy heavy dish but I don't eat out very often nowadays anyway!

QuitMoaning · 08/12/2021 12:51

We had a large family gathering a few days after Christmas for a birthday. A family member had switched to vegan a month or so previously and wanted a particular meal. I worked with the restaurant on providing a suitable dish as everyone else was having a set menu where the vegetarian option was put suitable for a vegan.

Whilst the meal was being served he told us all how he wasn’t a serious vegan, and even had eaten turkey at the Christmas meal. The staff heard.
I was furious. He could have had the vegetarian option and not caused extra headaches for the restaurant and me.

mustlovegin · 08/12/2021 12:45

Your guest is out of order (and she may be damaging her health). YANBU OP

Hillarious · 08/12/2021 12:34

@kennelmaid - you're welcome to a sensible and pragmatic dinner at my house any time.

GreenVia · 08/12/2021 12:32

YANBU

My 18 years old niece decided she is lastose interant and was a real pain to feed during holidays..We had to find special restaurants that had stuff she could eat etc.

Fast forward several weeks and I spot her putting diary milk into her coffee...

I don't bother listening to the newest requirements anymore..

kennelmaid · 08/12/2021 12:29

I agree with @Hillarious, sensible and pragmatic, no drama Smile

SpindlesWinterWhorl · 08/12/2021 12:29

I wonder if the mystery ingredient was onions / onion family? And if the guest was low-Fodmapping, rather than having known intolerances or allergies? It's to help people learn to avoid foods that can tigger IBS.

BeyondOurReef · 08/12/2021 12:29

The point isn’t whether lamb or gravy could have been made GF or whatever. It’s the fucking cheek of it all.

If you don’t cook gluten free food regularly, you aren’t going to be making all the GF substitutions/cross-contamination avoidance practices as standard. You probably aren’t even thinking about them.

In my experience, it actually is the better and safer thing when people just make a specific GF dish. Because it might be really easy for me to think ‘well I can just use cornflour/GF flour and GF stock, and so on’, but that’s because I’m used to considering this stuff.

Gluten is in lots of stuff that people who aren’t used to cooking GF just don’t even consider (why would they?). And it’s very easy to accidentally cross contaminate things.

The same applies to dairy free and many other dietary issues. Given that even people who are doing this everyday still have to check things and be careful, it really is not fair to complain that someone decided to go the safe path and just make (or buy) a separate dish they’re sure is suitable alongside whatever they were cooking anyway.

Franca123 · 08/12/2021 12:27

I should also put a word in for the people who have allergies. I have a family member with the same allergy as me who when out will eat all sorts he shouldn't. Then just deals with consequences!!!!! Horrifies me. But if something looks really yummy, you convince yourself it's OK. I was in a right mess when I ate too many pastries in France. But making someone go to special effort isn't OK.

cadburyegg · 08/12/2021 12:24

YANBU, I have coeliac and am well used to fielding comments such as "surely just a little bit won't hurt" and "you need to start eating gluten to build up your tolerance again" thanks to people like this.

Franca123 · 08/12/2021 12:23

I've got an allergy which has become much less severe over the years. I always tell people to not go to any particular bother but please just nothing dripping in dairy (lasagne, creamy sauces etc......). I think it's incredibly rude what uout friend did. And it's my issue not the hosts. So i never expect anything special in the way of starter or pudding. I just hope there's enough of a main course that I can eat.

muddyford · 08/12/2021 12:22

A friend cooked for us and another couple. The male partner who was supposedly eating dairy-free, ate the separate cheese sauce with the steamed cauliflower. My friend was annoyed as obviously cauliflower cheese is nicer with the cauliflower cooked in the cheese sauce. He then had double cream with his crumble and some cheese and biscuits.

CovidCorvid · 08/12/2021 12:19

And the sad thing is people like this make it harder for genuine coeliacs. Dd would be vomiting for days if she had even a tiny bit of cross contamination. But if you had a friend like this some people could think that a bit of whatever won’t matter.