Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's bad friend has taken 10 month old to the football tonight?

169 replies

wineislife21 · 07/12/2021 21:53

With no ear defenders, surrounded by a crowd of people, in this December weather?
She always says he still wakes her up at night.. but has no bedtime routine and then does stuff like this!?

In my book that is very wrong, won't be gone till gone 10pm!!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
prynaithda21 · 08/12/2021 21:13

If the friend was a glory seeking supporter such as 99% of those who follow Manchester United, then at any age unreasonable.

I think that ear defenders should have been worn by the child, even though football crowds are nowhere near the noise of concerts.

LynetteScavo · 08/12/2021 20:53

It's not the way I parented my babies. But then my babies would have been miserable about it, and I would have very much regretted it. Presumably this isn't the first time she's taken the baby to a football match and she knows he'll be mellow.

Kite22 · 08/12/2021 20:47

@Magicalwoodlands

We live in the west Hmm

It’s like saying to Australian parents that British parents don’t slather their children in sun lotion every time they step outside.

It’s not great parenting because ten month olds are generally mobile: crawling and cruising.

It’s not great parenting because it’s cold, windy and wet: there are severe weather warnings in several areas of the country.

It’s not great parenting because it’s dull for the baby.

It’s not great parenting because it’s loud and noisy.

A ten week old bundles up under blankets and you might get away with it. Ten months - no.

Not taking very young children and babies to night time events like football matches and concerts isn’t some sort of anal adhering to rules of an oppressive British society. It’s just common sense.

I do agree with everything on here.

However, whether any of us agree or don't agree, I don't get the wrath about the OP doing a bit of pondering on MN. Isn't that what it is here for ?
You notice someone doing something you think is pretty poor for one reason or another or several and you begin to wonder if maybe it is you that is a bit out of kilter, or not, so you ask what others think.
It doesn't mean the OP is going to say anything to the other parent
It doesn't mean she needs to get a life or get out more- she was just pondering and thought she would garner opinion of others.

BurntO · 08/12/2021 17:58

I honestly can’t imagine starting a thread over something trivial about someone I call a friend. How long have you been friends??

thepeopleversuswork · 08/12/2021 17:54

I probably wouldn’t choose to do this but more because it would ruin it for me.

As a one off and if the baby is wrapped up I can’t see the problem and I think you’re being unnecessarily judgmental.

Offmyfence · 08/12/2021 17:27

@Chocolatewheatos

Can you imagine working for social services, seeing children routinely abused and neglected and having someone ring and waste your time to tell you that someone is taking their child to a football match? Wasting their already stretched resources is really showing you empathise with the poor children being neglected, abused and murdered by their caregivers. Maybe if so many people didn't use social services as a threat or punishment to others they wouldn't miss vital signs and more children would be saved.
Totally agree and as for a PP who thinks this is a SS issue, because she works in child protection, so is "overly cautious", that is a total waste of resource!
Chocolatewheatos · 08/12/2021 14:26

Can you imagine working for social services, seeing children routinely abused and neglected and having someone ring and waste your time to tell you that someone is taking their child to a football match?
Wasting their already stretched resources is really showing you empathise with the poor children being neglected, abused and murdered by their caregivers. Maybe if so many people didn't use social services as a threat or punishment to others they wouldn't miss vital signs and more children would be saved.

AryaStarkWolf · 08/12/2021 14:19

YABU, her child, her life, none of your business

Chocolatewheatos · 08/12/2021 14:17

I think sticking to a set bedtime routine is making a rod for your own back tbh. DS would love it if he was wrapped up and being cuddled. He's quite flexible in when and where he sleeps. He'd be asleep before we went in and would probably wake after a couple of hours, enjoy the atmosphere and go back to sleep when it finished. No harm done. Not like he has to be up for school is it.

