Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I was called rude this morning - AIBU?

409 replies

Dinosaurhearmeroar · 07/12/2021 09:24

Hi everyone,

I had a call on the way to work from a random number - I picked up and it was someone asking if I was XX. I was tired and had a headache and said, "why are you calling so early?" (It was 7:20am). He replied;"I am a recruiter for supply teaching." I replied: "I have a permanent job, please take me off your books." Him: "Honestly. you don't have to be so rude." Me: "I'm tired and you know nothing about my life. Goodbye."

I then thought about the encounter all the way to work (another 30 minutes). Was I horrible? Am I someone who makes society worse with their behaviour? I have always been someone who smiles and is "nice" but sometimes it doesn't get me too far - particularly with men. Men still expect me to move out of the way, be a certain type of kind etc. and I sometimes have had enough. I do think I am angry and exhausted and my attempts to assert myself might come across as rude.

While I write this, I can't help thinking - would I even be questioning any of my behaviour if I was a man? Or even just a different woman?

Anyway - sorry for the thought ramble. I feel bad and then feel bad for feeling bad!

Thank you for your time XX

OP posts:
namechangetheworld · 07/12/2021 14:41

@tallduckandhandsome

If she had a brain, she would have answered the recruiter's original "Is this XX?" with a simple "No, wrong number", and swerved all of this nonsense completely.

Well that doesn't deal with the fact that her number on their database and that needed removing. Who knows why they have it.

Presumably simple human error? Either the person the call was intended for gave the wrong number, or someone at the office misheard or typed it in wrong? Or, more than likely, the OP was actually signed up to the agency and has changed her story after initially not getting the responses she wanted.
fairycakes1234 · 07/12/2021 14:40

I think you were a bit rude, i dont think i could talk to someone like that, there could be a reason why he rang so early and you could have asked him instead of being rude...

tallduckandhandsome · 07/12/2021 14:39

OMG now OP is responsible for making someone unemployed Grin

BlusteringBoobies · 07/12/2021 14:37

Oh and if it is a simple case of wrong number and OP hasn't corrected the recruiter then she's just removed someone from a database who could very well be desperate for work, rather than stating the number was wrong and leaving the recruiters to correct it with the right person who is looking for work.

BlusteringBoobies · 07/12/2021 14:35

I think it's all about perspective and you could
probably flip it either way to support an argument

tallduckandhandsome your assessment that the recruiter was in the wrong and rude in the first place would hold weight but the OP didn't tell him she wasn't the person he was calling. Quite possibly he dialled the right number and it's a mistype by the applicant (but I still think it's a massive coincidence it's a teacher agency and Op is a teacher)

So from his point of view
-he called someone who had signed up for supply teaching position
-he called them at a perfectly normal and reasonable time for supply teaching temp work
-he got an abrupt response on why he was calling so early (as is normal in this line of work)
-he was told she had a permanent position but could see the records hadn't been updated so was probably cross he had wasted time calling someone who didn't need the work
-he then suggested she was rude and got another curt reply of 'you know nothing about my life'

All of this could have easily been resolved if OP, when realising it wasn't a call for her had said 'sorry, that's not my name so I think you have the wrong number, can you remove this number from your list'.

Completely changes the conversation and I'd imagine the recruiter would have done so and possibly apologised instead of being confused why someone signed up with an agency would be a little arsey.

tallduckandhandsome · 07/12/2021 14:34

If she had a brain, she would have answered the recruiter's original "Is this XX?" with a simple "No, wrong number", and swerved all of this nonsense completely.

Well that doesn't deal with the fact that her number on their database and that needed removing. Who knows why they have it.

girlmom21 · 07/12/2021 14:33

@Dinosaurhearmeroar

Yes, it was. He was on my carphone which is always a bit fuzzy so I presumed he said my name originally hence my comment of taking me off his books (I get PR emails from time to time but never calls). He then asked again if I was so and so and I said no.
You haven't put the full conversation in your OP, so I'd assume you were rude in the bits you missed out.
namechangetheworld · 07/12/2021 14:32

@tallduckandhandsome

But she didn't say that, she said take me off your books. I do not understand why she said this, if she established it was a wrong number?

Because she's got a brain and wanted him off the phone so she can get on with her day.

If she had a brain, she would have answered the recruiter's original "Is this XX?" with a simple "No, wrong number", and swerved all of this nonsense completely.
tallduckandhandsome · 07/12/2021 14:29

@Chasingaftermidnight

The OP should have spoken in a more deferential way that made it sound like she was the one in the wrong.

‘Sorry, um, I don’t think I’m registered with you, I actually have a permanent job, would it be ok if you took me off your books?’

Yes, as I said upthread, OP should have apologised for being the wrong woman.

JustLikea · 07/12/2021 14:29

Not rude just blunt.

