Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I was called rude this morning - AIBU?

409 replies

Dinosaurhearmeroar · 07/12/2021 09:24

Hi everyone,

I had a call on the way to work from a random number - I picked up and it was someone asking if I was XX. I was tired and had a headache and said, "why are you calling so early?" (It was 7:20am). He replied;"I am a recruiter for supply teaching." I replied: "I have a permanent job, please take me off your books." Him: "Honestly. you don't have to be so rude." Me: "I'm tired and you know nothing about my life. Goodbye."

I then thought about the encounter all the way to work (another 30 minutes). Was I horrible? Am I someone who makes society worse with their behaviour? I have always been someone who smiles and is "nice" but sometimes it doesn't get me too far - particularly with men. Men still expect me to move out of the way, be a certain type of kind etc. and I sometimes have had enough. I do think I am angry and exhausted and my attempts to assert myself might come across as rude.

While I write this, I can't help thinking - would I even be questioning any of my behaviour if I was a man? Or even just a different woman?

Anyway - sorry for the thought ramble. I feel bad and then feel bad for feeling bad!

Thank you for your time XX

OP posts:
Blackberrybunnet · 07/12/2021 11:48

It doesn't sound rude to me. At the same time, he did have to call early to fill the positions available for that day. You didn't curse at him, and I think he was rude to accuse you of being rude when all you did was state facts.

TractorAndHeadphones · 07/12/2021 11:48

@AnotherOneWithNoGoodName exactly.
Also maybe he thought that he was doing a divine duty calling with an offer of work and someone has no right to be snappy.

I know I’m probably projecting but I have seen lots of this and men feel entitled to tell women off for lots of things they dk happily

KurtWildesChristmasNamechange · 07/12/2021 11:48

I can't see why she'd say 'why are you calling so early?' if she knew it was a wrong number. The general response is surely 'sorry wrong number..'

I'd say 'why are you calling so early?' to someone I WAS expecting a call from.

WomanWithDiamondEarring · 07/12/2021 11:46

@BlusteringBoobies

Sorry OP, I don't believe your drip feed and think you've changed the narrative due to the overwhelming comments stating you were rude.

You ARE a teacher so that tallies. And why not simply say they have the wrong number? You say your car phone was crackly and you didn't hear the name but then when he repeated it you clarified and still asked to be taken off the books?

Such important information would have been in the OP. I think you were a bit abrupt considering I think at some point you DID sign up with them, but we've all been too curt in situations so I'd let it go.

I agree. I don't believe one word of the OP's updates simply because they don't make sense or tally with what she originally wrote.

You were rude, you know you were rude and it wouldn't do any harm at all to try and put some manners on yourself whether you're speaking to a man, woman, child or cat.

May I also add that telling fibs to try and excuse your rudeness is a double whammy on the unpleasantness scale.

AnotherOneWithNoGoodName · 07/12/2021 11:46

@authenticforgery

You were rude and I think your being a woman is irrelevant.
I agree she was rude but I bet he wouldn't have said what he did to a man, so I don't think totally irrelevant.
Dinosaurhearmeroar · 07/12/2021 11:45

I know - it sounds made up but I’m not embellishing the story. I am not with any teacher agencies - I still get PR emails (my old job) but I’ve had the same and only job for several years. I assumed he was doing a PR cold call. Sometimes the truth is stranger than fiction! So many people on here getting a little cross about my encounter. I also didn’t do a vote - if you look I am (rightly or wrongly) being called out a lot on this thread and I’ll take it. I also thank those who agree with me. What this shows is we are all very different and to some I was a dick who got the wrong end of the stick and took my mood out in this bloke. To others, I was well within my rights and people have been far ruder. Such is life I suppose.

OP posts:
BertramLacey · 07/12/2021 11:44

And was factual and blunt. Women being terse are not rude. Just because she didn't pad out the call with social fluff doesn't make her rude, or worthy of the recruiter telling her off.

This. The OP was blunt and to the point, but not rude. I doubt he would have told a man off for being rude at this point. We hold women to different standards when it comes to communication. We expect women to hedge statements with 'maybe, possibly, terribly sorry' when we do not require the same of men.

The unreasonable bit is taking a call in the car. Hands free or not, I hate it when people think they can multi-task whilst driving, especially if they're already tired.

WeAllHaveWings · 07/12/2021 11:43

I really don't understand why you had to be so unnecessarily short with him, you were up and about and the only inconvenience was answering the call on your commute.

If you had listened instead of immediately being snappy and rude you would have realised he was ringing so early as trying to get hold of supply teacher (probably for that day) and had a wrong number. You would have said wrong number, he would have apologised and the world would have happily moved on.

Instead both of you were left feeling shite.

mirijones · 07/12/2021 11:42

You were rude.

silverbubbles · 07/12/2021 11:41

Forget all this man / woman nonsense - you simply sound like a rude person to me.

If you are a supply teacher and you are on the agencies books then you should be pleased that they called you. If you have work then get them to update their system so they don't call you so much.

If I was that recruiter you would not be at the top of my list next time I was looking for staff. I bet you would be reacting differently if you were scrabbling round for work.....

TractorAndHeadphones · 07/12/2021 11:41

@daisychain01

The recruiter had just as much right to express their opinion as the OP. Maybe "snappy" is a better descriptor.

