Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To never send MIL photos again?

339 replies

babybrain77 · 07/12/2021 16:48

This is actually a AIBU for DH.

DH feels extremely strongly about photos of the kids on social media. He has worked in cyber security and always knew that he didn't want pictures of his kids online (including shared by non secure message like whatsapp). It's been a pain in the backside, but I have supported him on it - never send pictures around or posted them anywhere. He found a secure messaging app which would allow us to share pictures with family and friends but which did not allow the pictures to be shared or stored. He set this up for anyone who wanted it and we've managed fine for 3 years.

MIL didnt want to use the app. So we have been printing off and giving her pictures of the kids whenever we see her, and also sending regular pictures in the post during lockdown.

DH recently sent a family friend a message congratulating them on the birth of a grandchild. The family friend replied saying thank you and "it has been so lovely watching your kids grow up from afar" (they live in Australia).

DH doesn't have Facebook so I searched for his mum (we aren't Facebook friends - I also don't really use it). His mum has been taking pictures of the hard copy photos we've sent and posting them on Facebook, freely viewable to all (no privacy restrictions). She has uploaded literally hundreds of pictures.

DH has explicitly explained why he doesn't want pictures online to his mum. He confronted her about it and she shrugged and said "I have to be able to show off my grandkids". He is spitting mad and has said he will never give her another picture, to which she has kicked off massively. IHBU?

OP posts:
DBI78 · 08/12/2021 01:30

Whatever people opinions of photos on social media the fact is this was your choice as parents and she has blatantly ignored that. I would also not give pictures, but does she never take her own pictures or spend time alone with kids?

Avarua · 08/12/2021 01:20

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

westofnormal · 08/12/2021 01:16

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Willowkins · 08/12/2021 00:15

I agree with your DH - my kids are now young adults so can make their own mind up (and choose not to) - but for years we got pushback for not allowing their photos on Facebook, school websites etc.

SingItToWinIt · 08/12/2021 00:15

Presumably those of you who think what MIL did is fine are also comfortable with strangers taking photos of your kids at school, in the park, on the beach, swimming etc?

I don't think what the MIL did was fine - but I'm not concerned at the thought of strangers taking photos of my kids at all. So yes I suppose you'd say I'm comfortable with it.

babybrain77 · 08/12/2021 00:04

Thank you for all the replies, they are helpful.

Some of the concerns seem a tad of a reach to me. He is not controlling, abusive, living a double life etc. He just doesn't want pictures of the kids online.

Re. Wickr - can't respond to the questions as I don't know. I asked him to find some forum he was comfortable for me to use to send pictures to my immediate family and close friends abroad and that was his choice. His preference would have been none, but it wasn't feasible for me to post pictures out to aunts/cousins/sister who are out of the country.

OP posts:
CelestiaNoctis · 07/12/2021 23:28

I would go no contact to be honest. That is massive and insane. I would make her take every single one down and then block her.

ChorltonWheelie · 07/12/2021 22:47

Wickr is owned by Amazon so instead of feeding the Facebook (now Meta) data lake you are feeding the Amazon one.

You pays your money (or of course dont) and makes your choice as to which conglomerate you give your data to

friedeggandsauce · 07/12/2021 22:42

@Bitofachinwag I've photos of me in the paper growing up and my children have been too- they love looking back at clippings. May not be to the extent of social media but photos are around

noodlezoodle · 07/12/2021 22:37

Presumably those of you who think what MIL did is fine are also comfortable with strangers taking photos of your kids at school, in the park, on the beach, swimming etc.?

Hortuslover · 07/12/2021 22:34

@PinkWaferBiscuit @lesenfantsdelesperance
I meant in general to all the posts and those with security knowledge. I keep my children off social media, I don’t have Facebook, I use Instagram but the kids don’t go on there. I never really thought about school and nursery funnily enough. I’m in agreement with op and her dh which has now made me think I want to withdraw my consent.

365sleepstogo · 07/12/2021 22:25

Whether your husband is excessive or not is irrelevant.
School photos is irrelevant.
What the children will do when they see teenagers is irrelevant.

Your DH clearly expressed what the boundaries are and his mother totally flouted them. She put photos on social media without the parents’ consent (quite the opposite).
I would be absolutely livid.

PrincessNutella · 07/12/2021 22:17

This is the best sort of in-law problem. Your husband is mad at his own mother , you agree with him, she was clearly out of line, and all you have to do is be a good wife!

EveningOverRooftops · 07/12/2021 22:13

@babybrain77

When you send pictures on WhatsApp, the image is on the recipient's phone. Often people have their phone set to backup to the cloud, at which point that image becomes part of the data packet held by big tech. Since we don't pay for any of these services we use, the data is the "product" and we lose all control of it (dummed down explanation for me!)

For those who have asked what we'll do when they are older (they are currently 3 and 1) - that's a bridge we will cross closer to the time. DH's hope and concern was that we would provide them with the same starting point that our generation had - the choice of what to share and when at a point where they were old enough to give informed consent to the sharing of their data.

The app we use is Wickr. You can prevent screenshotting and the data is automatically "burned" after a set period of time.

I’m with you on this one and your DH.

I don’t share pics of my DC and it’s caused great family issues because extended family didn’t follow my rules. To the point a sister caused a great fuck ton of drama saying I’d ruined her celebration after she was told explicitly not to put pics of my DC online. Properly flounced from FB etc after I reported the pictures of my DC.

Anyway, I stopped attending family events as she’d try to get pictures of DC (who doesn’t like pics taken either but that’s another story).

I really want DC to not have their entire life splayed out blow by blow. I don’t even refer to my DC by their actual names on social media if I do. Just the boy/girl.