PugInTheHouse · 08/12/2021 13:51

This thread just goes to show how different people are, I went to a match 4 days before having DS1 and we went together to the next match when he was 3 weeks. No dramas at all. Sat in the family section so not too rowdy. It's not bad parenting to do something even though it might be boring to your kids FFS. No wonder so many kids think the universe revolves around them these days!

It all really depends on your kids, DS1 was really into it from about 2, DS2 just fell asleep on my lap till he was about 5. There is bad language in the songs but we taught our DCs not to swear and they never ever swear in front of us or other adults. They both still go to the football and are 15 and 13.

The comparisons to Arthur are just outrageous. In any case it has been reported that people did speak up prior to his death so not sure of the relevance.

It may have been too cold, I get that, but no one would comment if the baby has been out for a couple of hours at a Christmas Market or firework display.

ShiftingSands21 · 08/12/2021 13:35

Idk about the ear defenders part but how can you be worried about a bedtime routine??

Cloudyzebra · 08/12/2021 13:22

I took mine to football matches regularly from a few days old. He slept through the night from about two months old, so it clearly did his sleep no harm. He never got upset at the football, so was clearly not cold or uncomfortable. The only time he stopped going to evening matches was when he was primary school age, and needed to be in bed at a sensible time to get up for school in the morning. I am really struggling to see what harm it could do. He is now a teenager, and usually chooses to come to matches with us so he clearly isn't too scarred by the experience.

OhGiveUp · 08/12/2021 13:17

Mine always went to football matches from birth. They were well wrapped up and suffered no harm whatsoever.
Comparing it with abused and murdered children is breathtakingly ridiculous.

5128gap · 08/12/2021 13:12

@ShirleyPhallus

Yeh I think that’s bad. She should have taken him to strip club and show him how to be a proper man.
Grin
blackcurrantjam · 08/12/2021 13:01

Comparing taking a baby to a football match to a child murdered by a disturbed woman is false equivalence, no? Extraordinary.

gogohm · 08/12/2021 11:44

@Changechangychange

There were always lots of babies and toddlers at sports in the USA too when mine were young - sports are a family affair. Love ice hockey used to watch it in Seattle indoors but it doesn't get as cold thereGrin

ReggaetonLente · 08/12/2021 11:06

No football matches here but I've taken mine to the basketball in the US and baseball and sumo wrestling in Japan from about 4 months albeit with ear defenders. Lots of other babies and toddlers there, every time.

BlackInk · 08/12/2021 10:27

At 10 months old my babies were marauding, clambering, wriggling little monsters at any time of the day. There's no way they would have stayed in a sling or buggy during a football match, even if it was past their bedtime. Good luck to your friend. Her baby might be a bit over tired and grumpy but that won't do any lasting harm. She's a braver woman than I though!

SpinsForGin · 08/12/2021 10:16

I agree. Mumsnet advise on babies is always bonkers. If I told my mum I was taking her grand daughter to a football match tonight, she'd probably call social services.
I'd be utterly ashamed if a relative of mine did this. What a waste of their time and resources.

No one I know would do this.

Doesn't make it wrong!!

People I know have their kids in bed in the evenings.
A one off of every now and then really isn't an issue.

Not sure why people on mumsnet are so intent on pretending that's strange or parochial in some way. Or indeed western ffs! I agree it's not abusive. But I would be alert to other signs in case it's part of a larger picture. This doesn't scream great parenting to me I'm afraid.

What a ridiculous over exaggeration! Such a bizarre reaction to someone taking a child to a football match.

Where we live, we have a number of events that go on until 10-11pm and the vast majority of children in the village stay up for these. They're often noisy and busy (party in the park and a huge brass band contest). Should we all expect a call from social services next time? Are we all shit parents??
Ridiculous

Offmyfence · 08/12/2021 10:09

I agree. Mumsnet advise on babies is always bonkers. If I told my mum I was taking her grand daughter to a football match tonight, she'd probably call social services.

