Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To never send MIL photos again?

339 replies

babybrain77 · 07/12/2021 16:48

This is actually a AIBU for DH.

DH feels extremely strongly about photos of the kids on social media. He has worked in cyber security and always knew that he didn't want pictures of his kids online (including shared by non secure message like whatsapp). It's been a pain in the backside, but I have supported him on it - never send pictures around or posted them anywhere. He found a secure messaging app which would allow us to share pictures with family and friends but which did not allow the pictures to be shared or stored. He set this up for anyone who wanted it and we've managed fine for 3 years.

MIL didnt want to use the app. So we have been printing off and giving her pictures of the kids whenever we see her, and also sending regular pictures in the post during lockdown.

DH recently sent a family friend a message congratulating them on the birth of a grandchild. The family friend replied saying thank you and "it has been so lovely watching your kids grow up from afar" (they live in Australia).

DH doesn't have Facebook so I searched for his mum (we aren't Facebook friends - I also don't really use it). His mum has been taking pictures of the hard copy photos we've sent and posting them on Facebook, freely viewable to all (no privacy restrictions). She has uploaded literally hundreds of pictures.

DH has explicitly explained why he doesn't want pictures online to his mum. He confronted her about it and she shrugged and said "I have to be able to show off my grandkids". He is spitting mad and has said he will never give her another picture, to which she has kicked off massively. IHBU?

OP posts:
NorthSouthcatlady · 07/12/2021 18:47

Your children = your rules. MIL knows the way your husband feels but decided to ignore it. Is she normally keen to ignore other people’s feelings and just do what suits her?

2022HereWeCome · 07/12/2021 18:46

OP, your Mil shouldn't have gone against your wishes but I think you will need to rethink your stance a little. It seems a little extreme.
When your DC start school there will be a whole raft of things that they will miss out on if you don't give consent for photos. I had to accept this the DS started reception. I am mindful of privacy and personal information but at some point you have determine what is more important, your kid not being allowed to be in the school photo / filmed nativity play or security concerns

Nanny0gg · 07/12/2021 18:44

@babybrain77

When you send pictures on WhatsApp, the image is on the recipient's phone. Often people have their phone set to backup to the cloud, at which point that image becomes part of the data packet held by big tech. Since we don't pay for any of these services we use, the data is the "product" and we lose all control of it (dummed down explanation for me!)

For those who have asked what we'll do when they are older (they are currently 3 and 1) - that's a bridge we will cross closer to the time. DH's hope and concern was that we would provide them with the same starting point that our generation had - the choice of what to share and when at a point where they were old enough to give informed consent to the sharing of their data.

The app we use is Wickr. You can prevent screenshotting and the data is automatically "burned" after a set period of time.

You're going to have to stop her taking actual physical photos when she sees them too.
Monkeymilkshake · 07/12/2021 18:44

I think it’s different to a 15yo putting their pictures online like a pp has said.
The child has no control over their image in this case; and something that might seem funny to parents to share might not be for the child.
I work in security/compliance and the number of things people can do with a picture is scary!
Re whatsapp, everytime you send a picture to someone it automatically saves it in their back ups (so google pics, apple photo… whatever you use) and for fb, anyone can take a screenshot of the picture and you (the poster) would know no better.
There are people in the class fb group that post pictures of their kids all the time (you know where they are at all times!), in the pool, at grandads/nanny, going to favourite park… it’s scary why they think this is ok to share with 100s of strangers online.

Most people probably just click through all this and pay no notice but you just need 1 weirdo!
I’m 100% with your DH

babybrain77 · 07/12/2021 18:42

@HollowTalk of course not, but I am suggesting it should be her choice whether/how/when to share pictures with you.

OP posts:
westofnormal · 07/12/2021 18:41

They're not under any obligation to go along with his paranoia. You can choose to fall out with them over it but it will just make you (or him) look worse.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 07/12/2021 18:40

MiL knows of your DH's concerns as she refused to use the secure app and has accepted printed copies of the pictures

Actually that's a point - why was she against using this secure app?

I'm not very techy, but if DH could send them using this, presumably MIL could have done the same when forwarding the images to friends?

luckylavender · 07/12/2021 18:40

@Bathmat1 - you can forward any WhatsApp message.

TheOccupier · 07/12/2021 18:39

Does MIL never babysit the children? Don't you think she will take photos if and when she does this? Would you deny her a relationship with her DGCs over it?

Expecting people to download and set up a special app just so you can send them pictures of your children and make those pictures that self-destruct after being viewed is one of the most paranoid, self-centred and PFB things I've seen on here - and that's saying a lot.

How is sharing pictures of a small child on Facebook today going to compromise their privacy in 15-20 years time? Do you think Facebook will even still exist then and even if it does, how would photos shared by their granny in 2021 be linked to any accounts they might set up for themselves in 2041? It just makes no sense at all.

meadowbleu · 07/12/2021 18:39

It's two separate issues isn't it. The security and protection of identity which DH seeks to protect and MIL's betrayal of trust and refusal to ackowledge her deceit.

