Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why are certain newspapers so against WFH?

233 replies

Circlesandtriangles · 07/12/2021 05:54

AIBU for seeing a persistent agenda in The Telegraph against working from home? It also has a completely misogynist undertone. Not everyone has to be a massive fan of it, but why work so hard to stoke up opinion against it??

Example headlines from November:

"If you want to lose your job, work from home"
"Just one in ten women working from home plan to return to office"
"Take it from a mother, working from home is a disaster for women"
"HMRC spends millions so staff can abandon offices"
"Afghan allies ‘left at the mercy of Taliban’ while civil servants worked from home"
"People working from home do half an hour less each day, study finds"
"It's high time staff returned to the office"

OP posts:
dropitlikeitsloth · 07/12/2021 09:21

@MasterGland

I read The Telegraph, although I am not their target audience. I think there is a great hesitancy about WFH amongst the section of society that make money from other people working and consuming. I think many fear WFH will be a slippery slope to a low economic growth society, albeit probably a happier one. WFH, 4 day week and eventually a universal basic income. These ideas are being seriously discussed by many. It is probably quite scary to those who profit from the current status quo.
This this this!! It’s all about the profit!
FelinaDaHousecat · 07/12/2021 09:19

[quote MrsTophamHat]@Elephantsparade not rewarded but compensated for in the wage. Surely workiing conditions is taken into account when deciding on a salary anyway. Things like unsociable hours and night shifts are recognised due to the impact on your work life balance, so I don't see why there couldn't be some recognition that WFH can make life easier and more flexible. [/quote]
In my work we were actually compensated with a flat fee for wfh because we use more utilities, and most importantly - space in your own house (basically you are paying for their office space!). Also with cycling, etc. commute is not necessarily more expensive. i do not believe wfh should be paid less. In fact, we were paid more.

thepeopleversuswork · 07/12/2021 09:16

Yeah that's a bloody joke. We do more work from home than those in the office do. The amount of people who walk away from their desk many times during the day for a coffee, which turns into a long chat with a coworker (and don't kid yourselves it's work related), or many many smoking breaks, or for the men long toilet breaks.

Yep. Working in an office is about 40% chit-chat and timewasting. Some of that is actually useful for social cohesion/mentoring and staying on top of what's happening so its not all bad and you do need a bit of that. But anyone who thinks their productivity is higher in the office than at home is deluding themself.

FreedomFaith · 07/12/2021 09:14

@PhilCornwall1

"People working from home do half an hour less each day, study finds"

Hmmm, having been WFH for 14 years, I've yet to have that happen. On average it's an hour and a half more each day.

Yeah that's a bloody joke. We do more work from home than those in the office do. The amount of people who walk away from their desk many times during the day for a coffee, which turns into a long chat with a coworker (and don't kid yourselves it's work related), or many many smoking breaks, or for the men long toilet breaks.

If they want me back in the office, I'll be doing the minimum needed and no more because I have a commute then. I'm not staying longer and missing out on my life for work, no thank you.

SusieBob · 07/12/2021 09:12

It's the Torygraph. What do you expect?

thepeopleversuswork · 07/12/2021 09:09

@olivehater

As someone who has never worked from home it pisses me off. I am still paying out childcare, petrol etc. I choose to work part time and take the equivalent pay cut that goes with that while I see people on the school run that then nip to activities/coffee shop/playground with their kids. Sure there are some that put all the hours in later but their are plenty more who don’t whilst taking a full time wage. Civil service appears to be the worst for it. If this is going to carry on then this that those that have to travel to work need to be paid a premium or no one is going to choose these careers going forward. And why the hell would you when this jobs that allow working from home have it so cushy?
Sorry this is just balls.

I work from home three days a week (partly hangover from COVID and partly because of childcare issues). Two outputs of this for me are:

a) Not having to commute for the best part of three hours a day means my productivity is way higher than it would be if I were trying to condense everything into office hours. I manage teams of more junior people there is rarely a half-hour period when someone is not pinging me to ask for guidance. If I'm on a train that's an hour when people don't have a senior person to talk to.

b) The trade off for my not being in the office every day is that I'm expected to be "always on". I start work much earlier than most people and finish later. It's not ideal for my W/L balance and sometimes pisses me off but for me its a trade-off worth making because I get to be at home when my daughter gets home and I don' have several hours of unproductive time when I'm on a train.

So your resentment of people who WFH is your own problem and that's understandable but that doesn't change the fact that for those of us who do, many of us find our productivity is way higher than when we're schlepping in and out purely so we can be seen to be sitting at a desk.

hotmeatymilk · 07/12/2021 09:00

Also The Telegraph aka the Torygraph isn't a great indicator of... anything really except possibly of tory twatness?
Ha, I came here to say this. “Tory rag in publishes Tory opinions shocker.”

Cattipuss · 07/12/2021 08:59

London weighting isn't often higher than commuting costs. In terms of time saved as well I am sure a lot of people will still find it a good deal.

Outsourcing isn't possible for many jobs, a lot of companies where it might work have already tried it. Probably national variation in pay will even out a bit, but that's not a bad thing.

I'm not overly arsed on home working, I live close to work which was a purposeful choice that came with a pay cut, but whether in or out the office don't have a preference, but the same boring and bitter lines getting trotted out are tedious.

MasterGland · 07/12/2021 08:58

In answer to a pp, I read The Telegraph at the weekend. I like the Review section on a Saturday for books and music. I also like the recipes in the magazine. The main section is my summary of news for the week, and I enjoy reading the opinion pieces from some of their columnists. I don't necessarily agree with them all, but then I didnt think I had to. The letters pages are normally full of letters from people disagreeing with columnists.