I'd go NC if my mum did that, or even considered it. SS have lots of genuine cases to deal with and spreading them thinly is not helping anyone!

gersteddybears · 08/12/2021 10:08

@AllesAusLiebe omg can u imagine 😂 you wouldn't even be allowed in. Where wld u put said pram.

For those saying why isn't it appropriate:

Crowds is the big one for me. It can get a bit squishy/squashy on exit and even sometimes when you are leaving in the streets. There's often a lot of stairs to deal with at the stadium and a fair walk bk to the car or ur transport.
Young kids get bored, obvs baby won't know any different.
The language/songs can somewhat colourful for little ears.
I wldnt have thought the noise wld be too bad. I imagine for a young kid that wld be the fun part not sure re a baby. I remember my baby going mental with the kicking (while I was pregnant) at my last game which was an old firm game and the noise was unbelievable. I was wondering whether I shld have been there at all as it didn't feel right and I knew I was doing the right thing not going bk after that point.

I stopped going when I was 6months pregnant because it's also not an environment for a pregnant lady either. Previous to that I wld come in early and leave early to avoid the crowds. But even folk getting up and down to the toilet and me having to get up and down to let them past and it's tight so they wld brush my bump. I wasn't visibly pregnant at that point either my bump as was small and it was winter so my coat hid it.

gogohm · 08/12/2021 10:04

@SpinsForGin

Ours went everywhere with us, they didn't have a sitter or nursery until over 3 ... live sports, concerts, the opera, not set bed time and slept with us ... well adjusted adults now. Oh and dd sings opera professionallyGrin

Attachment parenting it used to be called

Changechangychange · 08/12/2021 10:03

We started taking DS to ice hockey games when he was about 18 months old. In Canada, so we were out in -10C on the way there and back, and around 5C indoors during the matches. He loved it! Obviously wrapped up warm in a snow suit. Far more interested in the loud music, pyrotechnics, and mascots than the actual game play, but still had a great time. Loads of other kids there too.

I and the rest of Canada will await our visit from social services.

Franca123 · 08/12/2021 10:03

@Magicalwoodlands

Mumsnet has a bit of a strange view towards babies in general, I find. It’s true that tiny babies are portable and can fit in with what you’re doing within reason, but ten month olds don’t.

I don’t think that babies need to be tucked in at 7 on the dot and mine certainly isn’t. But being contained in s pushchair somewhere cold and loud at night isn’t great parenting and it’s stupid to pretend it doesn’t matter because it’s only a baby.

I agree. Mumsnet advise on babies is always bonkers. If I told my mum I was taking her grand daughter to a football match tonight, she'd probably call social services. No one I know would do this. People I know have their kids in bed in the evenings. Not sure why people on mumsnet are so intent on pretending that's strange or parochial in some way. Or indeed western ffs! I agree it's not abusive. But I would be alert to other signs in case it's part of a larger picture. This doesn't scream great parenting to me I'm afraid.
SpinsForGin · 08/12/2021 09:55

It completely depends on that age. My DB started going when he was about 8/9. He could understand what was going on, had a team he followed and actually got something from the experience.
My DS is 7 and has been going since he was a baby. He's understood what's going on for years. He loves his trips to the football with his dad.

I go now with DH and people being school-age kids but I’ve never seen babies/toddlers there. Largely, I expect because it’s more trouble than it’s worth and pointless.

A baby won’t have a clue what’s going on, has no preference for which team and won’t get anything from it.

We only took DS during the toddler years if both of us were going because it was hard work. He starting going with just dad aged 4 and was fine.
I'm pretty sure people aren't taking babies because they're expecting them to support the team 😂😂😂 DH took DS as a baby when we had no childcare. He was portable in his baby carrier and it meant DH didn't miss matches when I was working.

Pushchairs wouldn’t be allowed in the ground and some of the facilities (as I said I’ve never seen baby changes) aren’t always the best.
I agree that pushchairs won't be allowed but you can make do with changing facilities. You can never guarantee that the changing facilities will be decent anywhere so you just go prepared 🤷🏼‍♀️