ElftonWednesday · 07/12/2021 14:29

@Offmyfence

Never made a mistake *@tallduckandhandsome* , would it have been better if the recruiter were female?

Maybe the recruiter wasn't at fault, as in he'd be given the wrong number by the applicant?

It would have been better if the recruiter had not behaved like an entitled dick and just said "Thank you" and put the phone down, like a normal person.
ElftonWednesday · 07/12/2021 14:27

Also if the caller was looking for a supply teacher at short notice, surely the OP's reply would enable him to end the call quickly and get on and phone the next person? She did him a favour by not engaging him in conversation and by giving prompt and useful information.

TractorAndHeadphones · 07/12/2021 14:27

@Werehamster my number isn’t anywhere online either. Which is why I’m Hmm as to how recruiters have it.

Offmyfence · 07/12/2021 14:27

Never made a mistake @tallduckandhandsome , would it have been better if the recruiter were female?

Maybe the recruiter wasn't at fault, as in he'd be given the wrong number by the applicant?

tallduckandhandsome · 07/12/2021 14:26

*his

tallduckandhandsome · 07/12/2021 14:26

@Kennykenkencat

tallduckandhandsome

But she didn't say that, she said take me off your books. I do not understand why she said this, if she established it was a wrong number

Because she's got a brain and wanted him off the phone so she can get on with her day

Actually she asked a question. Not exactly a response you use if you want someone off the phone quickly.

Interested to know why people think this was someone cold calling.

The agency family member belongs to don’t really do much advertising. Definitely don’t do cold calling. To get taken on by the agency is incredibly hard.

She worked out quickly that she didn't want this guy to have her number on her database and dealt with it. That is to be commended.
CaptSkippy · 07/12/2021 14:24

You were a bit curt perhaps, but not rude. I don't think I would have been very friendly to get a call at 7:20 in the morning when I am busy getting ready for work and even less so on my days off when I sleep untill 8 on average.

Also, keep in mind that the standards for rude behavior are different for men than they are for women.

YANBU

Kennykenkencat · 07/12/2021 14:24

tallduckandhandsome

But DillonPanthersTexas is a contractor not a supply teacher. Completely different industry.

tallduckandhandsome · 07/12/2021 14:23

@Offmyfence

I had a call on the way to work from a random number - I picked up and it was someone asking if I was XX.

@tallduckandhandsome OP didn't say she wasn't the other person! So SHE also fucked up, or was that just an error because she's a woman?

No, she didn't fuck up because she is not the person calling the wrong person at 7.20am.

Honestly, people - again - this is basic shit.

ElftonWednesday · 07/12/2021 14:22

"Not interested, please take me off your list" is not rude, it's direct, practical and useful to the caller.

"Fuck off you wanker, who the fuck do you think you are calling me at this hour?" is rude.

Kennykenkencat · 07/12/2021 14:22

tallduckandhandsome

But she didn't say that, she said take me off your books. I do not understand why she said this, if she established it was a wrong number

Because she's got a brain and wanted him off the phone so she can get on with her day

Actually she asked a question. Not exactly a response you use if you want someone off the phone quickly.

Interested to know why people think this was someone cold calling.

The agency family member belongs to don’t really do much advertising. Definitely don’t do cold calling. To get taken on by the agency is incredibly hard.

tallduckandhandsome · 07/12/2021 14:22

@Werehamster

If she was x, he would have recognised her.

As it is, from his response, it shows he was a cold caller. Otherwise he'd have said 'are you not x?'.

So OP was not rude.

Well, not necessarily at all. It read to me that xxx had signed up to the agency so he was making contact. He was probably quite confused that xxx was being so rude when she was the one who had applied for a position there.

Why on Earth would a recruiter for supply teachers be cold calling people? It makes no sense whatsoever.

Here's why, from @DillonPanthersTexas's post

I'm a freelance contractor, sadly my CV has made its way onto the books of various agencies without my permission so I get loads of calls. Sometimes the tone of these agents is quite aggressive and curt which does rile me when it is them cold calling me without even bothering to introduce themselves. The agent in the OPs situation is in the wrong industry if he feels her response is 'rude'

Offmyfence · 07/12/2021 14:21

@ElftonWednesday

I think some posters here wouldn't be happy unless she went out to dinner with him. Fucking doormats.
Hilarious! Some of us see ourselves as equals to men and don't assume that they're rude to us because we are women.
Offmyfence · 07/12/2021 14:20

I had a call on the way to work from a random number - I picked up and it was someone asking if I was XX.

@tallduckandhandsome OP didn't say she wasn't the other person! So SHE also fucked up, or was that just an error because she's a woman?

ElftonWednesday · 07/12/2021 14:20

I think some posters here wouldn't be happy unless she went out to dinner with him. Fucking doormats.

Swipe left for the next trending thread