ThisBear · 07/12/2021 08:54

I find the outrage over wfh really bizarre. I've worked both ways, typically end up working over the time I would have been commuting when I wfh, and in one of the fields I've worked in it's been commonplace since the early 2000s. So these comments about doing less make me sick tbh.

Some people have a ten minute walking commute, some people have a two hour commute across two buses and a train. Some people work tough physical jobs but get home at a decent hour, others work in relaxed offices but don't get home before 9pm, or work in a 'cushy' job from home that's actually a really stressful one with a high level of responsibility. Jobs are different, they always have been.

Don't you dare tell anyone they should be paid less than you because you think they've got a bit of extra convenience.

MrsTophamHat · 07/12/2021 08:54

@Elephantsparade not rewarded but compensated for in the wage. Surely workiing conditions is taken into account when deciding on a salary anyway. Things like unsociable hours and night shifts are recognised due to the impact on your work life balance, so I don't see why there couldn't be some recognition that WFH can make life easier and more flexible.

TracyLords · 07/12/2021 08:52

I’ve wfh because of Covid. Just returned to the office as I hate wfh and the impact on my mental health.

But wfh was not a skive. I worked productively through it, even while homeschooling. And as soon as childcare was open; DS was there.

I honestly think that if there is the capability to wfh and it doesn’t impact someone’s productivity then they should be allowed to wfh. But it’s certainly not a skive

FelinaDaHousecat · 07/12/2021 08:49

Also The Telegraph aka the Torygraph isn't a great indicator of... anything really except possibly of tory twatness?

FelinaDaHousecat · 07/12/2021 08:48

I am only posting on MN because I am off today and chilling :)

FelinaDaHousecat · 07/12/2021 08:47

@manysummersago

Right, I didn’t see it happening here, somehow!

@PhilCornwall1 every time WFH is discussed on MN people say similar. They are so much more productive. Yet this doesn’t tally with my experiences to be honest. I’m certainly not saying that you personally aren’t but I think overall people may think they are more productive but aren’t.

I work from home. I do not 'think' I am more productive. I have hard evidence of it through my Key Performance Indicators.
Babybooboodedoo · 07/12/2021 08:46

My husband’s large employer is about to do an estates review, with the aim of rationalising their offices by a third.

That’s probably happening across the economy and commercial landlords/ investors will be doing everything they can to stop it.

fulanigirl · 07/12/2021 08:42

@manysummersago

I’d be inclined to think that young people would be missing out from wfh.

Even DH has commented that he doesn’t know how new people would be trained at the moment.

When we get new students, we take turns going into the office to train them until we are comfortable they can work from home. There is always a few people in the office everyday for them.
YourenutsmiLord · 07/12/2021 08:41

It's a bit like the 'women love to shop' trope in the past - I remember Tesco bringing in clothing - women will have the opportunity to clothes shop when they do the weekly food shopping - along comes online shopping and everyone very happily stays home.

CentrifugalBumblePuppy · 07/12/2021 08:38

I think it’s a combination of the papers having an agenda handed to them by their billionaire paymasters as previous posters have suggested, together with a loss of revenue due to decreased footfall; how many folk grab a paper as part of their daily commute? Yes, traditional papers like the Telegraph have subscription web sites, but compare the amount of ads between a website & a newspaper; I’d be willing to bet they’ve lost advertising revenue with decreased commuter footfall translating into reduced print newspaper sales.

fulanigirl · 07/12/2021 08:37

@hygtt

We are also the ones having to fork out childcare

So you think everyone who wfhs doesn't pay childcare? 😆

That's exactly what I've been asking myself. People that work from home pay for childcare, how else do they work?
Lunaduckdrop · 07/12/2021 08:35

07:15ShinyHappyPoster

There are lots of business sectors that rely on people going to work eg commercial property, retail, hospitality. Most media owners have varied investments and assets, and alliances with other business owners in other sectors.

They would prefer a burnt-out, workforce with higher Covid rates than a workforce that is questioning any aspect of the status quo.

The pandemic represented a great opportunity to restructure every aspect of society. That threatens the conglomerates and multinationals who thrive in the current system.

^This. Well put!

GreenWhiteViolet · 07/12/2021 08:35

@Fluffycloudland77

I’m going to go with the theory the owners friends own commercial office space.

About 14-15 years ago a relative was paying £12k a quarter in a shitty backwater town for an office space. It’s a huge amount to find each year.

This. When there's a big change, some people do well out of it and others don't, and those who don't will be trying to stop it. I think the silliest I've seen was an article about how 'we' love and miss our daily rush hour commute. Utterly bizarre.
Sprostongreen21 · 07/12/2021 08:30

My partner is local government and has worked from home not through choice but because they haven’t reopened their team office to them.

He has worked longer hours as his commute time has gone. He tends to start a little later than he did but now works later. Just because you can see people out and about doesn’t mean they aren’t working when home. They may do school hours or work later as their company allows more flexi working for their role. Could work through lunch etc. Doesn’t mean they are taking the piss tbh. I say this as someone working 13 hour days in the NHS throughout and never worked from home.

He never thought he would but he prefers it. Everything is fine with teams and he can get more done without office chatter. He certainly hasn’t been say twiddling his thumbs. It’s done wonders for his stress levels though.

hygtt · 07/12/2021 08:29

And then there are jobs which could easily be outsourced elsewhere. It wasn’t that long ago that call centre work was outsourced abroad,

and so many were bought back because it didn't work.

Elephantsparade · 07/12/2021 08:27

@MrsTophamHat - for you. Some people walk to work or cycle or have a very short commute that they car share. I have always worked really close to home. Its the same with childcare. large sections of the workforce have zero childcare costs, so they arent saving on childcare.
I dont work from home so its of no consequence to me, but I do find the idea i should be rewarded for going to my workplace or someone else penalised for not a bit off.

Swipe left for the next trending thread