I also work with vulnerable adults. Mostly learning difficulty, some with no understanding of boundaries so not having that stuff public or even in a private FB protects me and DC for any potential overlap as I have had individuals look me up on FB.

There’s countless reasons not to overshare online.

Abusive Ex, stalkers/potential stalkers, privacy, jobs we do, risks to new employment etc.

DrierThanANunsNasty · 07/12/2021 22:02

For those saying “what’s the worst that can happen?” Unfortunately, a close friend of mine recently found a Facebook group and page that shared pictures of young girls taken off of Facebook profiles/profile pictures etc. Her daughter was on there. The man running it said his perversions were a mental health condition and he should be allowed to take these photos and share them (he messaged her that when she asked him to take the photos down).

She and dozens of her friends, including me, reported it and Facebook said it wasn’t breaking any rules. The pictures are ‘harmless’ family photos, but the intent is very clear.

Please be careful where you’re sharing your photos.

Bitofachinwag · 07/12/2021 21:55

@BossLady007

This is possibly the weirdest thread I've ever read on here.

I'd be far more worried about a DH who wants no trace of a family anywhere. Whether that is work related or personal.

" no trace of a family anywhere" ? You don't mean " anywhere", do you? You mean " visible online".

You make it sound like unless you have your photo on the internet you don't exist.....

Juneberries · 07/12/2021 21:52

@BossLady007

This is possibly the weirdest thread I've ever read on here.

I'd be far more worried about a DH who wants no trace of a family anywhere. Whether that is work related or personal.

I don’t any evidence that I even have a child as I work with people who have severe mental health problems, some of whom have committed offences against children amongst other things like stalking.

I’m a total and complete weirdo right?! Obviously my MIL’s right to show off comes before the children’s safety?

There are many many reasons someone might not want their child’s image and information in accessible places, and it frankly is their decision as parents and no one else’s beeswax.

Bitofachinwag · 07/12/2021 21:51

@2022HereWeCome

OP, your Mil shouldn't have gone against your wishes but I think you will need to rethink your stance a little. It seems a little extreme. When your DC start school there will be a whole raft of things that they will miss out on if you don't give consent for photos. I had to accept this the DS started reception. I am mindful of privacy and personal information but at some point you have determine what is more important, your kid not being allowed to be in the school photo / filmed nativity play or security concerns
Well, this is wrong. Nobody should have to choose being safe or being in the school photo! I don't understand this recent trend to film or photograph everything and putting it online. Most of us on here didn't grow up like this. Did we miss out?
PinkWaferBiscuit · 07/12/2021 21:47

@BossLady007

This is possibly the weirdest thread I've ever read on here.

I'd be far more worried about a DH who wants no trace of a family anywhere. Whether that is work related or personal.

I'm so confused people find the idea of not sharing their child's photos publicly online odd, controlling or worrying.

It's not exactly uncommon to want to maintain your child's privacy until they have a say in the matter.

I find it much stranger people willingly and freely post so much onto social media when their children have no say in the matter and which will still be there for all the world to find decades later.

ShinyHappyPoster · 07/12/2021 21:47

Should MIL have ignored his wishes? No.

But it's kind of odd that your DH works in cyber security but thinks there's a way to share pics safely. There isn't. Plus the logic seems flawed. At the start, you said it was about your DCs not having a data footprint or profile without their consent. Then you said it was about ensuring people with access to the pics didn't have location details and meta data. It's fuzzy logic and that makes me wonder if there are other aspects of family life and relationships that your DH tries to micro-manage and control by bombarding you with different reasoning until you acquiesce. If that is the case then I have a sneaking sympathy with your MIL.

Summerfun54321 · 07/12/2021 21:44

Such a good point about WhatsApp pictures going to the cloud on various peoples phones and being stored and held. I’d honestly never thought of that….
Your MIL is either incredibly thick or incredibly deceitful.

BossLady007 · 07/12/2021 21:43

This is possibly the weirdest thread I've ever read on here.

I'd be far more worried about a DH who wants no trace of a family anywhere. Whether that is work related or personal.

Bitofachinwag · 07/12/2021 21:40

:15BertramLacey

I'm not a Nanna yet, but will be within the next few years, and I'd be so disappointed if my children told me that I couldn't send photo's of my grandchildren to my life long friends. I mean, why?

It doesn't matter why if the parents don't want you to! On the other hand, why do you need to send photos of your grandchildren to your friends? Just show them photos when you see them, if they really do want to see photos of your grandchildren.

thetruthisout · 07/12/2021 21:39

@BlondeDogLady

I never understand this. What "bad thing" do you think will happen, because some granny with about 10 friends (who she knows personally), has uploaded some photo's of her Grandkids?
I've only briefly rtft but OP said that although she isn't friends with MIL on fb she can still see the photos MiL has posted. That means EVERYONE ELSE on Facebook can also see the photos.
BertramLacey · 07/12/2021 21:15

I'm not a Nanna yet, but will be within the next few years, and I'd be so disappointed if my children told me that I couldn't send photo's of my grandchildren to my life long friends. I mean, why?

That's about what you want, not about what your children or grandchildren want. When I look for childhood photos of me, there are none on the internet. I was in my 20s when it was invented. The OP has said she wants her children to have that choice, to know that there are no photos of them out there, unless they specifically want to share them. It's not entirely about nefarious intent - it's about controlling what's available.

As a teenager at school I was bullied enough. I can't imagine what it would have been like if the school bullies had been able to get hold of a photo of seven year old me dressed as a unicorn, or whatever. And yes, that might happen anyway. but you do reduce the risk if you're careful.