Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think 2 year olds should do as they're told?

236 replies

SleepingStandingUp · 07/12/2021 18:10

And that if they don't it's a reflection on lax parenting? I'm taking not climbing and sitting in high sides, not going upstairs when told not to / coming down when told to, sitting at the table to eat, not pushing each other?

AIBU to expect that we'll raised two year olds can do all this and the fact mine don't is because I'm doing something wrong and therefore to ask how to make them behave??

OP posts:
Suretobe · 08/12/2021 06:36

No advice - just to say you are being completely unreasonable and those little old ladies telling you that you are doing a good job know what they are talking about.

Kanfuzed123 · 08/12/2021 06:05

Erm…. I think you’re not only being unreasonable but also ridiculous. At 2 they have 0 impulse control and their comprehension is still limited. Rather than punish bad behaviour, it should be about rewarding good behaviour i.e kind hands and listening ears. Any ‘punishment’ should be about natural consequences, ie hitting toy against coffee table, told no, if it continues they get removed from that space.

Not the point of your post but telling a 2 year old to go upstairs and come downstairs implies they arent supervised… not sure a 2 year old is old enough for that tbh…

toastywarm · 08/12/2021 04:58

it's not the kids that are behaving badly.

You are placing too much expectation on them. We were all 2 once.

Oh and wait till you get to the ''fucking fours''

toastywarm · 08/12/2021 04:55

@SleepingStandingUp

And that if they don't it's a reflection on lax parenting? I'm taking not climbing and sitting in high sides, not going upstairs when told not to / coming down when told to, sitting at the table to eat, not pushing each other?

AIBU to expect that we'll raised two year olds can do all this and the fact mine don't is because I'm doing something wrong and therefore to ask how to make them behave??

you are in for a shock.

You can explain to them that pushing is not nice and we don't do that to each other but you cannot expect a toddler to comply before they are 3yrs old.

they do not need to sit at the table at that age fgs. way too strict.

let them be children and ease up a bit.

snowpiercer · 08/12/2021 04:21

I left my unruly 2 yearold with a nanny and he was literally like a angel. My mum, the nanny, my in-laws don't put boundaries, rules or parent him like we do or don't follow through threats. I leave him with my mum and he is like a angel. I've had my in laws comment on how he behaves differently when me or DH is around but particularly me. I don't know why it's like this because he has great understanding and reasoning with everyone else apart from me or DH at home. Maybe it's because of the bond we have where he knows we stick through thick and thin no matter what and when he is with other people and we aren't around, he must behave. He sits on their laps lol and doesn't get up and then as soon as he sees us, he goes nuts lol

Laserbird16 · 08/12/2021 04:14

That's a hoot Grin well best of luck with that

Marvellousmadness · 08/12/2021 02:13

Its part nature part nurture

Discipline is important at this stage . 2yo are very capable of understanding and need to learn tons of shit. My kids never had terrible two's . They were very well behaved. My oldest had delayed terrible two's at 4 though 🤣

MyDcAreMarvel · 08/12/2021 01:42

I have twins , they thrive off each other. I am guessing you have identical boys.

Atlanticli · 08/12/2021 01:39

They're supposed to be inquisitive about everything.... so that means finding out what their own bodies can do, what objects can do, what people can do. Let them explore. Guidance is great and needed bit we can't talk about punishment at this age.

Their trying behaviour won't be forever. I'm currently telling myself the same and I have the evidence in the form of my older DC.

Good luck!

PrincessNutella · 08/12/2021 01:32

I am still ashamed of myself for a time out I gave my utterly uncomprehending 2 year old. He was naughty, but in retrospect, he truly did not understand why. He is now in his late 20s. I hope he has forgiven me!

Franca123 · 08/12/2021 01:26

It's so variable! My son is actually very good and people are amazed. But in all honesty, that's him rather than anything we've done. We don't punish. He's just quite calm and not a risk taker. By nature, he's quite congenial. I've seen his mates and some of them are terrors! But I can't see anything the poor parents are doing 'wrong'. It's luck of the draw at this age in my opinion.

Blossom64265 · 08/12/2021 01:24

I started laughing a little when I read the title.

I started laughing a lot when I read the OP.

2 year olds do not behave. They do not follow direction well. You will have to guide them over and over and over again. The rare 2 year old who is perfectly polite and perfectly behaved is not the product of ideal parenting, they are the result of genetics, solar winds, and a butterfly fluttering its wings 300 years ago. and

Mypathtriedtokillme · 08/12/2021 01:19

@Hoesbeforebroes

2 year olds are arseholes and I hate to tell you this now, but 3 year olds are no better.

I assume you've posted in response to being criticised?

Toddlers are the reason some animals eat their young. (Imagine having 15 of them at once)
Mypathtriedtokillme · 08/12/2021 01:17

They should in Theory…

But my practical experience says “hahahaha are you fucking delusional?”

Mine once had a screaming losing her shit sobbing tantrum about the wind blowing off her hat. It was a windy day, her hat had a tie on it and was just behind her head.

My oldest used to freak the fuck out when ever my Dh’s aunt or neighbour talked.
Her greatest fear was tiny elderly Italians chatting.

Hoesbeforebroes · 08/12/2021 01:12

2 year olds are arseholes and I hate to tell you this now, but 3 year olds are no better.

I assume you've posted in response to being criticised?

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 08/12/2021 01:03

@EatYourVegetables

They’re like tiny tyrannical drunks.

