Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just found out my dad threw away all of our school pictures

58 replies

Christmasbirdchristmasherd · 07/12/2021 14:22

School pictures, cards we made, photos of us stuck in taken at school, our school work we saved over the years, postcards from my dead nans holidays sent to us cards, handprints, self portraits. the lot. All of it I wanted to take, put in folders to look through easily.
I wasn't allowed to take it though.
Now the whole lot has been binned. I feel sick. I know some people aren't sentimental but I am and my parents know it. Me and my siblings look through it fairly frequently. Every few years or so
I was looking for something specific, a little book I had made when I was a child about the romans because my son is learning about it now and I wanted to show him. Its in a dump somewhere after being saved for decades.

I don't understand if he wanted to free up space why not ask me to come and get it. I wanted to take it before so he knew I wanted it.
And we go through it all often enough for it to not be deemed junk.
I feel sick.

The hpuse is cluttered up with all kinds of shit but they want to make room by dumping all of my childhood treasures.
I wouldn't have minded if they were thrown at the time but they have been kept for years and I'm an adult now. I have asked for it and been denied but it has been thrown away without my knowledge and without giving me a chance to take it to my own house.

I actually feel like never talking to my dad again, he has form for this.
When nan died we spent a few weeks going through her things, again I was told I couldn't take the lot to sort at my house, and so half was dumped without me knowing. AGAIN, I had asked for it all, AGAIN I was refused, AGAIN it was dumped.

ps I know it sounds like it but I'm not actually a hoarder.

OP posts:
whitehorsesdonotlie · 07/12/2021 16:00

Bloody hell, that's an awful thing to do. What goes through people's minds when they do something like that?

And it does seem to be men who do this... Nasty.

Fl0w3ry · 07/12/2021 15:59

It’s horrible, isn’t it? There were barely any photos of me as a child anyway, but my mother threw away every single one of them in one of her rages.
Your dad is a mystery though, why did he keep it all in the first place if he was just going to throw it all away when you asked for it?
That seems particularly cruel. I would go NC/LC with him.
How did you find out he threw it all away?

ManicPixie · 07/12/2021 15:58

@lunar1

It's an awful feeling isn't it. My mum threw everything of mine and my brothers away because she didn't want to be reminded of my dad. There literally isn't a single picture of us from that time in existence, not even a baby photo.

I don't blame you for being angry at all.

Woah. That's really, really weird.
MLMshouldbeillegal · 07/12/2021 15:57

@Skeumorph

He has form? Then he's not unsentimental or 'anti clutter' at all, he's nasty.

So yes I'd tell him you're done. Spiteful man, spiteful actions - there's no need to contact me again, thanks.

I'm sorry.

I also disagree with this interpretation. Yes the Dad might be a right piece of work. But perhaps more likely he is the sort of practical person who cannot see why on earth anyone would want decades old school work or drawings from their childhood. It's not that he's actively thought "Aha, I'll show her, I'll chuck ALL of her schoolwork just to be mean and horrid", it's that he's come across a massive pile of stuff he perceives as clutter, junk, rubbish.

Thoughtless perhaps. Spiteful probably not. Same goes with clearing grandparents' house - who knows what was going on, he didn't want to transport a load of what he perceived as junk to OP's house for her to deal with, or wait to complete the house clearance until she got round to it.

Jumping to NC is classic MN, but batshit.

Pudmyboy · 07/12/2021 15:55

My stepmother threw out all of our family photos when she married my dad, after my mum died. I was a baby and only know what my mum looked like as one aunt (her younger sister) was supposed to be her double. Yet there were young adult children (my older siblings) that she could have given them to.
I can see my stepmother wanted a clean slate but the in was not the only place for the memories, the other people in the photos would have loved them.
Apparently one pic was of me in my mother's arms soon after I was born, with her smiling at me. I would love to have seen it, as my stepmother was not affectionate towards me.
She kept a large pic of her deceased first husband on the bedroom, don't know why my dad didn't object.
So, @Christmasbirdchristmasherd you have my sympathy and commiserations.

GoodnightGrandma · 07/12/2021 15:54

That’s terrible, I’m so sorry. I’d be very angry about that.