If the tables were turned and it was a female recruiter going about their job by ringing someone out of hours, which is what recruiters have to do, and being snapped at, everyone would be saying typical arrogant bloke being rude and dismissive of you when you were oooooonly doing your job.

Trouble is it has become fashionable to treat men as The Enemy.. The OP sounds like she's pissed off with men in general and the person got the sharp end of her pointy shoe.

Honestly as a former customer service agent ( and still deal with customers) - if this is what ‘rude’ means they probably need another job.

You can’t expect people to be polite 100% of the time. A bit of snappiness, etc is to be expected and I just assume the person’s having a bad time and cut them some slack.

Now, abusive customers - those who swear, want to complain to the manager unecessarily, make threats , yell etc etc. Those are being rude and really unpleasant.

But this? It’s not. And to tell someone that they’re rude just because they weren’t overly polite is unprofessional.

DrManhattan · 07/12/2021 11:41

@HoardingSamphireSaurus
He's a guy doing his job. He has to call early. Don't answer if you can't be polite. Imo it's rude, it's not in yours, that's all.

Macmickmoo · 07/12/2021 11:38

I don't think you were rude - salespeople can be very pushy, I never enter into conversations with them other than to say, I'm not interested please remove me from your list and do not call me again.

Recruiters can make double-glazing salespeople look good!

SpiderinaWingMirror · 07/12/2021 11:38

I am pretty terse with random calls from recruiters. At 7.20 yanbu.

TractorAndHeadphones · 07/12/2021 11:36

@daisypond

I’m baffled why anyone thinks the OP was not rude. She clearly was. Her first words -“why are you calling so early?” In what world would that be an acceptable first interaction with a stranger? It’s the sort of thing a toddler says who doesn’t know any social cues. No hello or how are you? Forget the later bits of the conversation, where it gets exacerbated.
It’s not the most pleasant response but neither is it rude. If you’re rushing about in the morning and someone unknown calls at an unearthly hour it’s not wrong to ask why.

Also it was a response to someone asking if she was XX presumably she’d already said hello oaks that’s the first thing you say when people pick up the phone.

RedWingBoots · 07/12/2021 11:36

I deal with recruitment agencies all the time.

Lots of the staff don't bother reading your CV before they call so call with inappropriate jobs and/or early, late, at weekends and on bank holidays including Boxing Day.

Some repeatedly call after I tell them politely that I'm not what they are looking for.

Others email me and I politely tell them that I am not what they are looking for. A week later I get exactly the same email.

I therefore don't think you are rude.

daisychain01 · 07/12/2021 11:34

The recruiter had just as much right to express their opinion as the OP. Maybe "snappy" is a better descriptor.

If the tables were turned and it was a female recruiter going about their job by ringing someone out of hours, which is what recruiters have to do, and being snapped at, everyone would be saying typical arrogant bloke being rude and dismissive of you when you were oooooonly doing your job.

Trouble is it has become fashionable to treat men as The Enemy.. The OP sounds like she's pissed off with men in general and the person got the sharp end of her pointy shoe.

KurtWildesChristmasNamechange · 07/12/2021 11:34

I think OP has made it up because this thread didn’t go how she wanted.

OP, if you want a thread about men being patronising to women, then you could have created that. But instead you created one about your behaviour and have clearly backtracked.

Also.. you don't know anything about HIS life either. So how is it ok for you to be rude but not him? If this is true - and I'm not so sure considering the drip drip drip - then you were both having a shit start to the day and managed to both take it out on what is essentially a random stranger.

Atemyhat · 07/12/2021 11:33

I think you were rude and I don’t think it has anything to do with being a man or a woman. Just speak as you’d like to be spoken to.

Heidipi · 07/12/2021 11:33

I've had several sales calls at work from the same guy. The first time I asked him to email some info and said we would get back to him if interested. The next time I said I had forwarded it to a colleague, I would talk to them (all true) and get back to him if interested. The next time I said I thought it was unlikely that we were interested and we would reply if we were (true, it wasn't a definite no at that stage but I didn't want him to keep calling). The next time I said the same, and there was no need to call again. He said I was wasting his time! At that point I decided we would definitely not be going ahead.

5keletor · 07/12/2021 11:33

Nothing to do with gender, you were rude. "You know nothing about my life" was an odd thing to say, I'd probably laugh if someone said that to me. Confused

TractorAndHeadphones · 07/12/2021 11:32

@Fernando072020

You were rude. You also know nothing about his life. Poor guy was just doing his job
this statement was made in response to him chastising her for being rude - like a child.
fourminutestosavetheworld · 07/12/2021 11:31

" "I'm tired and you know nothing about my life. Goodbye." "

This is quite comical, not assertive. He'll be repeating that to colleagues.

daisypond · 07/12/2021 11:30

I’m baffled why anyone thinks the OP was not rude. She clearly was. Her first words -“why are you calling so early?” In what world would that be an acceptable first interaction with a stranger? It’s the sort of thing a toddler says who doesn’t know any social cues. No hello or how are you? Forget the later bits of the conversation, where it gets exacerbated.

PinkWednesdays · 07/12/2021 11:30

It’s just a pure coincidence that you’re a teacher and this person called you looking for a supply teacher…but yes, wrong number of course.