Regardless of whether anyone thinks DH's measures and rule is too strict, his mother is totally out of order and I'd want the photos taken down too.

Prescottdanni123 · 07/12/2021 18:38

YANBU. I would support your husband in this. He may seem excessive to some, but working in cyber security means he probably knows loads of stuff about social media security that the rest of us don't.

And even if he was being excessive (which I don't think he is) they are his kids and she should have respected his wishes.

babybrain77 · 07/12/2021 18:38

@Unihorn its also used by governments (not that the two categories are mutually exclusive Grin)

OP posts:
lesenfantsdelesperance · 07/12/2021 18:38

@crystal1717

You don't own your children. If grandparents should have more rights.

He sounds v controlling.

Poor kids

I pity the kids whose parents plaster their faces all over social media. Especially instagrammers. It's sad. I feel not in the slightest bit sorry for people who get receive regular photos of their grandchildren in the post.
crystal1717 · 07/12/2021 18:35

There's literally millions of kids on sm inc all mine. Then child models in all clothing and holiday websites.

I really really don't see the risk.
You lot should don your tin hats. It's a wonder you ever cross the road for fear of the risk.

Lockdownbear · 07/12/2021 18:34

@crystal1717

You don't own your children. If grandparents should have more rights.

He sounds v controlling.

Poor kids

Grandparents don't own them either.

Back in the day your childhood photos of which there were few because of money, lay in a box in the back of a cupboard.

Would you like anyone to have unfiltered access to that box and a shed load more photos of you?

lesenfantsdelesperance · 07/12/2021 18:33

@HollowTalk

My sister-in-law lives down south and I am in the north. Are you suggesting that she shouldn't be able to text me photos of her new grandchild?

Is your husband just objecting to photos being on social media or actually sending any digitally at all?

Are you suggesting that your sister in law wanting to send you photos trumps the parent's (possible) desire for her not to?
MaHBroon · 07/12/2021 18:31

@ModelMinnie

There really was no need for your rather rude ‘wow’.

crystal1717 · 07/12/2021 18:31

You don't own your children. If grandparents should have more rights.

He sounds v controlling.

Poor kids

MaHBroon · 07/12/2021 18:30

i understand about not posting photos of kids / babies undressed / using the potty etc

I understand this but that’s about it.

yourestandingonmyneck · 07/12/2021 18:30

@ModelMinnie

What "bad thing" do you think will happen, because some granny with about 10 friends (who she knows personally), has uploaded some photo's of her Grandkids?

Are people really that naive? Admittedly I work in IT, but do you honestly not understand what can happen in situations like this if you freely upload personal data / images to a privately owned, foreign-owned social media platform whose main aim is to make money from the data you're sharing?

Wow.

What money can they make from pictures of random kids? Genuine question, I think a lot of us on this post obviously aren't aware of the dangers.
BungleandGeorge · 07/12/2021 18:29

When making an assessment I think you have to consider the negative side of not ever allowing people to see photos. Not allowing people to have any pics at school or hobbies because you don’t want your child on line and that affects the entire group. Consider the likelihood of people getting hold of your pics- which obviously varies depending on whether they’re on fb with no security or whatsapp with encryption etc. Think about what shots they are. Anyone can take a picture of your child in a public place without you knowing. Im not sure full censorship is the best way. I would be interested what he will do when they go to secondary school and everyone has a phone and is on social media.

Unihorn · 07/12/2021 18:28

@Lorriestakingppe

I am a bit baffled too. My DC's are mid teens now and I put the odd picture up set on friends only. There must be literally billions of photos on line, why would anyone be bothered about my boring family at the park or whatever? Intrigued to know....
Paedophiles can doctor publicly available images of children and sell them. Putting images, full names, dates of birth, relative names etc of children online creates the perfect opportunity for identity theft. False legal documents are sold for thousands.

Wickr is used by criminals to exchange information so is pretty secure Grin

babybrain77 · 07/12/2021 18:28

I don't think the concern is the images being put to dark uses (although I'm sure there's an element of that), so much as a desire for the kids not to have an enormous data profile associated with them before they are old enough to consent.

OP posts:
MaHBroon · 07/12/2021 18:28

@ModelMinnie

What "bad thing" do you think will happen, because some granny with about 10 friends (who she knows personally), has uploaded some photo's of her Grandkids?

Are people really that naive? Admittedly I work in IT, but do you honestly not understand what can happen in situations like this if you freely upload personal data / images to a privately owned, foreign-owned social media platform whose main aim is to make money from the data you're sharing?

Wow.

Yes. I’m that naive.

I will say however that I’m given free reign with my grandchildren and because of that if my children ever said please don’t do x y or z with the children I would listen to them and make sure I never did it.

I genuinely don’t have a clue about cyberspace or things internet related except at a very basic level.

HollowTalk · 07/12/2021 18:26

My sister-in-law lives down south and I am in the north. Are you suggesting that she shouldn't be able to text me photos of her new grandchild?

Is your husband just objecting to photos being on social media or actually sending any digitally at all?