Christmasbirdchristmasherd · 07/12/2021 15:51

I feel so upset reading that my dad isn't the only one who has done this. Thankfully most of our photos are safe but a fair few have been ripped by my mum Hmm

OP posts:
MLMshouldbeillegal · 07/12/2021 15:51

If your child had kept it for decades would you not just ask them if they wanted it before throwing it though? Even if you wouldn't have kept it when they originally brought it home, surely it's just common sense/decency to see if something not belonging to you wanted to be kept

The OP's dad would probably say that the OP had not "kept" it, she had left it when she moved out to clutter up their house and be looked at very very infrequently.

trumpisagit · 07/12/2021 15:50

If he form for this you should have taken some of the things that were "yours" years ago.
You are an adult and you don't have to ask for your own belongings.

Skeumorph · 07/12/2021 15:47

He has form? Then he's not unsentimental or 'anti clutter' at all, he's nasty.

So yes I'd tell him you're done. Spiteful man, spiteful actions - there's no need to contact me again, thanks.

I'm sorry.

SpiderinaWingMirror · 07/12/2021 15:45

Yanbu. My grandmother threw away all of thr family photos going back to the 1930s including those of my grandads family.
It's inforgivable.

SeaToSki · 07/12/2021 15:45

Why wouldnt he let you take it all years ago… you said you had already asked to have it right?

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 07/12/2021 15:38

Have you asked him why?

Swirlywoo · 07/12/2021 15:34

I'd feel awful about this too. Sorry OP.

PanettoneSeason · 07/12/2021 15:34

@Christmasbirdchristmasherd I’m so sorry OP 😓 I would be devastated by this too.

My FIL is the most unsentimental person I know. MIL and FIL split when DH was mid teens. She left with a new partner (affair) and left him with the 2 kids in the family home. 2 years later he moved his new wife and her 3 kids in - had a clear out to make more space and threw out EVERYTHING. All family pictures, sentimental things from when he was younger, their birth certificates - literally everything. We now have our own DC and DH is gutted that he has no pictures or anything to show from when he was younger

tallduckandhandsome · 07/12/2021 15:31

Well, you know what the answer is next time he asks anything of you. A resounding NO.

Wanker Flowers

Theunamedcat · 07/12/2021 15:30

You asked him for it and he threw it away is there anything left at all

QuestionNumberOne · 07/12/2021 15:27

thegreencup You might not have attachment to things, but it’s decent behaviour to remember that others may feel differently before you chuck their stuff away.

sparepantsandtoothbrush · 07/12/2021 15:26

@Thegreencup

Hmm, photos I can understand why you would want to keep.

A book that a primary school child has written about the Romans over 20 years ago? Nope. I would chuck that too. I have absolutely no sentimental attachment to stuff.

In defence of your dad, was the stuff in decent condition? We've had to recently chuck out a lot of our kids stuff we'd kept because it was water damaged. Thankfully, all of the photos were backed up electronically. But the rest is gone.

If your child had kept it for decades would you not just ask them if they wanted it before throwing it though? Even if you wouldn't have kept it when they originally brought it home, surely it's just common sense/decency to see if something not belonging to you wanted to be kept
LiquidSodaCrystal · 07/12/2021 15:25

Well it’s a shame he didn’t ask you, but it obviously wasn’t sentimental to him. I’ve done the same tbh and thrown out all my kids’ stuff. I don’t like keeping old mementoes, it depresses me.

If he has anything left that you’d like to keep, ask if you can go through it and keep it yourself.

Prescottdanni123 · 07/12/2021 15:22

@Thegreencup

Hmm, photos I can understand why you would want to keep.

A book that a primary school child has written about the Romans over 20 years ago? Nope. I would chuck that too. I have absolutely no sentimental attachment to stuff.

In defence of your dad, was the stuff in decent condition? We've had to recently chuck out a lot of our kids stuff we'd kept because it was water damaged. Thankfully, all of the photos were backed up electronically. But the rest is gone.

We all have different ideas on what is valuable. It wasn't for OP's dad to decide that it was worthless.

Sorry this happened @Christmasbirdchristmasherd

again2020 · 07/12/2021 15:06

My Dad would do this for sure.
It's pretty horrible Flowers

MrsFin · 07/12/2021 15:02

My Dad threw my record collection out. It would have been worth a few bob these days Sad. He hated clutter though.

Thegreencup · 07/12/2021 14:58

Hmm, photos I can understand why you would want to keep.

A book that a primary school child has written about the Romans over 20 years ago? Nope. I would chuck that too. I have absolutely no sentimental attachment to stuff.

In defence of your dad, was the stuff in decent condition? We've had to recently chuck out a lot of our kids stuff we'd kept because it was water damaged. Thankfully, all of the photos were backed up electronically. But the rest is gone.

HangingDitch · 07/12/2021 14:55

A horrible thing to do. You are definitely not being unreasonable.