Like teenagers but less reasonable. Or like Henry VIII: “But I want that wife!! Want her want her want her. Wait… no didn’t want that one, want a different one!!!” They will scream for half an hour because you’ve stopped them from running into a road, or because you broke their cheese in half, or because the cup that was their favourite yesterday is no longer their favourite and why didn’t you guess that.

They’re terrifying.

🤣🤣 sounds like you've met my youngest.
Ilovecats1234 · 07/12/2021 23:58

Hmm, no I wouldn't. From what I've read and experienced toddlers don't actually listen to what your saying a lot of the time. They need repetition. I personally believe unless you're one stroke and you're in time out (which for me is too hard core given their brains struggle to listen all the time) then they simply won't always do those things. I think repetition and engaging eye contact and focus before repeating something is key. Equally a chance to listen before consequences eg timeout. That's how we operate. I sometimes give too many chances before timeout and she plays me for a fool (generally whilst getting ready for work!) but it'll come. Two is still so young. Their brains are taking in so much all the time and listening to you and rules isn't always top priority. Throw in hungry, tired, bored, cold etc and you'll have even less joy. Don't stress. If they're kind and listen a bit and understand the general achievable rules you'll be fine. I find when they're that bit older you can explain more and really give consequences and they understand more. Two is terrible and brutal. Just don't expect too much and try to remember how the world must look from their point of view. The grumpy lady may be making a face but to your two year old the funny looking carpet may just look far too interesting to sit at the table.

Sh05 · 07/12/2021 23:56

Two year olds are mood swinging little terrors/ angels.
My DD was two in September, sometimes she listens then says okay and obeys, other times she screams and says I yavan idea mummy and continues doing whatever it is she's not supposed to do.
( She doesn't really know what having an idea means but it's so cute the way she says it, I'm sure she knows we find it cute and thinks we won't try and stop her from whatever she's doing wrong.)

SarahAndQuack · 07/12/2021 23:45

[quote SleepingStandingUp]@SarahAndQuack the bus has the same effect. They wave and say bye to anyone who walks past, they stare with their big blue eyes at people then pretend to go shy, they are utterly utterly adorable. Because no one heard them screaming in the bus stop and I'm singing at them to keep them quiet. But people always wave and smile back, say how lovely they are and old ladies always tell me I'm doing a good job. The kind of idiot who declares "omg, I'd kill myself if I had twins" is quite rsre[/quote]
Grin Oh, that made me laugh because I relate! Yep, definitely this.

Honestly, I am sure most people think they are adorable children. I do know where you are coming from in feeling they're awful, but you are doing a good job. You just need to hear it more.

SleepingStandingUp · 07/12/2021 23:41

@SarahAndQuack the bus has the same effect. They wave and say bye to anyone who walks past, they stare with their big blue eyes at people then pretend to go shy, they are utterly utterly adorable. Because no one heard them screaming in the bus stop and I'm singing at them to keep them quiet. But people always wave and smile back, say how lovely they are and old ladies always tell me I'm doing a good job. The kind of idiot who declares "omg, I'd kill myself if I had twins" is quite rsre

OP posts:
SleepingStandingUp · 07/12/2021 23:36

@Hall84

I haven't read the thread yet but after 3 nights of terrible sleep and awful tantrums by a just turned 21 month old who objects to the word no and fish fingers in equal measures I'm hoping it's not my parenting!
Sending sleep dust and hugs
OP posts:
SleepingStandingUp · 07/12/2021 23:31

@LunaAndHerMoonDragons

OP as far as timeout goes I tried putting myself in it a few times when they were little and I still couldn't get any peace there. It's not you, they're being little kids. Sorry I missed the second bit of your post, I was too busy laughing at the title 😁.
Yeah I'd never get away with time out, their Maaaaaaam is solid and loud 😂😂
OP posts:
CoodleMoodle · 07/12/2021 23:30

When my DD was 2 she was an absolute angel. I was never smug about it because I knew it might not last, and I tried not to take it for granted, but I still did. She was an awful baby, then a superstar from 18mo (coincided with us doing sleep training and her actually sleeping for more than 45mins at a time) until about 3.5, then she had a stroppy threenager year or so before going back to being an angel. She's 7 now and is still very well behaved and generally a delight. Not looking forward to the teenage years but enjoying her while I can.

However. DS is 3 and has been a nightmare since 18mo. Before that he was pretty much a dream baby (sleep issues solved much earlier). He's only just starting to come out the other side, but he had a 45min tantrum this morning because DH said hello to him. He was a proper terrible two, is now a threenager, and we didn't do anything different with him. I adore him but he's hard work.

SarahAndQuack · 07/12/2021 23:19

Sorry, this is such a long thread and I've not taken it all in - but OP, the thing I cling to is that other people almost never think your children are as badly behaved as you do. They are so frustrating at this age! You sit there fuming, thinking you are a terrible parent. But chances are, most people around you won't even notice. They may even think your children are adorable and charming.

If you possible can, I highly recommend taking them to the supermarket on a weekday morning. Where I am, this means it's less busy, but often the people who shop at this time are not in such a rush. You get lots of positive feedback, and your children will love it - but you won't get in people's way. It's really good.

logsonlogsoff · 07/12/2021 23:09

@DeepaBeesKit. We gave up on the ‘naughty’ time out step when we caught DS 4 and DD 2 playing the naughty step game and doing not bad impersonations of us losing our shit… the power was gone… if it has ever existed!

Swipe left for the next trending thread